Forget it.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
|
Forget it. I think I have written the same thing over and over and I am still getting flamed. Message edited 2008-12-17 19:18:09.643000. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:14 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... My SILs dad was a JW. They just dont do holidays and bdays for ANYONE. It is their Religion. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... It is their religion and they don't celebrate any holidays. I don't know why you are mad at her. Christmas is recognized in school but that doesn't mean that those that don't celerbrate it should have to be made to celerbrate it because the teacher does. If the teacher celerbrated Chaunkaka instead, should they forbid anything related to Christmas in the classroom? |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything? *playing devils advocate* She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! I agree.I would be angry too that they are not contributing |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by shamrock124 It is their religion and they don't celebrate any holidays. I don't know why you are mad at her. Christmas is recognized in school but that doesn't mean that those that don't celerbrate it should have to be made to celerbrate it because the teacher does. If the teacher celerbrated Chaunkaka instead, should they forbid anything related to Christmas in the classroom? On the other hand, I think she was being very accommodating to say that if this is an appreciation gift, she would contribute. I think what I was trying to say is that I didn't understand why it would be a problem to help donate money toward the purchase of giftcards for the holiday season. I told her I could present it as an appreciation gift with NO holiday connotations.. Honestly its mid year, she hasn't helped with anything else when she said she would (i should have posted that earlier)...things like field trips...and I felt the conversation was manipulated on her part. She sounded in teh begininning like she would LOVE to acknowledge her sons teachers, is it for a gift of appreciation? I said "yes". She then goes "but its the holiday times and I don't believe in that"...even after I explained a few times that I would make sure it had no holiday wording or anything, she was just so weird about it. I guess I am not mad, more frustrated? It becomes very expensive to cover the other kids and i have done it more than once... |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! Contributing to a holiday gift goes against their religious beliefs. My coworker wouldn't sing Happy Birthday to anyone because it is against her religious beliefs and she should not have to do something she doesn't believe in just because someone else does. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by JennZ Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything? *playing devils advocate* She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong. I really don't see it as asking anyone to alter their religion! I do not celebrate hanukkah. I am christian. But in a heartbeat I would give money to get a hanukkah gift for a teacher who was jewish. That was my point. It does NOT make me jewish to give to another who is... |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by shamrock124 Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! Contributing to a holiday gift goes against their religious beliefs. My coworker wouldn't sing Happy Birthday to anyone because it is against her religious beliefs and she should not have to do something she doesn't believe in just because someone else does. I do understand now that it goes against their beliefs, I just think its not a nice part of religion...but it is what it is. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by maybebaby Posted by JennZ Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything? *playing devils advocate* She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong. I really don't see it as asking anyone to alter their religion! I do not celebrate hanukkah. I am christian. But in a heartbeat I would give money to get a hanukkah gift for a teacher who was jewish. That was my point. It does NOT make me jewish to give to another who is... NO, BUT being a Christian you exchange gifts. JW DO NOT! Its not like it is something you would not do is my point. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by maybebaby Honestly its mid year, she hasn't helped with anything else when she said she would (i should have posted that earlier)...things like field trips...and I felt the conversation was manipulated on her part. She sounded in teh begininning like she would LOVE to acknowledge her sons teachers, is it for a gift of appreciation? I said "yes". She then goes "but its the holiday times and I don't believe in that"...even after I explained a few times that I would make sure it had no holiday wording or anything, she was just so weird about it. I guess I am not mad, more frustrated? It becomes very expensive to cover the other kids and i have done it more than once... If you are doing it as an appreciation gift, then she should contribute. My coworker who acted as a p/t assistant for me was a JW. I used to give her a Winter gift instead of a holiday gift. She was able to accept that. But when she got married, her DH was much stricter and she wasn't able to accept it. It depends on how strict they are. If this is an ongoing issue, I, too, would be frustrated. Sorry if I came across harsh. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by shamrock124 Posted by maybebaby Honestly its mid year, she hasn't helped with anything else when she said she would (i should have posted that earlier)...things like field trips...and I felt the conversation was manipulated on her part. She sounded in teh begininning like she would LOVE to acknowledge her sons teachers, is it for a gift of appreciation? I said "yes". She then goes "but its the holiday times and I don't believe in that"...even after I explained a few times that I would make sure it had no holiday wording or anything, she was just so weird about it. I guess I am not mad, more frustrated? It becomes very expensive to cover the other kids and i have done it more than once... If you are doing it as an appreciation gift, then she should contribute. My coworker who acted as a p/t assistant for me was a JW. I used to give her a Winter gift instead of a holiday gift. She was able to accept that. But when she got married, her DH was much stricter and she wasn't able to accept it. It depends on how strict they are. If this is an ongoing issue, I, too, would be frustrated. Sorry if I came across harsh. Its ok... Its hard to explain the whole situation. It's been an ongoing thing with this mom not doing one thing for the class...it might sound trivial, but things really add up. And when we have one income, I just lost my job working from home etc..it irritates me. Like I said earlier..I am very respectful of religion. And I do realize now that any form of gift giving is not accepted in JW religion. I guess I just kind of wish she has listened to me more, and not acted like she was ready to give and then retracted...she made me feel very awkward like I was pulling a fast one on her...