WIC breastfeeding commericial...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8 | |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... All in all the commercial doesn't bother me, if it gets some people to give it a try then that's great. I NEVER wanted to breast feed, but the thought of losing the weightfaster gave me extra incentive to give it a try with #2 and I don't think that makes me selfish. It was/is a very hard thing to do,it didn't work out for me with a 3 1/2 year old to care for and very little BF support. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 4:14 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Dani10 Posted by Linda1003 They also have a commercial that basically says if you BF your DC will never get sick.. no ear infections...no flu.. They have horrible ads that make me everytime I see one!! Yeah, everytime I see this commercial, I mute it. It annoys me greatly. I just don't buy that. My kid was sick as anything the first year and he was BF for a year. Horribly sick. I guess if I didn't BF he would have been in the hospital in ICU? |
|
Posted 10/15/10 6:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I know people are so heated on this topic, but from the "breast is best" and "MY tax dollars" perspective. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 8:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by colette I know people are so heated on this topic, but from the "breast is best" and "MY tax dollars" perspective. However, 2 observations... 1)We're making this such a black and white issue when in fact it's a cloudy murky shade of gray. But if someone's on WIC let's presume their circumstances warrant it... Think back to your BFing days... Now imagine doing it... maybe with no spouse to support you... worse, maybe there is a domestic "issue" like violence or substance abuse... maybe you have 2, 3, 4 older kids who need time and attention... with no family help. Maybe there are other socio-economic factors... How successful would you have been??? And personally, I don't believe the govt has any business being in my bed or on my boobs, thanks. Support and education are FANTASTIC, but it's still a personal decision. 2) When Giselle famously uttered that BFing "should be a law", everyone was up in arms and called her an idiot. I'm just sayin'. Couldn't love you more!!!! (and Im pretty conservative but still feel this way) !!!!
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 8:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I think that in the circumstances that many of the moms who receive WIC are probably in, it can be very difficult to bf. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... No one on here is judging WIC! |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice No one on here is judging WIC! If you can't afford to buy your baby formula, try the stuff that is flowing out of your body for free. I don't care who is on WIC. I believe in WIC. I believe in WICs campaign to educate those who aren't taught that bfing is mainstream and fine to do. No one is saying abort babies or put mother's on BC. No one is saying make it law. No one is saying to force mothers into anything. Step outside the box for a second. If a commerical aires, be thankful that someone out there might see it who did not know bfing has other benefits. We can't make Bfing taboo to talk about on TV because some people are on meds, or low supplies... All these scenerios...sexually abused, meds, ppd, abusive husbands, single moms working 2 jobs...I am not sure if you get it, but someone is going to have to feed this baby anyway...why not try the BEST milk product you can give your baby. oh yeah, and it is free. oh and here is a pump for you. and pads. and we will give you food checks to make sure your nutrition is up to par. some may become bf'ers. others may not. it comes down to trying it. i realize, wic realizes, mothers realize it isn't for everybody. but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? I think these posts are sort of going back and forth between two ideas that are mutually exclusive. The first is that it is GOOD for WIC to inform women about breast feeeding. I agree that CAN'T be a bad thing- information is always great and yes there are probably many women who don't know enough about bfing. The second though is that women who are on WIC who can physically/medically bf should be DENIED formula. I think my prior post explains who IMO bfing is not always the "BEST". While it might be the "best milk", you have to consider the totality of the circumstances. Forcing the "best milk" might not foster "the best situation" for a baby whose mother could be very young, very stressed, overworked, alone, depressed, etc. Message edited 2010-10-15 09:25:24.117000. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... i never used the word force |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice No one on here is judging WIC! If you can't afford to buy your baby formula, try the stuff that is flowing out of your body for free. I don't care who is on WIC. I believe in WIC. I believe in WICs campaign to educate those who aren't taught that bfing is mainstream and fine to do. No one is saying abort babies or put mother's on BC. No one is saying make it law. No one is saying to force mothers into anything. Step outside the box for a second. If a commerical aires, be thankful that someone out there might see it who did not know bfing has other benefits. We can't make Bfing taboo to talk about on TV because some people are on meds, or low supplies... All these scenerios...sexually abused, meds, ppd, abusive husbands, single moms working 2 jobs...I am not sure if you get it, but someone is going to have to feed this baby anyway...why not try the BEST milk product you can give your baby. oh yeah, and it is free. oh and here is a pump for you. and pads. and we will give you food checks to make sure your nutrition is up to par. some may become bf'ers. others may not. it comes down to trying it. i realize, wic realizes, mothers realize it isn't for everybody. but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Why?? Because It is MY choice not to breast feed. Maybe I don't want to try it. I felt uncomfortable doing it. I also did try it, I was not able too. Personal problems I rather not discuss..Did you ever think it would be really hard to have to explain your personal story to the government if it was mandatory to breastfeed?? I don't think anyone should be forced to breastfeed because its FREE!! Women who do breastfeed I think that its great and you are doing an awesome job! I really get angry at the way you say its the BEST!! So are mothers who formula feed bad because they cant breastfeed or chose not to?? I don't understand why you cant just let it rest. People have been hurt by these posts. We are women who should support eachother, now I know you are not bashing women on WIC but you seem to be bashing anyone who doesn't breastfeed and to be honest it hurts my feelings as well and you make me feel like I deprived my baby. Lets all respect another ones decisions and let this topic go.
