Is this rude?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Is this rude?

DH, DS and I are going to my SIL's for Thanksgiving (yes, I am thinking aheadChat Icon ) and she is a vegan and her DH and kids are vegetarians. She said she is going to make all of the normal side dishes as dinner.

So, would it be rude to ask if I could make a small turkey breast for DH, DS and I? All I would need is some oven space and I'd bring it with me.

It doesn't sound rude to me, but I wanted to make sure before I approached her about it.

TIA!Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 9:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Is this rude?

Not rude at all. It is thanksgiving, you should be able to eat what you want

Posted 9/13/08 9:45 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

I would make it myself and bring it, she may have an issue touching or cooking meat, BUT you should have what YOU like too , not all about her beliefs KWIM?

eta- I forgot they live OOS, so No its not rude AT ALL to do that.

Message edited 2008-09-13 09:46:45.800000.

Posted 9/13/08 9:46 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Is this rude?

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.

Posted 9/13/08 9:49 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by 1stimemom

Not rude at all. It is thanksgiving, you should be able to eat what you want



I AGREEChat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 9:50 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

I don't think it's rude to ask. it's tradition to eat turkey that day - even small children know that.

Posted 9/13/08 9:51 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by BunnyWife

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.



Her DH still eats meat, she just doesn't know about it.Chat Icon

Her kids are 3 and 2 months.

Posted 9/13/08 9:52 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Is this rude?

I think it would depend on how close you are with SIL. She might think its rude if she isn't close with you and such, but if you are close enoguh where you can say "No offense but we are not vegeterians and would like turkey for Thanksgiving" then I would think its okay.

But like another poster said--she may not want meat in her oven so maybe you should ask if thats okay to cook it in there.

Posted 9/13/08 9:53 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel

I would make it myself and bring it, she may have an issue touching or cooking meat, BUT you should have what YOU like too , not all about her beliefs KWIM?

eta- I forgot they live OOS, so No its not rude AT ALL to do that.



Ooohh, I would cook it so she doesn't have to touch it. And I figured I'd use a disposable pan, ya know? So I don't use their stuff.

Posted 9/13/08 9:53 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by BunnyWife

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.



Her DH still eats meat, she just doesn't know about it.Chat Icon

Her kids are 3 and 2 months.





Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon That's funny and sad! How torturous if you bring that tasty turkey and all he can do is stare at itChat Icon

I say is she is a fairly laid back chick it shouldn't be a problem. Just don't offer to cook it in her place. Bring it hot and ready to eat.Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 9:55 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by BunnyWife

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by BunnyWife

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.



Her DH still eats meat, she just doesn't know about it.Chat Icon

Her kids are 3 and 2 months.





Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon That's funny and sad! How torturous if you bring that tasty turkey and all he can do is stare at itChat Icon

I say is she is a fairly laid back chick it shouldn't be a problem. Just don't offer to cook it in her place. Bring it hot and ready to eat.Chat Icon



she is OOS...

I dont think anyone can get offended at something liek that. Why would SHE get to eat what she eats and not you?

Her DH and kids eat the side dishes, so its not like shes doing it for you.

PErsonally if she had a problem w ith it, I'd stay home.

Message edited 2008-09-13 09:58:14.127000.

Posted 9/13/08 9:57 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I don't know, if her DH has to sneak eating meat; it may not be welcome in her house. It doesn't hurt to ask but I would bring the turkey already cooked so you dont have to use her oven. She will probably need it for the side dishes she is preparing.



eta. I see she lives OOS, maybe order a cooked breast from a place local to them. They could probably recommend a place that does that.

Message edited 2008-09-13 09:58:53.623000.

Posted 9/13/08 9:57 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by Christine

I don't know, if her DH has to sneak eating meat; it may not be welcome in her house. It doesn't hurt to ask but I would bring the turkey already cooked so you dont have to use her oven. She will probably need it for the side dishes she is preparing.



Nah, he sneaks meat b/c it is easier to agree with my SIL then to listen to her sometimes and he is married to herChat Icon

Can't bring it with me. She lives in Maryland, we are going for the whole weekend.

Listen, either way, I am not bailing, I haven't even met my new nephew yet.

Posted 9/13/08 9:59 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel


I dont think anyone can get offended at something liek that. Why would SHE get to eat what she eats and not you?

Her DH and kids eat the side dishes, so its not like shes doing it for you.

PErsonally if she had a problem w ith it, I'd stay home.



I think she gets to control the menu because she is hosting. When I have people over, I try to take other people's preferences into account but no one can be 100% accomodating.

I agree with the poster above that wondered why a vegan would host thanksgiving dinner since the centerpiece is a turkey.

Posted 9/13/08 10:01 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by Christine

Posted by dm24angel


I dont think anyone can get offended at something liek that. Why would SHE get to eat what she eats and not you?

Her DH and kids eat the side dishes, so its not like shes doing it for you.

PErsonally if she had a problem w ith it, I'd stay home.



I think she gets to control the menu because she is hosting. When I have people over, I try to take other people's preferences into account but no one can be 100% accomodating.

I agree with the poster above that wondered why a vegan would host thanksgiving dinner since the centerpiece is a turkey.



A vegan is hosting b/c we haven't seen them in 15 months, they have a new baby and a new house. It isn't THANKSGIVING it is a weekend when we can actually spend time together.

Thank you for the idea of ordering one, that might be the way to goChat Icon

Or maybe I will just make it the Sunday before for us.

