Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...
Posted 9/23/2009 9:38:40 AM by maybebaby


Posted by Goobster


Posted by quasi3


Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



I understand what your saying but I disagee.

If he is calling it a party then he should be paying.

If he is unable to afford to pay the full expense, then he should not be having a party out for her.

My dh is going to be 30 soon and if I can't save up for a party he will be having one at the house.

This puts people in a weird situation. What if some of the guests could not afford to go?

For the record I have gone to a few birthdays where we had to pay, but it was never said to be a party.



To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....



This is all I meant, you summed it up.

I love how I was told I wasnt a good friend for using the word "tacky". Whatever. I don't need to prove on LIF that i'm a great friend...maybe it was the wrong word, i even stated that earlier...I just know that if MY husband did the same thing for me I'd be a bit embarrased that he asked people to pay. I would think the gesture was sweet...and that he didn't do it thinking it was putting anyone in a bad position, but I'd still be embarrased.


Print Post      Close Window