WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >>

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

I just love the fact that that commercials were even MADE! I agree with those who said that before asking for assistance with money to buy formula, why not try to use something that is superior in nutritial value and that you can get for FREE. Mostly though, I am just really excited to see a commercial actually promoting breastfeeding!!!

And also, if this ad with convince even a handful of women, whether or not they are receiving WIC, to give BF a try than it was successful. I think it's also very smart that they mention weight lose as one fo the benefits for the mother. I am always surprised that not everyone knows about that great "side effect".

Posted 10/14/10 9:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by bayla

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Disneygirl

Posted by 5ofClubs

I hate these commercials!!!Chat Icon

Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances!



Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice???



Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food?


Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want?

If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses.

Does this hit a nerve with me...YES....

I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids.

Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times...

And Thank God for it.

Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help.

Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts.

I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway....

FLAME AWAY



no flames hereChat Icon you did what you had to for your family!!



Thank you! I feel we did. It was literally only a few months , and then financially we were better then ever and I went back to spending $$$ on pretty dresses, and throwing a huge birthday party for the girls because once again I could...and I DO NOT feel guilty, I pay taxes, thats what they are for, and I make sure to give back...as MANY MANY of the women on here can attest to, I have given away as much as I could of things of my sons and daughters to try to help others who could use it etc....It my way of giving back ....

I DO NOT get the trying to instill shame in people mentality some have.

Posted 10/14/10 9:43 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Nobody has the right to tell me what I should do with my body.

Could I BF my child... sure.... but I chose not to. I chose not to go through the stress and emotional distress I went through when I nursed my daughter. I gave it up when she was 6 weeks old because it was not a right fit for ME. She also had to be on Alimentium which was $$$$ and yes, I was annoyed that my insurance wouldn't cover it. (I know, insurance and WIC are two different things). Why should I put myself through that again? I went right to formula with DS.

As far as BM keeping my child from getting sick, or NOT sick as often as a FF baby.... well, DD has had 1 ear infection in 20 months, and as many colds as I can count on one hand.

My SIL's kids, who have all been nursed, are literally ALWAYS sick. My SIL nursed the oldest until he was 2 and she got pregnant with her 2nd. She nursed him also until he was 2 until she got pregnant again.





Posted 10/14/10 9:47 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by bayla

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Disneygirl

Posted by 5ofClubs

I hate these commercials!!!Chat Icon

Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances!



Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice???



Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food?


Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want?

If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses.

Does this hit a nerve with me...YES....

I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids.

Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times...

And Thank God for it.

Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help.

Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts.

I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway....

FLAME AWAY



no flames hereChat Icon you did what you had to for your family!!



Thank you! I feel we did. It was literally only a few months , and then financially we were better then ever and I went back to spending $$$ on pretty dresses, and throwing a huge birthday party for the girls because once again I could...and I DO NOT feel guilty, I pay taxes, thats what they are for, and I make sure to give back...as MANY MANY of the women on here can attest to, I have given away as much as I could of things of my sons and daughters to try to help others who could use it etc....It my way of giving back ....

I DO NOT get the trying to instill shame in people mentality some have.



Agree on all points. People always assume that they control their destiny. You can need the help you may not need the help, but a chose on how one feeds their baby shouldn't depend on whether you need aid or not.

Posted 10/14/10 9:57 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Disneygirl

Posted by 5ofClubs

I hate these commercials!!!Chat Icon

Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances!



Perhaps the gov't should provide them with a minivan too, hey how are they going to get the kiddos to soccer practice???



Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food?


Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want?

If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses.

Does this hit a nerve with me...YES....

I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids.

Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times...

And Thank God for it.

Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help.

Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts.

I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway....

FLAME AWAY



You did what you had to do for your family No flames here Chat Icon

This me me me me attitude and my my my attitude is what I hate...and probably one of the reasons why we don't have healthcare for all or most Americans Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 10:12 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

I have seen lots of POV on this thread and I have taken my side.

I didn't breastfeed DS1 past six weeks because of severe PPD. (It was so bad that DH took a few days off to let me take a break, until my medicine kicked in with out me even asking) When I quit bfing the PPD went away.

With DS 2 I didn't even try to BF. The reason being I wanted to enjoy this baby since he is my last. I had a two year old who thrived on Formula and was rarely sick (until he started Camp with 18 other kids and even then he's only been sick 2 times)

Now as for the comments about FORCING women to BF. Seriously? I am actually shocked! Yes some people abuse the system. It's par for the course. But just because something was right for one person doesn't mean it's right for everyone. Also I think forcing it down someones throat isn't the right way to go. Is that really the right way to go? How about educating better, (and no I don't mean a commercial saying "Try this you'll lose weight). Pay for pumps, pay for supplies, allow a time alotment at work for women to really stop and pump and still get paid, better benefits in general. But even still no guarentee that a woman is going to eat right, not smoke, not drink, not do drugs, all these things are HUGE contributors to me. JMHO

Posted 10/14/10 10:16 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel
Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food?


Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want?

If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses.

Does this hit a nerve with me...YES....

I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids.

Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times...

And Thank God for it.

Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help.

Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts.

I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway....

FLAME AWAY



You are right about not having to defend your reasons. You did what you had to do to provide for your family.
I understand that a lot of people get very heated about subjects like welfare, WIC benefits, unemployment, etc. because there are a lot of people who do take advantage of the system, but that does not mean EVERYONE on welfare or who utilize WIC does. What concerns me is if they bully/force women into BFing against their will, a line gets crossed. What would be next, mandatory sterilization/birth control? It just doesn't sit that well with me because I know I wouldn't want some state agency deciding how I will feed my child Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 10:28 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

abortions, sterilization...that is not even close to this.

BFing is natural. WIC is educating those who may never have considered it. Those who don't know people who have bf before. Making it more mainstream.

Meds, PPD, low supply...those are legit reasons.
It is not like you are having a baby in America and told to nurse or else...
You are going to a goverment agency.
You are telling them that you need help feeding your child.
They are going to help you do that while they educate you on a FREE supply that has so many benefits to it.

As far as people who abuse the system...where does that start and stop?
is it chosing not to give your baby free food on hand and instead asking for another source?
is it being on assistance and having cable in your home?
is it being pregnant while you already have a child receiving WIC?

there are going to be tons of different opinions as to who is abusing and who isn't.

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.

Posted 10/14/10 10:38 PM
 

Disneygirl
Disney cruise bound!

Member since 5/05

8126 total posts

Name:
D

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by Momma2Be

Posted by dm24angel
Huh? That does not even make sense. How could you compare driving/ playing a sport with providing food?


Some of you are so judgemental it is disgusting....I hate when I see so many fail to put themselves in others shoes, but make it all about THEM. My Tax Dollars, My this, my that...BLAH BLAH BLAH.....Do we really have to make it THAT hard to help people that may not believe AS YOU DO, Or want what you want?

If someone is uncomfortable with breastfeeding, they should anyway?.....just so your tax dollars arent spent? Where do you want those tax dollars to go? I mean cmon now, some people need to step down or fall down off those high horses.

Does this hit a nerve with me...YES....

I was on WIC after the twins were born for a few months. My one Daughters formula was hundreds of dollars a month in co-pays ( and thank god for insurance) ....Our insurance premiums went up to a staggering amount a month with 2 added children and I needed a new car to fit 3 carseats in.......and my husband's job rather then lay people off gave everyone a salary cut. I would have EASILY gone back to work to make up for the loss if I could have found a job, hell Walmarts not even hiring these days...that could pay for daycare for my 3 kids.

Anyway, we couldn't afford the $900+ a month of formula we needed , so we turned to what OUR TAX DOLLARS had been paying for all along.... It is there for people like us who fall on hard times...

And Thank God for it.

Within a few months, my husbands job was back on track and he actually got a promotion and a raise and we are much better financially now...and no longer need to depend on outside help.

Thats our background on why...and now here comes the shocker....Hold your hats.....I decided I didnt/couldnt breastfeed. I was on medication I would have to have stopped, and also didnt think I could emotionally handle breastfeeding twin newborns with a 2 yr old running around. To all of you who judged me in this Thread....I hope your not ever in a position to have to defend your choices against cruel judgemental MOTHERS because it hurts.

I'm FINE with my decisions/choices....shouldn't have to defend my reasons..but choose to anyway....

FLAME AWAY



You are right about not having to defend your reasons. You did what you had to do to provide for your family.
I understand that a lot of people get very heated about subjects like welfare, WIC benefits, unemployment, etc. because there are a lot of people who do take advantage of the system, but that does not mean EVERYONE on welfare or who utilize WIC does. What concerns me is if they bully/force women into BFing against their will, a line gets crossed. What would be next, mandatory sterilization/birth control? It just doesn't sit that well with me because I know I wouldn't want some state agency deciding how I will feed my child Chat Icon



You're right, I work with a lot of women who abuse the system so my frustration comes from them. There needs to be a line drawn because no one should be forced into doing something they truly don't want to do but I see no harm in providing the education and support and then allowing someone to make a decision. I still don't understand why everyone is up in arms over a commercial. It may not be the best breastfeeding commercial out there but I am all for promoting breastfeeding awareness.

Posted 10/14/10 10:40 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by Janice

abortions, sterilization...that is not even close to this.

BFing is natural. WIC is educating those who may never have considered it. Those who don't know people who have bf before. Making it more mainstream.

