WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

WWYD for a premier school district?

The elite school districts on LI are not elite by accident. Usually the affluence of the area plays a large role in the success of the schools and ultimately the children. If the parents are able to provide unlimited tutoring, SAT prep classes, college application experts, etc they would do extremely well in any district. When you put a lot of families together in one district that have the financial ability to provide these resources for their children it's easy to see why these districts have the statistics they do.
If you believe you can offer the same competitive edge to your children as their peers, go for it. On the flip side I would never want to be trying to "keep up" in some of the elite school districts on LI.

Message edited 2014-11-29 21:26:24.630000.

Posted 11/29/14 9:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.

Message edited 2014-11-29 23:21:47.127000.

Posted 11/29/14 9:30 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by mrswask

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by shellbebaby

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.




Wow, really?

Better not come into my hood then.

You might get attacked.

By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.




I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.



The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.




You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.



I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.

Posted 11/29/14 11:15 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Look, its just facts and I dont know why people take this so personally. My DH used to be a teacher in Brentwood HS and then taught in Commack HS, the two districts could not be more different. He was a year out from being eligible for tenure and chose to leave the brentwood district bc he spent FAR more time on disciplinary actions then he did teaching. No, of course this does not apply to ALL kids in every district. Every district has their bright students who work hard, who do what needs to be done, who excel and achieve, but if you generalize a district overall, it just is.....some are worse than others. I dont know why people get up in arms when people say some disctricts are worse than others.....they ARE. They just are.

To the OP - Im speaking in my original reply of a really good district vs a top 100. In that case, no, I wouldnt move for it. If your children are hard workers, I feel a really good distrcit will serve them just fine and wouldnt add the 45 minutes in that case.

Posted 11/30/14 12:09 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Look, its just facts and I dont know why people take this so personally. My DH used to be a teacher in Brentwood HS and then taught in Commack HS, the two districts could not be more different. He was a year out from being eligible for tenure and chose to leave the brentwood district bc he spent FAR more time on disciplinary actions then he did teaching. No, of course this does not apply to ALL kids in every district. Every district has their bright students who work hard, who do what needs to be done, who excel and achieve, but if you generalize a district overall, it just is.....some are worse than others. I dont know why people get up in arms when people say some disctricts are worse than others.....they ARE. They just are.

To the OP - Im speaking in my original reply of a really good district vs a top 100. In that case, no, I wouldnt move for it. If your children are hard workers, I feel a really good distrcit will serve them just fine and wouldnt add the 45 minutes in that case.



While I do get what you are saying, and know some are obviously better than others it is hard to NOT take it personally because when you are on the receiving end of blanket statements, especially by people who do not live in/know the district, it is upsetting.

It IS like you are speaking about me and my family directly in a negative light.

There are many positives about my district that I shouldn't have to defend.

Great young, involved teachers, some of the first trained in common core, good special Ed program, great neighbors,etc. Etc.

Also another example....DH and I are not religious, but have lost count the # of times "Christian" people have said to our faces "how can you raise your child where you are. Aren't you afraid for him with those black and Spanish kids?"

Said here on LI over past couple of years......

Posted 11/30/14 7:18 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Teach723

Posted by Millie3

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.



I so agree about the discipline. My kids went to a camp in another school district last summer. Huge difference.



You have to be kidding me. There are discipline issues in every school district. Do we think rich kids are better behaved? Ha!



I went to school in a "rich" area. I knew multiple kids that went to rehab and a bunch who ended up in jail. So money does not make kids behave.

Posted 11/30/14 7:28 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by alli3131

Posted by Teach723

Posted by Millie3

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.



I so agree about the discipline. My kids went to a camp in another school district last summer. Huge difference.



You have to be kidding me. There are discipline issues in every school district. Do we think rich kids are better behaved? Ha!



I went to school in a "rich" area. I knew multiple kids that went to rehab and a bunch who ended up in jail. So money does not make kids behave.



It was also not too long ago that Seaford and Massapequa were all over the news because of the "heroin epidemic"

Not going to judge because I don't live in either district but I have friends and family who do who were up in arms then when this came out. Either they were defending the districts or ready to go private school route.

Posted 11/30/14 7:32 AM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Message edited 2014-11-30 08:26:17.567000.

Posted 11/30/14 8:19 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Personal feelings aside, you CANNOT argue there are districts that are considered to be above others and those better districts absolutely have some advantages over lesser ones. There is a reason why houses and taxes are A LOT more in areas where the district is considered to be top notch. It's not by accident.

