.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >> | |
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... when i threw DH a party for his 30th, i invited people out to dinner to celebrate and it was a price fixed menu and i subsidized half of everyone's meal, except for any alcohol. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Beth the problem comes from calling it a "party" to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person I would never call that a party BINGO |
|
Posted 9/22/09 11:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky. it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife. ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't. I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really. to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE. "a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end. i agree with this - i've gone to several parties in the city (my own sister's included) where it was clearly stated on the invite that there would be a cover charge for the open bar. i don't have a problem with it at all. if you can afford it, go. if not, decline. it's that simple. i don't see what is tacky about it. if you were invited as a guest and THEN at the end of the night asked to cough up $90, that would be tacky! |
|
Posted 9/22/09 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... I don't see the words "free" "taken care of" or "it's on me" ANYWHERE in the definitions for the word "party" below. perhaps we are starting to expect too much. |
Posted 9/22/09 11:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by JBmommy I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it. I agree. I personally wouldn't do this, I'd have a party at my house or foot the bill if we went out and I was the host, but paying my own way wouldn't keep me from going if I could afford it and wanted to go. If I don't want to pay, I can say I can't make it. I would much rather know up front that I am expected to pay than have the awkward conversation when the bill comes. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... ITA with Ophelia. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Beth the problem comes from calling it a "party" to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person I would never call that a party I agree with this When I invited friends to come out for DH's birthday -- I said that we were going out for dinner at a restaurant - and I never said it was a 'party' and everyone knows that we are all just doing a GTG at a restaurant and everyone will have their share of the bill. The moment you say its a "surprise party" - I am under the assumption that its being sponsored by the person inviting. My sister had a 30th birthday party her mom and my dad threw for her at a restaurant - the invite clearly stated it was a party and no one had to pay for anything, as they would not have expected to. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky. it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife. ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't. I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really. to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE. "a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end. what is such a shame about this thread?? Honestly...she is a very good friend and I have NO PROBLEM celebrating her bday. but do you see what position these things put people in?? If we don't go I feel badly that we aren't there for her-to be a part of her 30th. HOWEVER....all of us are married w/kids...money is very tight. It also means hiring a babysitter for us as we do not have family close by. So this bday celebration which the DH is throwing turns into a minimum $140 night (give or take). For my 30th and DH's 30th as well as all our other friends 30th bdays we either had people over our home to have some drinks/appetizers OR a few close friends got together for a cheaper dinner...thats just what is usual. I think its VERY nice that her DH wants to make her bday special. But honestly when I opened the evite and saw that he said its $45/per person I was taken aback. I just wouldn't do it. I wouldn't throw a party for my DH unless I was paying for the dinner for everyone. I don't think my post was ridiculous at all. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by MrsPJB2007 Posted by Beth the problem comes from calling it a "party" to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person I would never call that a party I agree with this When I invited friends to come out for DH's birthday -- I said that we were going out for dinner at a restaurant - and I never said it was a 'party' and everyone knows that we are all just doing a GTG at a restaurant and everyone will have their share of the bill. The moment you say its a "surprise party" - I am under the assumption that its being sponsored by the person inviting. My sister had a 30th birthday party her mom and my dad threw for her at a restaurant - the invite clearly stated it was a party and no one had to pay for anything, as they would not have expected to. This is exactly what I meant. When you are invited to a party it usually means the host takes care of expenses..and guests bring gifts of course. This is what made me scratch my head about it. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky. it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife. ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't. I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really. to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE. "a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end. ITA with this, so what if he used the word party. And honestly I would prefer to know the cost beforehand. I think its good planning, now ppl know what to expect. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by maybebaby Posted by MrsPJB2007 Posted by Beth the problem comes from calling it a "party" to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person I would never call that a party I agree with this When I invited friends to come out for DH's birthday -- I said that we were going out for dinner at a restaurant - and I never said it was a 'party' and everyone knows that we are all just doing a GTG at a restaurant and everyone will have their share of the bill. The moment you say its a "surprise party" - I am under the assumption that its being sponsored by the person inviting. My sister had a 30th birthday party her mom and my dad threw for her at a restaurant - the invite clearly stated it was a party and no one had to pay for anything, as they would not have expected to. This is exactly what I meant. When you are invited to a party it usually means the host takes care of expenses..and guests bring gifts of course. This is what made me scratch my head about it. ITA! A party is different then going out to dinner to celebrate someones b-day. maybe he should have just worded it differently! |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Sash Posted by Ophelia I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky. it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife. ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't. I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really. to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE. "a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end. ITA with this, so what if he used the word party. And honestly I would prefer to know the cost beforehand. I think its good planning, now ppl know what to expect. It may be good planning...however it leaves people in an awkward position. Decline and feel badly or accept and pay the money. We are not cheap people at all...but when we go out these days, which is few and far between we spend maybe half that on dinner. Its just a tough time for us. Maybe if money weren't an issue I would't have thought twice?! |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia I don't see the words "free" "taken care of" or "it's on me" ANYWHERE in the definitions for the word "party" below. perhaps we are starting to expect too much. par·ty (pärt) n. pl. par·ties 1. a. A social gathering especially for pleasure or amusement: a cocktail party. b. A group of people who have gathered to participate in an activity. See Synonyms at band2. 2. An established political group organized to promote and support its principles and candidates for public office. 3. a. A person or group involved in an enterprise; a participant or an accessory: I refuse to be a party to your silly scheme. b. Law A person or group involved in a legal proceeding as a litigant. 4. a. A subscriber to a telephone party line. b. A person using a telephone. 5. A person: "And though Grainger was a spry old party, such steps couldn't be his" (Anthony Hyde). 6. A selected group of soldiers: a raiding party. 7. Slang a. An act of sexual intercourse. b. An orgy. adj. 1. Of, relating to, or participating in an established political organization: party members; party politics. 2. Suitable for use at a social gathering: party dresses; a party hat. 3. Characteristic of a pleasurable social gathering: a party atmosphere. intr.v. par·tied, par·ty·ing, par·ties To celebrate or carouse at or as if at a party: That night we partied until dawn. hold on, i have to look up con·de·scend·ing. . .
|
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by maybebaby what is such a shame about this thread?? Honestly...she is a very good friend and I have NO PROBLEM celebrating her bday. but do you see what position these things put people in?? If we don't go I feel badly that we aren't there for her-to be a part of her 30th. HOWEVER....all of us are married w/kids...money is very tight. It also means hiring a babysitter for us as we do not have family close by. So this bday celebration which the DH is throwing turns into a minimum $140 night (give or take). For my 30th and DH's 30th as well as all our other friends 30th bdays we either had people over our home to have some drinks/appetizers OR a few close friends got together for a cheaper dinner...thats just what is usual. I think its VERY nice that her DH wants to make her bday special. But honestly when I opened the evite and saw that he said its $45/per person I was taken aback. I just wouldn't do it. I wouldn't throw a party for my DH unless I was paying for the dinner for everyone. I don't think my post was ridiculous at all. what I find to be a shame about threads like this is that it basically opens a FRIEND of the OP (in this case your friend, or rather, her husband) up to being called TACKY. I think that is kind of ******, to be honest. I COMPLETELY understand money being tight. but he's giving you the option of going or not going. why don't you call him and find out WHY the cost is $45 not including drinks and apps...if he's done a prix fixe, perhaps you can tell him you'll be attending, but going a la carte??? it seems the real issue here is the cost to you-again, understandable..but it would have been the same NO MATTER HOW the evite was worded. whether he said "I'm organizing a GTG" or "let's party on behalf of my wife". otherwise, this thread implies that the IDEA of having a "celebratory group of adults" paying their own way is tacky, which again I will say is beyond ridiculous TO ME. and thankfully, to my friends and my circle as well. ETA: I also think it's sad that we feel we need to cover everyone or we can't have a "party". regardless of what one person can afford, if a person deserves to be celebrated for whatever reason, it deserves to happen. and anyone that loves/cares/wants to celebrate with them should see the event for what it is and do whatever is in THEIR power to celebrate the person, WITHOUT judging the person trying to organize and make it happen. Message edited 2009-09-22 12:26:56.057000. |
