Is this rude?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

As a vegetarian, I would find it rude. When someone is going to the trouble of cooking dinner for you, it is rude to bring something else unless YOU are the one with the dietary restriction. Why don't you pick another day to have the turkey dinner with your fam?

If you're close you could ask her, but she might not want it to be in her oven or fridge or touch her utensils. Even aside from that, I'm sure she is going to great lengths to make a meal she thinks your family will enjoy. Let her cook the thanksgiving dinner. you may be pleasantly surprised!

Posted 9/13/08 11:00 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

an9elic
♥ HJ ♥

Member since 6/07

3331 total posts

Name:
kristen

Re: Is this rude?

I was a vegetarian for 9 years.. IMO if your SIL is anything like the way I was then she might get offended and/or not want a turkey cooked in her oven or sitting on her table in front of her vegetarian family. If I were a guest at a vegetarian's house and I hadn't seen them in a long time I would sacrifice the turkey for one day. I would not bring a turkey.. I would maybe have a Thanksgiving dinner with my family and our turkey on another day or something.. Or like a PP suggested a Tofurkey.. It would be a nice way for your family to try something that your SIL and her family consider part of their tradition. Again, this is JMO. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 11:02 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by JenniferEver

As a vegetarian, I would find it rude. When someone is going to the trouble of cooking dinner for you, it is rude to bring something else unless YOU are the one with the dietary restriction. Why don't you pick another day to have the turkey dinner with your fam?

If you're close you could ask her, but she might not want it to be in her oven or fridge or touch her utensils. Even aside from that, I'm sure she is going to great lengths to make a meal she thinks your family will enjoy. Let her cook the thanksgiving dinner. you may be pleasantly surprised!



REALLY? I find this odd.

Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.

My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.

I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?

I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?

Posted 9/13/08 11:02 AM
 

an9elic
♥ HJ ♥

Member since 6/07

3331 total posts

Name:
kristen

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by JenniferEver

As a vegetarian, I would find it rude. When someone is going to the trouble of cooking dinner for you, it is rude to bring something else unless YOU are the one with the dietary restriction. Why don't you pick another day to have the turkey dinner with your fam?

If you're close you could ask her, but she might not want it to be in her oven or fridge or touch her utensils. Even aside from that, I'm sure she is going to great lengths to make a meal she thinks your family will enjoy. Let her cook the thanksgiving dinner. you may be pleasantly surprised!



ITA, I had trouble putting into words what I was thinking, but you did a better job than I did I think lol

Posted 9/13/08 11:03 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Is this rude?

I wouldn't ask about the turkey. Like others have said, thanksgiving is not about turkey, its about about being thankful and spending time with loved ones.
I think if she was ok with the turkey she would have told you up front it was ok if with her if you wanted to bring it for yourself.
IMO the sides are the best part anyway. Maybe you can do a mini thanksgiving for your immediate family the week before or after, but I don't think its appropriate to bring meat into a vegan household. It would be like asking someone who is kosher if it was ok to bring pork.

Posted 9/13/08 11:05 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Is this rude?

Honestly, I don't think it's rude at all. MOST people eat Turkey on Thanksgiving, so if she doesn't want it in her house, she shouldn't be hosting thanksgiving dinner to non-vegans. I don't think you should expect HER to cook it, but I do think you or someone else should be able to cook it there or bring it cooked.

If it's not an actual celebration for Thanksgiving, then I would not ask bring meat. I would eat what she made. But if it's for Thanksgiving, yes, I don't think it's rude and I would think she would realize your family would expect Turkey to be a staple.

Message edited 2008-09-13 11:13:31.543000.

Posted 9/13/08 11:10 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel



REALLY? I find this odd.

Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.

My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.

I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?

I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?




I totally disagree for a number of reasons.

its not as if the vegetarian stuff is something the meat eaters CAN'T eat, as is the case with a vegan going to someone's house and there being no vegan food. That excludes people, wheras the vegan meal includes people and everyone can eat it. There's no rule that says that if you eat meat you need it at every meal, so I don't see how people are being deprived of "things they eat."

It's like if someone says "i'm going to invite you over for a big italian style dinner. I'm making ravioli" and you say "well, to me, an italian dinner means lasagne, so can I bring some of that?" If someone's inviting you for dinner, you have to eat what they serve, unless YOU are the vegan or if you're kosher or have an allergy, etc.

