.

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I just went out for a very good friends of mines birthday & his fiance invited us all out for dinner with a prix fix menu, I didn't think twice about it being tacky...at all & if I didn't want to pay for it I would've just not gone at all.

I did dinner for my sisters 30th, although I didn't tell people the price point, I just said if you'd like to come out to dinner for her birthday please meet us at XXX, if not we'll be here after dinner.

I mean $45 is a lot to ask, yes but I don't think we should be calling this poor guy tacky, maybe they just don't have the money to pay for everyone but he still wanted to give people the option of being able to celebrate his wifes 30th. Maybe he should've had it at his home and provided the food but still maybe they don't have a big enough house....I did that for DH's 30th. I had a surprise party at our house for him, supplied all the food and drinks b/c going out to a restaurant was to expensive

Posted 9/22/09 3:19 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lakadema
LIF Adult

Member since 5/08

1180 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I think that $45 per head is a bit much to ask for. The economy is tough right now and a lot of people may not be able to swing $90 to go out on top of they may have to get a babysitter(don't know if any of you have kids). I know if it were my birthday I would want all my friends to be there, not join in because they couldn't afford it.

I don't know if you are close with him but, maybe you can suggest to him just having appetizers and drinks at someone's house if he doesn't want to(or can't) host at his? Then, get a great cake(or someone can bake). It would be cheaper for everyone all around and probably a lot more fun than sitting at a restaurant.

If I were your friend I would rather all my friends be there than one person missing it because they could not afford it.
Hope that helps!Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 3:34 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I wouldn't think twice about joining someone to celebrate their birthday (and paying our own way) .

Posted 9/22/09 3:34 PM
 

MrsList
Sweet cheeks

Member since 4/09

1696 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Maybe checkout the website of the place and see why it's so much. Or maybe they told him with apps and drinks it was $45 a person and then he just forgot to take it off the top and then give the new price.

We recently went to a party at a bar and it was $30pp but that did include drinks and bartender tip. But it was basically 4 chafing dishes of horrible food (like really bad wedding food), a wilted salad, and some bread. No apps or anything like that. So I could see how it could get up to $45 at an actual restaurant, especially if it's sit down or something special.

Posted 9/22/09 3:43 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I really don't think the issue is paying for one's own plate at the dinner. The issue is with the manner in which the "guests" were invited. That is what could be considered "tacky."

Obviously, the husband wants to have a really nice birthday for his wife, and that's great. But, it sounds like it hit those invited as an out of the blue thing. And to see the price tag in that way is a bit jarring to say the least, particularly since it sounds as though this is out of character for how their group of friends normally celebrates.

If I were trying to plan something similar, I would have called all those who I was planning on inviting and verbally talked out the plan with everyone to make sure they were ok with that, or take into my confidence a few of my spouse' close friends to help plan. That way no one would have been blindsided with what on paper (or in this case email) seems to be a super expensive dinner out with little choice therein after one accepts the invitation. That's probably not a practical thing for the husband in this case, and what's done is done.

But again, I think all of the judgements of tackiness are based in the manner in which people were invited, not necessarily in the concept of having everyone pay for themselves to celebrate a good friend.

jmo.

Posted 9/22/09 3:46 PM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Beth

the problem comes from calling it a "party"

to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift

we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person

I would never call that a party




ITA...I would make it sound much more casual and informal.

Posted 9/22/09 4:03 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

If I throw a party I don't expect anyone to pay for anything...it's my choice to throw the party and invite the people...that's JMO. I think asking people to pay to go to a party is tacky.

I do think his heart is in the right place though and that's what countsChat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 4:14 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Beth

the problem comes from calling it a "party"

to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift

we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person

I would never call that a party



BINGO




Ditto. I'd phrase it as "going out to dinner to celebrate ____'s b-day"

But it wouldn't bother me if I was a guest, I'd go and eat

but I'd be embarrassed if DH did that for me!

Posted 9/22/09 4:30 PM
 

AnnBrunoXO
2 Girls For Me!

