Forget it.

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

ria
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

664 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

You and who ever contributed for the gift for the teacher's should be on the card. The JW would not want her, nor her child's name on the card anyway.

I am sure she would give a gift to the teacher's at other times. Like in June at the end of the year, when there are no ties to any holiday. Gift giving is fine, if it is one, not a burden to her financially
and if it has no ties to any holiday or birthday.

Posted 12/17/08 11:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Kara

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Shelly

I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me.

The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you.



and that statement is absolutely rude!!! calling someone intolerant is unbelievable especially since she's trying to understand the situation. she is not giving a christmas gift---who's to say the teachers are even christian?

mo---do not put that child's name on the card since he's not allowed to give gifts (even though the mother said she would--but that's another story). do NOT write "from the class" because that INCLUDES the child. list the other 6 names--including those who are not in a financial position to donate. the teachers will know why the kid's name is not on there.

the mother is playing a game with you. she called YOU and said she would donate to an appreciation gift but when asked for it she declined. just let her be. don't call her for anything. you have enough to deal with. she'll do what she wants to do for the class--which is apparently nothing.

do not give the gift at any other time of year. my students NEVER give me a christmas card---it's usually a thank you card. do the same for the teachers since you probably don't know what they celebrate anyway.

ETA: i have had jehovas witnesses before and some HAVE contributed to end of year/mid year gifts. and some have not---just like people of any other religion




The mother is not playing games, she is living within the bounds of HER PERSONAL religious beliefs. I may have missed something, but it says she spoke to the mother on the phone. I didn't see where the mother called the OP. Even if she did, she called to try to understand if it was a holiday gift or not... Clearly whatever explanation was given, she feels it's a holiday gift and won't contribute for religious reasons. It's her prerogative to decline to contribute for any reason (and I doubt the OP has intimate knowledge of her finances...) - I'd at least hope that when the reason is religious people could be more understanding.

I don't get how this is an issue.



yes, she is playing games--she said she would contribute and then backed out. and yes, the OP DOES have knowledge of her finances--obviously not in detail but a general overview based on certain aspects. and yes the OP did speak to her on the phone.

and i know this for fact



I know they spoke on the phone - I said that in my post. I said I didn't see it posted that the JW mother called the OP.

She said she would contribute if it was an appreciation gift. Apparently she decided that since it's being given near the holidays it's a holiday gift to which she is not comfortable contributing. Guess what - that's her right. Whenever group collections are taken, some people contribute and some don't. It happens. It even happens that people say they will and don't. That's just the way it goes. I would certainly hope people would be tolerant enough to accept a RELIGIOUS reason why one cannot contribute, even if she did change her mind on how she viewed the gift. And c'mon. While the gift may be to show appreciation, it's pretty clear that it's being given now b/c of the holidays.

It's obvious that the OP has a history of being frustrated with this woman -- but that doesn't change the fact that she has a very valid reason for not contributing to this gift. And I honestly don't think just her not contributing is going to ruin the gift in some way. It's against her religion. Whatever else has happened, that should be respected.

Posted 12/17/08 11:28 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Thanks everyone Chat Icon

I didn't mean for this to get heated in anyway. I WAS very frustrated as I guess I didn't understand enough about the religion.....

And browneyedgirl is 100% right as I spoke to her about this this am. I called the mom (I always call the parents) and she called me back and the convo started with her saying she'd help out with an appreciation gift.

I do completely understand its a gift being given at the holiday season....but it is going to be a non religious card and more of a "thank you for all you do" type of thing.

I respect this persons religion...but if you knew all the background from day one people may feel a bit different.

I don't mind having only 4 parents contribute in the end...I mean it IS the holiday season and any kind of giving is good enough for me Chat Icon

I am not going to include this boys name, obviously if his mom is so against a gift for his teachers from HER then his name will not go on the card but I do not want ANYONE excluded. I am simply going to write "from your class" and that will be that. That way no one gets hurt!

Posted 12/17/08 12:26 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

I can see where you are coming from, but also where they are coming from.

I am sure a religious Jew would not participate in Christmas at all, KWIM?

They may contribute for a holiday gift, or Hannukah, but if someone called it Christmas, they may not contribute - sure, some would, but some wouldn't....

Posted 12/17/08 12:45 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

IMO, This is why teacher gifts should not be permitted. It gets so sticky with all of the parents and children and different financial/religious situations.

The DOE doesn't permit teachers to accept gifts valued at over 5 dollars. They are also supposed to be used for the entire class and not for the teacher's personal use. Of course it happens that some teachers receive generous gifts, but much more rarely than in the suburbs or private schools.