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice i never used the word force i never used the word deny i would think a mother who could not buy formula would attempt to bf if medically capable to do so before she asked for gov't assistance. obviously, i thought wrong. Well you did say, "you should not be able to get WIC unless you have a reason for not bfing!". What reasons would be acceptable to you outside of a medical issue? If no other reasons are acceptable then the words "force" and "deny" are imo implied. And honestly, I wasn't trying to "call you out" specifically on something. I just quoted your post b/c in general I see this thread going in two different directions (WIC should inform about bfing and then WIC should only pay for formula if the mom physically/medically can't bf). |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice.
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... An interesting study regarding breasmilk vs formula: |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice.
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice. I understand that WIC covers way more than just formula, but why isn't Janice allowed to feel this way, any more than you are allowed to feel the way you do? I said it before, early in the post - If a woman CAN breastfeed but CHOOSES not to, I'd rather she purchased the formula on her own. If formula companies are donating free formula, great. But if my tax dollars are going towards formula instead of, say, education, then I am going to take issue with that. And like it's been said on here before, so many times it's about EDUCATION. Not right vs. wrong. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Bunny, YES YES YES: |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by BunnyWife An interesting study regarding breasmilk vs formula: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1241051/Breast-milk-NOT-better-baby-formula-scientists-claim.html Interesting... but I think that the reason previous studies have shown that BM is best has only to do with the antibodies, not the "ingredients" per se - which this article says is covered by having a healthy pregnancy? Doesn't make sense to me, but then, I'm npt a scientist
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MarisaK I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead. If I couldn't afford that formula, I think my comfort and 'personal decision' would be trumped by the fact that my CHILD NEEDED TO EAT so I think the expectation that I suck it up and TRY is perfectly acceptable - If I COULDN"T do it for whatever reason, that's different. But taking gov't aid simply b/c I didn't 'feel like doing it' ??? - Um, no sorry, I don't agree with that. But I don't think many women on WIC don't breastfeed just bc they don't "feel like it", kwim? Many of these women are very young, the dad isn't around, working for extremely low wages, under-informed about ppd and other stresses of motherhood, etc. It's great if many of these mothers even get their babies to routine well visits could you imagine them trying to bf and/or pump for hours each day? I feel that denying formula is putting these babies at serious risk. I'm not trying to classify all mom's who get WIC- but these are the circumstances for MANY. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by headoverheels Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice. I understand that WIC covers way more than just formula, but why isn't Janice allowed to feel this way, any more than you are allowed to feel the way you do? I said it before, early in the post - If a woman CAN breastfeed but CHOOSES not to, I'd rather she purchased the formula on her own. If formula companies are donating free formula, great. But if my tax dollars are going towards formula instead of, say, education, then I am going to take issue with that. And like it's been said on here before, so many times it's about EDUCATION. Not right vs. wrong. What about MY tax dollars? We pay taxes too? That whole tax dollar issue is ludicrious...I bet there are times where my tax dollars will go to something I'm not happy with, but thats the US of A for ya.... Why is Janice not allowed to have an opinion? She is..no one said she could not. There is a difference between having and stating an opinion and coming across as if this is the ONLY way and all others are abusing the system....cheats...frauds ( as that is what that implies) and judging a woman..MOTHERS choice. That to me is hurtful and sad. I respect all Mothers for what they do for their children , whether I like the method or not...as long as the children are being taken care of. Message edited 2010-10-15 09:51:20.500000. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by headoverheels Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice. I understand that WIC covers way more than just formula, but why isn't Janice allowed to feel this way, any more than you are allowed to feel the way you do? I said it before, early in the post - If a woman CAN breastfeed but CHOOSES not to, I'd rather she purchased the formula on her own. If formula companies are donating free formula, great. But if my tax dollars are going towards formula instead of, say, education, then I am going to take issue with that. And like it's been said on here before, so many times it's about EDUCATION. Not right vs. wrong. I never said Janice wasn't allowed to feel this way. I was giving MY opinion to her question. I'm all for education, I'm ALL for breastfeeding. I totally applaud all women that do it, love it, and do it for extended periods of time. It's just not for me. From the second I put DD to my breast, I HATED it. I chose not to BF because of how I felt. I kept at it for 6 weeks, because I felt pressured to do so, and BECAUSE of the pressure, I started to resent my DD, THERE IS NOTHING WORSE IN THIS WORLD THAN FEELING RESENTMENT TOWARDS YOUR CHILD AND NOT BEING ABLE TO CONTROL THOSE FEELINGS. Nobody knows someone circumstances for being on WIC, all I'm saying is that a woman should not be told.... "don't try, figure out your own way then to pay for formula to feed your baby" |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I just can't with the "debate". I want babies FED, I have NO PROBLEM if my tax $ pays for formula. God bless the mom, god bless that baby. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by headoverheels Posted by MrsRbk Posted by Janice but why rule it out if you can't afford food for your baby? Because it's MY body and my decision whether or not to BF. Nobody else's. A woman shouldn't be told in order to receive formula via WIC she should try to BF first. It's MY choice as that childs parent to decide how to feed that child and what is best for MY child. Not the governments choice. I understand that WIC covers way more than just formula, but why isn't Janice allowed to feel this way, any more than you are allowed to feel the way you do? I said it before, early in the post - If a woman CAN breastfeed but CHOOSES not to, I'd rather she purchased the formula on her own. If formula companies are donating free formula, great. But if my tax dollars are going towards formula instead of, say, education, then I am going to take issue with that. And like it's been said on here before, so many times it's about EDUCATION. Not right vs. wrong. What about all the other crazy stuff tax dollars go to? I just see the WIC formula issue as so small compared to some of the imo ridiculous things our tax dollars go to. Here is an article- "Stupid Things Your taxes Pay For" |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by BrinaEsq Posted by MarisaK I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead. If I couldn't afford that formula, I think my comfort and 'personal decision' would be trumped by the fact that my CHILD NEEDED TO EAT so I think the expectation that I suck it up and TRY is perfectly acceptable - If I COULDN"T do it for whatever reason, that's different. But taking gov't aid simply b/c I didn't 'feel like doing it' ??? - Um, no sorry, I don't agree with that. But I don't think many women on WIC don't breastfeed just bc they don't "feel like it", kwim? Many of these women are very young, the dad isn't around, working for extremely low wages, under-informed about ppd and other stresses of motherhood, etc. It's great if many of these mothers even get their babies to routine well visits could you imagine them trying to bf and/or pump for hours each day? I feel that denying formula is putting these babies at serious risk. I'm not trying to classify all mom's who get WIC- but these are the circumstances for MANY. I'm sure your're right - I"m not saying ANYONE should be denied formula - b/c who are you really denying? The poor helpless baby ........KWIM? My response was to those who's attitude was 'it's MY body and MY choice" - and while I agree with that under normal circumstances, I personally don't think it's right to ask for financial assistance simply b/c you don't feel like TRYING something ......... I'm only applying it to MYSELF and why "I" didn't want to BF. I just didn't want to, I was uncomfortable with the idea, it didn't appeal to me at all - I personally don't think that's enough of a reason to ask for financial assistance. KWIM? |
|
Posted 10/15/10 9:50 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MarisaK I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead. If I couldn't afford that formula, I think my comfort and 'personal decision' would be trumped by the fact that my CHILD NEEDED TO EAT so I think the expectation that I suck it up and TRY is perfectly acceptable - If I COULDN"T do it for whatever reason, that's different. But taking gov't aid simply b/c I didn't 'feel like doing it' ??? - Um, no sorry, I don't agree with that. this is what I mean. I think brinaesq brought up some good posted about the effects of forcing it upon the mother in respect to how it would effec the child. it has softened by view i suppose b/c it makes me react emotionally, not fiscally. but I guess I feel like rather than just hand over a can of formula, an LC ccan sit down with the mom and at least try. if you try and fail, at that point fine. then that is a REASON (which we siad, without reason. with reason is reasonable) if this was about anything other than BF people would be so up in arms. I see MANY otherwise very conservative people being very liberal here and i can only surmise it's b/c they can relate in a way to this issue. I wonder though, if we started talking about illegal women getting wic. getting free formula for their babies...where would that conversation go (ftr, I think they should try to bf too) when you ask for assistance it cannot always be on your terms. it's not. there are rules and laws when you are on wic. on welfare. there are certain parameters that must be met. it's not about using the services if you are in need. there is NO SHAME in that whatsoever. i just feel the basic idea and message is being lost and instead people are being painted in the light that I think is pretty harsh and unfair. |
Posted 10/15/10 9:51 AM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breastfeeding question | betty | 9/7/05 | 5 | Parenting |
| ? for breastfeeding moms | MrsBumbleb | 9/6/05 | 10 | Parenting |
| Questions about breastfeeding, and pumps... | 05mommy09 | 8/21/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| The Breastfeeding Protection Initiative | KPtoys | 8/19/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Breastfeeding | NK926 | 8/17/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| Calling all breastfeeding moms | Dani00518 | 7/25/05 | 7 | Parenting |





everytime I see one!!