Of course wonderful teachers can be everywhere and just because someone isn't in a top notch school doesn't mean they won't succeed in life BUT these threads where some try to pretend all school districts on LI are equal and great is silliness. It's a FACT that some districts WAY outshine others.

Posted 11/30/14 9:27 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by alli3131

Posted by Teach723

Posted by Millie3

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.



I so agree about the discipline. My kids went to a camp in another school district last summer. Huge difference.



You have to be kidding me. There are discipline issues in every school district. Do we think rich kids are better behaved? Ha!



I went to school in a "rich" area. I knew multiple kids that went to rehab and a bunch who ended up in jail. So money does not make kids behave.



I've taught in really nice districts and really $hitty ones, there is a DEFINITE difference in the kids attitudes, behavior, effort, motivation, parent involvement, etc. That's not to say they aren't good and bad kids everywhere but on the whole, there IS a difference.

Posted 11/30/14 9:31 AM
 

oldtimerocknroll
LIF Adult

Member since 11/14

1657 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Hofstra26

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.



I just want to point out... You wrote "Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford..."

Everyone defines "the best" differently, and money is not always the answer to achieving "the best." Perhaps, money defines "the best" to some, but that's not an unequivocal statement for everyone.

Posted 11/30/14 9:54 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Hofstra26

Personal feelings aside, you CANNOT argue there are districts that are considered to be above others and those better districts absolutely have some advantages over lesser ones. There is a reason why houses and taxes are A LOT more in areas where the district is considered to be top notch. It's not by accident.

Of course wonderful teachers can be everywhere and just because someone isn't in a top notch school doesn't mean they won't succeed in life BUT these threads where some try to pretend all school districts on LI are equal and great is silliness. It's a FACT that some districts WAY outshine others.




It's also a fact that racism and classism is also very rampant on LI. This is the elephant in the room a lot of people want to tip toe around when they are talking about what defines a good and bad district.

These two threads alone make me look at a couple posters A LOT differently.

Posted 11/30/14 11:59 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by MrsA1012

This website is so politically correct it is laughable. Some districts are better than others. Very often, the better districts have residents with a higher socioeconomic status. Welcome to reality. This doesn't mean a child can't get a good education in a lower ranked district. My two cents on schools ,based on professional experience, is that if your child is extremely intelligent, learns in a different way or just doesn't fit into a cookie cutter mold, most schools will have trouble meeting his or her needs. I also feel that most intense learning happens at home. Make sure your child reads every day, avoid electronics ,have stimulating discussions, keep a list of vocabulary words, keep them up to date on current events, teach about history, travel to historic places,introduce to them to fine arts and culture etc etc. If you do all this ,your child will be beautifully educated regardless of what district he goes to. Imo, no one can educate a child better than a parent.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/30/14 12:27 PM
 

babyfever24
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

3340 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by lynnd126

I wouldn't care and wouldn't move. Unless you are in a horrible school district, education is what you make of it. Imo what matters the most is what goes in at home regarding reinforcement and enrichment.

Eta- When I say horrible I mean things like violence or zero activities etc. Maybe no support for special needs if you have them.



same....you can be in a great school and if you don't sit and do homework with your kids, carry over etc it won't make a difference.

Posted 11/30/14 12:52 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by mrswask

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by shellbebaby

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.




Wow, really?

Better not come into my hood then.

You might get attacked.

By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.




I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.



The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.




You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.



I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.

We have the Internet so any admissions committee can find out more about any given school in an instant.

Posted 11/30/14 1:06 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by Hofstra26

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.



I just want to point out... You wrote "Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford..."

Everyone defines "the best" differently, and money is not always the answer to achieving "the best." Perhaps, money defines "the best" to some, but that's not an unequivocal statement for everyone.

Then why is there such a strong link between a town's median income, housing prices, property taxes and the ranking of its schools? I don't live on Long Island, but things are the same where I live. I imagine they are the same all over the country.

Posted 11/30/14 1:14 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by MrsA1012

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by Hofstra26

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.



I just want to point out... You wrote "Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford..."

Everyone defines "the best" differently, and money is not always the answer to achieving "the best." Perhaps, money defines "the best" to some, but that's not an unequivocal statement for everyone.

Then why is there such a strong link between a town's median income, housing prices, property taxes and the ranking of its schools? I don't live on Long Island, but things are the same where I live. I imagine they are the same all over the country.



