.

Posted By Message
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6

TotallyTrying
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

121 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Here is the thing for me.

If my friend is having this type of party it is probably bc they can't afford to host it.

Now if they are my FRIEND, I want to be there for them to celebrate.

I do not pass judgment on my friends or think them tacky. I would think "DH wants to do something nice for DW".

If it was too much money I would decline and take my friend out for a drink or coffee and cake for their bday.

Honestly just don't go if you deem it tacky or whatever.

But for me, I would not pass judgment on my friend like that. With friends like that who needs....

Message edited 2009-09-23 09:02:26.640000.

Posted 9/23/09 8:57 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I think it's tacky. If you want everyone to get together for YOUR or YOUR SOs birthday, YOU pay for a party and invite people. Bottom line. I hate that, it's ridiculous. Then are you also supposed to give a gift too?

I know people who have done this who also want a gift too after people just paid to come out for them. Tacky.

Posted 9/23/09 9:28 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

He is throwing a party - this is more then just dinner. That should mean he is covering the cost. He should pick a venue he can afford to serve everyone the meal he intends to serve. He could have phrased the invite so that it was a cocktail party for a certain length of time but you are welcome to stay for dinner afterwards and it will cost $45 each.

I wouldn't invite someone to a party at my house and expect everyone to bring the meal or give me money to cover the cost of groceries. What he's doing is the pretty close to the same thing.

Ftr...when my friends & I go out for birthdays, the guest of honor picks the place and the host (usually the spouse) pays for dinner for everyone.

Posted 9/23/09 9:32 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by quasi3

Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



I understand what your saying but I disagee.

If he is calling it a party then he should be paying.

If he is unable to afford to pay the full expense, then he should not be having a party out for her.

My dh is going to be 30 soon and if I can't save up for a party he will be having one at the house.

This puts people in a weird situation. What if some of the guests could not afford to go?

For the record I have gone to a few birthdays where we had to pay, but it was never said to be a party.



To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....

Posted 9/23/09 9:33 AM
 

ThePinkGoose
In Your Hands

Member since 8/08

4706 total posts

Name:
Nunya

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I don't think it's tacky. I would be ok with paying our way and he did state in the invite that dinner is your own cost so I think it's fine. Don't sweat the small stuff. :o) I'm sure your friend will be very happy to see you there.

Posted 9/23/09 9:36 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Goobster

Posted by quasi3

Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



I understand what your saying but I disagee.

If he is calling it a party then he should be paying.

If he is unable to afford to pay the full expense, then he should not be having a party out for her.

My dh is going to be 30 soon and if I can't save up for a party he will be having one at the house.

This puts people in a weird situation. What if some of the guests could not afford to go?

For the record I have gone to a few birthdays where we had to pay, but it was never said to be a party.



To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....



This is all I meant, you summed it up.

I love how I was told I wasnt a good friend for using the word "tacky". Whatever. I don't need to prove on LIF that i'm a great friend...maybe it was the wrong word, i even stated that earlier...I just know that if MY husband did the same thing for me I'd be a bit embarrased that he asked people to pay. I would think the gesture was sweet...and that he didn't do it thinking it was putting anyone in a bad position, but I'd still be embarrased.

Posted 9/23/09 9:38 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: .

Posted by maybebaby

I don't think my post was ridiculous at all.



It's not ridiculous. Inviting people to a party for yourself or your spouse, and asking them to pay is what is ridiculous.

Posted 9/23/09 9:42 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Goobster

Posted by maybebaby

I don't think my post was ridiculous at all.



It's not ridiculous. Inviting people to a party for yourself or your spouse, and asking them to pay is what is ridiculous.



Yep.

Posted 9/23/09 10:02 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: .

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.

Posted 9/23/09 10:37 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Goobster

To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....



Yikes! I think that's a bit harsh. To tell someone they shouldn't get together with their friends on their birthday because they can't afford to pay for everyone is a little much.

I've thrown myself countless parties and certainly don't expect to pay for everyone's drinks. We usually do a pre-party at my place and then head to a bar/club for the night where everyone pays for what they drink. Its what we all do and its never been an issue for anyone. We've been doing this since we were students. What, when your in grad school your supposed to take all your friends out for YOUR birthday? Even brunch with the girls - we always take the birthday girl out and pay our own way.

On the flip side- no one really gets each other gifts in my circle of friends.

Message edited 2009-09-23 10:43:01.107000.

Posted 9/23/09 10:41 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.



I don't think there is anything at all lame about proper etiquette.

Don't package something as you are throwing a party if you are not covering the costs.



Posted 9/23/09 10:57 AM
 

TotallyTrying
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

121 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.



ITA!

This is your FRIEND not someone you dislike Chat Icon

Posted 9/23/09 11:01 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky.

it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife.


ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't.

I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really.

to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE.

"a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end.