I understand that a lot of people have a really big connection with eating turkey on thanksgiving, and if it were any other meal I'm sure OP would not even be posting, but you can always have a mini turkey dinner another night (maybe SIL will let you bring home leftovers and you can just add the turkey). it won't hurt anyone to not have it on that one thanksgiving. if it's that important, don't go to her house for Thanksgiving.



Posted 9/13/08 11:12 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by dm24angel



REALLY? I find this odd.

Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.

My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.

I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?

I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?




I totally disagree for a number of reasons.

its not as if the vegetarian stuff is something the meat eaters CAN'T eat, as is the case with a vegan going to someone's house and there being no vegan food. That excludes people, wheras the vegan meal includes people and everyone can eat it. There's no rule that says that if you eat meat you need it at every meal, so I don't see how people are being deprived of "things they eat."

It's like if someone says "i'm going to invite you over for a big italian style dinner. I'm making ravioli" and you say "well, to me, an italian dinner means lasagne, so can I bring some of that?" If someone's inviting you for dinner, you have to eat what they serve, unless YOU are the vegan or if you're kosher or have an allergy, etc.

I understand that a lot of people have a really big connection with eating turkey on thanksgiving, and if it were any other meal I'm sure OP would not even be posting, but you can always have a mini turkey dinner another night (maybe SIL will let you bring home leftovers and you can just add the turkey). it won't hurt anyone to not have it on that one thanksgiving. if it's that important, don't go to her house for Thanksgiving.






I get yoru points, Im just saying as a former vegetarian and with my my own SIL as one, I would think its rude, but hey we are all entitled to our own opinion and if it became a big deal, I would eat the sides and not care .

Posted 9/13/08 11:14 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by dm24angel



REALLY? I find this odd.

Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.

My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.

I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?

I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?




I totally disagree for a number of reasons.

its not as if the vegetarian stuff is something the meat eaters CAN'T eat, as is the case with a vegan going to someone's house and there being no vegan food. That excludes people, wheras the vegan meal includes people and everyone can eat it. There's no rule that says that if you eat meat you need it at every meal, so I don't see how people are being deprived of "things they eat."

It's like if someone says "i'm going to invite you over for a big italian style dinner. I'm making ravioli" and you say "well, to me, an italian dinner means lasagne, so can I bring some of that?" If someone's inviting you for dinner, you have to eat what they serve, unless YOU are the vegan or if you're kosher or have an allergy, etc.

I understand that a lot of people have a really big connection with eating turkey on thanksgiving, and if it were any other meal I'm sure OP would not even be posting, but you can always have a mini turkey dinner another night (maybe SIL will let you bring home leftovers and you can just add the turkey). it won't hurt anyone to not have it on that one thanksgiving. if it's that important, don't go to her house for Thanksgiving.






I get yoru points, Im just saying as a former vegetarian and with my my own SIL as one, I would think its rude, but hey we are all entitled to our own opinion and if it became a big deal, I would eat the sides and not care .




Well truth be told if I were the one cooking I would be ****** off, but I probably would allow them to bring a cooked turkey. Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 11:16 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by dm24angel



REALLY? I find this odd.

Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.

My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.

I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?

I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?




I totally disagree for a number of reasons.

its not as if the vegetarian stuff is something the meat eaters CAN'T eat, as is the case with a vegan going to someone's house and there being no vegan food. That excludes people, wheras the vegan meal includes people and everyone can eat it. There's no rule that says that if you eat meat you need it at every meal, so I don't see how people are being deprived of "things they eat."

It's like if someone says "i'm going to invite you over for a big italian style dinner. I'm making ravioli" and you say "well, to me, an italian dinner means lasagne, so can I bring some of that?" If someone's inviting you for dinner, you have to eat what they serve, unless YOU are the vegan or if you're kosher or have an allergy, etc.

I understand that a lot of people have a really big connection with eating turkey on thanksgiving, and if it were any other meal I'm sure OP would not even be posting, but you can always have a mini turkey dinner another night (maybe SIL will let you bring home leftovers and you can just add the turkey). it won't hurt anyone to not have it on that one thanksgiving. if it's that important, don't go to her house for Thanksgiving.






I get yoru points, Im just saying as a former vegetarian and with my my own SIL as one, I would think its rude, but hey we are all entitled to our own opinion and if it became a big deal, I would eat the sides and not care .




