Re: WWYD for a premier school district?
Posted 11/30/2014 3:29:40 PM by Lillykat
Posted by lynnd126
Posted by MrsA1012
Posted by lynnd126
Posted by mrswask
Posted by lynnd126
Posted by shellbebaby
Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee
Posted by shellbebaby
Yes I would. My cousins grew up in a top school district and it definitely opened up a lot more opportunities for them. Not only did they get into better colleges, they had more connections for top jobs, I think school districts are very important.
I think a good school district also spends more time on education and less time on discipline. This is important.
Wow, really?
Better not come into my hood then.
You might get attacked.
By the same kids who got into med school and Ivy League.
I'm not saying you can't get into good schools from another school district. My district was good but not Top and 10 people in my class went to IVY or IVY equivalent, and ranked #46 I attended a top liberal arts college. 'm saying my cousins went to better schools then they would have gone to had they come from another school district. A lot of top schools will take lesser grades from better school districts. I don't believe for a second my cousin would have gone to an IVY with his grades out of another district.
The admissions departments of Ivy league colleges are not comparing Long Island school districts, lol. They may be familiar with some very special schools (usually preparatory school academy type places where students come from real BIG money) but believe me you are fooling yourself if you think they are even familiar with the nuances of districts around here.
You are very wrong and "you are fooling yourself" if you think the colleges don't know the high schools. The Ivies, as well as most of the colleges and universities, are very familiar with the different schools and the nuances of the schools. That's why admissions departments have counselors divided into regions. They know the schools in their regions and they are the first people, and maybe the last, who will read your application and make the admissions decision.
I won't bother to argue but this is one topic I happen to know a lot about and I stand behind my opinion. Imo the op, who is already happy with her district, would better serve her kids with the extra time.
We have the Internet so any admissions committee can find out more about any given school in an instant.
I get that but what I'm really trying to say to the op is that she is already in a good district. She's not talking about moving from a very poorly achieving district to the best one in the world. That's really what I meant about admissions committees not being concerned with the nuances that get beat to death on here. They know some schools that I described as "big money" bc they know it helps them financially in the long term. The alumni relations directors are pushing on those instances to recruit students who have parents with the ability to make big donations. Obviously that's only a part of the pie, but imo they are not differentiating between similar districts, the way we are here, like talking about different towns in a 15 mile radius.
Actually we don't know that. She said she is happy with her community, she never specified what the schools were like. I think it does make a difference. Are we talking about going from an average LI district to say one of the top 2, or are we talking about going from say number 5 on LI to number 3.
Actually from speaking to someone years ago, schools do know each district's reputations. They also look at how students who were admitted did. If they have students who were accepted, then underperformed they are less likely to admit as many from that school in the future. They also know that some districts inflate their grades, etc.
Everyone has different values, and different experience which shape their views. Obviously the ranking is of importance to the OP or she would not have asked the question. Everyone makes their choices for their families. Some people do consider these things important as I know people who buy the smallest home in a "top" district or an apartment just to get in the door. Whereas another family is very happy with a very good but slightly less district but a bigger home. Each person has to do what is right for their family.
Also we live in an area with so much history and culture. Some never take their children to museums, or other places. Even the top schools need parents who supplement their education.
|