Posted 9/22/09 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Tilde hold on, i have to look up con·de·scend·ing. . . while you're at it, look up bi'tchy moo dy and my favorite s'o do'ne bee'ing pre'gn'ant
Message edited 2009-09-22 12:24:31.167000. |
Posted 9/22/09 12:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia Posted by Tilde hold on, i have to look up con·de·scend·ing. . . while you're at it, look up bi'tchy moo dy and my favorite s'o do'ne bee'ing pre'gn'ant |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by maybebaby Posted by Sash Posted by Ophelia I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky. it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife. ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't. I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really. to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE. "a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end. ITA with this, so what if he used the word party. And honestly I would prefer to know the cost beforehand. I think its good planning, now ppl know what to expect. It may be good planning...however it leaves people in an awkward position. Decline and feel badly or accept and pay the money. We are not cheap people at all...but when we go out these days, which is few and far between we spend maybe half that on dinner. Its just a tough time for us. Maybe if money weren't an issue I would't have thought twice?! ok, so he used the wrong choice of words. It seems evident that you are more upset/annoyed about the price per person. If its out of your price range than I would kindly decline and say I had other plans that couldnt be broken. Maybe you cn take your friend out another day or send her a gift. It sucks, but I can totally understand with this economy. Ive turned down my fair share of dinners and event cause we are strapped these days. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Ophelia what I find to be a shame about threads like this is that it basically opens a FRIEND of the OP (in this case your friend, or rather, her husband) up to being called TACKY. I think that is kind of ******, to be honest. I COMPLETELY understand money being tight. but he's giving you the option of going or not going. why don't you call him and find out WHY the cost is $45 not including drinks and apps...if he's done a prix fixe, perhaps you can tell him you'll be attending, but going a la carte??? it seems the real issue here is the cost to you-again, understandable..but it would have been the same NO MATTER HOW the evite was worded. whether he said "I'm organizing a GTG" or "let's party on behalf of my wife". otherwise, this thread implies that the IDEA of having a "celebratory group of adults" paying their own way is tacky, which again I will say is beyond ridiculous TO ME. and thankfully, to my friends and my circle as well. I don't think the issue is that people are saying that a celebratory group of adults paying their way is tacky....that is absolutely not what I think the issue is. Because I know that I find the evite a bit tacky, but I go out with friends all the time and we all pay our way. No one is saying that is the issue. The issue is more about having a pre-set amount for this "prixe-fixe" meal, even after he is covering the appetizers and drinks, and its $45 a person. Perhaps the OP wanted to celebrate with them and not have to shell out a pre-determined amount that is being dictated to them by this invite. Its one thing to ask people to come out and celebrate and you pay for what you have, but to be told "You can come to the party IF you pay $45 a person" comes of as very presumptuous. Maybe the OP would have gone and had a small meal or split an appetizer with her DH just to keep the cost low and still be able to enjoy her time out with her friend for her birthday? I see nothing wrong with that. I would not organize a party where there is a certain amount that people have to pay -- because I don't think that would be fair to the guests. I'd rather they come out--order what they want and if one wants to get a filet mignon and lobster tail - they can pay for that and if a couple just wants a salad and chicken fingers, that's fine too. Its the part of saying "you have to pay $xx amount to be able to celebrate" that is what is bothering people, IMO. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Well if this is acceptable I guess I'll start charging folks that attend our yearly SuperBowl and 4th of July parties. