WWYD

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

mrsBLT
missing my baby

Member since 1/10

1359 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

I want to know exactly what you guys are considering a 'pop in the mouth'?

Are we talking about a punch?!!

A hard smack across the face?

A light smack on the mouth?



Because sometimes I'm in stores and hear mouthy OVERLY mouthy teenagers and I, myself, would sort of like to smack them on the mouth?




i consider a "pop" to be a punch

Posted 1/6/11 2:19 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: WWYD

Posted by DiamondGirl


How I choose to parent is irrelevant.

It is NOT illegal to displine your child physically. (I mean a spank/smack not a beatdown)

You CAN say something and risk your own safety that this parent will take objection to you butting in and smack you! lol

You CAN call the cops--but they won't do ish bc it is not illegal.

I mean it is not to say anyone wants/enjoys seeing a kid get spanked it is just to say that some things are none of your damnn business



absolutely agree with you! i can't believe people would interfere with another parent's disciplining.

i don't agree with spanking at all, but that's MY decision. if i choose to hit my child (not beat--that's obviously a different story), that's my choice as a parent. it's no one else's business.

i may get sad seeing a child get hit or yelled at, but it is not my place to say anything. i'm surprised people think they have the right to interfere.

Posted 1/6/11 2:19 PM
 

MillerTime424
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/09

737 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: WWYD

i would only intrude if i thought the child was in danger.

Posted 1/6/11 2:20 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

Posted by mrsBLT

meh... not really. it's legal to smoke cigarettes but you can't do it in restaurants. kwim?




But only Mer can answer this...

IS it against your buildings rules?

Because you get a smart mouth parent going to your boss to say 'Hey so and so tells me that I can't legally spank my kid for acting up within your building.'

I feel things could get awkward...



oh, i see what you're saying

yes, our agency has a policy against aggressive physical contact. MOST social services agencies do even if it isnt advertised. It is MEANT to protect against more severe acts than a spanking but can definitely be applied to that, especially if it makes you uncomfortable.

ETA: its also, in my situation at least as a social worker, about how you word it. you dont want to be accusatory but rather polite about pointing out that the policy is in place to protect everyone

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:22:32.643000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:20 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

Okay. I was just wondering!

Posted 1/6/11 2:21 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: WWYD

I am not a parent.. but if I see a parent disclipine a child, I wouldn't say anything. Spanking a child when in a public space as an effort to disclipine a child is not a crime. As a parent, you MUST discipline your child.. I am very old fashioned, and I believe on ocassion spanking is absolutely needed. Beating up a child, pushing, shoving., dragging a visibly upset child and the child is scared $hitle$$ then I would notify a cop of security guard. No excuses.

I see parents just sweet coating their crazy kids.. "no johnny, you should not do that" and laughing it off, when a stern look and spank on the tush would have curbed it on the spot. What kind of example is that setting?!


Posted 1/6/11 2:22 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by DiamondGirl


How I choose to parent is irrelevant.

It is NOT illegal to displine your child physically. (I mean a spank/smack not a beatdown)

You CAN say something and risk your own safety that this parent will take objection to you butting in and smack you! lol

You CAN call the cops--but they won't do ish bc it is not illegal.

I mean it is not to say anyone wants/enjoys seeing a kid get spanked it is just to say that some things are none of your damnn business



absolutely agree with you! i can't believe people would interfere with another parent's disciplining.

i don't agree with spanking at all, but that's MY decision. if i choose to hit my child (not beat--that's obviously a different story), that's my choice as a parent. it's no one else's business.

i may get sad seeing a child get hit or yelled at, but it is not my place to say anything. i'm surprised people think they have the right to interfere.





I like this.

How would you anti-spankers feel if your kid was being a nightmare in the grocery store line and a bunch of people turned around and said 'Hey, your 'parenting methods' clearly aren't working. We want you to know that we think you should spank your kid and while you're at it... watch us glare at you liek you're the worst parent ever..'

I'm pretty sure that wouldn't go over well.

Posted 1/6/11 2:24 PM
 

StaceyWill
It's a girl!!!

Member since 6/10

21539 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: WWYD

This happened to me once and I did not say anything. I was outside of my office and from across the street I heard two or so loud smacks- I looked and there was a woman pushing a stroller and the kid was crying. I didn't want to yell across the street at her, I think I was at a loss for words because of what had happened. I also didn't call the cops. I felt horrible for days.

