.

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

.

thanks for the replies. didn't expect as many as i got and didn't think some people would take the post so personally!! i of course meant no harm!

Message edited 2009-09-23 09:41:03.033000.

Posted 9/22/09 8:38 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

k-diggity
stay classy.......

Member since 6/08

1332 total posts

Name:
: )

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

that's tacky IMO

Posted 9/22/09 8:40 AM
 

quasi3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

1764 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I think it is tacky to invite people to a party and expect them to pay.

He should have just asked if anyone was interested in getting together for dinner at a resturant.

I would go, but I think it is very strange and he will probably be in trouble when your friend finds out about the details! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-09-22 08:41:32.800000.

Posted 9/22/09 8:41 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by quasi3

I think it is tacky to invite people to a party and expect them to pay.

He should have just asked if anyone was interested in getting together for dinner at a resturant.

I would go, but I think it is very strange and he will probably be in trouble when your friend finds out about the details! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with this. If he had called us a few days before her bday and asked if we wanted to get together for dinner that is one thing. but this is a party he is throwing...I would kill DH if he did that!!!

Posted 9/22/09 8:44 AM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

we're doing this for my DHs 30th on saturday. I asked everybody to go out to dinner, and let them know the cost per person. i think in your case, its not so much that hes asking everybody to pay, but $45 is a lot to ask people to spend!! ( for DHs, its $22 a person)
this is just how our group always does stuff- we each pay our own way... its more just going out to dinner together and saying " h appy birthday" to the person, rather than a "party".... we only have like 20 people coming, so it wouldn't have been a ton of money for me to pay for everybody... BUT we're also trying to save to adopt a baby, so its hard... maybe your friend and DH have some kind of situation like that going on.
also, we're a realy close group so i kind of know everybody's situation- nobody has lost their jobs recently or anything, so its not like paying would keep anybody from coming... if that was the case, i would pay for them, just so they could be there.

Posted 9/22/09 8:53 AM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I don't know what their economic status is, but I know mine is not up to paying for a huge party for a lot of people. I think the price high if he is paying for drinks and apps though.

Posted 9/22/09 8:56 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

it depends... in NYC it's pretty much the norm- although for my birthday party my DH, Mom & Dad all picked up the tab for everyone (it wasn't a huge amount of people- more like 15 or so).

Posted 9/22/09 8:56 AM
 

JBmommy
LIF Infant

Member since 8/09

252 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.

Posted 9/22/09 9:08 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Sassyz75

it depends... in NYC it's pretty much the norm- although for my birthday party my DH, Mom & Dad all picked up the tab for everyone (it wasn't a huge amount of people- more like 15 or so).




This is what I was going to say. I threw a 30th for DH (FH at the time) and it was going to be like $30 per head for drinks and apps. ILs ended up paying the bill because they felt weird about it.

Posted 9/22/09 9:18 AM
 

quasi3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

1764 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



I understand what your saying but I disagee.

If he is calling it a party then he should be paying.

If he is unable to afford to pay the full expense, then he should not be having a party out for her.

My dh is going to be 30 soon and if I can't save up for a party he will be having one at the house.

This puts people in a weird situation. What if some of the guests could not afford to go?

For the record I have gone to a few birthdays where we had to pay, but it was never said to be a party.

Posted 9/22/09 9:22 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by quasi3

I think it is tacky to invite people to a party and expect them to pay.

He should have just asked if anyone was interested in getting together for dinner at a resturant.

I would go, but I think it is very strange and he will probably be in trouble when your friend finds out about the details! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with this. If he had called us a few days before her bday and asked if we wanted to get together for dinner that is one thing. but this is a party he is throwing...I would kill DH if he did that!!!



ITA. I would be mortified if someone made a party for me and asked everyone to chip in like that. I think the better option would be to invite less people or only serve drinks & appetizers instead of a whole dinner.

Posted 9/22/09 9:23 AM
 

quasi3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

1764 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Christine

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by quasi3

I think it is tacky to invite people to a party and expect them to pay.

He should have just asked if anyone was interested in getting together for dinner at a resturant.

I would go, but I think it is very strange and he will probably be in trouble when your friend finds out about the details! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with this. If he had called us a few days before her bday and asked if we wanted to get together for dinner that is one thing. but this is a party he is throwing...I would kill DH if he did that!!!



ITA. I would be mortified if someone made a party for me and asked everyone to chip in like that. I think the better option would be to invite less people or only serve drinks & appetizers instead of a whole dinner.




ITA

Posted 9/22/09 9:24 AM
 

theburbshereicome
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/08

885 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Tacky. Tacky. Tacky.