ITTTTTTTA-Who cares? I hate these threads. If i never hear the word tacky again it would be great!

Posted 9/23/09 11:03 AM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: .

I think it's time to agree to disagree....


External Image

Posted 9/23/09 11:16 AM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.



Word.

Posted 9/23/09 11:26 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: .

double post

Message edited 2009-09-23 11:46:21.003000.

Posted 9/23/09 11:44 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.



I also dislike threads like this... I think it's mean to talk about your friends on a public message board and open them up to public scrutiny... I just don't get it... Unless you were HONESTLY confused about something, then why post about a "friend" where people will criticize them negatively.
As for 'proper etiquette' This isn't a formal event... This is a close circle of friends. I am really REALLY glad that my close circle of friends don't care about proper etiquette when it comes to each other...


ETA:
To the OP: My response was not directed at your specifically... mainly towards the comments IN the thread.

Message edited 2009-09-23 11:46:37.283000.

Posted 9/23/09 11:45 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: .

Posted by Shelly

Posted by Goobster

To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....



Yikes! I think that's a bit harsh. To tell someone they shouldn't get together with their friends on their birthday because they can't afford to pay for everyone is a little much.

I've thrown myself countless parties and certainly don't expect to pay for everyone's drinks. We usually do a pre-party at my place and then head to a bar/club for the night where everyone pays for what they drink. Its what we all do and its never been an issue for anyone. We've been doing this since we were students. What, when your in grad school your supposed to take all your friends out for YOUR birthday? Even brunch with the girls - we always take the birthday girl out and pay our own way.

On the flip side- no one really gets each other gifts in my circle of friends.



I dont think it's harsh. Maybe you aren't seeing my point. A tradition of a few friends going out on birthdays and paying for themselves and the birthday person, thats one thing. But organizing a large gathering or party, for yourself, when others in the group dont do that, thats where the difference comes in.

I think there is a VERY big difference if your friend pulls together a bunch of friends to go out for your birthday, to celebrate you, and everyone paying their own way. But for someone to say to their friends "HEY, it's my birthday. Let's go celebrate me" and then to send out invites, etc but expect people to pay their own way is quite different(and odds are you will be getting gifts small or not), I find that uncool and crossing a line...

I know people who do this, and YES, they DO expect gifts. And then they have the nerve to complain when people give them inexpensive gifts too...I know this isn't everyone but the people I know who like to organize their own birthday bashes, this is how they are. They like attention and yes, they certainly enjoy getting gifts if that comes along with the night out.

I would never in a million years organize my own birthday bash unless I was going to foot the bill. But that's just me I guess. If another friend surprised me and got all our friends together, that would fall into a totally different category.

JMO I guess


Message edited 2009-09-23 11:58:54.873000.

Posted 9/23/09 11:47 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Goobster


I think there is a VERY big difference if your friend pulls together a bunch of friends to go out for your birthday, to celebrate you, and everyone paying their own way. But for someone to say to their friends "HEY, it's my birthday. Let's go celebrate me" and then to send out invites, etc but expect people to pay their own way is quite different(and odds are you will be getting gifts small or not), I find that uncool and crossing a line...

I know people who do this, and YES, they DO expect gifts. And then they have hte nerve when people give them crappy gifts too...I know this isn't everyone but the people I know who liek to organize their own birthday bashes, this is how they are.

I would never in a million years organize my own birthday bash unless I was going to foot the bill. But that's just me I guess. If another friend surprised me and got all our friends together, that would fall into a totally different category.

JMO I guess



Well your friends are different that mine I guess. We are all very casual. We will organize our own birthday event- and just send an email. Its rarely dinner- and usually brunch or drinks. Its just the way we are- and everyone expects to pay their own way. Its never been an issue. Maybe because we're causal- or maybe because its never an expensive place- but its the way we've been doing things for years.

Before kids we'd have people over at our apartments (we live in the city)- but now with kids- we really don't because the kids are sleeping.


Now that we're getting older, sometimes someone's spouse will foot the bill, but we always come willing to pay. Why shouldn't we celebrate someone's birthday because they can't foot the bill for everyone.

Call it a party, dinner, whatever- for us, its a gathering of friends which- these days with work and kids- is tough to come by. We're just all happy to get together, see each other and catch up. To celebrate someone's birthday is special- and we all enjoy it.

But no one expects a gift, and certainly no one would ever comment on a gift being crappy. That is tacky!

Message edited 2009-09-23 12:01:00.560000.

Posted 9/23/09 11:57 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: .

Posted by Shelly

Well your friends are different that mine I guess. We will organize our own birthday event- and everyone expects to pay. We just never let the birthday girl pay. Before kids we'd have people over at our apartments (we live in the city)- but now with kids- we really don't because the kids are sleeping.

And we really don't send out invites. Just emails. Its really not so formal.

