Is this rude?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by neenie

Posted by DavaDay

If you were going to a recovering alcoholic's home, and you knew no alcohol was going to be served, would you bring a bottle of wine for yourself so that YOU could drink?



Comparing illness and addiction to personal food preference is quite the stretch.




Yeah. There is a TOTAL difference here. Addiction is a mental illness. In MOST cases, not eating meat is a choice.



So what you're saying is that you would defer to mental illness but not to choice. In both cases the person doesn't want the substance in their home. As a guest, you either respect the host's wishes or you don't.

I'm not the food police. My DH eats meat. We had take-out last night and sat together as I ate a veggie burger and he ate a hamburger. I didn't care. I make my choices and he makes his. But if I were hosting a vegetarian dinner that I had spent 2 days preparing, and my dinner wasn't good enough for my guests, I'd feel upset. I can't keep saying the same thing. I'm done.

Posted 9/13/08 7:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by neenie

Posted by DavaDay

If you were going to a recovering alcoholic's home, and you knew no alcohol was going to be served, would you bring a bottle of wine for yourself so that YOU could drink?



Comparing illness and addiction to personal food preference is quite the stretch.




Yeah. There is a TOTAL difference here. Addiction is a mental illness. In MOST cases, not eating meat is a choice.



So what you're saying is that you would defer to mental illness but not to choice. In both cases the person doesn't want the substance in their home. As a guest, you either respect the host's wishes or you don't.

I'm not the food police. My DH eats meat. We had take-out last night and sat together as I ate a veggie burger and he ate a hamburger. I didn't care. I make my choices and he makes his. But if I were hosting a vegetarian dinner that I had spent 2 days preparing, and my dinner wasn't good enough for my guests, I'd feel upset. I can't keep saying the same thing. I'm done.



Honestly, YES, I would defer to mental illness but not choice!!!

First of all, she didn't she didn't invite us for "thanksgiving" as I've said like 93 times, we chose that weekend b/c my DH could get off and their house would be done. It so HAPPENS to be Thanksgiving.

Listen, I'm sorry that people don't respect your choices, but I do respect my SIL's choices that is why I would ASK beforehand. You seem like you have people in your life who question your choices and I am sorry, but please, STOP TAKING IT OUT ON ME!! I will NOT bring turkey to your house!

Posted 9/13/08 7:38 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

[ It's not a "preference" to me. It's a belief system. I don't "not like" meat; I don't "prefer" to not eat meat; I don't eat meat. To me, it's as edible as the porcelain plate on which it sits. It doesn't matter why, it just is what it is.




Well because you seem really READY to argue and I find that funny personally when we are just trying to have a dicussion.

I DO GET it. I was a vegetarian for YEARS.

The thing is not everyone is a vegan/Vegetarian for the same reasons and therefore, not everyone feels how YOU DO and you are coming across as very unyielding in your opinion.

I CERTAINLY understand and respect your opinion, I just had an issue with the way it was voiced as if everyone who couldnt understand was stupid.

You feel prejudiced against yet in turn you do seem to be doing the same with a little bit of a " I try so hard,...... I wouldnt expect you to understand,.....I have been insulted bfore...." attitude.

Your point is valid and I respect that.

Posted 9/13/08 7:38 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by neenie

I have a question for the vegetarians/vegans that say they would be offended.. just because i'm curious.

If the situation was reversed, and the host was only making dishes that had meat in them, would you bring some of your own food? Some vegetable dishes? I know people are going to say "well, she *can* eat veggies, vegetarians *can't* eat meat, but isn't it still offensive if you assume that the host went through SO much trouble to cook all the meals....?



Apples and oranges. One is because you can't eat the food, one is because you simply prefer something else.

That being said, if it's the first time I'm going to someone's house I won't bring anything unless asked, and I'll make do with sides. But most people know I'm veg and are absolutely wonderful and gracious enough to prepare something vegetarian. Other people also know, and are ok with me bringing my own food.

Posted 9/13/08 8:39 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay
So what you're saying is that you would defer to mental illness but not to choice. In both cases the person doesn't want the substance in their home. As a guest, you either respect the host's wishes or you don't.

I'm not the food police. My DH eats meat. We had take-out last night and sat together as I ate a veggie burger and he ate a hamburger. I didn't care. I make my choices and he makes his. But if I were hosting a vegetarian dinner that I had spent 2 days preparing, and my dinner wasn't good enough for my guests, I'd feel upset. I can't keep saying the same thing. I'm done.



You're really pushing it with the vegetarian/alcoholism comparison- just give it up. Your example right there just proves it. I would think (and hope) that if you were an alcoholic, that your DH wouldn't sit there chugging a 40 just as he sat there eating a hamburger. I get that you find this situation offensive... but comparing it to a disease process, an addiction, and making references based on that, just makes your argument look silly.