Well truth be told if I were the one cooking I would be ****** off, but I probably would allow them to bring a cooked turkey. Chat Icon



see everyone feels differently. Me and my SIL were/are vegetarians for reasons other then Animal welfar...so touching , cooking meat was not a problem for us. everyones different.

I think Kate should ask SIL and if she sounds hesitant, then just forget it. SImple as that.

Posted 9/13/08 11:20 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

It all depends on why she is vegan. She may or may not have an objection to it.

My first thought was why would a vegan host Thanksgiving for non-vegans. Then I thought about it more. Thanksgiving is more about being thankful for family & what you have than the food.

I say go, eat what she serves & have turkey when you're home.

At one point, my sister had severe diet restrictions (no sugar, no wheat, no dairy, etc). She brought her own food every where she went & discussed with the host what they were making. That was because she felt the host should not make special accomodations for what she cannot eat. I don't see the need to have turkey as a special accomodation.

Posted 9/13/08 11:25 AM
 

Moosey911
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

771 total posts

Name:
Nicki

Re: Is this rude?

I really don't see why this would be considered "rude" at all. My ex-DH was a vegetarian and all of our friends/family knew that. They would specifically make things that he would eat when we were invited over to their houses. Shoot, my Mom would make two completely different meals for us and him!!!

And vice versa, if I was inviting guests that had specific dietary needs/wants, I'm MORE than happy to accommodate them in my home.

Obviously, the important thing is being together for Thanksgiving, but.....it is otherwise known as "Turkey Day", so I don't see how you couldn't have a Turkey on Turkey Day!!! Chat Icon

If SIL does have very strict "rules" in her home, I would take the recommendation of a PP and bring in a "pre-cooked" turkey for your family.

Posted 9/13/08 11:26 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by nrthshgrl


At one point, my sister had severe diet restrictions (no sugar, no wheat, no dairy, etc). She brought her own food every where she went & discussed with the host what they were making. That was because she felt the host should not make special accomodations for what she cannot eat. I don't see the need to have turkey as a special accomodation.



I always offer to bring vegetarian food and non-dairy stuff so that the host doesn't have to make 2 meals, but most people know I'm a vegetarian and already plan veg options.

Posted 9/13/08 11:27 AM
 

mommy0604
My Son is my world...

Member since 10/07

3270 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I know Thanksgiving is about being with Family and friends and all that but it still is "Turkey Day". Thanksgiving Day without a Turkey wouldn't feel like Thanksgiving to me.

Posted 9/13/08 11:42 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by dm24angel

I would make it myself and bring it, she may have an issue touching or cooking meat, BUT you should have what YOU like too , not all about her beliefs KWIM?

eta- I forgot they live OOS, so No its not rude AT ALL to do that.

I would ask if they have a problem cooking meat in their oven. Some vegans are very strict that wayChat Icon
Chat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 11:56 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Coming from a vegan - I don't think its rude - but how hardcore is she? Does she allow meat in the house? (My older stepdaughter eats meat so we have meat in the house) - would she be ok with it? Is she a good hostess that way?

Posted 9/13/08 11:58 AM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Is this rude?

Any vegetarian I have ever known that has hosted Thanksgiving has still made a turkey for the other guests or has at least asked someone else to bring the turkey. Go ahead and do it. Why should you not eat turkey on Thanksgiving because THEY'RE vegetarians? This is coming from someone who was a vegetarian for years.

Posted 9/13/08 11:59 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by BunnyWife

mmm..It depends. If she is going through all this trouble making sides dishes (she will probably make a lot more then what you are used to seeing) she may find it rude that you need to bring something her family can't even eat. Have you ever had tofurkey? It actually tastes a lot like turkey and is veg friendly.

But seriously, call and ask her. She might not care one bit.



Noooo - tofurkey tastes nothing like turkey - I like tofurkey slices, but the tough little football thats avialable on thanksgiving is gross!!!!Chat Icon

ETA - if we were hosting thanksgiving, we wouldn't have turkey. Sorry Chat Icon We would have lots of yummy stuff, but not turkey.

Message edited 2008-09-13 12:02:05.380000.

Posted 9/13/08 12:01 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Coming from a vegan - I don't think its rude - but how hardcore is she? Does she allow meat in the house? (My older stepdaughter eats meat so we have meat in the house) - would she be ok with it? Is she a good hostess that way?



She isn't terribly hardcore. I think she wanted to become a vegan from the book Skinny B!tch.

