Is this rude?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

I'm a vegetarian. If someone wanted to bring turkey to a Thanksgiving meal that I spent all day (probably 2 days) preparing, taking into account that meat-eating family would be there so I'd probably make TONS of dishes of all sorts to please everyone... yes, I'd "let" them eat the turkey because *I'M* not rude. But I'd be steaming mad. Vegetarianism is a choice. Just like you have a choice to stay home and eat your traditional turkey dinner.

Let's say your MIL is a terrible cook, and she invites you over for pot roast. Do you accept her offer, and then show up with a leg of lamb and eat that instead, because you don't like her pot roast? No. You either don't go, or you eat the side dishes and thank her for inviting you over, because having dinner with family is about the sharing, and the company. And yes, in many cases, the food is the best part, but who's to say her veggie Thanksgiving won't be delicious?

I realize you want your family to have a "traditional" Thanksgiving, but I haven't eaten turkey in 10 years and I promise you, I don't enjoy Thanksgiving any less.



Honestly, I don't think you have read anything I have said.

I was going to call and ask her months before the holiday as to not have her do a ton of stuff, I would NEVER show up at her house with a turkey. Please read what I have said.

ETA: AND I have said over and over on this post that seeing them is WAY more important to me than eating turkey.

Message edited 2008-09-13 12:27:23.147000.

Posted 9/13/08 12:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I read it. I guess what I was trying to say was that calling and asking to bring a turkey would be offensive to me. Not as offensive as just showing up with one, surely, but I would be offended for the same reason.

The title of this thread is "Is this rude?" I'm saying, "yes, it is."

Message edited 2008-09-13 12:29:11.830000.

Posted 9/13/08 12:28 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

I read it. I guess what I was trying to say was that calling and asking to bring a turkey would be offensive to me. Not as offensive as just showing up with one, surely, but I would be offended for the same reason.

The title of this thread is "Is this rude?" I'm saying, "yes, it is."



Wow. No offense, but it seems like you are looking for things to get offended aboutChat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 12:32 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?

Posted 9/13/08 12:40 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I could see how it could be offensive. Chances are that someone who is vegan, will not want meat cooked in thier oven. Being a vegan is pretty extreme.

The first thing I would ask is what could I bring.

If she doesn't say something like "turkey" or anything meat based, just let her know its your family tradition to eat turkey, but want to be respectful of her home and her traditions. Tell her you understand if she is not comfortable with this and of course want to be respectful of her house rules, but since youa re family and love her, you feel comfortable enough to ask if you could cook a turkey at her house. And tell her you understand if she isn't, but you thought you would ask.

Posted 9/13/08 12:41 PM
 

Babe49
M...

Member since 4/08

1880 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Is this rude?

I don't know your SIL obviously, but I don't think the asking her part is rude at all. Maybe if you just showed up with turkey it may look rude, but asking her is actually being polite, not rude. KWIM?

Posted 9/13/08 2:44 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Is this rude?

I know some of the supermarkets have the pre made turkeys. You do have to order it early though.

Posted 9/13/08 2:55 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by Babe49

I don't know your SIL obviously, but I don't think the asking her part is rude at all. Maybe if you just showed up with turkey it may look rude, but asking her is actually being polite, not rude. KWIM?


ITA! You're family...why would it EVER be rude to call and ask something like that? Personally, I don't think it's as big a deal as everyone's making out to be.

You want to make sure, so calling is the proper thing to do! End of story.

Moving on.

Posted 9/13/08 4:20 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by BunnyWife

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.



Noooo - tofurkey tastes nothing like turkey - I like tofurkey slices, but the tough little football thats avialable on thanksgiving is gross!!!!Chat Icon

ETA - if we were hosting thanksgiving, we wouldn't have turkey. Sorry Chat Icon We would have lots of yummy stuff, but not turkey.



I've only had the slices! Thought they were yummy but I'll eat just about anything veg! I'll avoid the footballChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 4:39 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Is this rude?

