WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

I think the most important question to ask is: how good is your current school district?

One a scale of 1 to 10, if you would be moving from a school that is an 8 to a school that is a 10, perhaps it is not really worth it. However, if you are potentially going from school that is a 5 or a 6 to school that is a 9 or a 10, then without a doubt it seems like the right thing to do!

Posted 11/30/14 8:54 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by Hofstra26

Personal feelings aside, you CANNOT argue there are districts that are considered to be above others and those better districts absolutely have some advantages over lesser ones. There is a reason why houses and taxes are A LOT more in areas where the district is considered to be top notch. It's not by accident.

Of course wonderful teachers can be everywhere and just because someone isn't in a top notch school doesn't mean they won't succeed in life BUT these threads where some try to pretend all school districts on LI are equal and great is silliness. It's a FACT that some districts WAY outshine others.




It's also a fact that racism and classism is also very rampant on LI. This is the elephant in the room a lot of people want to tip toe around when they are talking about what defines a good and bad district.

These two threads alone make me look at a couple posters A LOT differently.





You may be able to talk about classism, however the racism argument is weak and I can show why it doesn't really apply.

I have immediate family that either went to Riverhead, or have kids in Riverhead. Every single member of my family says the district is lousy and I can go on and on as to why. All I need to say is the property values in Riverhead reflect the quality of the district.

It has nothing to do with race. Sure there is a large percentage of minority that goes to this SD, but that doesn't tell the entire picture. It has to do with undisciplined kids attending the district that don't want to do the work, as well as the parents who simply don't give a crap. It produces a toxic environment in the classroom and the education suffers.

Jericho is one of the highest ranked SDs in the state, yet they also have a high percentage of minority (almost 40%). Just because there is minority attending the district, doesn't make it automatically bad.

If the "racism" argument was valid, you can say the two Levittown SDs should automatically be the best districts on the island since they are close to being the most "white". The amount of "white" doesn't dictate how good a district is.

Posted 12/1/14 1:54 AM
 

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

WWYD for a premier school district?

We live in the Great Neck school district, and I am so grateful. I think it was worth the cost and extra travel time. (and smaller house! we could have bought bigger in another district!)

Posted 12/1/14 7:27 AM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Calla

We live in the Great Neck school district, and I am so grateful. I think it was worth the cost and extra travel time. (and smaller house! we could have bought bigger in another district!)



I have presented there (I do educating and presenting for a living).

What a great district. I have been in pretty much every school on LI - both public and private - and I was super impressed by that district and the students/parents.

I left there and the whole way home I was like wow! Chat Icon

Posted 12/1/14 8:51 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Ugh, I hate when people play the race card in these threads. Its BS. Im not saying racism isnt alive and well on the island, but it is NOT why most of us choose the districts we do. We choose based on performance, funding, safety, programs, if some of the better ranked districts are predominantly white, that is NOT why I chose it and I didnt not chose a lower performing district bc of the racial makeup of the school but bc they are lacking in regards to the other factors listed above in comparison. Is it socioeconomic, sure, that Ill give you, but it is NOT racism. I hate when people play that card.

Posted 12/1/14 11:07 AM
 

Mrs&MrsK
i need sleep ;-)

Member since 2/14

2008 total posts

Name:
L

WWYD for a premier school district?

I may. still deciding. (20-30 min vs 45 and i grew up in the further town)

Posted 12/1/14 12:31 PM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by WhatNow

I think the most important question to ask is: how good is your current school district?

One a scale of 1 to 10, if you would be moving from a school that is an 8 to a school that is a 10, perhaps it is not really worth it. However, if you are potentially going from school that is a 5 or a 6 to school that is a 9 or a 10, then without a doubt it seems like the right thing to do!



Agree with this. If it is not much of a better rating then I would stay put. Right now my commute is 45 min and sometimes I wish I lived closer to work. Forget about when it snows.

Posted 12/1/14 1:01 PM
 

Ballet46
LIF Infant

Member since 6/14

180 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Eh no. I am honestly not impressed. Of course this is because I went to an "average" LI high school and ended up doing very well. It is really up to you what you regard as a huge value. I know that all the average districts are still better than most across the country. Truthfully, the fancier your district, the less chance you have of ranking high and going to an elite college. Everyone is competing, ya know what I mean.

Posted 12/1/14 1:31 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Nope. Not a chance. The school district is less important than time with my kids. Even the best school district isn't going to sit with my kids at night & review their work & talk to them about their day.