(I should add that Turkey is also my least favorite thing for Thanksgiving dinner Chat Icon but i couldnt get past your comparison here)

Posted 9/13/08 8:45 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by JenniferEver
Apples and oranges. One is because you can't eat the food, one is because you simply prefer something else.



Not really. I know plenty of meat eaters that despise veggies. And, most vegans/vegetarians i know are that by CHOICE, not because they couldn't physically eat meat. (i'm sure that exists though, and of course those are the exceptions). I think it's unfair to say that one should be accomodated and the other shouldn't.

Posted 9/13/08 8:49 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Is this rude?

I am not a vegetarian. But I see it this way.

If you are going to a vegan's house to eat, I would most definitely NOT bring any meat based dishes. I find this to just be rude.

If the host is one of those vegetarians that doesn't mind cooking and having meat at the table, I am sure this person would either make a meat dish herself for the meat eating guests, or she would OFFER you the option of bring your own meat dish.

If this person hasn't done either, then she probably doesn't feel comfortable with having Meat at her house. I would NOT ask if you can bring a meat dish because this may make her feel uncomfortable. She may be inclined to say yes to you just to save face even if she really doesn't want meat there.

Posted 9/13/08 8:53 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Is this rude?

I was a "veggie person" (lol as I called it) for many years. It did not bother me AT ALL if people ate meat around me, wanted to have it at my house, wanted to bring it if they really wanted it - especially on a popular meat eating holiday. I'm not saying how she will definitely feel but it would not bother me A BIT. I never tried to push my feelings on other people or tried to make them feel "guilty" for my own personal choices in life.

I would just ask her - in a polite way.

HTH! Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 10:04 PM
 

PreshusSmurf
So in love with my little guys

Member since 1/07

2963 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by neenie

Not really. I know plenty of meat eaters that despise veggies. And, most vegans/vegetarians i know are that by CHOICE, not because they couldn't physically eat meat. (i'm sure that exists though, and of course those are the exceptions). I think it's unfair to say that one should be accomodated and the other shouldn't.




ITA with this neenie. In fact, I'm married to one of them! Chat Icon

And I, myself, really don't eat many vegetables either.

I will NEVER eat anything made with tofu. Ever. There is nothing appealing about it to me. Neither of us are very good at that whole "trying new foods" thing ...

If we went to someone's house and all they had to eat was tofu and vegetables, we would Chat Icon that there was bread or rolls on the table. And we'd probably sit there and watch them eat, because they hadn't been considerate enough to take their guest's into account. And then we'd grab some fast food on the way home Chat Icon

I had a roommate who was a vegetarian, it was a conscious choice that she made for her self that SHE was not going to eat meat. While I'm sure it exists out there in the world, it is still a CHOICE or a PREFERENCE to be a vegetarian. At some point in their lives, they made the DECISION.

Alcoholism is not PREFERENCE, it is an illness. To compare the two is just beyond ridiculous to me.


Posted 9/13/08 11:20 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by DavaDay

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?



When we go out to dinner (DH and I are vegan, DS is vegetarian) and we are invited out, and we don't choose the restaraunt, we do it for the company, not the food. Yes, we have had expensive plates of spaghetti at Italian restaraunts and french fries and wilted broccoli at steak houses. Its part of being a vegetarian in a non-vegtarian world. not ideal but it is what it is. Thats the pay-off for being social and vegan. And vegans who are willing to compromise for the sake of not being pains in the as ses. Part of making a choice like that is to be respectful and not cram it down other people's throats, and not expect the waves to be parted wherever we go.....

I tell everyone the same thing when they stress about what we will eat. "We have not starved to death yet."

Message edited 2008-09-13 23:32:22.640000.

Posted 9/13/08 11:31 PM
 

rocket3499
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

128 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Honeslty, I don't really see this as a vegetarian vs. meat-eater kind of thing.

I see it more as a "yes, I'd love to come over and understand you're going to great lengths to prepare a meal, but I don't think it's good enough for me and my family."

So, yes. I think it's crazy rude and I'm kind of surprised that so many others disagree.

You mentioned having turkey the weekend before or after and I think that sounds like a win-win for everyone.


Posted 9/14/08 12:37 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Is this rude?

Well, I am not sure that I would ask but I think it depends upon your relationship with your family. I would be sad about not having turkey on thanksgiving but at the same time I understand that as a guest I have the option to attend and eat what is prepared for me or not go. I think in your situation you want to see your new family member, so I would just go and eat turkey another weekend and not ask to have a turkey. If you really need a turkey - I would eat something at a resturant the day after turkey day in the OOS area.