IMO, yes it's rude.

thanksgiving is for family, as you've said, and you're 100% right. it's not about the turkey. since she's making a ton of other food for the day, i would eat it and have the turkey another day.

i would be upset if i was hosting a holiday and someone asked if they could bring a main course of something they know i wouldn't cook myself. i was a strict vegetarian for 10 years and even now only eat chicken on occasion and turkey even less. DH's family doesn't understand that i still don't eat most meat, and i won't cook it in my house. DH can cook it himself, but i won't do it. i don't even like it in the house. if DH's family asked to bring lamb, beef, etc to a holiday i was hosting knowing how i feel, i would be very upset and hurt. i probably would let them but would be fuming inside. when they come to dinner here, they know to expect pasta or chicken only. when i go there, i know that i will only be eating side dishes (and that includes christmas day since they make ham) only.

i guess it really depends on your relationship with her. you definitely have the right attitude about the day, so it depends on how she would take the request. if you think she'd be offended or put off by it at all, don't ask. but if she's like your own sister to you, it doesn't hurt to ask---but if she hesitates even slightly before saying yes, she probably isn't happy with it and is doing it to not cause a problem.

go meet your beautiful new nephew and enjoy the weekend. and when you get back, cook a turkey!

Posted 9/13/08 4:44 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Is this rude?

my brothers and sister are all vegans.

If you must have a turkey, I would cook it in the middle of the night, the night before.

no joke, seriously. My siblings aren't preachy at all, not trying to convert anyone...but they cannot tolerate their food being in the oven while I cook non vegan in same oven.

I would hate to get in the host's way of cooking the day of....

I would throw turkey in a bag, throw in oven at night, set alarm on phone or something when I have to get up to take it out.

Posted 9/13/08 5:00 PM
 

Sherwood
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1643 total posts

Name:
s

Re: Is this rude?

I am a vegetarian. I might be a little offended, but I would allow them to bring their turkey anyway. Becoming a vegetarian was MY decision, and I feel that I dont have a right to force that on other people. Thanksgiving is a day when people traditionally eat turkey; if I'm inviting someone to my house on Thanksgiving, I'd expect that they'd want turkey. To me the holiday is more about family, friends and togetherness; I'd rather have them there with their turkey than not have them share the holiday with me.

Message edited 2008-09-13 17:04:45.647000.

Posted 9/13/08 5:02 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I wouldn't think it was rude if someone showed up at my house with it. I guess it all depends on the person. I know alot of people are saying "if i went through alllll the trouble of making..... blah blah blah", but in my family, we all bring something (or a few dishes) and some are because of personal preference, some are because of dietary restrictions and most of it's for everyone.

There are worse things in life than turkey on thanksgiving. Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 5:03 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by browneyedgirl

IMO, yes it's rude.

thanksgiving is for family, as you've said, and you're 100% right. it's not about the turkey. since she's making a ton of other food for the day, i would eat it and have the turkey another day.

i would be upset if i was hosting a holiday and someone asked if they could bring a main course of something they know i wouldn't cook myself. i was a strict vegetarian for 10 years and even now only eat chicken on occasion and turkey even less. DH's family doesn't understand that i still don't eat most meat, and i won't cook it in my house. DH can cook it himself, but i won't do it. i don't even like it in the house. if DH's family asked to bring lamb, beef, etc to a holiday i was hosting knowing how i feel, i would be very upset and hurt. i probably would let them but would be fuming inside. when they come to dinner here, they know to expect pasta or chicken only. when i go there, i know that i will only be eating side dishes (and that includes christmas day since they make ham) only.

i guess it really depends on your relationship with her. you definitely have the right attitude about the day, so it depends on how she would take the request. if you think she'd be offended or put off by it at all, don't ask. but if she's like your own sister to you, it doesn't hurt to ask---but if she hesitates even slightly before saying yes, she probably isn't happy with it and is doing it to not cause a problem.

go meet your beautiful new nephew and enjoy the weekend. and when you get back, cook a turkey!



I agree. Obviously you're not trying to offend which is why you are asking opinions. I think you are better off having what she serves. yes, its not the "typical" thanksgiving dinner but I would just enjoy what's there and make the best of it. Def cook the turkey when you come home too.