Posted 1/6/11 2:24 PM
 

mrsBLT
missing my baby

Member since 1/10

1359 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by DiamondGirl


How I choose to parent is irrelevant.

It is NOT illegal to displine your child physically. (I mean a spank/smack not a beatdown)

You CAN say something and risk your own safety that this parent will take objection to you butting in and smack you! lol

You CAN call the cops--but they won't do ish bc it is not illegal.

I mean it is not to say anyone wants/enjoys seeing a kid get spanked it is just to say that some things are none of your damnn business



absolutely agree with you! i can't believe people would interfere with another parent's disciplining.

i don't agree with spanking at all, but that's MY decision. if i choose to hit my child (not beat--that's obviously a different story), that's my choice as a parent. it's no one else's business.

i may get sad seeing a child get hit or yelled at, but it is not my place to say anything. i'm surprised people think they have the right to interfere.





I like this.

How would you anti-spankers feel if your kid was being a nightmare in the grocery store line and a bunch of people turned around and said 'Hey, your 'parenting methods' clearly aren't working. We want you to know that we think you should spank your kid and while you're at it... watch us glare at you liek you're the worst parent ever..'

I'm pretty sure that wouldn't go over well.




Chat Icon most of the people said they don't care about spanking and wouldn't say anything Chat Icon

Posted 1/6/11 2:28 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: WWYD

A spank on the tush for discipline, no.

A pop in the mouth? Chat Icon YES! Chat Icon

Posted 1/6/11 2:31 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by DiamondGirl


How I choose to parent is irrelevant.

It is NOT illegal to displine your child physically. (I mean a spank/smack not a beatdown)

You CAN say something and risk your own safety that this parent will take objection to you butting in and smack you! lol

You CAN call the cops--but they won't do ish bc it is not illegal.

I mean it is not to say anyone wants/enjoys seeing a kid get spanked it is just to say that some things are none of your damnn business



absolutely agree with you! i can't believe people would interfere with another parent's disciplining.

i don't agree with spanking at all, but that's MY decision. if i choose to hit my child (not beat--that's obviously a different story), that's my choice as a parent. it's no one else's business.

i may get sad seeing a child get hit or yelled at, but it is not my place to say anything. i'm surprised people think they have the right to interfere.





I like this.

How would you anti-spankers feel if your kid was being a nightmare in the grocery store line and a bunch of people turned around and said 'Hey, your 'parenting methods' clearly aren't working. We want you to know that we think you should spank your kid and while you're at it... watch us glare at you liek you're the worst parent ever..'

I'm pretty sure that wouldn't go over well.



BIG BIG difference though between a spank or a swat and something that's borderline abusive.
People do have the right to interfere. And this is not because I have a child, it's just the way I was raised. I witnessed my mother MANY times telling a parent to COOL IT when they were excessively aggressive with a young child in public. My mother is a petite little thing, but she had the DEATH STARE for those parents. If you're having a bad day, fine, we all have those, but you do NOT take it out on a child.
And if you're doing it in a public place you INVITE a tongue lashing.
Maybe that parent needs the intervention to prevent them from losing it.
Maybe the child needs someone to be his advocate.
Maybe the parent will find another way to discipline.
Maybe none of the above. But my conscience wouldn't allow me to stay silent if someone slapped a child in the face.

Last year a woman at the laundromat called the toddler she was babysitting an "a-hole". YOu bet I said something and I would do it again tomorrow.

Posted 1/6/11 2:31 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: WWYD

A small smack? Prob not. But when we were coming home from Jamaica in Montego Bay airport I saw a mother and father continually beat their son because they wanted him to try on a shirt. He just stood there taking it...didn't say anything, didn't wince - nothing. That made me think this happens very often. The mother hit him once and the father hit him repeatedly. I was SO upset that I did say something. I really gave the mother a piece of my mind (the father had walked off with the son).

Posted 1/6/11 2:32 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD

mer i meant outside of the agency walls, on your own time. obv theres a big difference and a fine line between chastising and abuse so i was just wondering where everyone else drew the line.

FTR DH used to get pops in the mouth. i think its awful but it was partly cultural. if he tries that with our kid guess what he's gunna get?

eta i was afraid this would dissolve into drama, so glad it didnt!

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:36:37.350000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:35 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: WWYD

a slap no - a punch yes

my mom hit me in the face (slap) and i deserved it but no one deserves a bunch or repeated hitting.

