Forget it.

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by CrankyPants


I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday.




A JW wouldn't want their name included on any card or gift attached to birthdays or holidays. It is the same as participating and it is against their religious beliefs.

Posted 12/17/08 10:40 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by MST9106

I think the situation you're in is like Chat Icon . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it.



It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest!



I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday.

I also don't think you are hateful at all, I just don't think you understand all the dimensions of this persons religion. There are certain aspects of other religions that as a Catholic I would never participate in. It may not seem like a big deal to others, but it is to me and my religion. I would extend the same understanding to her.



Why isn't that the answer? How else do you go about the situation? Exclude 99% of the people from gift giving around the holidays just bc 1 person does not believe in it? I think the mom should (if she wants to) do something on her own whenever she wants to.

Posted 12/17/08 10:42 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.

ETA: I would call her back and ask her how she feels about having her family name included in the card.

I don't understand why this is such a big deal....

Message edited 2008-12-17 10:55:59.390000.

Posted 12/17/08 10:54 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




This post made me think of the fact that they come to my house at least once a week when I have MY own religion as well. But yet, they insistantly ring my bell, interrupt my household to see if I am interested in their religion. So what's up with that?
ETA - I know this has nothing to do with Xmas gifts, but just made me think. Talking out loud I guess about something that always irks me (them being so persistent in trying to share their religion with me).

Message edited 2008-12-17 10:58:15.780000.

Posted 12/17/08 10:56 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Ophelia

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.



I wouldn't do that. They don't give gifts. It would be against their religious beliefs.

From now on I wouldn't even ask this mother. See will not participate and then you save yourself the aggravation.

We have had children in the day care I work who are JW. When we have any kind of celebration in their classroom we have to take them to another room. As sad as it is for us to understand, it is how they live their lives everyday.

Posted 12/17/08 10:56 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

The child is JW too, it would be against his religion to be a part of the gift.

I would list the names of the children who's parent's contributed.

I'm sure those who couldn't afford to give much will be doing something small on their own (homemade cookies or whatever).


The JW mom will, possibly, show her appreciation for the teacher another time.

I understand your frustration Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:00:37.123000.

Posted 12/17/08 10:57 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Ophelia

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.



I wouldn't do that. They don't give gifts. It would be against their religious beliefs.

QUOTE]

I edited my post Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 10:57 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by kahlua716

Posted by Ophelia


the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.



I disagree- the child is JW too, and thus it is against his religion to be a part of the gift.

I would list the names of the children who's parent's contributed.

I'm sure those who couldn't afford to give much will be doing something small on their own (homemade cookies or whatever).


The JW mom will, possibly, show her appreciation for the teacher another time.

I understand your frustration Chat Icon



I edited my post.

Posted 12/17/08 10:58 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by shamrock124

Posted by CrankyPants


I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday.




A JW wouldn't want their name included on any card or gift attached to birthdays or holidays. It is the same as participating and it is against their religious beliefs.



Yeah, I get that. But if you would normally just say "from your class", why go out of the way to say ,"except from XX".

Posted 12/17/08 10:58 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Ophelia

I edited my post.



I saw after I posted Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-12-17 10:59:34.530000.

Posted 12/17/08 10:59 AM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Ophelia

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.

ETA: I would call her back and ask her how she feels about having her family name included in the card.

I don't understand why this is such a big deal....



I think this is the point - they can't give gifts - so how is including the child's name on the card ok, but giving money not? I would term it as the end of the year gift, not a holiday gift b/c I am giving my Ds' daycare providers gift cards not really for the holidays but for appreciation for their work all year.

Posted 12/17/08 10:59 AM
 

justmefornow
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/08

859 total posts

Name:
n

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Religion or not, contributing money to a teacher's gift is always voluntary, and typically a card would just be signed from the entire class. Signed, "your 1st grade class, 2008-2009" or something like that.