She currently does not have a house (they are building, will have one by Thanksgiving), but she lives with her ILs who are not veg/vegan, so she is used to it being around.

We are very close, and laid back, so she can be honest with me about it, ya know.

The more I think about it, the more I like ordering one, but I am such a lazy arse, I may not get to it.Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-13 12:02:02.987000.

Posted 9/13/08 12:01 PM
 

kellsbells7
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/07

590 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by SweetTooth

I wouldn't ask about the turkey. Like others have said, thanksgiving is not about turkey, its about about being thankful and spending time with loved ones.
I think if she was ok with the turkey she would have told you up front it was ok if with her if you wanted to bring it for yourself.
IMO the sides are the best part anyway. Maybe you can do a mini thanksgiving for your immediate family the week before or after, but I don't think its appropriate to bring meat into a vegan household. It would be like asking someone who is kosher if it was ok to bring pork.




I agree

Posted 9/13/08 12:01 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Is this rude?

On a side note...I now want Zorn's for dinnerChat Icon

Posted 9/13/08 12:02 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

.



Because Thanksgiving doesn't have to be synonymous with eating a bird. Its being with family. They could serve bread and water as hosts. Its about being together and being thankful for what we have.

Posted 9/13/08 12:03 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Coming from a vegan - I don't think its rude - but how hardcore is she? Does she allow meat in the house? (My older stepdaughter eats meat so we have meat in the house) - would she be ok with it? Is she a good hostess that way?



She isn't terribly hardcore. I think she wanted to become a vegan from the book Skinny B!tch.

She currently does not have a house (they are building, will have one by Thanksgiving), but she lives with her ILs who are not veg/vegan, so she is used to it being around.

We are very close, and laid back, so she can be honest with me about it, ya know.

The more I think about it, the more I like ordering one, but I am such a lazy arse, I may not get to it.Chat Icon



Well, if you guys are close, call her and tell her exactly what you asked us, "I know this might sound weird, but I know you guys are veg, and I'm not sure etiquette wise if this is rude, but I wanted to be respectful, so i was wondering if...." She will appreciate it and probably will tell you to go ahead and do it!

Posted 9/13/08 12:05 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

my 1st thought was, why would a vegan host Thanksgiving dinner? Chat Icon

.



Because Thanksgiving doesn't have to be synonymous with eating a bird. Its being with family. They could serve bread and water as hosts. Its about being together and being thankful for what we have.



Liza, that's what I said too. I am dying to meet my new nephew and see my SIL, niece and BIL (all my Parenting buddies know what a nut she is, but I miss herChat Icon )

I would NEVER not go b/c she wasn't serving turkey!!

Posted 9/13/08 12:06 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this rude?

I'm a vegetarian. If someone wanted to bring turkey to a Thanksgiving meal that I spent all day (probably 2 days) preparing, taking into account that meat-eating family would be there so I'd probably make TONS of dishes of all sorts to please everyone... yes, I'd "let" them eat the turkey because *I'M* not rude. But I'd be steaming mad. Vegetarianism is a choice. Just like you have a choice to stay home and eat your traditional turkey dinner.

Let's say your MIL is a terrible cook, and she invites you over for pot roast. Do you accept her offer, and then show up with a leg of lamb and eat that instead, because you don't like her pot roast? No. You either don't go, or you eat the side dishes and thank her for inviting you over, because having dinner with family is about the sharing, and the company. And yes, in many cases, the food is the best part, but who's to say her veggie Thanksgiving won't be delicious?

I realize you want your family to have a "traditional" Thanksgiving, but I haven't eaten turkey in 10 years and I promise you, I don't enjoy Thanksgiving any less.

Posted 9/13/08 12:17 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I hope I dont turn into the traveling mom who lets her toddler get away with being rude HarleyGirlFLA 6/18/08 10 Pregnancy
Is it rude of me to ask people to remove their shoes when coming in my house ???? babybugsmum 12/5/07 145 Parenting
Is this rude? (esp. for Moms of more than 1) Tfor3 11/24/07 13 Parenting
Is this response too rude? UPDATED BELOW WITH SOME info about why the question scares me......... Kerie-is-so-very 8/29/07 29 Pregnancy
Is this rude or is it just me? (long) BabyAvocado 10/29/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Is it rude to ask someone how much they are offering when they call to set up an interview?**updated** LIMOMx2 7/27/06 16 Families Helping Families ™