Posted 1/6/11 2:37 PM
 

MissRadiant
Happily Ever After

Member since 9/08

2534 total posts

Name:
N

Re: WWYD

Unless the child's life was in danger I would not say anything. It is not my place to say or have an opinion as to how a parent disciplines their child.

Everyone needs to realize that people are different and have different ways of raising their children. Whether you agree or not, at times people just need to mind their own business.

Posted 1/6/11 2:37 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: WWYD

Posted by MissRadiant

Unless the child's life was in danger I would not say anything. It is not my place to say or have an opinion as to how a parent disciplines their child.

Everyone needs to realize that people are different and have different ways of raising their children. Whether you agree or not, at times people just need to mind their own business.



Absolutely agree with the above!

Posted 1/6/11 2:39 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: WWYD

Posted by MissRadiant

Unless the child's life was in danger I would not say anything. It is not my place to say or have an opinion as to how a parent disciplines their child.




same.

if the parent was Chat Icon i would definitely say something/call someone.

Posted 1/6/11 2:40 PM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: WWYD

No I wouldn't call the police. It is not illegal to "slap" a child in the way you described.

Posted 1/6/11 2:41 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD

I agree with a lot of the statements above

if its a smack on the butt, slight slap etc to get the child in line, then i would not say anything
it's none of my business

if the parent was berating the child and being unnecessarily cruel or hitting them repeatedly.. i'd probably say something

Posted 1/6/11 2:48 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by MissRadiant

Unless the child's life was in danger I would not say anything. It is not my place to say or have an opinion as to how a parent disciplines their child.




same.

if the parent was Chat Icon i would definitely say something/call someone.



novel use of the new emoticon!

Posted 1/6/11 2:51 PM
 

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: WWYD

I think parents smacks/slaps are fine - "pop"/punches in the mouth seem kind of excessive, but I still don't think I would say anything.

Frankly, I want to say things to the parents that let their children scream and grossly misbehave in public - not that they have to hit them, but please do something to make them realize it's NOT okay to act this way in public.

Posted 1/6/11 2:54 PM
 

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: WWYD

Posted by cateyemm

Posted by Bearcat

if the parent was Chat Icon i would definitely say something/call someone.



novel use of the new emoticon!



Haha I laughed when I saw that.

Posted 1/6/11 2:55 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD

If it was a few spanks on the bottom, I don't have an issue with it. If it was a "pop" aka punch in the mouth, I would probably say something because I feel there is a huge difference.

If I felt the parent was out of control & disciplining in anger, I'd ask if they needed help or it they were ok (not help punching their kid, obviously).

The reason I'd ask if they would need help is I once encountered a woman with holding a baby with an out of control 2 year old, throwing himself on the grown. She was screaming at him & spanked him - a few times in front of a crowd of people. I asked if she needed help because she couldn't grab the 2 year old off the ground holding the baby. She sat down on my blanket, took the bottle of water I offered her & then broke down into tears. She had just moved to the area, her husband was working crazy hours, she hadn't unpacked or been out of the house in ages & wanted to go to the park for a walk. I completely understood that overwhelming feeling & she needed to compose herself.

Posted 1/6/11 2:59 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: WWYD

Posted by cateyemm

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by MissRadiant

Unless the child's life was in danger I would not say anything. It is not my place to say or have an opinion as to how a parent disciplines their child.




same.

if the parent was Chat Icon i would definitely say something/call someone.



novel use of the new emoticon!



sometimes i have to get creative, it keeps me sane.Chat Icon

Posted 1/6/11 3:00 PM
 

MrsYankeeGirl72
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

452 total posts

Name:
J

Re: WWYD

Posted by CouponKT

if it was a "spank" for discipline reasons, no I wouldn't say anything

if the parent was enraged and beating the kid out of anger, then yes

ITA.

Posted 1/6/11 3:12 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
okay, another WWYD... I find this odd... Kara 10/3/07 32 Home
WWYD? Neighbors dog left out in rain...I am so upset Goobster 9/11/07 19 Pets
WWYD? Buyers and realtors, a question. greenfreak 9/5/07 7 Home
WWYD? about the hotel we stayed at on my vacation DanaRenee 5/1/07 4 Travel & Vacations
WWYD? Etiquette related. greenfreak 4/19/07 31 Families Helping Families ™
xpost: old bff comes out of the wood worx wwyd? need some more opinions Nicole728 1/7/07 10 Families Helping Families ™