I liken your situation to going to my ultra orthodox family. I would never dream of bringing something non kosher to their home because they believe that keeping kosher is important. In my house we are only kosher style but I will eat lobster on a plastic plate with plastic utensils to accomodate my DH.

Posted 9/14/08 1:12 AM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by ave1024

I am not a vegetarian. But I see it this way.

If you are going to a vegan's house to eat, I would most definitely NOT bring any meat based dishes. I find this to just be rude.

If the host is one of those vegetarians that doesn't mind cooking and having meat at the table, I am sure this person would either make a meat dish herself for the meat eating guests, or she would OFFER you the option of bring your own meat dish.

If this person hasn't done either, then she probably doesn't feel comfortable with having Meat at her house. I would NOT ask if you can bring a meat dish because this may make her feel uncomfortable. She may be inclined to say yes to you just to save face even if she really doesn't want meat there.




Very well said - I agree. I am not a vegetarian but I think it would be rude.

Posted 9/14/08 2:11 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by LSP2005


I liken your situation to going to my ultra orthodox family. I would never dream of bringing something non kosher to their home because they believe that keeping kosher is important. In my house we are only kosher style but I will eat lobster on a plastic plate with plastic utensils to accomodate my DH.



Not to continue the debate, but I think this is totally different. Kosher is religious, being a veg/vegan is not. Especially in my SIL's case.

I spoke to her and she doesn't care either way! So I just have to decide what to do.

ETA: I totally think it is hysterical that people think my SIL would just say yes to appease me b/c that is totally not her personality (it is mine!) she is soooooo not that way.

Message edited 2008-09-14 08:11:40.273000.

Posted 9/14/08 8:08 AM
 

IrishLasss334
I'll be there soon!

Member since 1/08

6549 total posts

Name:
Patty

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

I don't think it's rude to ask. it's tradition to eat turkey that day - even small children know that.




i thought that too!

Posted 9/14/08 8:10 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by DavaDay

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?



When we go out to dinner (DH and I are vegan, DS is vegetarian) and we are invited out, and we don't choose the restaraunt, we do it for the company, not the food. Yes, we have had expensive plates of spaghetti at Italian restaraunts and french fries and wilted broccoli at steak houses. Its part of being a vegetarian in a non-vegtarian world. not ideal but it is what it is. Thats the pay-off for being social and vegan. And vegans who are willing to compromise for the sake of not being pains in the as ses. Part of making a choice like that is to be respectful and not cram it down other people's throats, and not expect the waves to be parted wherever we go.....

I tell everyone the same thing when they stress about what we will eat. "We have not starved to death yet."



I disagree off topic but I had NO issues eating anywhere when a vegetarian and had lots more then wilted broccoli ..

Did you recently switch to vegan from vegetarian? I though you drank foamy coffee drinks and ate pizza Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-14 08:13:54.040000.

Posted 9/14/08 8:11 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by LSP2005

Well, I am not sure that I would ask but I think it depends upon your relationship with your family.



I think this is the point. I mean her SIL is close, shes not gonna get offended. Thats silly, they are FAMILY.

She may say no, but I dont think she will do it in a rude way?

Posted 9/14/08 8:12 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by IrishLass

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

I don't think it's rude to ask. it's tradition to eat turkey that day - even small children know that.




i thought that too!



Because we didn't pick the weekend b/c it was Thanksgiving, we picked it b/c it was the weekend we could all get together and see family...it just HAPPENS to be Thanksgiving.

Posted 9/14/08 8:13 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by DavaDay

I think you don't understand. I'm really used to that, so I'm not offended. My own mother doesn't understand. She'll invite me out to dinner at an Italian place, tell me that she looked up the menu online and that there is a lot for me to eat there, and I'll get there and everything will be Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Pasta with Shrimp and Spinach, etc., and I'll be like - huh? So she'll say, "just order it without the meat!" Because I want to drive all the way into the City and pay $20 for spaghetti with tomato sauce.

Sorry, off topic, I'm just saying that I'm used to non-veggies not understanding what it's like to be veggie, and really, how could you? But you came on here asking, "Is this rude?" when you just wanted to hear, "No, go ahead." If you didn't want to hear opinions from vegetarians who disagree with you, then why did you ask? And if 4 people before me told you the same thing I did, then why are you calling me easily offended?