Posted 12/17/08 10:59 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Goobster

Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




This post made me think of the fact that they come to my house at least once a week when I have MY own religion as well. But yet, they insistantly ring my bell, interrupt my household to see if I am interested in their religion. So what's up with that?
ETA - I know this has nothing to do with Xmas gifts, but just made me think. Talking out loud I guess about something that always irks me (them being so persistent in trying to share their religion with me).



honestly, how on earth does one have to do with the other???

unless you have a sign on your door that says "this home is Xreligion. respect mine and I'll respect yours" (there are signs like this..I've seen them on doors in spanish) why would they know what your religion is or interests are?

ALL missionaries do this...christianity just isn't one that is recruiting here that hard core right now...

ask the Incas though...they'll tell you what it's like to have those dang catholics knocking on their door Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 11:00 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by justmefornow

Religion or not, contributing money to a teacher's gift is always voluntary, and typically a card would just be signed from the entire class. Signed, "your 1st grade class, 2008-2009" or something like that.



I think many cards would have each child who participated name listed. Not just "from your class". Most parents would want an acknowledgement that they chipped in.

Posted 12/17/08 11:01 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by MST9106

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by MST9106

I think the situation you're in is like Chat Icon . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it.



It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest!



I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday.

I also don't think you are hateful at all, I just don't think you understand all the dimensions of this persons religion. There are certain aspects of other religions that as a Catholic I would never participate in. It may not seem like a big deal to others, but it is to me and my religion. I would extend the same understanding to her.



Why isn't that the answer? How else do you go about the situation? Exclude 99% of the people from gift giving around the holidays just bc 1 person does not believe in it? .



I'm not saying that either. I would just write "from your class" to avoid leaving anyone out or overtly including anyone who wouldn't want to be included.

ETA I also like Ophelia's solution:
Posted by Ophelia

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.

ETA: I would call her back and ask her how she feels about having her family name included in the card.

I don't understand why this is such a big deal....

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:02:47.200000.

Posted 12/17/08 11:01 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Goobster

Posted by 5ofClubs

I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!




This post made me think of the fact that they come to my house at least once a week when I have MY own religion as well. But yet, they insistantly ring my bell, interrupt my household to see if I am interested in their religion. So what's up with that?
ETA - I know this has nothing to do with Xmas gifts, but just made me think. Talking out loud I guess about something that always irks me (them being so persistent in trying to share their religion with me).



honestly, how on earth does one have to do with the other???

unless you have a sign on your door that says "this home is Xreligion. respect mine and I'll respect yours" (there are signs like this..I've seen them on doors in spanish) why would they know what your religion is or interests are?

ALL missionaries do this...christianity just isn't one that is recruiting here that hard core right now...

ask the Incas though...they'll tell you what it's like to have those dang catholics knocking on their d

oor Chat Icon



I guess the part where 5ofclubs said "it's not like you are asking her to change her religion" made me think of the constant solicitation to change my religion, at my front door, on a frequent basis.

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:13:29.613000.

Posted 12/17/08 11:03 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Goobster

Posted by justmefornow

Religion or not, contributing money to a teacher's gift is always voluntary, and typically a card would just be signed from the entire class. Signed, "your 1st grade class, 2008-2009" or something like that.



I think many cards would have each child who participated name listed. Not just "from your class". Most parents would want an acknowledgement that they chipped in.



I don't know. For me, the point of the gift is to appreciate the teacher not for the recognition of the gift (not that you are saying that).

In classroom situations where the child has no say one way or the other if they participate, I just think it's inappropriate to exclude anyone regardless of why they didn't contribute unless the parent specifically tells you to exclude their kid, because what choice do you have in that case?

Posted 12/17/08 11:08 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Goobster

Posted by justmefornow

Religion or not, contributing money to a teacher's gift is always voluntary, and typically a card would just be signed from the entire class. Signed, "your 1st grade class, 2008-2009" or something like that.



I think many cards would have each child who participated name listed. Not just "from your class". Most parents would want an acknowledgement that they chipped in.



I don't know. For me, the point of the gift is to appreciate the teacher not for the recognition of the gift (not that you are saying that).

In classroom situations where the child has no say one way or the other if they participate, I just think it's inappropriate to exclude anyone regardless of why they didn't contribute unless the parent specifically tells you to exclude their kid, because what choice do you have in that case?



