Re: Is this rude?
Posted 9/13/2008 5:04:18 PM by Elizabeth


Posted by browneyedgirl

IMO, yes it's rude.

thanksgiving is for family, as you've said, and you're 100% right. it's not about the turkey. since she's making a ton of other food for the day, i would eat it and have the turkey another day.

i would be upset if i was hosting a holiday and someone asked if they could bring a main course of something they know i wouldn't cook myself. i was a strict vegetarian for 10 years and even now only eat chicken on occasion and turkey even less. DH's family doesn't understand that i still don't eat most meat, and i won't cook it in my house. DH can cook it himself, but i won't do it. i don't even like it in the house. if DH's family asked to bring lamb, beef, etc to a holiday i was hosting knowing how i feel, i would be very upset and hurt. i probably would let them but would be fuming inside. when they come to dinner here, they know to expect pasta or chicken only. when i go there, i know that i will only be eating side dishes (and that includes christmas day since they make ham) only.

i guess it really depends on your relationship with her. you definitely have the right attitude about the day, so it depends on how she would take the request. if you think she'd be offended or put off by it at all, don't ask. but if she's like your own sister to you, it doesn't hurt to ask---but if she hesitates even slightly before saying yes, she probably isn't happy with it and is doing it to not cause a problem.

go meet your beautiful new nephew and enjoy the weekend. and when you get back, cook a turkey!



I agree. Obviously you're not trying to offend which is why you are asking opinions. I think you are better off having what she serves. yes, its not the "typical" thanksgiving dinner but I would just enjoy what's there and make the best of it. Def cook the turkey when you come home too.
Print Post      Close Window