I think you're reading into it way too literally, and by doing that, you are discounting all the families who are working hard every day to keep a roof over their heads, food on the table, and provide their children with solid educations.

I wanted to buy a house. I bought in a middle class area with a solid, middle class district. Does that make me a bad person? I did "the best" I could with the salaries that DH and I make - by your logic, should I have rented an apartment in a more affluent district? My "best" was buying a house I could afford in a district I liked, because I know that parental involvement in academics is essential as well.

Everyone has different priorities. Why do people live where they do? Why do people value diversity over test scores and median household incomes? Why do some people who have the means to live in a Manhattan penthouse choose to live in a suburb? It's about what that individual person places their own internal value on, whether it's emotional or financial.

Posted 11/30/14 1:25 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by MrsA1012

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by Hofstra26

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.



I just want to point out... You wrote "Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford..."

Everyone defines "the best" differently, and money is not always the answer to achieving "the best." Perhaps, money defines "the best" to some, but that's not an unequivocal statement for everyone.

Then why is there such a strong link between a town's median income, housing prices, property taxes and the ranking of its schools? I don't live on Long Island, but things are the same where I live. I imagine they are the same all over the country.



I think you're reading into it way too literally, and by doing that, you are discounting all the families who are working hard every day to keep a roof over their heads, food on the table, and provide their children with solid educations.

I wanted to buy a house. I bought in a middle class area with a solid, middle class district. Does that make me a bad person? I did "the best" I could with the salaries that DH and I make - by your logic, should I have rented an apartment in a more affluent district? My "best" was buying a house I could afford in a district I liked, because I know that parental involvement in academics is essential as well.

Everyone has different priorities. Why do people live where they do? Why do people value diversity over test scores and median household incomes? Why do some people who have the means to live in a Manhattan penthouse choose to live in a suburb? It's about what that individual person places their own internal value on, whether it's emotional or financial.

I don't disagree with anything you are saying. I think we are making two different points and it is getting lost because of the limitations of writing on a message board. I am merely arguing that there is a strong connection between school rankings and the wealth of an area. For example, I imagine the schools in your " solid, middle class area " are better raked than those in a poorer area. That's the sum total of my argument.

Posted 11/30/14 1:42 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by MrsA1012

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by mrswask

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by shellbebaby

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.




Wow, really?

Better not come into my hood then.

You might get attacked.

By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.




I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.



The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.




You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.



I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.

We have the Internet so any admissions committee can find out more about any given school in an instant.



I get that but what I'm really trying to say to the op is that she is already in a good district. She's not talking about moving from a very poorly achieving district to the best one in the world. That's really what I meant about admissions committees not being concerned with the nuances that get beat to death on here. They know some schools that I described as "big money" bc they know it helps them financially in the long term. The alumni relations directors are pushing on those instances to recruit students who have parents with the ability to make big donations. Obviously that's only a part of the pie, but imo they are not differentiating between similar districts, the way we are here, like talking about different towns in a 15 mile radius.

Posted 11/30/14 1:54 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by MrsA1012

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by mrswask

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by shellbebaby

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.




Wow, really?

Better not come into my hood then.

You might get attacked.

By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.




I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.



The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.




You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.



I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.

We have the Internet so any admissions committee can find out more about any given school in an instant.



I get that but what I'm really trying to say to the op is that she is already in a good district. She's not talking about moving from a very poorly achieving district to the best one in the world. That's really what I meant about admissions committees not being concerned with the nuances that get beat to death on here. They know some schools that I described as "big money" bc they know it helps them financially in the long term. The alumni relations directors are pushing on those instances to recruit students who have parents with the ability to make big donations. Obviously that's only a part of the pie, but imo they are not differentiating between similar districts, the way we are here, like talking about different towns in a 15 mile radius.

Yes, I hear what you are saying. I've been told that admissions committees at top schools are very aware of the most elite prep schools and some of the top public schools, as these are feeders to the Ivy League. Beyond that, I'm not aware of how much each committee knows; however, they can easily gain more information,if they choose.

Posted 11/30/14 1:59 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22153 total posts

Name:

WWYD for a premier school district?

While I would strive to get my child into the best district I could possibly afford, I also come from the school of thought that it is ALSO what your child makes of it.

Posted 11/30/14 3:26 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by MrsA1012

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by mrswask

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by shellbebaby

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by shellbebaby

Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.

I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.




Wow, really?

Better not come into my hood then.

You might get attacked.

By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.




I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.



The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.




You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.



I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.

