Re: .
Posted 9/23/2009 11:57:21 AM by Shelly


Posted by Goobster


I think there is a VERY big difference if your friend pulls together a bunch of friends to go out for your birthday, to celebrate you, and everyone paying their own way. But for someone to say to their friends "HEY, it's my birthday. Let's go celebrate me" and then to send out invites, etc but expect people to pay their own way is quite different(and odds are you will be getting gifts small or not), I find that uncool and crossing a line...

I know people who do this, and YES, they DO expect gifts. And then they have hte nerve when people give them crappy gifts too...I know this isn't everyone but the people I know who liek to organize their own birthday bashes, this is how they are.

I would never in a million years organize my own birthday bash unless I was going to foot the bill. But that's just me I guess. If another friend surprised me and got all our friends together, that would fall into a totally different category.

JMO I guess



Well your friends are different that mine I guess. We are all very casual. We will organize our own birthday event- and just send an email. Its rarely dinner- and usually brunch or drinks. Its just the way we are- and everyone expects to pay their own way. Its never been an issue. Maybe because we're causal- or maybe because its never an expensive place- but its the way we've been doing things for years.

Before kids we'd have people over at our apartments (we live in the city)- but now with kids- we really don't because the kids are sleeping.


Now that we're getting older, sometimes someone's spouse will foot the bill, but we always come willing to pay. Why shouldn't we celebrate someone's birthday because they can't foot the bill for everyone.

Call it a party, dinner, whatever- for us, its a gathering of friends which- these days with work and kids- is tough to come by. We're just all happy to get together, see each other and catch up. To celebrate someone's birthday is special- and we all enjoy it.

But no one expects a gift, and certainly no one would ever comment on a gift being crappy. That is tacky!


Print Post      Close Window