I get that times are tough for some, and people need to adapt to having less.

That being said, if you can't afford a party do not have one. If I could only afford to have drinks and apps, then I would host a simple cocktail party. I would stick with my budget and not expect people to pay for something I want to throw my DH.

Posted 9/22/09 9:28 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Christine

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by quasi3

I think it is tacky to invite people to a party and expect them to pay.

He should have just asked if anyone was interested in getting together for dinner at a resturant.

I would go, but I think it is very strange and he will probably be in trouble when your friend finds out about the details! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with this. If he had called us a few days before her bday and asked if we wanted to get together for dinner that is one thing. but this is a party he is throwing...I would kill DH if he did that!!!



ITA. I would be mortified if someone made a party for me and asked everyone to chip in like that. I think the better option would be to invite less people or only serve drinks & appetizers instead of a whole dinner.




ITA, I would be SO embarassed if DH did this for me, even though he means well!

I would much rather something like "hey we are going to be at XYZ lounge at 8PM, hope you can all come to celebrate!"

and its so expensive too!

Posted 9/22/09 9:30 AM
 

TotallyTrying
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

121 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



ITA.

Our friend graduated with his MBA and his DW did this and we all went and paid.

I thought nothing of it

Posted 9/22/09 9:32 AM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

tacky, and not technically "correct" per etiquette.

Posted 9/22/09 9:49 AM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Tacky IMO

Posted 9/22/09 9:52 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I'm torn on this... I just went out to dinner for a friend's birthday and it cost DH and I $85 EACH because of the 4 bottles of wine that some people ordered that we did not drink...

I think your friend's DH should not have called it a party - he should asked everyone if they wanted to go out to dinner to celebrate because I think that implies everyone pays their own way.

Posted 9/22/09 9:55 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by JBmommy

I dont think it is tacky, he is trying to do something special for his wife, YOUR friend and maybe he can not afford to pay for everyone's meal. I honestly wouldnt think twice about it.



Then he should pay for whatever celebration he arranges.

If he can't afford $45 a head he could pick a cheaper place or cut down the invite list.

This is very tacky.

Posted 9/22/09 10:06 AM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by k-diggity

that's tacky IMO



I also agree

Posted 9/22/09 10:14 AM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I do not know that I am so put off by it. In my group of friends, when celebrating birthdays and such, we usually do pay for ourselves and then we all chip in for the cost of the birthday person. In this case, the DH likely wanted to get his wife's friends together to celebrate. I reserve judgment on the per person cost because I do not know where it is being held.

Posted 9/22/09 10:21 AM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I think it is poor ettiquette as well. There are PLENTY of places where he could have hosted a simple cocktail party for less $, or he could have done something more informal at home.

Throwing a party and expecting others to pay is the essential issue, and I do think it is tacky.

Posted 9/22/09 10:24 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I cannot fathom why it would be considered tacky.

it's a bday party for an adult at a restaurant, not a child at McDonalds. this is how my friends and I always operate...we all pay our own way and chip in for the celebrant, regardless of who sent out the evite. I think it's actually NICE of the husband to be covering ANY part of the meal...and gesture no doubt on his part for his wife.


ETA: it appears the evite was pretty clear about what it would cost those that wanted to attend....so it's quite simple...go if you can swing it, send a card and a rain check if you can't.

I am always so put off by threads like this. it's such a shame really.

to ME, the word "party" implies FUN TIME, not necessarily FREE RIDE.

"a dinner party in honor of Jane" does not say to me that I am not paying. it says to me that I am invited to a special event in honor of Jane. period. the end.

Message edited 2009-09-22 11:39:03.373000.

Posted 9/22/09 11:34 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

the problem comes from calling it a "party"

to me that implies as a guest- you are not paying- but bringing a gift

we normally do group dinner for friends b-days - where every pays for themselves and then splits the cost of the bday person

I would never call that a party

Posted 9/22/09 11:36 AM
 

MrsList
Sweet cheeks

Member since 4/09

1696 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

If I'm invited to a restaurant for any function, I always assume that I will be paying for myself and usually expect to be splitting it X ways if it's a large group. If I couldnt' afford it, I just wouldn't go and I would send her a gift with my apologies instead.

If the $45/$90 is a lot of money, just don't bring a gift or bring something small, just a card and maybe flowers or a bottle of wine.

Posted 9/22/09 11:40 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
30th surprise bday JennJay41 8/1/08 3 Dining In or Out
Review of DH's surprise 30th bday party Pumpkin 8/20/06 8 Families Helping Families ™