.

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6

vicky1125
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/08

767 total posts

Name:
Victoria

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

i see nothing wrong with this but that's probably cause i'm russian. whenever someone throws a party at a russian restaurant, the guests always bring an envelope. the person throwing the event orders the food (banquet style) and the guests usually assume the price per head and try to cover themselves. the person who threw the event pays the bill and the envelopes are gifts. i guess that's just our culture.

but whenever we're invited for dinner for a bday celebration we always assume that we're paying for ourselves.

Posted 9/22/09 12:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Its the part of saying "you have to pay $xx amount to be able to celebrate" that is what is bothering people, IMO.




but we don't even know he is saying that. we are going by a vent..not even seeing the details of the evite.

like I said, it takes a PHONE CALL to the organizer to say "hey, I'd love to come but the prix fixe is too steep, we'd like to order separate from the menu and a la carte" but wait...maybe that would be tacky too!Chat Icon

I really don't see the issue. but I guess that is why I disagree.




Well as a guest, I think it would feel a bit uncomfortable to have to make that phone call to him, and even embarassing to say "Yeah thats a lot for us" - who wants to come out and say that to someone when he clearly wanted the party to go the way he planned with everyone paying their way?

So now the OP will be uncomfortable/embarrassed calling the husband throwing the party, and chances are he will feel a bit uncomfy as well receiving that phone call. Hence why I see her venting, cause it puts him in an awkward situation cause if she wants it a la carte, there might be others who want it a la carte too and his whole "party" could start to unravel.

I could see why she might not want to call and ask him straight out about the amount.

Posted 9/22/09 12:49 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Funny, I thought the definition of a GUEST was:

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.

Maybe I'm confused. Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 12:52 PM
 

Ali1
Mommy

Member since 8/05

3116 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I have been invited to a number of things like this either by the person who's birthday it is ($30 open bar type thing) a dinner and a party.

I don't find the $30 open bar thing tacky. You can go or not go and no one is really expected to bring a gift. You go, pay $30 and celebrate with yoru friend.

I threw my DH a surprise 30th bday party and paid for it all and it was expensive, but I in no way expected to have people pay. Almost everyone who came brought a brithday gift.

I have also been invited to a brithday dinner and was under the assumption that it was being paid for my the spouse of the brithday person so we brought a gift and needless to say it was one of the most expensive friend birthdays I ever went to.

So I think the DH in this case is being good with telling you what you have to pay, but I just think if you go, you are not expected to bring a gift. Seems expensive, but you also have the right to say no. Times are tough....

Posted 9/22/09 12:59 PM
 

Pumpkin
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3353 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I have been invited to parties like this and it is tacky IMO. When I gave my DH his suprise party. It was pricey but my choice to have the party so IMO it was my responsibilty to pay.

Posted 9/22/09 1:05 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Jennie0898

Funny, I thought the definition of a GUEST was:

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.

Maybe I'm confused. Chat Icon



here is the rest of it.

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.
2. One to whom entertainment or hospitality has been extended by another in the role of host or hostess, as at a party.
3. One who pays for meals or accommodations at a restaurant, hotel, or other establishment; a patron
4. A distinguished visitor to whom the hospitality of an institution, city, or government is extended.
5. A visiting performer, speaker, or contestant, as on a radio or television program.
6. Zoology A commensal organism, especially an insect that lives in the nest or burrow of another species.

maybe it's not so strange, after all.
Chat Icon unless restaurant owners are tacky too for making "guests" pay. Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 1:10 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Jennie0898

Funny, I thought the definition of a GUEST was:

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.

Maybe I'm confused. Chat Icon



here is the rest of it.

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.
2. One to whom entertainment or hospitality has been extended by another in the role of host or hostess, as at a party.
3. One who pays for meals or accommodations at a restaurant, hotel, or other establishment; a patron
4. A distinguished visitor to whom the hospitality of an institution, city, or government is extended.
5. A visiting performer, speaker, or contestant, as on a radio or television program.
6. Zoology A commensal organism, especially an insect that lives in the nest or burrow of another species.

maybe it's not so strange, after all.
Chat Icon unless restaurant owners are tacky too for making "guests" pay. Chat Icon



number 3 pertains to a guest a hotel or restaurant not at a party or event...number 1 or 2 is the valid example for this situation

Posted 9/22/09 1:13 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

I don't think it's "tacky" because he's being upfront about the cost.

I definitely wouldn't call to say I couldn't afford it though either.