When we go out to dinner (DH and I are vegan, DS is vegetarian) and we are invited out, and we don't choose the restaraunt, we do it for the company, not the food. Yes, we have had expensive plates of spaghetti at Italian restaraunts and french fries and wilted broccoli at steak houses. Its part of being a vegetarian in a non-vegtarian world. not ideal but it is what it is. Thats the pay-off for being social and vegan. And vegans who are willing to compromise for the sake of not being pains in the as ses. Part of making a choice like that is to be respectful and not cram it down other people's throats, and not expect the waves to be parted wherever we go.....

I tell everyone the same thing when they stress about what we will eat. "We have not starved to death yet."



I disagree off topic but I had NO issues eating anywhere when a vegetarian and had lots more then wilted broccoli ..

Did you recently switch to vegan from vegetarian? I though you drank foamy coffee drinks and ate pizza Chat Icon



Who me?

I've been vegan for 12 years!!! I love my soy lattes (when I can afford them) and friday night is pizza night (soy cheese pizza - I will eat casein on those nights because non-casein soy cheese tastes like clay!!!!! ) I'm not as hardcore as I used to be . The casein thing, plus I own some items with a little leather on them (bags, shoes, etc)


(ETA - in the last 2 years I got less vigilant because I have to focus on other things!)

My friends will ALWAYS go somewhere where everyone can eat (Chinese, Japanese, Thai, Indian) but my family? Forget about it. They could care less where and what I eat! Chat Icon

ETA again - at GTGs when there's pizza and I'm starving, I just eat the crust - I pull all the cheese off so I'm eating the bread. Usually someone will eat my cheese! Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-14 08:25:07.080000.

Posted 9/14/08 8:21 AM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Is this rude?

I think it would be rude to bring it without asking... asking first is the right thing to do and if she says no, you would have to oblige.

Posted 9/14/08 8:34 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

I don't think it's rude to ask. it's tradition to eat turkey that day - even small children know that.



I'm a veggie and we host thanksgiving but mainly because my family asks me to.

My mom always brings a turkey with her and cooks it in our oven. To be completely honest, it really does gross me out, but I put up with it because they should be able to eat what they want. But I do ask that she bring all her own cookware, knives, plates, etc, for the turkey because I just really don't want turkey juice all over my cookware, even if it's cleaned after.

And she takes any remaining turkey home with her.

ETA - I would definitely ask first, and when you do, offer to prepare everything yourself and bring your own cookware for it. What I REALLY love is sometimes my mom already cooks the turkey, then brings it and only heats it up in the oven. Doesn't gross me out quite as much Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-14 10:59:47.630000.

Posted 9/14/08 10:56 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine


I spoke to her and she doesn't care either way! So I just have to decide what to do.




Glad it went the way you wantedChat Icon

Posted 9/14/08 11:28 AM
 

BabyAvocado
Happy New Year

Member since 5/05

17334 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I don't see why it would be rude to simply ASK.

If I'm hosting a dinner and one of my guests is a vegetarian and they call to ASK if they can bring something, why would I find that rude? I would not be offended one bit. But maybe I'm just not that sensitive. It's just a question.

Now, she is hosting this dinner as if it were Thanksgiving with the traditional sides so you can treat it as a Thanksgiving dinner and not just any old GTG. So the turkey question is not completely irrelevant.

To me, it comes down to a more general hosting issue:

If you are a vegetarian/vegan/etc hosting a meal and can't handle a simple question from a guest about bringing a dish without getting offended - maybe you shouldn't be hosting.

Posted 9/14/08 11:31 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Is this rude?

I think it should be ok if they called ahead and asked but the only thing I would be concerned with is if my family was eating a turkey breast, would they get skeeved? Since I was a guest at their home I would want to know before it became awkward. I wouldn't push the issue bc having a nice thanksgiving to me is more important than bringing the meat.

Posted 9/14/08 11:44 AM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Is this rude?

Unless you planned on killing the turkey on their kitchen table and dipping Christopher in it's blood in some macabre Thanksgiving ritual.... I think you'll be OK.

Chat Icon

I'm glad you were able to work it out. It sounds like you have the kind of relationship with your SIL where she would tell you if she felt uncomfortable.

Posted 9/14/08 11:47 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I hope I dont turn into the traveling mom who lets her toddler get away with being rude HarleyGirlFLA 6/18/08 10 Pregnancy
Is it rude of me to ask people to remove their shoes when coming in my house ???? babybugsmum 12/5/07 145 Parenting
Is this rude? (esp. for Moms of more than 1) Tfor3 11/24/07 13 Parenting
Is this response too rude? UPDATED BELOW WITH SOME info about why the question scares me......... Kerie-is-so-very 8/29/07 29 Pregnancy
Is this rude or is it just me? (long) BabyAvocado 10/29/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Is it rude to ask someone how much they are offering when they call to set up an interview?**updated** LIMOMx2 7/27/06 16 Families Helping Families ™