Re: Is this rude?
Posted 9/13/2008 11:20:18 AM by dm24angel
Posted by JenniferEver
Posted by dm24angel
Posted by JenniferEver
Posted by dm24angel
REALLY? I find this odd.
Why would you invite people over if you werent going to make things they eat as well.
My SIL is a vegetarian. We eat there all the time, she always cooks something for us and something for them.
I was a vegetarian for a long time till I had my son, I never gave it a thought?
I find it rude to not serve meat for meat eaters....and vice versa, if she were at kates house, I would expect Kate to provide HER with Vegan friendly foods. KWIM?
I totally disagree for a number of reasons.
its not as if the vegetarian stuff is something the meat eaters CAN'T eat, as is the case with a vegan going to someone's house and there being no vegan food. That excludes people, wheras the vegan meal includes people and everyone can eat it. There's no rule that says that if you eat meat you need it at every meal, so I don't see how people are being deprived of "things they eat."
It's like if someone says "i'm going to invite you over for a big italian style dinner. I'm making ravioli" and you say "well, to me, an italian dinner means lasagne, so can I bring some of that?" If someone's inviting you for dinner, you have to eat what they serve, unless YOU are the vegan or if you're kosher or have an allergy, etc.
I understand that a lot of people have a really big connection with eating turkey on thanksgiving, and if it were any other meal I'm sure OP would not even be posting, but you can always have a mini turkey dinner another night (maybe SIL will let you bring home leftovers and you can just add the turkey). it won't hurt anyone to not have it on that one thanksgiving. if it's that important, don't go to her house for Thanksgiving.
I get yoru points, Im just saying as a former vegetarian and with my my own SIL as one, I would think its rude, but hey we are all entitled to our own opinion and if it became a big deal, I would eat the sides and not care .
Well truth be told if I were the one cooking I would be ****** off, but I probably would allow them to bring a cooked turkey.
see everyone feels differently. Me and my SIL were/are vegetarians for reasons other then Animal welfar...so touching , cooking meat was not a problem for us. everyones different.
I think Kate should ask SIL and if she sounds hesitant, then just forget it. SImple as that.
|