We have the Internet so any admissions committee can find out more about any given school in an instant.



I get that but what I'm really trying to say to the op is that she is already in a good district. She's not talking about moving from a very poorly achieving district to the best one in the world. That's really what I meant about admissions committees not being concerned with the nuances that get beat to death on here. They know some schools that I described as "big money" bc they know it helps them financially in the long term. The alumni relations directors are pushing on those instances to recruit students who have parents with the ability to make big donations. Obviously that's only a part of the pie, but imo they are not differentiating between similar districts, the way we are here, like talking about different towns in a 15 mile radius.



Actually we don't know that. She said she is happy with her community, she never specified what the schools were like. I think it does make a difference. Are we talking about going from an average LI district to say one of the top 2, or are we talking about going from say number 5 on LI to number 3.

Actually from speaking to someone years ago, schools do know each district's reputations. They also look at how students who were admitted did. If they have students who were accepted, then underperformed they are less likely to admit as many from that school in the future. They also know that some districts inflate their grades, etc.

Everyone has different values, and different experience which shape their views. Obviously the ranking is of importance to the OP or she would not have asked the question. Everyone makes their choices for their families. Some people do consider these things important as I know people who buy the smallest home in a "top" district or an apartment just to get in the door. Whereas another family is very happy with a very good but slightly less district but a bigger home. Each person has to do what is right for their family.

Also we live in an area with so much history and culture. Some never take their children to museums, or other places. Even the top schools need parents who supplement their education.

Message edited 2014-11-30 15:31:27.547000.

Posted 11/30/14 3:29 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

WWYD for a premier school district?

Yes and I did. I can afford my mortgage but I could get a bigger house with this money in another district. I chose instead to move into a sought after district and a home within the district of one of the top high schools, highly rated elementary school and brand new middle school. The money is here. The taxes are high but the schools are well funded and this area has better programs and opportunities.

Yes I did very well in a not so great school district. Yes home is the priority for good education but if I could move to an area with a better advantaged school system, I would (and did) move.

Ironically, if she decides to attend a program school, she'll have to go to school in a less advantageous school because the city wants to integrate kids in advanced programs with those who are not to provide diversity and exposure for both.

Posted 11/30/14 4:48 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

Posted by FirstMate

I would not just because of the commute. I never truly appreciated a short commute until I had a kid. I can run home to go to his pre-K pageants, mother's day teas, pick up from school due to illness, doctor's appointments, etc. and use it as my lunch hour. My co-worker, who commutes about 50 minutes, can not do that. If she needs to do those things, its a half day for her. Also, it really stinks when you get that call from school that your kid is sick as a dog and you know you can't get there for at least an hour. Also, I can stay at work later and get more done after hours because I have a quick commute home. My co-worker is running out the door at 5 because at that time of day she isn't home until 6:30. In my office, my partners perceive that the later you stay, the harder you work (even though that is not necessarily true). My bonus has never been effected since I had my DS but my co-worker has suffered a lot.

Just food for thought.



Such excellent points.

Posted 11/30/14 6:44 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: WWYD for a premier school district?

I drive 45 minutes now. It's not fun, but it's doable. I deal with all the stuff the poster above mentioned (calls from my child's school, having to leave on time, etc) but I make that work too. I don't have a choice, so I kind of have to. But who wouldn't love a short commute?

*I* personally don't think a top school is always worth it; I think that the child(ren) of involved parents will probably be fine almost anywhere on LI.

To the posters that mentioned admissions committees: I'm a guidance counselor / college advisor in one of the top schools in the state. Yes, there is some level of brand recognition in a "top" school. But not all colleges divide application reading by geographic region, and most competitive colleges have multiple readers for a single app. Nuanced differences in school district are not a major factor in whether the child was ultimately admitted. Some top schools will have caps on the number of students that can be admitted from a single school/district - so attending a competitive high school is actually a disadvantage, because students are duking it out with their classmates for a spot.

So, no, I would's do it. But that's me. If you think it's worth it and can swing it financially, go for it!

Message edited 2014-11-30 20:46:33.647000.

Posted 11/30/14 8:34 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
WWYD - nursery school related Diana1215 9/29/09 29 Parenting
WWYD? School park and drugs My4GirlsMyLife 7/11/09 5 Parenting
wwyd? (type of school) LoveBeingMrsT 6/19/09 11 Parenting
WWYD? Pre-school related nbc188 5/20/09 9 Parenting
WWYD...school related Dani00518 4/1/09 7 Parenting