Member since 5/05

4377 total posts

Name:
MaMMa

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Its tacky but its happened to us as well.

I could never ask people to pay.

Posted 9/22/09 4:31 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by headoverheels

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.




ITA. Ordinarily, if I'm going to spend $90 on a dinner for myself and DH, you'd better believe it's a special occasion - like an anniversary or something, not my friend's birthday. I'd be way more put off by the expense involved than the way the invite was worded.

Posted 9/22/09 4:42 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by JessInCA

Posted by headoverheels

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.




ITA. Ordinarily, if I'm going to spend $90 on a dinner for myself and DH, you'd better believe it's a special occasion - like an anniversary or something, not my friend's birthday. I'd be way more put off by the expense involved than the way the invite was worded.



Me too. I really wouldn't mind paying, but not this much. I would not attend.

Posted 9/22/09 5:02 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I agree with what a few other have said, the issue lies in calling it a "party"....I think being invited to a party doesn't involve spending money.

Posted 9/22/09 6:06 PM
 

ostrichhh
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

301 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

i would never dream of calling something a party and then asking guests to pay. i am throwing a 30th bday party here at the house for DH this weekend and even when guests asked me if they could bring some food or drinks i said no. to me, "birthday party" means the guests show up are treated to food and drinks, whatever the host sees fit to provide. also, to a party the guests generally bring a gift, making a request for money seem even more tacky.
the only way it is acceptable to ask people to pay, IMO, is to say "we're going here for dinner to celebrate john's birthday and would love if you could join us." i dunno, just what seems right to me.

Posted 9/22/09 6:12 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I can see how calling it a party may confuse a few but I don't see anything tacky about having a birthday celebration and asking people to pay their own way. I doubt if they are asking you to pay your own way they expect a gift, I would just bring a card. Those who want to come out to celebrate will and the rest can stay home.

Posted 9/22/09 6:52 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Ok, here's my feeling: he's a guy just trying to put something together for his wife. He's paying for wine and appetizers, which is probably all her can swing, so it just sounds like he's a stand-up guy that wants his wife to have a nice birthday, but he can't swing the whole thing. There's too many hang-ups in this world about this kind of stuff. It is what it is, and if you don't like it, oh wellChat Icon (that was the general "you", not directed at the OP)

Posted 9/22/09 7:56 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I haven't read each and everyone's reply, but honestly, I think this is pretty much "the norm" nowadays, especially in the NYC area. DH and I have gotten invited to stuff like this where we are told in advance the price per head. If it's too much money we just don't go.

I also think it's really generous that he's paying for drinks at appetizers. A drink tab especially can be pretty darn pricey.

Posted 9/22/09 8:09 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Shelly

Posted by headoverheels

Maureen i totally get that $45 per person is a lot of money if that doesn't even include drinks and appetizers. i agree with Jess - i would ask the person with the biggest pair Chat Icon to find out why it's so expensive.

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.




I agree with this. Its expensive, but not tacky. He (rightfully) doesn't want anyone to feel ambushed when they are there.




ITA with Shelly. At least he had the decency to let everyone know before the bill came Chat Icon

I can see both sides of this argument. We threw huge bashes for my parents (each a special birthday party, and also an anniversary party) and cant fathom having to ask a guest to pay for their night out.
Ive also thrown parties at my local town park, and I insist they keep a tab of my non-residents family's cars so they dont have to pay the $5 parking fee.

and Ive also been to a friends birthday dinner, where people ordered to their hearts content (even a child ordered wayyyy too many things off the menu as if it were make believe & the waitress brought every last thing she ordered, even "the most expensive steak on the menu" Chat Icon) several people had drinks all night, and then 2-3 couples ordered VERY limited, thinking they were keeping to their budget, until they heard the $50pp split of the tab..one girl turned ten shades of red, and was ruffling through her bag for money. I didnt see what winded up happening but I felt terrible for them.
In this case it was person we're close with so we didnt mind at all, but I can totally see where this can get uncomfortable, awkward and just wrong.


But I think the hubby in this post, has all the right intentions Chat Icon
Id rather this scenario than the one I mentioned above.