If they don't celebrate and don't chip in b/c of that, I don't feel anyone should be obligated to make sure the child isn't left out. It's a fact, they don't celebrate and that's why the child's name isn't on the card. Bottom line.

Posted 12/17/08 11:11 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Shelly

I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me.

The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you.



and that statement is absolutely rude!!! calling someone intolerant is unbelievable especially since she's trying to understand the situation. she is not giving a christmas gift---who's to say the teachers are even christian?

mo---do not put that child's name on the card since he's not allowed to give gifts (even though the mother said she would--but that's another story). do NOT write "from the class" because that INCLUDES the child. list the other 6 names--including those who are not in a financial position to donate. the teachers will know why the kid's name is not on there.

the mother is playing a game with you. she called YOU and said she would donate to an appreciation gift but when asked for it she declined. just let her be. don't call her for anything. you have enough to deal with. she'll do what she wants to do for the class--which is apparently nothing.

do not give the gift at any other time of year. my students NEVER give me a christmas card---it's usually a thank you card. do the same for the teachers since you probably don't know what they celebrate anyway.

ETA: i have had jehovas witnesses before and some HAVE contributed to end of year/mid year gifts. and some have not---just like people of any other religion

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:12:47.050000.

Posted 12/17/08 11:11 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by kahlua716

The child is JW too, it would be against his religion to be a part of the gift.

I would list the names of the children who's parent's contributed.

I'm sure those who couldn't afford to give much will be doing something small on their own (homemade cookies or whatever).


The JW mom will, possibly, show her appreciation for the teacher another time.

I understand your frustration Chat Icon



I would assume the card won't have specific names on it. I would HOPE it would just say "From Your X Grade Class" and not list individual names.

If it IS going to list names, then the right thing to do is to ask the mother if it is all right to put the child's name on the card, not to make a decision either way about whether or not it's all right.

Posted 12/17/08 11:12 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Goobster

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Goobster

Posted by justmefornow

Religion or not, contributing money to a teacher's gift is always voluntary, and typically a card would just be signed from the entire class. Signed, "your 1st grade class, 2008-2009" or something like that.



I think many cards would have each child who participated name listed. Not just "from your class". Most parents would want an acknowledgement that they chipped in.



I don't know. For me, the point of the gift is to appreciate the teacher not for the recognition of the gift (not that you are saying that).

In classroom situations where the child has no say one way or the other if they participate, I just think it's inappropriate to exclude anyone regardless of why they didn't contribute unless the parent specifically tells you to exclude their kid, because what choice do you have in that case?



If they don't celebrate and don't chip in b/c of that, I don't feel anyone should be obligated to make sure the child isn't left out. It's a fact, they don't celebrate and that's why the child's name isn't on the card. Bottom line.



But what about the other kids that she said don't chip in for financial reasons?

IMO if you just sign the card "from your class" you don't exclude anyone but don't overtly include someone who might not want their name listed on the card.

Posted 12/17/08 11:13 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Shelly

I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me.

The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you.



and that statement is absolutely rude!!! calling someone intolerant is unbelievable especially since she's trying to understand the situation. she is not giving a christmas gift---who's to say the teachers are even christian?

mo---do not put that child's name on the card since he's not allowed to give gifts (even though the mother said she would--but that's another story). do NOT write "from the class" because that INCLUDES the child. list the other 6 names--including those who are not in a financial position to donate. the teachers will know why the kid's name is not on there.

the mother is playing a game with you. she called YOU and said she would donate to an appreciation gift but when asked for it she declined. just let her be. don't call her for anything. you have enough to deal with. she'll do what she wants to do for the class--which is apparently nothing.

do not give the gift at any other time of year. my students NEVER give me a christmas card---it's usually a thank you card. do the same for the teachers since you probably don't know what they celebrate anyway.

ETA: i have had jehovas witnesses before and some HAVE contributed to end of year/mid year gifts. and some have not---just like people of any other religion




The mother is not playing games, she is living within the bounds of HER PERSONAL religious beliefs. I may have missed something, but it says she spoke to the mother on the phone. I didn't see where the mother called the OP. Even if she did, she called to try to understand if it was a holiday gift or not... Clearly whatever explanation was given, she feels it's a holiday gift and won't contribute for religious reasons. It's her prerogative to decline to contribute for any reason (and I doubt the OP has intimate knowledge of her finances...) - I'd at least hope that when the reason is religious people could be more understanding.

