Re: .
Posted 9/23/2009 11:47:29 AM by Goobster


Posted by Shelly


Posted by Goobster

To me, if you can't afford to THROW a party yourself and invite people, then don't get together for a "birthday". Just get together on another night, where it's NO ONE"S birthday and pay your own way then. This way NO ONE feels obligated to bring a gift, etc.

When you invite people together for your birthday or spouse's birthday, then you are setting people up to possibly feel obligated to give you a gift. And then to ask them to pay too....



Yikes! I think that's a bit harsh. To tell someone they shouldn't get together with their friends on their birthday because they can't afford to pay for everyone is a little much.

I've thrown myself countless parties and certainly don't expect to pay for everyone's drinks. We usually do a pre-party at my place and then head to a bar/club for the night where everyone pays for what they drink. Its what we all do and its never been an issue for anyone. We've been doing this since we were students. What, when your in grad school your supposed to take all your friends out for YOUR birthday? Even brunch with the girls - we always take the birthday girl out and pay our own way.

On the flip side- no one really gets each other gifts in my circle of friends.



I dont think it's harsh. Maybe you aren't seeing my point. A tradition of a few friends going out on birthdays and paying for themselves and the birthday person, thats one thing. But organizing a large gathering or party, for yourself, when others in the group dont do that, thats where the difference comes in.

I think there is a VERY big difference if your friend pulls together a bunch of friends to go out for your birthday, to celebrate you, and everyone paying their own way. But for someone to say to their friends "HEY, it's my birthday. Let's go celebrate me" and then to send out invites, etc but expect people to pay their own way is quite different(and odds are you will be getting gifts small or not), I find that uncool and crossing a line...

I know people who do this, and YES, they DO expect gifts. And then they have the nerve to complain when people give them inexpensive gifts too...I know this isn't everyone but the people I know who like to organize their own birthday bashes, this is how they are. They like attention and yes, they certainly enjoy getting gifts if that comes along with the night out.

I would never in a million years organize my own birthday bash unless I was going to foot the bill. But that's just me I guess. If another friend surprised me and got all our friends together, that would fall into a totally different category.

JMO I guess



Print Post      Close Window