Meds, PPD, low supply...those are legit reasons.
It is not like you are having a baby in America and told to nurse or else...
You are going to a goverment agency.
You are telling them that you need help feeding your child.
They are going to help you do that while they educate you on a FREE supply that has so many benefits to it.

As far as people who abuse the system...where does that start and stop?
is it chosing not to give your baby free food on hand and instead asking for another source?
is it being on assistance and having cable in your home?
is it being pregnant while you already have a child receiving WIC?

there are going to be tons of different opinions as to who is abusing and who isn't.

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



yeah, it seems like the "reason" part of the whole equation is lost in the ranting.

in any event, I don't have any problem with WIC handing out free formula if they aren't paying for it. if it's coming from the manufacturer gratis, as someone said. then that is fine. the problem I would have with paying is that there are FINITE resources and money, and it seems unfair to me that someone could be taking resources someone else b/c bf "wasn't for them". looking at the totality of that circumstance, and not on a individual level, it isn't right to me. I am sorry if that is called "cruel".

I just find it so odd that people are so much for this WIC benefit when the predominant feeling on the boards in regards to public assistance has always slanted FAR to the negative.Chat Icon

like I've said before (and my prior posts back me up) I am a HUGE fan of public assistance. even in the face of fraudsters. of abusers. but even those people are held accountable. you can't just walk in and get something. you have to prove need. this should be no different.

and I would myself be in that situation. b/c my son has been on formula since his 3rd day of life. without it he would not have flourished. so this has nothing to do with "me me me" or what I think is right b/c it's what *I* did. it's what I think its right b/c it follows logic. not emotion. so I would have gladly explained to the case worker that I cannot physically produce enough milk for my son. I would provide documentation...the days and hours I spent crying in my pediatrician's office shirtless with a "my breast friend" wrapped around my waste.

no one wants anyone to be shamed. that is just ridiculous. and yes I personally know how hard it is for SOME to go down and ask for help. I also know people who don't give a rats asss and will take whatever "the man" will give free.

Posted 10/14/10 10:52 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.

Message edited 2010-10-14 22:58:05.570000.

Posted 10/14/10 10:56 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.



you can't win 'em all, but I admire you, Donna

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 10:59 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.



Don't feel badly at all about what you did AT ALL

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 11:03 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by Janice

abortions, sterilization...that is not even close to this.

BFing is natural. WIC is educating those who may never have considered it. Those who don't know people who have bf before. Making it more mainstream.




Just wanted to present something regarding the BFing is natural comment - it may be an organic choice, but who is to say what is "natural" and what isn't?

pacifers aren't natural.
neither are diaper warmers, and cow's milk sure isn't even natural, if you want to get scientific - we are the only creatures drinking an animal's milk past the baby stage.

and breastfeeding may not be natural or comfortable to some who have maybe been sexually abused, too. A lot of people neglect to think of that angle, but some people may understand.

people have their reasons and nothing should be mandated in order to receive something we ALL pay into.

Message edited 2010-10-14 23:05:30.587000.

Posted 10/14/10 11:04 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by brownie

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.



Don't feel badly at all about what you did AT ALL

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Oh I don't...not at all...

We only needed a small helping hand till we could save up enough $ to cover it ourselves, I feel no guilt....I donate often, I give back often, I can sleep at night just fine with my decision...I feel badly that someone I admire and like like Janice feels that way about a choice I made...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Thank you though Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 11:08 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by 5ofClubs

I hate these commercials!!!Chat Icon

Women on WIC should be able to make whatever decision they want about breastfeeding or not. They are not criminals! They are people that need aid because of their circumstances!


Ditto!
Because I have money I am more entitled to make decisions for my child then someone on WIC?

Posted 10/14/10 11:09 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by Ophelia

I just find it so odd that people are so much for this WIC benefit when the predominant feeling on the boards in regards to public assistance has always slanted FAR to the negative.Chat Icon
.



I have been thinking the same thing tonight.
For years I have been on the side of universal healthcare...the person on this thread who commented on the me me me and mine mine mine...that is the furtherest thing from my mind.
It might be naive, but I just feel that if people limit the resources they need rather then want, we might be one step closer to healthcare. Showing nay sayers that we won't take a system and runaway with it. That we would respect it.
If this means quality free lunches for school aged children because money is being saved on nursing rather then formula...that is all that I mean.

Posted 10/14/10 11:11 PM
 

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by kahlua716

I dunno how I feel about this....my first thought is to agree that women should have to at least try bf'ing to receive aid. However, there are some women who are just plain uncomfortable breast feeding. Why should we force them? It may cause more stress, lead to PPD or other issues and cost more tax dollars anyhow.

Also, what if a woman is working 2 jobs to try and support her family? WIC doesn't pay the rent...she may not have the time with the baby to breast feed....