I am a teacher and do my job because I love it. The best (and only) gifts I have ever received were notes of appreciation from parents and students AFTER I taught them. If I received a gift with a card signed by the majority of my students, with a few left out, I think I would feel very sad.

Again, JMO.

Posted 12/17/08 2:22 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by JennZ

Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything?

*playing devils advocate*

She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I'm sorry, I think it's silly that you're so furious with her. It's her religious beliefs and that should be respected. She also acknowledged that she was no problem giving an appreciation gift, just not something tied in to the holidays. Also, the fact that she's well off has nothing to do with it and I personally find it a little offensive that you would mention that.

Posted 12/17/08 6:03 PM
 

mommyago
&hearts; Lucas and Layla

Member since 8/08

2979 total posts

Name:
Jenise

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

I just want to say that i understand your frustrations


Im on the opposite end of it as a teacher and the last 2 years ive had children who are JW and I understand that they dont celebrate anything but why cant they learn about different holidays? I do christmas/ Hanukkah/ Kwanza activities and ive had a parent who would rip out anything in their notebook that had to do with any holiday....anytime i had some other kid bring in something for their bday the JW had to leave the class (as per her parents request) when wed sing happy birthday and have a cupcake, they werent allowed to get a "goody bag" if the kids brought them in for any reason

I feel so bad for these children...even though i know they are used to it and they know they cant have it, they look so sad...i mean how much does a little kid understand that everyone else gets to have cupcakes and goody bags but not them?

This year my JW was sooooo sad on halloween (im teaching kindergarten this year) and i dont think my girl has ever been to school before and has never experienced halloween where every kid gets all dressed up and excited but shes not..all she kept talking about is how she wished she could dress up as a witch but wasnt allowed

sorry for being so long and i hope i dont get flamed either..i completely respect the religion and would never go against the parents wishes but i just feel so bad for the kids that dont understand it

Posted 12/17/08 7:15 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by mrswask

Posted by JennZ

Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything?

*playing devils advocate*

She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I'm sorry, I think it's silly that you're so furious with her. It's her religious beliefs and that should be respected. She also acknowledged that she was no problem giving an appreciation gift, just not something tied in to the holidays. Also, the fact that she's well off has nothing to do with it and I personally find it a little offensive that you would mention that.



Sorry you were offended.

I wasn't saying that because she was well off she needs to give holiday gifts...I was saying that she does NOTHING for the class for any occasion...it gets left to the same three parents all the time and it gets old really fast.

I am not FURIOUS with her. I was frustrated and explained myself ten thousand times in other posts that I didn't truly understand the religion and why they couldn't help out towards non-denominational gifts.

If people read my posts maybe there woudln't be as much flaming and confusion. I NEVER EVER said I was giving them christmas or hanukah gifts..it was just a simple THANK YOU to the teachers at this time. Which i know is the holidays, but the gift is seriously not related to any specific religion.

I am cleared now on the confines of JW faith, and I am more aware of what their beliefs are. It was more the background of this lady and what I've been through with her.

Posted 12/17/08 7:16 PM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Forget it.

Posted by Jenise

I just want to say that i understand your frustrations


Im on the opposite end of it as a teacher and the last 2 years ive had children who are JW and I understand that they dont celebrate anything but why cant they learn about different holidays? I do christmas/ Hanukkah/ Kwanza activities and ive had a parent who would rip out anything in their notebook that had to do with any holiday....anytime i had some other kid bring in something for their bday the JW had to leave the class (as per her parents request) when wed sing happy birthday and have a cupcake, they werent allowed to get a "goody bag" if the kids brought them in for any reason

I feel so bad for these children...even though i know they are used to it and they know they cant have it, they look so sad...i mean how much does a little kid understand that everyone else gets to have cupcakes and goody bags but not them?

This year my JW was sooooo sad on halloween (im teaching kindergarten this year) and i dont think my girl has ever been to school before and has never experienced halloween where every kid gets all dressed up and excited but shes not..all she kept talking about is how she wished she could dress up as a witch but wasnt allowed

sorry for being so long and i hope i dont get flamed either..i completely respect the religion and would never go against the parents wishes but i just feel so bad for the kids that dont understand it



Singing "Happy Birthday" and having the birthday cupcake is not learning about other birthdays/other religions - its celebrating the birthday. How else do you celebrate? JW's have specific reasons why they do not celebrate bdays and holidays and it seriously violates their consciences to do so. As for your student who was sad on Halloween, there are actually other religions who do not celebrate Halloween. I know you said she said she wished she could dress up, but I can assure you that is rare - most jw children know why they aren't dressing up and accept it. But is is likely that she was sad to feel like she wasn't part of the group, that she were left out from what everyone else was doing. It is awkward to be different and stand out and no kid likes *that* - it doesn't necessarily mean they wished they could *celebrate*, because the children of JW's are taught the "reasons" they don't celebrate each holiday, and not just that they aren't allowed. They are taught from a very early age, beginning before they go to school. You're not giving them enough credit, JW's are VERY well educated on why they believe and do what they do - even the kids.