I don't get how this is an issue.

Posted 12/17/08 11:15 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Goobster


If they don't celebrate and don't chip in b/c of that, I don't feel anyone should be obligated to make sure the child isn't left out. It's a fact, they don't celebrate and that's why the child's name isn't on the card. Bottom line.



But what about the other kids that she said don't chip in for financial reasons?

IMO if you just sign the card "from your class" you don't exclude anyone but don't overtly include someone who might not want their name listed on the card.



Odds are their names would not be on
the card. It's unfortunate that their families can't donate (or some circumstances want to donate) but that's usually the way it works. Your name gets acknowledged when you chip in.

Most times families who can't afford to "chip" in who truly want to show their appreciation will buy their own small token, could be a one dollar plastic rose, to send the child to school with to say thank you. That way the teacher knoms and the child feels special giving her a gift as well.

I never had a gift given to me that said "FROM everyone".

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:20:05.747000.

Posted 12/17/08 11:18 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

You don't sign the child's name - as it is against their religion.

You sign the people that contributed for the gift. I don't know why you would kick in extra money for families that aren't chipping in whether it be for financial or religious reasons.

Just get a gift with the money you did collect. There is no reason why you should take the hit.

As for her class participation, that is an entirely different issue. If your school/daycare requires some type of obligatory participation from parents, then you should discuss that with the director & have her handle it. It's not the class mom's job to harange parents into participating. If there is no obligation, then I would drop it as it's HER option whether she participates or not.

Message edited 2008-12-17 11:19:12.513000.

Posted 12/17/08 11:18 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...

Posted by Kara

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Shelly

I don't understand how you could be mad???? Your asking her to engage in a ritual that is a part of your religion, and against hers. Seems pretty intolerant to me.

The solution to me is simple- if you want to include this mother, give the teachers a gift in January for the new year- or next year- for thanksgiving. That way it doesn't conflict with christmas- a VERY RELIGIOUS holiday that she celebrates differently than you.



and that statement is absolutely rude!!! calling someone intolerant is unbelievable especially since she's trying to understand the situation. she is not giving a christmas gift---who's to say the teachers are even christian?

mo---do not put that child's name on the card since he's not allowed to give gifts (even though the mother said she would--but that's another story). do NOT write "from the class" because that INCLUDES the child. list the other 6 names--including those who are not in a financial position to donate. the teachers will know why the kid's name is not on there.

the mother is playing a game with you. she called YOU and said she would donate to an appreciation gift but when asked for it she declined. just let her be. don't call her for anything. you have enough to deal with. she'll do what she wants to do for the class--which is apparently nothing.

do not give the gift at any other time of year. my students NEVER give me a christmas card---it's usually a thank you card. do the same for the teachers since you probably don't know what they celebrate anyway.

ETA: i have had jehovas witnesses before and some HAVE contributed to end of year/mid year gifts. and some have not---just like people of any other religion




The mother is not playing games, she is living within the bounds of HER PERSONAL religious beliefs. I may have missed something, but it says she spoke to the mother on the phone. I didn't see where the mother called the OP. Even if she did, she called to try to understand if it was a holiday gift or not... Clearly whatever explanation was given, she feels it's a holiday gift and won't contribute for religious reasons. It's her prerogative to decline to contribute for any reason (and I doubt the OP has intimate knowledge of her finances...) - I'd at least hope that when the reason is religious people could be more understanding.

I don't get how this is an issue.



yes, she is playing games--she said she would contribute and then backed out. and yes, the OP DOES have knowledge of her finances--obviously not in detail but a general overview based on certain aspects. and yes the OP did speak to her on the phone.

and i know this for fact

Posted 12/17/08 11:19 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Not a TTC question, but a personal question Ambersmom 12/26/06 5 TTC
First question....now 2nd question... dree 10/27/06 10 Parenting
Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) MrsSchwags 10/5/06 12 Home
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting
Just a question - jehovas witnesses KPtoys 12/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™