I'd either a) save so both my DH and I could go, b) go solo b/c it's MY friend, or c) decline.

It would be tacky if he sent out the invite and sprung it upon the guests AT the restaurant.



Posted 9/22/09 1:19 PM
 

JP826
=)

Member since 9/06

10903 total posts

Name:
Me!! All about ME!

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

When my friends go out to celebrate a b-day, we all divide the bill by the amount of people that came, minus the birthday boy/girl.

This is just how it has always been with us.

Posted 9/22/09 1:28 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Maybe tacky is the wrong word. Because his heart is in a good place and I really think he's just clueless.

HOWEVER..to clear up confusion...

This is not a thing where a few people are going to dinner. This is a full out party thrown by HIM inviting over 20 people (I didn't count but it was well around 25-30 people).

If someone is throwing a party, I just feel it should be covered by the person throwing it..I threw my mom a 50th bday this past summer and would never dream of asking people to pay. Nor would I do that for any other event..

Just my own opinion.

Posted 9/22/09 1:37 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...


Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Jennie0898

Funny, I thought the definition of a GUEST was:

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.

Maybe I'm confused. Chat Icon



here is the rest of it.

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.
2. One to whom entertainment or hospitality has been extended by another in the role of host or hostess, as at a party.
3. One who pays for meals or accommodations at a restaurant, hotel, or other establishment; a patron
4. A distinguished visitor to whom the hospitality of an institution, city, or government is extended.
5. A visiting performer, speaker, or contestant, as on a radio or television program.
6. Zoology A commensal organism, especially an insect that lives in the nest or burrow of another species.

maybe it's not so strange, after all.
Chat Icon unless restaurant owners are tacky too for making "guests" pay. Chat Icon



I like the idea of performing (number 5) or burrowing (number 6) for my mealsChat Icon

I think whether or not this is acceptable/tacky depends on what is the norm with your group.

If your group typically gets together for b-days and everyone split the bill, then I don't see an issue with this.

However, if your group usually has a traditional party with a host who pays, then I would be put off by this as well.

As for the $45 pp price tag-I would also go by what the norm is for your group. If you usually spend $20pp, then yes, I see the issue.



Posted 9/22/09 1:38 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

This doesn't sit well with me. I threw a 40th for DH and I never in a gazillion years would expect my guests to pay.

If it were a dinner out with friends to celebrate that's one thing. But this is borderlining on inappropriate.

What if you and DH went for drinks and appys and left before dinner? Then give a gift and leave? Sounds crappy too.

I would go if I could afford it. If not, decline and take them out another time if it bothers you so much.

Posted 9/22/09 1:41 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Between this thread and the one on the parenting board (yes I was lurkingChat Icon) it's been quite a day here!

I agree with Ophelia. For a gathering at a restaurant I would expect to pay.

Posted 9/22/09 1:44 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by MrsPJB2007

[





The issue is more about having a pre-set amount for this "prixe-fixe" meal, even after he is covering the appetizers and drinks, and its $45 a person.
Its the part of saying "you have to pay $xx amount to be able to celebrate" that is what is bothering people, IMO.



ITA with this! i think he should have given you options for food/ how much you want to pay...
i posted about DHs party, and that i told everyone it would be $22 a person. BUT, his is at a Brazilian steakhouse, and they have Rodiziio ( all you can eat meat, basically) for $22 a person... so i told people that if they want rodizio, thats $22 a person.... they're more than welcome to order something else off of the regular menu, or just get an appetizer or something instead...

Posted 9/22/09 1:49 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Jennie0898

Funny, I thought the definition of a GUEST was:

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.

Maybe I'm confused. Chat Icon



here is the rest of it.

guest (gst)
n.
1. One who is a recipient of hospitality at the home or table of another.
2. One to whom entertainment or hospitality has been extended by another in the role of host or hostess, as at a party.
3. One who pays for meals or accommodations at a restaurant, hotel, or other establishment; a patron
4. A distinguished visitor to whom the hospitality of an institution, city, or government is extended.
5. A visiting performer, speaker, or contestant, as on a radio or television program.
6. Zoology A commensal organism, especially an insect that lives in the nest or burrow of another species.

maybe it's not so strange, after all.
Chat Icon unless restaurant owners are tacky too for making "guests" pay. Chat Icon



Sorry darling, I would have replied sooner but I posted and then scooted to lunch.

I didn't include the one you referenced b/c it really doesn't pertain to this situation.

