Re: WWYD for a premier school district?
Posted 11/30/2014 1:42:55 PM by MrsA1012


Posted by Kitten1929


Posted by MrsA1012


Posted by oldtimerocknroll


Posted by Hofstra26

I would do what I had to in order to give my children the best education and opportunities possible because I think those things matter in the long run. Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford, it's only beneficial to them and their future.

My parents moved us from a crummy district and I'm thankful ever single day they did. I truly believe my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district and NOT had the opportunities I was afforded by being in a better school. It matters.

OP, do what you think is in the best interest of your children.



I just want to point out... You wrote "Who wouldn't want to give their child the best they could afford..."

Everyone defines "the best" differently, and money is not always the answer to achieving "the best." Perhaps, money defines "the best" to some, but that's not an unequivocal statement for everyone.

Then why is there such a strong link between a town's median income, housing prices, property taxes and the ranking of its schools? I don't live on Long Island, but things are the same where I live. I imagine they are the same all over the country.



I think you're reading into it way too literally, and by doing that, you are discounting all the families who are working hard every day to keep a roof over their heads, food on the table, and provide their children with solid educations.

I wanted to buy a house. I bought in a middle class area with a solid, middle class district. Does that make me a bad person? I did "the best" I could with the salaries that DH and I make - by your logic, should I have rented an apartment in a more affluent district? My "best" was buying a house I could afford in a district I liked, because I know that parental involvement in academics is essential as well.

Everyone has different priorities. Why do people live where they do? Why do people value diversity over test scores and median household incomes? Why do some people who have the means to live in a Manhattan penthouse choose to live in a suburb? It's about what that individual person places their own internal value on, whether it's emotional or financial.

I don't disagree with anything you are saying. I think we are making two different points and it is getting lost because of the limitations of writing on a message board. I am merely arguing that there is a strong connection between school rankings and the wealth of an area. For example, I imagine the schools in your " solid, middle class area " are better raked than those in a poorer area. That's the sum total of my argument.
Print Post      Close Window