WWYD

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

WWYD

maybe its a sort of spinoff.

If you saw a mom slapping or hitting her kid, would you say something to her, call the cops, or do nothing?

not punching or repetitive hitting, just a smack on the backside or a pop in the mouth.

This happens all the time to me and I wonder what others' reactions would be.

Posted 1/6/11 2:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD

I would personally never slap or hit a child. However, I realize that quite a number of people do. While I can't assume, I'd venture to say that more people than not would slap a child for a scolding.

If it was just once I would do nothing. If a person was beating a child up, I'd say that I would call 9-11.

ETA: If my child went to touch the stove/sharp knife/etc, I would slap his/her hand away from it. Therefore, I shouldn't say "never."

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:04:28.317000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:03 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: WWYD

if it was a "spank" for discipline reasons, no I wouldn't say anything

if the parent was enraged and beating the kid out of anger, then yes

Posted 1/6/11 2:04 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: WWYD

A smack on the rump would probably make me look, but not say anything; I don't hit mine but that seems minor.

A "pop in the mouth" would absolutely get a calling out from me. Absolutely. I don't care what the infraction you don't do that.


Posted 1/6/11 2:04 PM
 

Cacarina
Two girls!

Member since 12/09

2971 total posts

Name:
Cari

Re: WWYD

Unless I felt that the child's life was in danger or something VERY serious was happening, I tend to mind my own business.

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: WWYD

i dont care about spaking at all... i would never say anything to a mom who spanked her kid...

slapping in the mouth i think is a little different... i cant really explain why... it just feels a little more like humiliation than punishment...

but again, i have no idea what i would do

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: WWYD

In NYS parents are well within their rights to displine their children by spanking, a smack etc. So long as they are not using excessive force or close fist hitting their kids in the mouth I mind my damnn business!

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:05:52.310000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: WWYD

I would probably say something like "That's a great lesson you're teaching your child, you should be ashamed of yourself." I don't think I could ever bring myself to call CPS, because I have no frame of reference for her actions. I don't know what goes on behind closed doors.

ETA: Also, it depends on if it is a quick smack to keep the child from harm (running into traffic) or a malicious backhand Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:06:31.443000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: WWYD

A smack on the butt or something...I wouldn't say anything. My mom used to do that to my sister and I and we turned out fine.

Hurtful, nasty yelling or something that's more than a simple smack on the butt - depending on where I was and who was around, I would either say something to the person or call the police.

ETA: I just saw your "pop in the mouth" part...that doesn't sit well with me at all - it's just different than a smack on the heiny. That would elicit some action from me.

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:07:15.423000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

mrsBLT
missing my baby

Member since 1/10

1359 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Re: WWYD

well, to me those are very different things:

spanking a child? i'd do nothing.

lightly smacking? probably still wouldn't do anything.

punching or hitting hardly? i'd speak up!

Posted 1/6/11 2:05 PM
 

OffWithHerHead23
Keep passing the open windows

Member since 10/06

3627 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: WWYD

Posted by CouponKT

if it was a "spank" for discipline reasons, no I wouldn't say anything

if the parent was enraged and beating the kid out of anger, then yes



This. I have seen kids act up in stores and the parent pop them on the backside. I have called the police for a parent administering a beating.

Posted 1/6/11 2:06 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: WWYD

I would not say anything to a mother spanking a child once, or tapping their hand to say no.

Legally, you are allowed to hit your children in public to discipline them. Once you start repetitively hitting your child or causing them physical harm it is illegal and I would intervene if I saw that.

Posted 1/6/11 2:09 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

I'm going to get further rejected from a lot of you... but I think sometimes 100% kid's need a good slap on the butt.

I mean not a first line (or even 2nd) line of defense.

I don't care what the studies show.

My parents spanked me.

DH's parents spanked him.

We both feel we're better for it and turned out just fine.



So my answer? I'd probably say 'good for you' if the kid was being a nightmare and they weren't afraid to swat the kid.

It ISN'T illegal to spank the kid on the butt.

Now... unnecessary force? But the kid ain't in danger? I'd probably mind my own business.

BEATING?! I'd say something.

Posted 1/6/11 2:09 PM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: WWYD

None of my business if a parent chooses to spank thier child. It's thier right to do so. The only time I would call the cops is if someone was beating thier child. There is a huge difference between spanking and abuse.

Posted 1/6/11 2:11 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: WWYD

Catey- depends the context....if it was a client and the parent hit the child I would probably say something to the effect of "at this agency we really can't allow anyone to put their hands on anyone else while in this building..." or something

if it was just on the street and it was a spanking I wouldn't say anything, but smacking them in the face or anything repeated I would probably step in, BUT i'm not sure what I'd say in that situation KWIM?

Posted 1/6/11 2:12 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: WWYD

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:15:16.553000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:13 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: WWYD


How I choose to parent is irrelevant.