I'm assuming this is hypothetical because if money was no object, I could not work or work significantly less hours to be home for the kids.

Posted 12/1/14 2:14 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Hofstra26

Personal feelings aside, you CANNOT argue there are districts that are considered to be above others and those better districts absolutely have some advantages over lesser ones. There is a reason why houses and taxes are A LOT more in areas where the district is considered to be top notch. It's not by accident.

Of course wonderful teachers can be everywhere and just because someone isn't in a top notch school doesn't mean they won't succeed in life BUT these threads where some try to pretend all school districts on LI are equal and great is silliness. It's a FACT that some districts WAY outshine others.



This this this!!!

Posted 12/1/14 3:13 PM
 

Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties
LIFamilies Business

Member since 2/11

3992 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

As others have said, I think only the OP can decide what is right for her. I personally wouldn't uproot from a good school district and a community where I was happy -- at the price of increasing my commute -- to get into a top-ranked district. But I think if someone places a higher priority on that "premiere," top ranked district and feels that such a district is where their family will thrive, then they should move! If I've learned anything from being in real estate, it's that people have different priorities and make subjective judgments when buying a house. As long as the buyer is happy, then it doesn't matter if the driving factors in their decision are universally desirable or not. There shouldn't be any judgments about wanting to be in a certain district or NOT wanting to be, imo.

However, I feel like I've experienced many educational environments -- I went to Catholic grade school, a good (but not top-ranked) public high school, a local college with a large commuter population for undergrad, and an Ivy League law school that had the quintessential college life/campus. There are advantages AND drawbacks to every single educational setting, even a top-ranked public school district on Long Island.

A top-ranked district would undoubtedly offer many advantages to a student -- but perhaps for some students, the competitiveness or academic pressure would be a negative. Not every student is academically gifted or even inclined. Some students, no matter how much effort they put in or how much parental support they have, are just not cut out for a 4 year college. Some students benefit from learning a trade, such as the auto mechanic training program at Division High in Levittown.

Also, while I agree that most parents want "the best" for their children, the "best" isn't always the most that money can buy.

For example, I graduated from a good, solid school district, but not what the OP or people on this boards would consider "premiere." My husband graduated from a "premiere" district in a more wealthy area. When buying our house, we could have afforded to buy in my husband's hometown, which is lovely, but we opted to buy in an area more akin to where I grew up. We just felt that the less expensive town with the good but not TOP school district was a better fit for us to raise our family. What's best for anyone could involve considerations other than money. (When my son gets his driver's license in 10 or 11 years, I may be able to afford to buy him a car, but perhaps I think he should work to earn one. Or if I do buy him a car, maybe I will get him a used Ford, not a brand new sports car, because I think the less flashy car would be "best."). So I don't agree that anyone would choose to live in a premiere school district if it was within their means.

I also look at rankings and am aware of them, but I personally put more stock in what the school offers overall (in programs, curriculum, activities) than the rankings alone. Because as others have said, rankings can be manipulated based on what data sets you use or exclude, and can change (although I will agree that a top ranked school won't suddenly fall to the bottom of the list and vice-versa).



Posted 12/1/14 5:47 PM
 

Sheena
LIF Infant

Member since 3/07

264 total posts

Name:
queen of the jungle

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by DaniRella

Posted by Calla

We live in the Great Neck school district, and I am so grateful. I think it was worth the cost and extra travel time. (and smaller house! we could have bought bigger in another district!)



I have presented there (I do educating and presenting for a living).

What a great district. I have been in pretty much every school on LI - both public and private - and I was super impressed by that district and the students/parents.

I left there and the whole way home I was like wow! Chat Icon



I'm a teacher, and I'm curious. What impressed you and made you say, "Wow!"

Posted 12/1/14 6:03 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

I would love to know some of the districts we are talking about here

Posted 12/1/14 6:51 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Sheena

Posted by DaniRella

Posted by Calla

We live in the Great Neck school district, and I am so grateful. I think it was worth the cost and extra travel time. (and smaller house! we could have bought bigger in another district!)



I have presented there (I do educating and presenting for a living).

What a great district. I have been in pretty much every school on LI - both public and private - and I was super impressed by that district and the students/parents.

I left there and the whole way home I was like wow! Chat Icon



I'm a teacher, and I'm curious. What impressed you and made you say, "Wow!"



