Re: WWYD for a premier school district?
Posted 12/1/2014 5:47:20 PM by Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties

As others have said, I think only the OP can decide what is right for her. I personally wouldn't uproot from a good school district and a community where I was happy -- at the price of increasing my commute -- to get into a top-ranked district. But I think if someone places a higher priority on that "premiere," top ranked district and feels that such a district is where their family will thrive, then they should move! If I've learned anything from being in real estate, it's that people have different priorities and make subjective judgments when buying a house. As long as the buyer is happy, then it doesn't matter if the driving factors in their decision are universally desirable or not. There shouldn't be any judgments about wanting to be in a certain district or NOT wanting to be, imo.

However, I feel like I've experienced many educational environments -- I went to Catholic grade school, a good (but not top-ranked) public high school, a local college with a large commuter population for undergrad, and an Ivy League law school that had the quintessential college life/campus. There are advantages AND drawbacks to every single educational setting, even a top-ranked public school district on Long Island.

A top-ranked district would undoubtedly offer many advantages to a student -- but perhaps for some students, the competitiveness or academic pressure would be a negative. Not every student is academically gifted or even inclined. Some students, no matter how much effort they put in or how much parental support they have, are just not cut out for a 4 year college. Some students benefit from learning a trade, such as the auto mechanic training program at Division High in Levittown.

Also, while I agree that most parents want "the best" for their children, the "best" isn't always the most that money can buy.

For example, I graduated from a good, solid school district, but not what the OP or people on this boards would consider "premiere." My husband graduated from a "premiere" district in a more wealthy area. When buying our house, we could have afforded to buy in my husband's hometown, which is lovely, but we opted to buy in an area more akin to where I grew up. We just felt that the less expensive town with the good but not TOP school district was a better fit for us to raise our family. What's best for anyone could involve considerations other than money. (When my son gets his driver's license in 10 or 11 years, I may be able to afford to buy him a car, but perhaps I think he should work to earn one. Or if I do buy him a car, maybe I will get him a used Ford, not a brand new sports car, because I think the less flashy car would be "best."). So I don't agree that anyone would choose to live in a premiere school district if it was within their means.

I also look at rankings and am aware of them, but I personally put more stock in what the school offers overall (in programs, curriculum, activities) than the rankings alone. Because as others have said, rankings can be manipulated based on what data sets you use or exclude, and can change (although I will agree that a top ranked school won't suddenly fall to the bottom of the list and vice-versa).




Print Post      Close Window