WIC breastfeeding commericial...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Dani10 Sorry, but I don't believe that bf babies are less likely to get sick. How can they really test that since they can't test the same baby, you know? they do extensive research... |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:12 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... also... WIC covers a lot more than just formula & milk. Its nutrition for babies... cheese, eggs, cereal etc... |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I dunno how I feel about this....my first thought is to agree that women should have to at least try bf'ing to receive aid. However, there are some women who are just plain uncomfortable breast feeding. Why should we force them? It may cause more stress, lead to PPD or other issues and cost more tax dollars anyhow. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... with pregnant women I can assure you that there is a large majority of WIC moms that have no shame in taking what they don't pay for and then asking for more. I've had medicaid patients demand private rooms, extra diapers, formula, etc... This campaign ad is directed towards these moms I assure you. So for those of you with bruised egos try not to make this all about you please. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by kahlua716 I dunno how I feel about this....my first thought is to agree that women should have to at least try bf'ing to receive aid. However, there are some women who are just plain uncomfortable breast feeding. Why should we force them? It may cause more stress, lead to PPD or other issues and cost more tax dollars anyhow. I wasn't thrilled with the idea of BF'ing but I was willing to give it a try. I wound up not being able to because of medication. I would hate to have to be forced. :-/ Also, what if a woman is working 2 jobs to try and support her family? WIC doesn't pay the rent...she may not have the time with the baby to breast feed.... JMO they provide pumps and supplies Message edited 2010-10-14 18:22:26.117000. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I hate the commercials because I hate any reminder of the pain I went through trying to breastfeed. i don't need random people reminding me of my inability to provide what was best for my child. Just like I hate anytime I hear someone say "breastmilk is best". |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I can't afford the formula that both my babies needed. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by HeathKernandez also... WIC covers a lot more than just formula & milk. Its nutrition for babies... cheese, eggs, cereal etc... I was JUST going to post this. Just because a woman BFs her baby doesn't mean that she won't still need WIC. If anyhthing, WIC will provide her with the healthy foods needed so that she can produce the best breast milk possible for her baby. Formula is only ONE component of WIC. And, seriously, I know that from the fact that if you walk around the supermarket, you can see "WIC Approved" on the shelves, so i'm shocked more people don't realize that. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. AMEN. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I am glad to see that they are trying to educate people and make breastfeeding a positive thing. The weight loss thing is playing to a specific audience. I hope that there is further support for those who want and need it. We need more positive breastfeeding education in this country. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by BaroqueMama Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. AMEN. right on. this is what they do...distract us with nonsense so we debate and turn against each other over something silly when there is a BIGGER, DARKER issue playing out in the background. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. This is a fantastic point! I wrote a paper on our maternity/paternity leave suport in the US vs. other nations and it is just SO sad. There are third world countries with better benefits then ours. We are literally at the bottom of the barrel. Australia is the only other industrialized nation without a federally funded leave program and they offer job protection for up to one year. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 6:49 PM
|
|
|
munchkinfacemama
Member since 11/07 15800 total posts Name: |
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by headoverheels Posted by Mariabella I hate this commercial! Then again I hate all the commercials were they associate breastfeeding being better than formula. I think it's a personal decision that no one can make for you. Doesn't matter if you can't or if you won't. Sorry but if my tax dollars are going to pay for formula that you don't actually need, but CHOOSE to use, then I am damn sure going to be annoyed. I am ALL FOR freedom of choice when it comes to BFing and formula feeding. If you CAN breastfeed but don't WANT to breastfeed, then that is fine! Seriously, go for it. But buy it yourself then. You said it LB! Word for word what I was going to say. I noticed there are a lot of bus stop advertisements to BF. I pointed them out to my mom. No doubt in my mind that WIC wants to encourage moms to BF instead of providing formula. |
Posted 10/14/10 6:57 PM
|
|
|
munchkinfacemama
Member since 11/07 15800 total posts Name: |
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. Amen sister! As an EBFing mom, I cannot imagine how hard it would be if I was working full time right now! |
Posted 10/14/10 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by munchkinfacemama Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. Amen sister! As an EBFing mom, I cannot imagine how hard it would be if I was working full time right now! Excellente! |
|
Posted 10/14/10 7:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Ophelia Posted by Janice haven't seen it...but glad it is on! you should not be able to get WIC unless you have a reason for not bfing! I agree with this. bm is FREE and if you are so broke you need public assistance, you should have to provide a damned good reason why you cannot provide what your boday makes naturally. I believe wholeheartedly in aid. in the welfare system, in wic. but I also believe you as a recipient should be using every resource you have before putting your hand out. ITA |
|
Posted 10/14/10 7:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by LoriH I am glad to see that they are trying to educate people and make breastfeeding a positive thing. The weight loss thing is playing to a specific audience. I hope that there is further support for those who want and need it. We need more positive breastfeeding education in this country. As for making someone prove a medical reason not to breastfeed and get assistance, I think that is just an example of what is wrong with the breastfeeding movement. Forcing someone to do something they may not be comfortable with and making them feel ashamed is a horrible way to handle it. All that will do is make them, angry, ashamed and possibly in need of other forms of assistance. What we need to do is make breastfeeding easier for women, acceptable in society and educate on the benefits while still supporting those who can't or choose not to breastfeed. Excellent, excellent points! I EBF my daughter for 26m, not bc I had to but bc I wanted to - it was my choice. I honestly think it's kind if appalling that people/women would support the idea that a woman has to prove why they wouldn't choose to BF. I think it's sad how motherhood can unite and divide women all at once. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by 5ofClubs I hate these commercials!!! Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances! Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice??? |
|
Posted 10/14/10 8:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by shamrock124 What really bothers me about these advertisements is not that they are trying to support breastfeeding but this is really the only support. Encouragement. You really want to try to get more mothers to breastfeed their babies...whether on assistance or not...make a fair maternity and paternity leave policy in this country. What we have now is APPALLING and in no way supports a new mom in breastfeeding. You get 6 or 8 weeks of STD if you qualify and at that, it's capped out at a ridiculously low #. I realize this is NYS specific but I don't think there are any states that have much better laws on their books. Make the laws that govern the workforce be across the board. No more loop hole if you employ less then 50 employees. If it's a hardship on the employer...offer a tax incentive for the business. Make insurance companies cover things like LC visits and follow up, pumps, breastfeeding classes. Right now, most of these things are out of pocket. So, for a LC visit to my home..I have to lay out a minimum of $250. For some families that just had their income cut, this is not something they can afford! It makes me so angry that this country is so backward in this area...among other things. Couldn't agree with you more. Encouragement is only half the battle. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by ~Colleen~ I think it's sad how motherhood can unite and divide women all at once. I agree.