Parents and the kids. The way they carry themselves. How they speak. How they behave. I see kids their age all the time - all different districts. These kids were impressive and it takes a lot for me to notice things like that or honestly for me to even give a shit to notice.

Posted 12/1/14 8:40 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

A few random thoughts:

1. I don't think there is anything useful about making the case either for or against race as an issue here. Clearly, some people are racists and will therefore avoid certain districts. On the other hand, some people are genuinely not racist and just want the best for their children regardless of whether their classmates are white, black, purple, green, spotted, etc. I didn't analyze every response, but I don't recall evidence on this thread that anyone said anything overtly racist. That's a hefty allegation and should only be used when warranted.

2. Someone mentioned the desirability of Jericho as proof that it's not about racism, but frankly, I think the minorities that make up Jericho are not the same minorities that comprise many of the districts that some people label "bad." So, I don't believe that holds water, but again, I don't think there is anything to argue about. Some of those people are racists, some aren't.

3. I think many people, when looking at district quality, look at the overall stats, maybe get a few opinions from others, then call it a day. What people should really do is decide what is important in a district and then look for those things even if it means going beyond the stats and rankings - go to the school's website, look at the course offerings, etc. Many of the qualities that make the premier schools so great are equally evident in schools that are not considered "premier" and get overlooked. For example, I used to teach in Bay Shore. It doesn't get the stigma that say Brentwood, its neighbor, gets, but no one would mistake it for a "premier" school either. Well, the district has SO much to offer - plenty of AP courses and activities, plus it is only one of a handful of schools on the island that offer the I.B. program. I would send my kids there in a heartbeat. I suspect a lot of people never know this about the district when they're doing research, and yes I do believe that SOME people (by no means all) might get scared away by the diversity.

Posted 12/1/14 9:11 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

I live in a great district, in a very nice community. But what brought us here was primarily the commute. There are a lot of good districts on LI. I would not have wanted to add even 15 minutes each way to my husband's commute. If money is no object, unless you work wayyyyy out east, I think that you should be able to find a highly rated district closer to where you are now.

Posted 12/2/14 8:13 AM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

WWYD for a premier school district?

I live wayyyyy out east and our schools are not considered top notch, yet each year kids here regularly get into top colleges, including Ivys. The kids in our schools come from all walks of life, races and backgrounds. Some are wealthy, many are middle class and quite a few are poor or very disadvantaged. The schools vary widely in sizes and what they can offer, so anyone considering living out here ought to visit each before making a decision.

However, I believe, from a great deal of volunteering in my kid's schools which are fairly diverse, what makes the biggest difference in kid's outcomes and their chances to get into top colleges is the support each gets from their families, no matter their race and regardless of income. Those with support do well, those without have a higher chance of not doing so.

Posted 12/2/14 2:04 PM
 

MrsD121011
LIF Adult

Member since 5/12

1460 total posts

Name:
Elicia

WWYD for a premier school district?

There are definitley better school districts and not so great districts. I personally would move to get into a better district. As someone who grew up in one of the bad districits (Central Islip), a good district was essential when I was house hunting. Anyone can say it is what you make of it but it helps to have the support of a safe well funded district. I was a quiet, civically involoved student who did fairly well and stayed out of trouble, but the area I was in I was surrounded by gang activity, a school shooting, constant fights and many other issues that don't seem to plague districts with better reputations. It was imperetive to me and my DH who grew up in Brentwood (another tougher district) to move to an area and school district where my daughter would not have to worry so much about her safety and have a better leg up with after school activities, arts and music programs. So yes I would move to get the better schools.

Posted 12/3/14 9:07 AM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Nope. Not a chance. The school district is less important than time with my kids. Even the best school district isn't going to sit with my kids at night & review their work & talk to them about their day.

I'm assuming this is hypothetical because if money was no object, I could not work or work significantly less hours to be home for the kids.



This. I would not give up that much time with my kids just to go from good to better. In fact I might even consider going from better to just regular ol' good if it meant I could have significantly more time with my kids each day.

Posted 12/3/14 9:23 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
WWYD - nursery school related Diana1215 9/29/09 29 Parenting
WWYD? School park and drugs My4GirlsMyLife 7/11/09 5 Parenting
wwyd? (type of school) LoveBeingMrsT 6/19/09 11 Parenting
WWYD? Pre-school related nbc188 5/20/09 9 Parenting
WWYD...school related Dani00518 4/1/09 7 Parenting