Message edited 2009-09-22 20:32:28.890000.

Posted 9/22/09 8:28 PM
 

EckoRed81504
We are complete <3

Member since 12/07

6299 total posts

Name:
April

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

We went to a 30th bday and had to pay $25/pp. I had never heard of that before. I threw dh a 30th and wouldn't even dare ask anyone to pay to help me cover the cost. If I'm throwing a party, I'm throwing it....

Posted 9/22/09 8:29 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I don't think it's normal. A friend of ours, his wife had a small (expensive)surprise dinner. I wasn't sure if she would pay or not. she didn't, we all had to pay Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 11:09 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I don't know why everyone is calling it *tacky* b/c it's a *party* when the OP clearly stated that he sent out evites for a birthday DINNER.... Even so... why is it tacky? He's trying to get a group of friends together for his wife... i think offering to pay for drinks is a HUGE deal (considering prices of drinks these days)

I've done this before (not me organizing the dinner though...) If they were a good friend, I would be happy to go out to dinner with them and pay for myself, DH & partly for THEM.

This is not something new to me. We live in nyc.

Perhaps the husband thought you were good enough friends that you wouldn't criticize.

Message edited 2009-09-22 23:25:46.887000.

Posted 9/22/09 11:22 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by EckoRed81504

We went to a 30th bday and had to pay $25/pp. I had never heard of that before. I threw dh a 30th and wouldn't even dare ask anyone to pay to help me cover the cost. If I'm throwing a party, I'm throwing it....



Same here...I would NEVER EVER invite someone to a party (regardless of where it was) and have them pay for it. If he wants everyone to pay for it, he should have definitely worded the invitation differently. Something along the lines of "Please join us for dinner celebration for xyz. Attached is a menu with selections and prices. Please respond by xyz if you can make it". Something like that is a little more acceptable.

Posted 9/22/09 11:30 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I also think it's important to mention again a point people keep missing.........he's a GUY. Not all of them are good at wording and party "etiquette" and all of that. I always find it funny too when people get all riled up about these things, when all along they have a CHOICE to respond with a NO anyways.

Posted 9/23/09 5:39 AM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by lakadema

I think that $45 per head is a bit much to ask for. The economy is tough right now and a lot of people may not be able to swing $90 to go out on top of they may have to get a babysitter(don't know if any of you have kids). I know if it were my birthday I would want all my friends to be there, not join in because they couldn't afford it.

I don't know if you are close with him but, maybe you can suggest to him just having appetizers and drinks at someone's house if he doesn't want to(or can't) host at his? Then, get a great cake(or someone can bake). It would be cheaper for everyone all around and probably a lot more fun than sitting at a restaurant.

If I were your friend I would rather all my friends be there than one person missing it because they could not afford it.
Hope that helps!Chat Icon



ITA with everything. so true.
and im sure many people got her gifts as well if it's a milestone birthday.

Posted 9/23/09 6:44 AM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Ophelia

I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky.

it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife.


ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't.

I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really.

to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE.

"a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end.



ITA! In my group of friends it's always pay your own way and chip in for the guest of honor.
I would NEVER be offended to chip in for my FRIEND.

Posted 9/23/09 8:33 AM
 

bride07
Ava Rose you are an angel!!!

Member since 3/09

6115 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...


That is just tacky!!!! If you are throwing a surprise party - then you are supppose to pay. If they wanted to friends to pay for themselves....THEN that should be her friends's decisions to take her out for a birthday dinner.

I had a friend do a similiar thing ( she wanted a surprise party) DH threw it and then we alll paid for whatever we ordered. I know we all thought it was a bit tacky.

If you can't pay for it- then don't throw it!


P.S It is ok to treat your friends for dinner. I do every year with my girlfriends. However it should be our offer and suggestion.

Message edited 2009-09-23 08:53:23.620000.

Posted 9/23/09 8:51 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
30th surprise bday JennJay41 8/1/08 3 Dining In or Out
Review of DH's surprise 30th bday party Pumpkin 8/20/06 8 Families Helping Families ™