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by MrsPJB2007 Posted by Ophelia what I find to be a shame about threads like this is that it basically opens a FRIEND of the OP (in this case your friend, or rather, her husband) up to being called TACKY. I think that is kind of ******, to be honest. I COMPLETELY understand money being tight. but he's giving you the option of going or not going. why don't you call him and find out WHY the cost is $45 not including drinks and apps...if he's done a prix fixe, perhaps you can tell him you'll be attending, but going a la carte??? it seems the real issue here is the cost to you-again, understandable..but it would have been the same NO MATTER HOW the evite was worded. whether he said "I'm organizing a GTG" or "let's party on behalf of my wife". otherwise, this thread implies that the IDEA of having a "celebratory group of adults" paying their own way is tacky, which again I will say is beyond ridiculous TO ME. and thankfully, to my friends and my circle as well. I don't think the issue is that people are saying that a celebratory group of adults paying their way is tacky....that is absolutely not what I think the issue is. Because I know that I find the evite a bit tacky, but I go out with friends all the time and we all pay our way. No one is saying that is the issue. The issue is more about having a pre-set amount for this "prixe-fixe" meal, even after he is covering the appetizers and drinks, and its $45 a person. Perhaps the OP wanted to celebrate with them and not have to shell out a pre-determined amount that is being dictated to them by this invite. Its one thing to ask people to come out and celebrate and you pay for what you have, but to be told "You can come to the party IF you pay $45 a person" comes of as very presumptuous. Maybe the OP would have gone and had a small meal or split an appetizer with her DH just to keep the cost low and still be able to enjoy her time out with her friend for her birthday? I see nothing wrong with that. I would not organize a party where there is a certain amount that people have to pay -- because I don't think that would be fair to the guests. I'd rather they come out--order what they want and if one wants to get a filet mignon and lobster tail - they can pay for that and if a couple just wants a salad and chicken fingers, that's fine too. Its the part of saying "you have to pay $xx amount to be able to celebrate" that is what is bothering people, IMO. Great points |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by annoyedTTCer Well if this is acceptable I guess I'll start charging folks that attend our yearly SuperBowl and 4th of July parties. Maybe I'll even bill my no good MIL & FIL for Xmas eve at our place.
|
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... I agree that if you are throwing a party for someone you should be paying for it. This is completely different than gettting a group of friends together to celebrate and go to dinner. |
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:38 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by annoyedTTCer Well if this is acceptable I guess I'll start charging folks that attend our yearly SuperBowl and 4th of July parties. Maybe I'll even bill my no good MIL & FIL for Xmas eve at our place. and have Santa send you his dry cleaning bill for when he scoots down your chimney. your extremist answer and sarcasm only makes me feel more right so thank you!!! |
Posted 9/22/09 12:39 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by MrsPJB2007 Its the part of saying "you have to pay $xx amount to be able to celebrate" that is what is bothering people, IMO. but we don't even know he is saying that. we are going by a vent..not even seeing the details of the evite. like I said, it takes a PHONE CALL to the organizer to say "hey, I'd love to come but the prix fixe is too steep, we'd like to order separate from the menu and a la carte" but wait...maybe that would be tacky too! I really don't see the issue. but I guess that is why I disagree. |
Posted 9/22/09 12:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay... Posted by Tilde Posted by Ophelia I don't see the words "free" "taken care of" or "it's on me" ANYWHERE in the definitions for the word "party" below. perhaps we are starting to expect too much. par·ty (pärt) n. pl. par·ties 1. a. A social gathering especially for pleasure or amusement: a cocktail party. b. A group of people who have gathered to participate in an activity. See Synonyms at band2. 2. An established political group organized to promote and support its principles and candidates for public office. 3. a. A person or group involved in an enterprise; a participant or an accessory: I refuse to be a party to your silly scheme. b. Law A person or group involved in a legal proceeding as a litigant. 4. a. A subscriber to a telephone party line. b. A person using a telephone. 5. A person: "And though Grainger was a spry old party, such steps couldn't be his" (Anthony Hyde). 6. A selected group of soldiers: a raiding party. 7. Slang a. An act of sexual intercourse. b. An orgy. adj. 1. Of, relating to, or participating in an established political organization: party members; party politics. 2. Suitable for use at a social gathering: party dresses; a party hat. 3. Characteristic of a pleasurable social gathering: a party atmosphere. intr.v. par·tied, par·ty·ing, par·ties To celebrate or carouse at or as if at a party: That night we partied until dawn. hold on, i have to look up con·de·scend·ing. . . this cracked me up
|
|
Posted 9/22/09 12:43 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30th surprise bday | JennJay41 | 8/1/08 | 3 | Dining In or Out |
| Review of DH's surprise 30th bday party | Pumpkin | 8/20/06 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |













