Re: Forget it.
Posted 12/17/2008 7:35:32 PM by timanda


Posted by Jenise

I just want to say that i understand your frustrations


Im on the opposite end of it as a teacher and the last 2 years ive had children who are JW and I understand that they dont celebrate anything but why cant they learn about different holidays? I do christmas/ Hanukkah/ Kwanza activities and ive had a parent who would rip out anything in their notebook that had to do with any holiday....anytime i had some other kid bring in something for their bday the JW had to leave the class (as per her parents request) when wed sing happy birthday and have a cupcake, they werent allowed to get a "goody bag" if the kids brought them in for any reason

I feel so bad for these children...even though i know they are used to it and they know they cant have it, they look so sad...i mean how much does a little kid understand that everyone else gets to have cupcakes and goody bags but not them?

This year my JW was sooooo sad on halloween (im teaching kindergarten this year) and i dont think my girl has ever been to school before and has never experienced halloween where every kid gets all dressed up and excited but shes not..all she kept talking about is how she wished she could dress up as a witch but wasnt allowed

sorry for being so long and i hope i dont get flamed either..i completely respect the religion and would never go against the parents wishes but i just feel so bad for the kids that dont understand it



Singing "Happy Birthday" and having the birthday cupcake is not learning about other birthdays/other religions - its celebrating the birthday. How else do you celebrate? JW's have specific reasons why they do not celebrate bdays and holidays and it seriously violates their consciences to do so. As for your student who was sad on Halloween, there are actually other religions who do not celebrate Halloween. I know you said she said she wished she could dress up, but I can assure you that is rare - most jw children know why they aren't dressing up and accept it. But is is likely that she was sad to feel like she wasn't part of the group, that she were left out from what everyone else was doing. It is awkward to be different and stand out and no kid likes *that* - it doesn't necessarily mean they wished they could *celebrate*, because the children of JW's are taught the "reasons" they don't celebrate each holiday, and not just that they aren't allowed. They are taught from a very early age, beginning before they go to school. You're not giving them enough credit, JW's are VERY well educated on why they believe and do what they do - even the kids.

I hope this all makes sense. Chat Icon And to be honest, there is no reason to feel bad for them. They are happy and VERY loved and are well taken care of. Their parents often make up for the things their children don't get to do x10.
Print Post      Close Window