The 3rd definition is the description of a patron, not friends being invited as guests to a "party".

But to your point, there are people who are inviteds as guests of the owner of a restaurant and they do not pay for their meal or drinks, since they're a guest of the owner. So I suppose there are times where #3 wouldn't apply either. Not to mention then the owner of said restaurant would certainly not be considered tacky in the least bit!! Chat Icon

Sorry honey, I just had to press your big old preggo button... I couldn't resist. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 2:23 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

The title of this thread states that the OP was invited to a 'dinner', not a 'party'

So there should be no confusion on anyone's part as to if it's tacky or not.

it's not

The person who sent out the invite didn't say "come to a party at the restaurant", he said "come to a dinner", which clearly implies that everyone pays for themselves and chips in for the guest of honor.
Frankly, that he's even chipping in for everyone's drinks and apps is generous IMO.

A few years back, i organized a dinner for my DH for his birthday - everyone who could afford to go went and paid for themselves and a portion of his meal. Anyone else who couldn't afford it or didn't want to go met us at a bar after.

There's nothing tacky at all about it and i hate seeing everyone's responses like some grave sin has been committed.

Posted 9/22/09 2:24 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

The specifics just in case anyone cares ..


The evite went out to 34 people.

The wording is:

SHHHHHH! It's a Surprise Party!!

***is turning 30! Please join us at *** in Old Town at 8pm on October 24th to celebrate her special day. I will cover the cost of appetizers and drinks. The price per person is $45 which can be paid on the day of the party-please don't send anything in the mail as I'd like to keep this a surprise. Hope to see you all there!! I've included hotel accomodations below in case anyone is interested in making a weekend out of it.


So there you go..that is the invite. Like I said...we will go and have fun, I love my friend very much I just thought it wasn't right to throw a party and ask for money. I know I'm not the only one who thinks that way-I got an email from 3 friends so far saying "$45pp???? Are you going?". So i'm not alone...

Posted 9/22/09 2:25 PM
 

quasi3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

1764 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by maybebaby

The specifics just in case anyone cares ..


The evite went out to 34 people.

The wording is:

SHHHHHH! It's a Surprise Party!!

***is turning 30! Please join us at *** in Old Town at 8pm on October 24th to celebrate her special day. I will cover the cost of appetizers and drinks. The price per person is $45 which can be paid on the day of the party-please don't send anything in the mail as I'd like to keep this a surprise. Hope to see you all there!! I've included hotel accomodations below in case anyone is interested in making a weekend out of it.


So there you go..that is the invite. Like I said...we will go and have fun, I love my friend very much I just thought it wasn't right to throw a party and ask for money. I know I'm not the only one who thinks that way-I got an email from 3 friends so far saying "$45pp???? Are you going?". So i'm not alone...



Tacky!

If apps and drinks he is paying for what are you eating for $45 pp? seems a bit much!

Message edited 2009-09-22 14:28:44.330000.

Posted 9/22/09 2:27 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Otherme

The title of this thread states that the OP was invited to a 'dinner', not a 'party'

So there should be no confusion on anyone's part as to if it's tacky or not.

it's not

The person who sent out the invite didn't say "come to a party at the restaurant", he said "come to a dinner", which clearly implies that everyone pays for themselves and chips in for the guest of honor.
Frankly, that he's even chipping in for everyone's drinks and apps is generous IMO.

A few years back, i organized a dinner for my DH for his birthday - everyone who could afford to go went and paid for themselves and a portion of his meal. Anyone else who couldn't afford it or didn't want to go met us at a bar after.

There's nothing tacky at all about it and i hate seeing everyone's responses like some grave sin has been committed.



I wrote out exactly what he said...I wrote "dinner" in my post b/c I had just read the evite and it said dinner. But it does say "party" at the top. But is a surprise dinner with over 30 people really differnet from a party?? I don't really think so...

Posted 9/22/09 2:28 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by Otherme

The title of this thread states that the OP was invited to a 'dinner', not a 'party'

So there should be no confusion on anyone's part as to if it's tacky or not.

it's not

The person who sent out the invite didn't say "come to a party at the restaurant", he said "come to a dinner", which clearly implies that everyone pays for themselves and chips in for the guest of honor.
Frankly, that he's even chipping in for everyone's drinks and apps is generous IMO.

A few years back, i organized a dinner for my DH for his birthday - everyone who could afford to go went and paid for themselves and a portion of his meal. Anyone else who couldn't afford it or didn't want to go met us at a bar after.