Posted 9/13/08 10:03 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by Christine

Posted by dm24angel


I dont think anyone can get offended at something liek that. Why would SHE get to eat what she eats and not you?

Her DH and kids eat the side dishes, so its not like shes doing it for you.

PErsonally if she had a problem w ith it, I'd stay home.



I think she gets to control the menu because she is hosting. When I have people over, I try to take other people's preferences into account but no one can be 100% accomodating.

I agree with the poster above that wondered why a vegan would host thanksgiving dinner since the centerpiece is a turkey.



A vegan is hosting b/c we haven't seen them in 15 months, they have a new baby and a new house. It isn't THANKSGIVING it is a weekend when we can actually spend time together.

Thank you for the idea of ordering one, that might be the way to goChat Icon

Or maybe I will just make it the Sunday before for us.



I just want to say I think your attitude is amazing! So many people get caught up in the traditions surrounding thanksgiving and forget what the day is all about. I'm sure what ever happes you will have a great time that weekendChat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-13 10:11:43.940000.

Posted 9/13/08 10:11 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by BunnyWife



I just want to say I think your attitude is amazing! So many people get caught up in the traditions surrounding thanksgiving and forget what the day is all about. I'm sure what ever happes you will have a great time that weekendChat Icon



Thank youChat Icon Chat Icon

It is a quasi-miracle it is working out. My DH is FDNY and he actually has off Thanksgiving, Friday and SaturdayChat Icon Chat Icon

It is more important to me to see themChat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 10:15 AM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Is this rude?

I just have to ask... What is she planning on serving instead of the turkey?

Posted 9/13/08 10:15 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dilb712

I just have to ask... What is she planning on serving instead of the turkey?



I thought I put in my OP, but the side dishes, sweet potatoes (my dad's recipe actually), green beans, stuffing, etc, etc.

Posted 9/13/08 10:17 AM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by dilb712

I just have to ask... What is she planning on serving instead of the turkey?



I thought I put in my OP, but the side dishes, sweet potatoes (my dad's recipe actually), green beans, stuffing, etc, etc.



So just side dishes? Ok i see..

Posted 9/13/08 10:23 AM
 

DayDay
Livin' the Good Life....

Member since 9/06

5939 total posts

Name:
Dayna

Re: Is this rude?

It's Thanksgiving.. you shouldn't have to sacrifice what you eat for someone who doesn't share the same eating habits you do..

Posted 9/13/08 10:24 AM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dilb712

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by dilb712

I just have to ask... What is she planning on serving instead of the turkey?



I thought I put in my OP, but the side dishes, sweet potatoes (my dad's recipe actually), green beans, stuffing, etc, etc.



So just side dishes? Ok i see..



Nothing wrong with that. The "idea" of Thanksgiving is to be Thankful, not to just eat Turkey Chat Icon

In fact, in past years, my sister and I would cook a turkey and end up throwing it out since it was never done right. We just ate the sides Chat Icon The sides are the best part IMO

Posted 9/13/08 10:24 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Is this rude?

You are awesome. And you have the right idea about Thanksgiving being more than just a day to eat turkey!

If I am a guest in someone's house - I eat what they offer. I am always afraid that the host may feel like their efforts aren't 'good enough' if I make a special request.

Having said that.. I think that it wouldn't be rude to ask if you approach the question in the right manner. I mean - making it clear that having turkey or not having turkey is NOT a deal breaker - but merely an idea if she is open to it.

If she does say no (I have a friend who will not allow meat to be cooked or prepared in her apartment because of how strongly she feels about it) - then I would suggest having a big ole bird with all the trimmings the following weekend when you guys are home.

Posted 9/13/08 10:49 AM
 

MeeshkaMich
LL=Yum

Member since 2/06

5616 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by dm24angel

I would make it myself and bring it, she may have an issue touching or cooking meat, BUT you should have what YOU like too , not all about her beliefs KWIM?

eta- I forgot they live OOS, so No its not rude AT ALL to do that.



Ooohh, I would cook it so she doesn't have to touch it. And I figured I'd use a disposable pan, ya know? So I don't use their stuff.





ETA: I think its very nice of you to ask first about bringing the turkey.

As a guest I always have to bring something even when I'm told not to, so this could be your "something" to bring.. I don't know my mom always told me never go to someone's home empty handed. So in your case you're bringing the main part of the mealChat Icon Although I'm not a turkey fan anyway.Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-13 10:53:55.953000.

Posted 9/13/08 10:52 AM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Is this rude?

You mentioned that they are in MD, so not sure where, but there are two places that you might be able to get a cooked turkey day of:

Boston Market

Chicken Out Rotisserie

Posted 9/13/08 10:53 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I hope I dont turn into the traveling mom who lets her toddler get away with being rude HarleyGirlFLA 6/18/08 10 Pregnancy
Is it rude of me to ask people to remove their shoes when coming in my house ???? babybugsmum 12/5/07 145 Parenting
Is this rude? (esp. for Moms of more than 1) Tfor3 11/24/07 13 Parenting
Is this response too rude? UPDATED BELOW WITH SOME info about why the question scares me......... Kerie-is-so-very 8/29/07 29 Pregnancy
Is this rude or is it just me? (long) BabyAvocado 10/29/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Is it rude to ask someone how much they are offering when they call to set up an interview?**updated** LIMOMx2 7/27/06 16 Families Helping Families ™