Posted 9/13/08 5:04 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by neenie

I wouldn't think it was rude if someone showed up at my house with it. I guess it all depends on the person. I know alot of people are saying "if i went through alllll the trouble of making..... blah blah blah", but in my family, we all bring something (or a few dishes) and some are because of personal preference, some are because of dietary restrictions and most of it's for everyone.

There are worse things in life than turkey on thanksgiving. Chat Icon



Its funny b/c I was thinking about when we hosted Christmas last year and my cousin brought a shrimp tray and I loathe seafood, we never have it in my house and I wouldn't have ever said something. Maybe I should haveChat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 5:07 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

I'm a vegetarian. If someone wanted to bring turkey to a Thanksgiving meal that I spent all day (probably 2 days) preparing, taking into account that meat-eating family would be there so I'd probably make TONS of dishes of all sorts to please everyone... yes, I'd "let" them eat the turkey because *I'M* not rude. But I'd be steaming mad. Vegetarianism is a choice. Just like you have a choice to stay home and eat your traditional turkey dinner.

Let's say your MIL is a terrible cook, and she invites you over for pot roast. Do you accept her offer, and then show up with a leg of lamb and eat that instead, because you don't like her pot roast? No. You either don't go, or you eat the side dishes and thank her for inviting you over, because having dinner with family is about the sharing, and the company. And yes, in many cases, the food is the best part, but who's to say her veggie Thanksgiving won't be delicious?

I realize you want your family to have a "traditional" Thanksgiving, but I haven't eaten turkey in 10 years and I promise you, I don't enjoy Thanksgiving any less.



ITA

Posted 9/13/08 5:44 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I have a question for the vegetarians/vegans that say they would be offended.. just because i'm curious.

If the situation was reversed, and the host was only making dishes that had meat in them, would you bring some of your own food? Some vegetable dishes? I know people are going to say "well, she *can* eat veggies, vegetarians *can't* eat meat, but isn't it still offensive if you assume that the host went through SO much trouble to cook all the meals....?

Posted 9/13/08 5:52 PM
 

Sherwood
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1643 total posts

Name:
s

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by neenie

I have a question for the vegetarians/vegans that say they would be offended.. just because i'm curious.

If the situation was reversed, and the host was only making dishes that had meat in them, would you bring some of your own food? Some vegetable dishes? I know people are going to say "well, she *can* eat veggies, vegetarians *can't* eat meat, but isn't it still offensive if you assume that the host went through SO much trouble to cook all the meals....?



I have to say that I'm guilty of doing this. But I told the host first, and it was just an addition to the meal, another side dish.

Posted 9/13/08 6:00 PM
 

TheLorax
LOVE

Member since 2/06

5581 total posts

Name:
Suzanne / SuzBride

Re: Is this rude?

Depends on how strict they are. I was vegan for many years, and I would not have minded, but i know there are many vegans who do not want meat in their refrigerators/oven/home. So I guess it would depend on how strict they were.

ETA: I have brought Tofurkey with me to dinners hosted at my DH's aunt's house. I get hungry sometimes if I don't bring something for myself

Message edited 2008-09-13 18:30:18.787000.

Posted 9/13/08 6:29 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

If you were going to a recovering alcoholic's home, and you knew no alcohol was going to be served, would you bring a bottle of wine for yourself so that YOU could drink?

Posted 9/13/08 6:34 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

If you were going to a recovering alcoholic's home, and you knew no alcohol was going to be served, would you bring a bottle of wine for yourself so that YOU could drink?



Comparing illness and addiction to personal food preference is quite the stretch.

Posted 9/13/08 6:44 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?



No one responded as you did. your posts are the only rude things I see here.

Also she IS A VEGAN not a vegetarian so the choice of what she is cooking is very limited, but she said she would make all the traditional side dishes, which means shes not hard core vegan because not too many of those would be ok with her, and you have to take in to account the many comments on these 3 pages Kate has made about the situation.

