Re: So..we were invited to a surprise 30th bday dinner...and everyone is asked to pay...
Posted 9/22/2009 8:28:32 PM by 4monkeys


Posted by Shelly


Posted by headoverheels

Maureen i totally get that $45 per person is a lot of money if that doesn't even include drinks and appetizers. i agree with Jess - i would ask the person with the biggest pair Chat Icon to find out why it's so expensive.

i still wouldn't call it tacky - expensive yes, tacky no.




I agree with this. Its expensive, but not tacky. He (rightfully) doesn't want anyone to feel ambushed when they are there.




ITA with Shelly. At least he had the decency to let everyone know before the bill came Chat Icon

I can see both sides of this argument. We threw huge bashes for my parents (each a special birthday party, and also an anniversary party) and cant fathom having to ask a guest to pay for their night out.
Ive also thrown parties at my local town park, and I insist they keep a tab of my non-residents family's cars so they dont have to pay the $5 parking fee.

and Ive also been to a friends birthday dinner, where people ordered to their hearts content (even a child ordered wayyyy too many things off the menu as if it were make believe & the waitress brought every last thing she ordered, even "the most expensive steak on the menu" Chat Icon) several people had drinks all night, and then 2-3 couples ordered VERY limited, thinking they were keeping to their budget, until they heard the $50pp split of the tab..one girl turned ten shades of red, and was ruffling through her bag for money. I didnt see what winded up happening but I felt terrible for them.
In this case it was person we're close with so we didnt mind at all, but I can totally see where this can get uncomfortable, awkward and just wrong.


But I think the hubby in this post, has all the right intentions Chat Icon
Id rather this scenario than the one I mentioned above.
Print Post      Close Window