There's nothing tacky at all about it and i hate seeing everyone's responses like some grave sin has been committed.



I wrote out exactly what he said...I wrote "dinner" in my post b/c I had just read the evite and it said dinner. But it does say "party" at the top. But is a surprise dinner with over 30 people really differnet from a party?? I don't really think so...



I don't think the number of people attending has anything to do with it.
I think all of this could be easily cleared up by a quick phone call to the husband. Just say you were confused by the evite and you wanted to ask if there was an option to order ala carte instead of paying $45 a person since that's a lot of $$ for you guys. In these times i think its perfectly understandable to be concerned about how much $$ you're spending - and $130 for a night out for you and DH is a lot of money.
He should understand that - and if as you say, you had other friends question it also, i bet he's already gotten similar phone calls.
Poor guy, all he's trying to do is organize a party to celebrate his wife's birthday and he's been vilified by an online chat board! Chat Icon
i certainly hope his wife doesn't hear about any of this Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 2:38 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Jennie0898

Sorry honey, I just had to press your big old preggo button... I couldn't resist. Chat Icon Chat Icon



could you make it the "eject" button. that would be AWESOME. Chat Icon Chat Icon

to the OP, I REALLY understand where you are coming from pricewise. is there ANYONE that is close enough or feels comfortable enough with the husband to maybe talk to him about this.

I DO agree that it IS expensive if apps and drinks are being taken care of...unless this place is UBER swanky.

I would have no issue calling and being like "dude, what is this exactly" but I am a terrible person Chat Icon but if it's something completely OUT of the norm for your circle, maybe someone should get to the bottom of it.

it could very well be that this was her dream restaurant, but things are tight for them right now too so this is the only way he could figure it out, you know.....

ftr, I am a very generous host/hostess Chat Icon I don't charge people when they come over for thanksgiving dinner...even though my stuffing is so good, I should! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 2:40 PM
 

hunnybunnyxoxo
this is what it's all about

Member since 11/07

3321 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

i dont think it's tacky.

i think he really meant well by it and he told everyone upfront the cost. it's not like he was going to ambush people with a bill at the end of the night.

Posted 9/22/09 2:51 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Maureen i totally get that $45 per person is a lot of money if that doesn't even include drinks and appetizers. i agree with Jess - i would ask the person with the biggest pair Chat Icon to find out why it's so expensive.

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.

i hope your friend isn't embarrassed by this! Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/09 2:54 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by headoverheels

Maureen i totally get that $45 per person is a lot of money if that doesn't even include drinks and appetizers. i agree with Jess - i would ask the person with the biggest pair Chat Icon to find out why it's so expensive.

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.




I agree with this. Its expensive, but not tacky. He (rightfully) doesn't want anyone to feel ambushed when they are there.

Posted 9/22/09 3:13 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...

Posted by Ophelia
could you make it the "eject" button. that would be AWESOME. Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ok, seriously, I almost spit my water out on my computer when I read this b/c I pictured a baby being launched into the air from you. It was quite a visual, thanks for the laugh! Chat Icon

Posted by Ophelia
to the OP, I REALLY understand where you are coming from pricewise. is there ANYONE that is close enough or feels comfortable enough with the husband to maybe talk to him about this.

I DO agree that it IS expensive if apps and drinks are being taken care of...unless this place is UBER swanky.

I would have no issue calling and being like "dude, what is this exactly" but I am a terrible person Chat Icon but if it's something completely OUT of the norm for your circle, maybe someone should get to the bottom of it.

it could very well be that this was her dream restaurant, but things are tight for them right now too so this is the only way he could figure it out, you know.....

ftr, I am a very generous host/hostess Chat Icon I don't charge people when they come over for thanksgiving dinner...even though my stuffing is so good, I should! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Honestly, I think this is a really good idea. I too an a "terrible friend" b/c I have a pretty big mouth and would approach this the same way.

If you're that close with this couple maybe you could talk to the Dh and explain that you'd love to come but it's a little pricy. Do you know if anyone else was taken aback by the cost?

Maybe you could explain to him that the cost is possibly prohibiting people from coming to his wife's birthday shin dig and maybe he could reconsider the place or who knows...

Just a thought.

Message edited 2009-09-22 15:30:37.000000.

Posted 9/22/09 3:15 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
30th surprise bday JennJay41 8/1/08 3 Dining In or Out
Review of DH's surprise 30th bday party Pumpkin 8/20/06 8 Families Helping Families ™