Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...
Posted 12/17/2008 7:16:16 PM by maybebaby


Posted by mrswask


Posted by JennZ


Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything?

*playing devils advocate*

She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I'm sorry, I think it's silly that you're so furious with her. It's her religious beliefs and that should be respected. She also acknowledged that she was no problem giving an appreciation gift, just not something tied in to the holidays. Also, the fact that she's well off has nothing to do with it and I personally find it a little offensive that you would mention that.



Sorry you were offended.

I wasn't saying that because she was well off she needs to give holiday gifts...I was saying that she does NOTHING for the class for any occasion...it gets left to the same three parents all the time and it gets old really fast.

I am not FURIOUS with her. I was frustrated and explained myself ten thousand times in other posts that I didn't truly understand the religion and why they couldn't help out towards non-denominational gifts.

If people read my posts maybe there woudln't be as much flaming and confusion. I NEVER EVER said I was giving them christmas or hanukah gifts..it was just a simple THANK YOU to the teachers at this time. Which i know is the holidays, but the gift is seriously not related to any specific religion.

I am cleared now on the confines of JW faith, and I am more aware of what their beliefs are. It was more the background of this lady and what I've been through with her.
Print Post      Close Window