Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...
Posted 12/17/2008 11:28:01 AM by Kara


Posted by browneyedgirl


Posted by Kara


Posted by browneyedgirl


Posted by Shelly

I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me.

The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you.



and that statement is absolutely rude!!! calling someone intolerant is unbelievable especially since she's trying to understand the situation. she is not giving a christmas gift---who's to say the teachers are even christian?

mo---do not put that child's name on the card since he's not allowed to give gifts (even though the mother said she would--but that's another story). do NOT write "from the class" because that INCLUDES the child. list the other 6 names--including those who are not in a financial position to donate. the teachers will know why the kid's name is not on there.

the mother is playing a game with you. she called YOU and said she would donate to an appreciation gift but when asked for it she declined. just let her be. don't call her for anything. you have enough to deal with. she'll do what she wants to do for the class--which is apparently nothing.

do not give the gift at any other time of year. my students NEVER give me a christmas card---it's usually a thank you card. do the same for the teachers since you probably don't know what they celebrate anyway.

ETA: i have had jehovas witnesses before and some HAVE contributed to end of year/mid year gifts. and some have not---just like people of any other religion




The mother is not playing games, she is living within the bounds of HER PERSONAL religious beliefs. I may have missed something, but it says she spoke to the mother on the phone. I didn't see where the mother called the OP. Even if she did, she called to try to understand if it was a holiday gift or not... Clearly whatever explanation was given, she feels it's a holiday gift and won't contribute for religious reasons. It's her prerogative to decline to contribute for any reason (and I doubt the OP has intimate knowledge of her finances...) - I'd at least hope that when the reason is religious people could be more understanding.

I don't get how this is an issue.



yes, she is playing games--she said she would contribute and then backed out. and yes, the OP DOES have knowledge of her finances--obviously not in detail but a general overview based on certain aspects. and yes the OP did speak to her on the phone.

and i know this for fact



I know they spoke on the phone - I said that in my post. I said I didn't see it posted that the JW mother called the OP.

She said she would contribute if it was an appreciation gift. Apparently she decided that since it's being given near the holidays it's a holiday gift to which she is not comfortable contributing. Guess what - that's her right. Whenever group collections are taken, some people contribute and some don't. It happens. It even happens that people say they will and don't. That's just the way it goes. I would certainly hope people would be tolerant enough to accept a RELIGIOUS reason why one cannot contribute, even if she did change her mind on how she viewed the gift. And c'mon. While the gift may be to show appreciation, it's pretty clear that it's being given now b/c of the holidays.

It's obvious that the OP has a history of being frustrated with this woman -- but that doesn't change the fact that she has a very valid reason for not contributing to this gift. And I honestly don't think just her not contributing is going to ruin the gift in some way. It's against her religion. Whatever else has happened, that should be respected.
Print Post      Close Window