(I think she thought I would take her money and then write the giftcard out as a christmas gift??) and I would never back out on my word.. From now on I will not ask her for help for anything, she can contribute on her own but I doubt that would happen.. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... why not have the 3 parents who are not contributing for the "holiday" gift, put in the same amt you're all giving at the end of the year for the "appreciation" gift. This way it's not the same parents giving all the $$ |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by Little-J-Mommy why not have the 3 parents who are not contributing for the "holiday" gift, put in the same amt you're all giving at the end of the year for the "appreciation" gift. This way it's not the same parents giving all the $$ That would be a great idea, however I think the reason for the other parents not contributing is financial..and I am ok w/that, they aren't in the greatest situations BUT they still manage to help out with parties and give for that which is great... |
|
Posted 12/17/08 9:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by maybebaby Posted by JennZ Posted by 5ofClubs I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!! And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything? *playing devils advocate* She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong. I really don't see it as asking anyone to alter their religion! I do not celebrate hanukkah. I am christian. But in a heartbeat I would give money to get a hanukkah gift for a teacher who was jewish. That was my point. It does NOT make me jewish to give to another who is... But YOUR religion doesn't forbid celebrating holidays / birthdays and giving gifts for these things. Honestly, I see where this mother is coming from. I think it's pretty obvious that this IS a holiday gift for the teacher no matter what you call it. Yes, it's to show appreciation for the teacher, but it's also pretty directly related to the fact that the holidays are this time of year, as opposed to say an end of year present. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me. Message edited 2008-12-17 10:27:43.117000. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by Shelly I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me. First off, you don't know this mom doesn't give the teachers a gift on her own at another time of year. The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you. Jehovah's Witnesses don't celebrate ANY holiday or birthday, regardless of whether it is religious or not. The gift would need to be given without any connection to a holiday or birthday. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... I think the situation you're in is like |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by Shelly I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me. First off, you don't know this mom doesn't give the teachers a gift on her own at another time of year. The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you. I am NOT intolerant, I think that is a very very unfair statement. I am a VERY tolerant and understanding person. I was simply saying that I was frustrated over it....with all the background of this mother not helping with a THING..I think I am allowed to feel that way. I researched more about the religion just now actually. I didn't know a lot about it. I didn't understand why it was against "rules" to help with a class gift at this time. But I DO understand it, I really do....I don't have to agree but I understand. And like I said I will leave the mother out of all other things, it is totally fine with me. I just get sad that we cannot give these teachers as much as they deserve at this time...I wish we could do more and I would more than make up for this moms money if i could. But I can't |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... I think it is totally appropriate of her to decline to participate based on her religious practices. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by MST9106 I think the situation you're in is like . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it. It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest! |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by maybebaby Posted by MST9106 I think the situation you're in is like . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it. It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest! I would be frustrated just like you, but like I said, I would leave it alone and NOT go out of my way and give a winter gift or Thanksgiving gift just bc of this one mom. I would simply exclude her from gift giving.
|
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:35 AM
|
|
|
LaurenExp
Member since 8/06 11613 total posts Name: |
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by MST9106 Posted by maybebaby Posted by MST9106 I think the situation you're in is like . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it. It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest! I would be frustrated just like you, but like I said, I would leave it alone and NOT go out of my way and give a winter gift or Thanksgiving gift just bc of this one mom. I would simply exclude her from gift giving.ITA. And the teacher will probably understand since that teacher has probably made modifications all year long celebrating birthdays and holidays in the classroom. I'm sure they won't be surprised. |
Posted 12/17/08 10:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses... Posted by maybebaby Posted by MST9106 I think the situation you're in is like . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it. It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest! I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday. I also don't think you are hateful at all, I just don't think you understand all the dimensions of this persons religion. There are certain aspects of other religions that as a Catholic I would never participate in. It may not seem like a big deal to others, but it is to me and my religion. I would extend the same understanding to her. |
|
Posted 12/17/08 10:37 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not a TTC question, but a personal question | Ambersmom | 12/26/06 | 5 | TTC |
| First question....now 2nd question... | dree | 10/27/06 | 10 | Parenting |
| Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) | MrsSchwags | 10/5/06 | 12 | Home |
| I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) | luvsbob4603 | 6/16/06 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question | Shelly | 4/10/06 | 11 | Parenting |
| Just a question - jehovas witnesses | KPtoys | 12/19/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |








. I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it. 