JMO



I totally agree with this statement.It is HARD to breastfeed. It may be in the best interest of her AND her baby to pay for formula. Maybe it would alleviate some stress- make her a happier mom. Breastfeeding was very difficult to me. I would like to think that I would get help for formula if I needed the money. Moms on WIC probably do not have teh time and the luxury to keep trying at breastfeeding if it comes hard to them.

Posted 10/14/10 11:14 PM
 

JRD2008
CT. here we come!!

Member since 5/08

2944 total posts

Name:
Kathleen

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.



I am so sorry you feel that way. Chat Icon Chat Icon You did what was best for your family and that is really all anyone can do!

Posted 10/14/10 11:15 PM
 

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by CookieMomster

I have seen lots of POV on this thread and I have taken my side.

I didn't breastfeed DS1 past six weeks because of severe PPD. (It was so bad that DH took a few days off to let me take a break, until my medicine kicked in with out me even asking) When I quit bfing the PPD went away.

With DS 2 I didn't even try to BF. The reason being I wanted to enjoy this baby since he is my last. I had a two year old who thrived on Formula and was rarely sick (until he started Camp with 18 other kids and even then he's only been sick 2 times)

Now as for the comments about FORCING women to BF. Seriously? I am actually shocked! Yes some people abuse the system. It's par for the course. But just because something was right for one person doesn't mean it's right for everyone. Also I think forcing it down someones throat isn't the right way to go. Is that really the right way to go? How about educating better, (and no I don't mean a commercial saying "Try this you'll lose weight). Pay for pumps, pay for supplies, allow a time alotment at work for women to really stop and pump and still get paid, better benefits in general. But even still no guarentee that a woman is going to eat right, not smoke, not drink, not do drugs, all these things are HUGE contributors to me. JMHO




I had a very similar situation as you- BF my son and then not my daughter due to PPD and difficulties.
I am really shocked at some of the thoughts on here. We all pay taxes- is it so bad that some of them will to to formula? It can be SO hard to nurse- I would never want to think that a stressed out new mom feel forced to.....

Posted 10/14/10 11:21 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.

I am so amazed by you. You did what you needed to as a mother for your children, and I give you a round ofChat Icon for letting us share in what must have been a difficult time for you.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 11:22 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by CookieMomster

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.

I am so amazed by you. You did what you needed to as a mother for your children, and I give you a round ofChat Icon for letting us share in what must have been a difficult time for you.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree... Donna, you are an amazing mother and I see your point of view... Honestly, after reading a lot of these post... I am now understanding it from so many different views.

I would never want someone in an office to make your personal decision for anyone, but unfortunatly some people do abuse the system... for instance woman using abortions for birth control...

I am not against abortions it is 100% a womans choice... but I am against a woman using it as a form of birth control and abusing the system... I know it is obviously a different topic, but it really isn't... its all about figuring out a better system and everyone speaking up and providing different points of views is what will provide us with solutions in the long run.

So thank you for speaking up! Chat Icon

Posted 10/14/10 11:36 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Posted by CookieMomster

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Janice

for me, yes...chosing not to try and bf-going straight to wic is abusing the system.



I'm saddened and offended by this....but this whole thing will become a typical LIF Parenting Post of judgement, over-analyzation, social commentary and plain old
BullSh!t,so I will leave it at that.

I am so amazed by you. You did what you needed to as a mother for your children, and I give you a round ofChat Icon for letting us share in what must have been a difficult time for you.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Thank you..but honestly...I'm no saint or not even not to blame for my situation...hell...I spent mad money in preparation for the twins that had I been more careful about or forseen a possible situation I would have avoided needing even the minimal help I did get....but I did need it regardless if I ill prepared for its possibility and I don't like the implications I have read that I'm wrong for it because I choose not to BF.....I made that choice even BEFORE I found myself needing any help anyway...

Posted 10/14/10 11:39 PM
 

DanandNette
Love my baby boy!

Member since 9/08

2830 total posts

Name:
Jennette

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

I hate these commercials. I had the hardest time bf'ing, struggled with it for 6 weeks, it totally broke my heart. These commercials remind of that feeling of being inadequate.

Posted 10/14/10 11:47 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C &hearts;'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...

Message edited 2010-10-15 06:53:51.930000.

Posted 10/15/10 12:00 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Breastfeeding question betty 9/7/05 5 Parenting
? for breastfeeding moms MrsBumbleb 9/6/05 10 Parenting
Questions about breastfeeding, and pumps... 05mommy09 8/21/05 7 Parenting
The Breastfeeding Protection Initiative KPtoys 8/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
Breastfeeding NK926 8/17/05 7 Parenting
Calling all breastfeeding moms Dani00518 7/25/05 7 Parenting