|
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by ~Colleen~ Posted by LoriH I am glad to see that they are trying to educate people and make breastfeeding a positive thing. The weight loss thing is playing to a specific audience. I hope that there is further support for those who want and need it. We need more positive breastfeeding education in this country. As for making someone prove a medical reason not to breastfeed and get assistance, I think that is just an example of what is wrong with the breastfeeding movement. Forcing someone to do something they may not be comfortable with and making them feel ashamed is a horrible way to handle it. All that will do is make them, angry, ashamed and possibly in need of other forms of assistance. What we need to do is make breastfeeding easier for women, acceptable in society and educate on the benefits while still supporting those who can't or choose not to breastfeed. Excellent, excellent points! I EBF my daughter for 26m, not bc I had to but bc I wanted to - it was my choice. I honestly think it's kind if appalling that people/women would support the idea that a woman has to prove why they wouldn't choose to BF. I think it's sad how motherhood can unite and divide women all at once. I agree with this. I couldn't breastfeed with my first because my milk never came and with my second I am on some serious meds. I didn't want to anyway and that was my choice. I am shocked by some of the statements posted here. Forcing women to breastfeed if they financially need WIC? Next why don't we make people who can't afford to have children have abortions? Who are we to say how people should feed their babies regardless of whether they need finance assistance or not? We fight for the rights to chose what to do with our bodies but we lose that right if we choose to formula feed if we are uncomfortable with breastfeeding because one might need WIC? I am just so surprised that people feel that way.
Message edited 2010-10-14 21:21:11.210000. |
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Disneygirl Posted by 5ofClubs I hate these commercials!!! Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances! Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice??? Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food? Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want? If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses. Does this hit a nerve with me...YES.... I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids. Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times... And Thank God for it. Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help. Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts. I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway.... FLAME AWAY |
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by nicrae Posted by ~Colleen~ Posted by LoriH I am glad to see that they are trying to educate people and make breastfeeding a positive thing. The weight loss thing is playing to a specific audience. I hope that there is further support for those who want and need it. We need more positive breastfeeding education in this country. As for making someone prove a medical reason not to breastfeed and get assistance, I think that is just an example of what is wrong with the breastfeeding movement. Forcing someone to do something they may not be comfortable with and making them feel ashamed is a horrible way to handle it. All that will do is make them, angry, ashamed and possibly in need of other forms of assistance. What we need to do is make breastfeeding easier for women, acceptable in society and educate on the benefits while still supporting those who can't or choose not to breastfeed. Excellent, excellent points! I EBF my daughter for 26m, not bc I had to but bc I wanted to - it was my choice. I honestly think it's kind if appalling that people/women would support the idea that a woman has to prove why they wouldn't choose to BF. I think it's sad how motherhood can unite and divide women all at once. I agree with this. I couldn't breastfeed with my first because my milk never came and with my second I am on some serious meds. I didn't want to anyway and that was my choice. I am shocked by some of the statements posted here. Forcing women to breastfeed if they financially need WIC? Next why don't we make people who can't afford to have children have abortions? Who are we to say how people should feed their babies regardless of whether they need finance assistance or not? We fight for the rights to chose what to do with our bodies but we lose that right if we choose to formula feed if we are uncomfortable with breastfeeding because one might need WIC? I am just so surprised that people feel that way. ITA!!
|
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by dm24angel Posted by Disneygirl Posted by 5ofClubs I hate these commercials!!! Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances! Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice??? Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food? Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want? If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses. Does this hit a nerve with me...YES.... I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids. Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times... And Thank God for it. Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help. Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts. I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway.... FLAME AWAY no flames here you did what you had to for your family!!
|
|
Posted 10/14/10 9:33 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breastfeeding question | betty | 9/7/05 | 5 | Parenting |
| ? for breastfeeding moms | MrsBumbleb | 9/6/05 | 10 | Parenting |
| Questions about breastfeeding, and pumps... | 05mommy09 | 8/21/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| The Breastfeeding Protection Initiative | KPtoys | 8/19/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Breastfeeding | NK926 | 8/17/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| Calling all breastfeeding moms | Dani00518 | 7/25/05 | 7 | Parenting |