It is NOT illegal to displine your child physically. (I mean a spank/smack not a beatdown)

You CAN say something and risk your own safety that this parent will take objection to you butting in and smack you! lol

You CAN call the cops--but they won't do ish bc it is not illegal.

I mean it is not to say anyone wants/enjoys seeing a kid get spanked it is just to say that some things are none of your damnn business

Message edited 2011-01-06 14:14:34.663000.

Posted 1/6/11 2:13 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

Posted by MandJZ

Catey- depends the context....if it was a client and the parent hit the child I would probably say something to the effect of "at this agency we really can't allow anyone to put their hands on anyone else while in this building..." or something

if it was just on the street and it was a spanking I wouldn't say anything, but smacking them in the face or anything repeated I would probably step in, BUT i'm not sure what I'd say in that situation KWIM?





... but it's LEGAL to kid's butt. So... wouldn't that sort of be a lie?

Posted 1/6/11 2:14 PM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

I'm going to get further rejected from a lot of you... but I think sometimes 100% kid's need a good slap on the butt.

I mean not a first line (or even 2nd) line of defense.

I don't care what the studies show.

My parents spanked me.

DH's parents spanked him.

We both feel we're better for it and turned out just fine.



So my answer? I'd probably say 'good for you' if the kid was being a nightmare and they weren't afraid to swat the kid.

It ISN'T illegal to spank the kid on the butt.

Now... unnecessary force? But the kid ain't in danger? I'd probably mind my own business.

BEATING?! I'd say something.



I totally agree with you 100%.

Posted 1/6/11 2:14 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: WWYD

a good whallop on the fanny for misbehaving wouldn't bother me.

slaps in the mouth would make me cringe. but it would depend on a great many things, most especially the reaction of the child and the disposition of the hitter.

Posted 1/6/11 2:15 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: WWYD

Posted by colette

A smack on the rump would probably make me look, but not say anything; I don't hit mine but that seems minor.

A "pop in the mouth" would absolutely get a calling out from me. Absolutely. I don't care what the infraction you don't do that.





Same.

Posted 1/6/11 2:15 PM
 

mrsBLT
missing my baby

Member since 1/10

1359 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

Posted by MandJZ

Catey- depends the context....if it was a client and the parent hit the child I would probably say something to the effect of "at this agency we really can't allow anyone to put their hands on anyone else while in this building..." or something

if it was just on the street and it was a spanking I wouldn't say anything, but smacking them in the face or anything repeated I would probably step in, BUT i'm not sure what I'd say in that situation KWIM?





... but it's LEGAL to kid's butt. So... wouldn't that sort of be a lie?



meh... not really. it's legal to smoke cigarettes but you can't do it in restaurants. kwim?

Posted 1/6/11 2:16 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

I want to know exactly what you guys are considering a 'pop in the mouth'?

Are we talking about a punch?!!

A hard smack across the face?

A light smack on the mouth?



Because sometimes I'm in stores and hear mouthy OVERLY mouthy teenagers and I, myself, would sort of like to smack them on the mouth?

Posted 1/6/11 2:17 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: WWYD

Posted by mrsBLT

meh... not really. it's legal to smoke cigarettes but you can't do it in restaurants. kwim?




But only Mer can answer this...

IS it against your buildings rules?

Because you get a smart mouth parent going to your boss to say 'Hey so and so tells me that I can't legally spank my kid for acting up within your building.'

I feel things could get awkward...

Posted 1/6/11 2:18 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: WWYD

Posted by Motown Throwdown

Posted by MandJZ

Catey- depends the context....if it was a client and the parent hit the child I would probably say something to the effect of "at this agency we really can't allow anyone to put their hands on anyone else while in this building..." or something

if it was just on the street and it was a spanking I wouldn't say anything, but smacking them in the face or anything repeated I would probably step in, BUT i'm not sure what I'd say in that situation KWIM?





... but it's LEGAL to kid's butt. So... wouldn't that sort of be a lie?



Becki- as a social worker in a social services agency we can have agency policy that may be stricter than what the law is. Kinda like a TEACHER can't smack a kid, while inside our walls we can not allow a parent to smack a kid even on the butt. What they do in their home is not for us to judge but we can control what happens inside our walls based on agency policy or protocol. I know Catey is also a social worker so I was trying to give an opinion based on if the context was within the parameters of her professional world Chat Icon

Posted 1/6/11 2:19 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
okay, another WWYD... I find this odd... Kara 10/3/07 32 Home
WWYD? Neighbors dog left out in rain...I am so upset Goobster 9/11/07 19 Pets
WWYD? Buyers and realtors, a question. greenfreak 9/5/07 7 Home
WWYD? about the hotel we stayed at on my vacation DanaRenee 5/1/07 4 Travel & Vacations
WWYD? Etiquette related. greenfreak 4/19/07 31 Families Helping Families ™
xpost: old bff comes out of the wood worx wwyd? need some more opinions Nicole728 1/7/07 10 Families Helping Families ™