I hope this all makes sense. Chat Icon And to be honest, there is no reason to feel bad for them. They are happy and VERY loved and are well taken care of. Their parents often make up for the things their children don't get to do x10.

Posted 12/17/08 7:35 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Forget it.

sorry I worded that wrong.

this is why I always give my son's teacher my OWN gift Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-12-17 20:48:23.507000.

Posted 12/17/08 8:47 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Forget it.

We have 2 JWs in my office of 15 people, and we renamed our holiday lunch a winter celebration so that they might come. They still won't come, thinking that it is holiday related (we really don't talk about holidays at all; it's just one of the few times we all socialize together). They also won't contribute to our collection of appreciation for our cleaning person, though they too said they would contribute other times of the year.

I just think it's a sticky situation. I don't fully understand the religion, but I respect the fact that they want to distance themselves during these holiday times. The two JWs in my office are two of the most generous people I know, and they will be the first to celebrate anniversaries by bringing in gifts and cake...They just want to distance themselves from holidays.

Posted 12/17/08 8:54 PM
 

sticklee
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

2984 total posts

Name:
Stick

Re: Forget it.

I think you're in a difficult position and I don't blame you at all.

I personally celebrate Christmas but I have many Jewish friends and I've gone to their homes to have Chabbas (sp?) dinner with them. I don't find it in any way disrespectful of my own religion to honor that of others.

I am with you in that I don't understand why this parent can't help to celebrate a tradition that is celebrated by the teacher. I don't think it's in any way asking her to renounce her own faith.

Isn't that what tolerance is all about?? I think it's this other mother who is being quite intolerant.

Message edited 2008-12-17 21:15:37.443000.

Posted 12/17/08 9:15 PM
 

youngmama
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/06

530 total posts

Name:

Re: Forget it.



If I was JW and I couldnt give a gift, I would feel more obligated to provide some support. Whether it was to offer help with parties,ideas or calls!

I can understand you being frusterated in this matter.

Its hard for me to understand why a religion doesnt allow gifts or celebration. Luckily in this country we can choose our religions!Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 10:19 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Forget it.

I really think that if you don't want to give to a class gift, for anything, then you shouldn't be pressured to. Religion or not. JMHO.

Posted 12/17/08 10:30 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Forget it.

Posted by KateDevine

I really think that if you don't want to give to a class gift, for anything, then you shouldn't be pressured to. Religion or not. JMHO.



I think this is the bottom line. She said no...its no. Though I understand the OP's frustrations. I guess as much as we try to intermingle as a society there will always be a gap between various groups.

Posted 12/17/08 10:37 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Forget it.

Posted by youngmama



If I was JW and I couldnt give a gift, I would feel more obligated to provide some support. Whether it was to offer help with parties,ideas or calls!

I can understand you being frusterated in this matter.

Its hard for me to understand why a religion doesnt allow gifts or celebration. Luckily in this country we can choose our religions!Chat Icon




But see thats thing.. they can't participate in anything having to do with the holidays. When I was in school and we would have cupcakes for a kids birthdays the kids who were JW would have to leave the room. You can't be mad at them for that

Posted 12/17/08 10:41 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Forget it.

Posted by sticklee

I am with you in that I don't understand why this parent can't help to celebrate a tradition that is celebrated by the teacher. I don't think it's in any way asking her to renounce her own faith.

Isn't that what tolerance is all about?? I think it's this other mother who is being quite intolerant.



The mother who is JW is not telling anyone that they cannot celebrate in whatever way they want. How is that even remotely intolerant?

She is not saying that they cannot celebrate, just that she and her kid will not. It is against their religion to do so and to fault them for that is intolerant IMO

(this is not directed in any way at the OP as she is trying to understand the religion , which I think is the most important piece of this whole conversation).

Posted 12/18/08 9:50 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Forget it.

Posted by sticklee



I am with you in that I don't understand why this parent can't help to celebrate a tradition that is celebrated by the teacher. I don't think it's in any way asking her to renounce her own faith.




I personally don't see why its so hard for people to understand that it is AGAINST her religion.

in a way, YES.. it IS asking her to renounce her faith.

Posted 12/18/08 10:16 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Not a TTC question, but a personal question Ambersmom 12/26/06 5 TTC
First question....now 2nd question... dree 10/27/06 10 Parenting
Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) MrsSchwags 10/5/06 12 Home
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting
Just a question - jehovas witnesses KPtoys 12/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™