You made it seem like she was offending YOU Chat Icon

she Actually didnt want to hear "no go ahead" b/c her responses seem to be leaning towards what the vegetarians are saying so I have to agree with Kate, I dont think you read the entire thread before commenting and there was more info.

ALSO..you are one person. Not everyone feels like you do. Your opinion was wanted but you did make it sound like all vegetarians would agree with you. And they dont.

Message edited 2008-09-13 18:44:55.917000.

Posted 9/13/08 6:44 PM
 

doublestroller
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

1179 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by rojerono
If I am a guest in someone's house - I eat what they offer. I am always afraid that the host may feel like their efforts aren't 'good enough' if I make a special request.

Having said that.. I think that it wouldn't be rude to ask if you approach the question in the right manner. I mean - making it clear that having turkey or not having turkey is NOT a deal breaker - but merely an idea if she is open to it.

If she does say no (I have a friend who will not allow meat to be cooked or prepared in her apartment because of how strongly she feels about it) - then I would suggest having a big ole bird with all the trimmings the following weekend when you guys are home.

this is how i view things as well. "rude" is all in the approach, i think. if it were me, i would probably say "can i cook a little bird and bring it over or is that a total no-no for you. if it's no, just say so i don't mind at all..."

Posted 9/13/08 7:12 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by DavaDay

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?



No one responded as you did. your posts are the only rude things I see here.

Also she IS A VEGAN not a vegetarian so the choice of what she is cooking is very limited, but she said she would make all the traditional side dishes, which means shes not hard core vegan because not too many of those would be ok with her, and you have to take in to account the many comments on these 3 pages Kate has made about the situation.

You made it seem like she was offending YOU Chat Icon



I certainly didn't mean to come off as rude. I think I do have a bit of a chip on my shoulder when it comes to this stuff because I've been a vegetarian for 10 years and have put up with so many people denigrating it, as a poster above did, as a "food preference." It's not a "preference" to me. It's a belief system. I don't "not like" meat; I don't "prefer" to not eat meat; I don't eat meat. To me, it's as edible as the porcelain plate on which it sits. It doesn't matter why, it just is what it is.

So many people don't understand, that I go out of my way when I'm cooking for friends and family to make food that no one can argue with. I spend so much time coming up with recipes for pasta, casseroles, etc. to convince my mother that I'm not missing out. When I have people over for dinner, I stress out a lot about whether or not they'll be full or they'll feel like stuff is missing. And so what I was trying to say was that if I invited family over for Thanksgiving, I would work so hard on making a meal that everyone would enjoy, that yes, I would consider it an insult if a family member called me up and asked to bring her own food. I'm not being rude; I'm not trying to call the OP ignorant. I'm telling you how I would feel after years and years of experience with this stuff.

Kate had a question about if it's rude to call and ask to reheat a turkey in a vegan's oven. I gave my opinion. Laughing about how it seems that I'm offended by all this doesn't seem very productive.

Posted 9/13/08 7:12 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by neenie

Posted by DavaDay

If you were going to a recovering alcoholic's home, and you knew no alcohol was going to be served, would you bring a bottle of wine for yourself so that YOU could drink?



Comparing illness and addiction to personal food preference is quite the stretch.




Yeah. There is a TOTAL difference here. Addiction is a mental illness. In MOST cases, not eating meat is a choice.

Posted 9/13/08 7:24 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I hope I dont turn into the traveling mom who lets her toddler get away with being rude HarleyGirlFLA 6/18/08 10 Pregnancy
Is it rude of me to ask people to remove their shoes when coming in my house ???? babybugsmum 12/5/07 145 Parenting
Is this rude? (esp. for Moms of more than 1) Tfor3 11/24/07 13 Parenting
Is this response too rude? UPDATED BELOW WITH SOME info about why the question scares me......... Kerie-is-so-very 8/29/07 29 Pregnancy
Is this rude or is it just me? (long) BabyAvocado 10/29/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Is it rude to ask someone how much they are offering when they call to set up an interview?**updated** LIMOMx2 7/27/06 16 Families Helping Families ™