Now that we're getting older, sometimes someone's spouse will foot the bill, but we always come willing to pay.

Call it a party, dinner, whatever- for us, its a gathering of friends which- these days with work and kids- is tough to come by. We're just all happy to get together, see each other and catch up. To celebrate someone's birthday is special- and we all enjoy it.

But no one expects a gift, and certainly no one would ever comment on a gift being crappy. That is tacky!




I added this in above but I dont think you saw it. This is the bigger point that I guess I wanted to make..

A tradition of a few friends going out on birthdays and paying for themselves and the birthday person, thats one thing. But organizing a large gathering or party, for yourself, when others in the group dont do that for themselves and it's NOT a tradition for all to get the same in return, thats where the difference comes in. KWIM?

I think what you and your friends do makes sense. But the OPs situation/party that she posted about was not in the same terms as that.

Message edited 2009-09-23 12:02:23.027000.

Posted 9/23/09 12:01 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: .

Posted by Goobster

I added this in above but I dont think you saw it. This is the bigger point that I guess I wanted to make..

A tradition of a few friends going out on birthdays and paying for themselves and the birthday person, thats one thing. But organizing a large gathering or party, for yourself, when others in the group dont do that for themselves and it's NOT a tradition for all to get the same in return, thats where the difference comes in. KWIM?

I think what you and your friends do makes sense. But the OPs situation/party that she posted about was not in the same terms as that.




I understand what you are saying- but I still don't see the big deal about the OP's situation. He wants to something special for his wife, he can't afford to foot the bill of it all. People have the choice to come, or not, without specifying why they can't. Anyone who wants to celebrate the birthday girl - can do so another time on their own on their own terms.

I think its better this way and being upfront about it. I was invited to a "dinner party" at a restaurant by a man who OWNED A BANK when I was a student. Its was an insanely expensive place, so I made sure to order the cheapest thing on the menu and didn't drink. When the bill came- and was divided between the amount of people there and we were told its $70 each, the older man next to me saw my face and told me not to worry about it. From that day on, I learned- if I'm going out- be prepared to pay for myself and expect the bill to be split evenly amongst everyone. If I don't want to pay, I don't go.



Posted 9/23/09 12:09 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE.

"a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end.



ITA, I would never assume that being invited to a dinner to celebrate a friends birthday autimatically means it is paid for. I would assume we would be paying.

Posted 9/23/09 12:47 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE.

"a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end.



What about a wedding to celebrate the union of Jane and John?

Wouldn't that be the same thing? Yet, no one pays their way at a wedding.

Posted 9/23/09 2:27 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: .

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.



Just needed to clarify....I NEVER said her birthday shouldn't be celebrated. This has nothing to do with HER it has to do with the question of her husband throwing her a party (not a casual dinner out w/ a group of friends, a PARTY) and it costing $90/couple.

I was asking if anyone else thought that was abnormal. And yes I did say two diff. times that tacky was not the right word...because they are not tacky people, they are good people who we love...but the rest of our close friends have exchanged emails about it because truthfully its a hard time for everyone and we all are attending a wedding the very night before. then there is the party the next night costing us all over $100 for cost of party, a present and babysitters..

There is NOTHING wrong with celebrating a bday!! I go to dinner all the time for friends bdays..they call us up, we get together at a restauarant adn split the bill. This, to me, is different. It's at least 35 people at a private room in a nice restaurant...and whenever I've thrown parties or been to others like this NEVER have we been charged for it. Thats all.

Why does it have to turn so ugly?? It was more a question of etiquette..thats all. Geez. Chat Icon

Posted 9/23/09 2:31 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: .

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by Ophelia

and this is all I meant by saying threads like this put me off.

if my "friends" bashed me like this, I would probably scratch their eyes out. I am not directing this at the OP specificially, b/c she did in fact say that "tacky" was perhaps the wrong word to use..

but how effing TACKY it is to judge other people for what they can afford or not afford? to say people shouldn't CELEBRATE a BIRTHDAY if they can't pony up for every tom, ****, and harry that decides to go.

I think it's LAME to hold such a standard over a FRIEND's head. LAME LAME LAME.





Why does it have to turn so ugly?? It was more a question of etiquette..thats all. Geez. Chat Icon



I'm sorry if what I wrote made you feel badly. I specifically included in what you quoted that I wasn't directing my words directly at you, but rather the "tone" of the thread in general.

it turns ugly b/c that's what it does when it comes to these types of things, which is precisely why these threads put me off. it's easy to be ugly and call people names when we don't know them.

again, I did not want to make you feel badly. my apologies. Chat Icon

Posted 9/23/09 2:37 PM
 
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
30th surprise bday JennJay41 8/1/08 3 Dining In or Out
Review of DH's surprise 30th bday party Pumpkin 8/20/06 8 Families Helping Families ™