WIC breastfeeding commericial...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 | |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I think we also need to remember.. and I apologize if this point has already been made- I haven't read the whole thread.. that we all know that BF is HARD and not all companies support women who BF.. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:15 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Ophelia Posted by MarisaK I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead. If I couldn't afford that formula, I think my comfort and 'personal decision' would be trumped by the fact that my CHILD NEEDED TO EAT so I think the expectation that I suck it up and TRY is perfectly acceptable - If I COULDN"T do it for whatever reason, that's different. But taking gov't aid simply b/c I didn't 'feel like doing it' ??? - Um, no sorry, I don't agree with that. this is what I mean. I think brinaesq brought up some good posted about the effects of forcing it upon the mother in respect to how it would effec the child. it has softened by view i suppose b/c it makes me react emotionally, not fiscally. but I guess I feel like rather than just hand over a can of formula, an LC ccan sit down with the mom and at least try. if you try and fail, at that point fine. then that is a REASON (which we siad, without reason. with reason is reasonable) if this was about anything other than BF people would be so up in arms. I see MANY otherwise very conservative people being very liberal here and i can only surmise it's b/c they can relate in a way to this issue. I wonder though, if we started talking about illegal women getting wic. getting free formula for their babies...where would that conversation go (ftr, I think they should try to bf too) when you ask for assistance it cannot always be on your terms. it's not. there are rules and laws when you are on wic. on welfare. there are certain parameters that must be met. it's not about using the services if you are in need. there is NO SHAME in that whatsoever. i just feel the basic idea and message is being lost and instead people are being painted in the light that I think is pretty harsh and unfair. Ah thank you this is the point I've been trying to make all along. However BF is just one tiny issue in a giant sea of problems with how the gov't offers assistance to women in need as Goldi pointed out. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by nrthshgrl Wow. I was wondering what the controversy was over this commercial. Turns out it wasn't so much about the commercial. I wasn't on WIC, so while I'm not sure how the sytem works - I did breastfeed/pumped for 11 months and 5 months exclusively. That was while I worked ONE job. An office job. It was difficult to do. Meetings & conference calls needed to be scheduled around my ability to pump. A train ride home was painful if I didn't get to pump when I needed to do it. Breastfeeding takes WORK. A lot of work. I cannot fathom telling someone that they MUST do it in order to feed their baby when there are options availabe to people that aren't on WIC. People don't breastfeed for any number of reasons - some cannot physically do it, keep up with the demand, are uncomfortable with their bodies, their schedule doesn't permit it, uncomfortable with breastfeeding in public, they are on medication. I can't see faulting anyone for their decision. I'm a huge proponent of giving it a shot & if it doesn't work for you, than move on - only because you truly never know if you'll like it or want that & there is no going back. i think part of the issue is so many women don't even try And I'm taliking about women that could try but don't as in they aren't on any meds that would keep them from BF |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MrsA714 Posted by Goldi0218 Again I have to ask if anyone would want a woman who is limited financially and cannot afford healthy food for HERSELF much less her children to BF. I am sure many of the BFing mom's here make a concerted effort to eat as healthy as possible. A woman of limited funds cannot and often does not eat as well as those of us who can afford to do so in which case, BFing may NOT be he best option. Seriously? If all I could afford to eat was a can of Spaghettios, Id give my kid formula. I totally see what you're saying. However WIC does provide nutritional food for BFing mothers as well (and of course for children). From their website: The following benefits are provided to WIC participants: Supplemental nutritious foods Nutrition education and counseling at WIC clinics Screening and referrals to other health, welfare and social services Food, nutrition counseling, and access to health services are provided to low-income women, infants, and children under the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children, popularly known as WIC. WIC provides Federal grants to States for supplemental foods, health care referrals, and nutrition education for low-income pregnant, breastfeeding, and non-breastfeeding postpartum women, and to infants and children who are found to be at nutritional risk. ETA: this thread has obviously gone in a whole other direction but I do think WIC promoting BFing is a good thing. Nothing wrong with that. Maybe this specific commercial wasn't the best but I see nothing wrong with WIC making an effort to promote BFing. OK I stand corrected. But can you honestly tell me if a service is available or provided, that people are seriously taking advantage of it? MAYBE some are. But I am sure there are plenty who aren't. I would like to share another related scenario I witnessed years ago at work. A Social worker applied for a grant to pay a utility bill for a family who claimed that they could not afford to eat much less pay their bills. The same family had two dogs - a Rottweiler and a German Shepard. When I asked the student why he has such big dogs...the response was "To protect our stuff" - the stuff being all of his gaming systems, big screen TV, computer etc. Come on now. get rid of your toys, get rid of your dogs and feed your kids. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by CaMacho I didn't read through this whole thing (sorry), but I did go on youtube and found the commercials. I think they are simply trying to say... hey, you know if you breastfeed here are the possible positive effects. Some people need to see/hear about the physical benefits of things for them. Just like smoking. If you say, smoking turns your lungs black it doesn't have the same effect to some people as saying smoking gives you deep wrinkles. They can't see their lungs turning black or they choose not to believe it... but they can see the wrinkles. I have absolutely no experience with this... but we all know that there are people who have a baby and say, nah i'm not going to breastfeed b/c WIC will just pay for my baby's formula anyway. I think the previous posters were just trying to say that there should be something put in place to get those women to maybe just TRY to breastfeed before immediately relying on assistance. That's what I took from it anyway, sorry if i'm wrong. late to the game, completely agree with everything you posted |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:25 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by MrsA714 Posted by Goldi0218 Again I have to ask if anyone would want a woman who is limited financially and cannot afford healthy food for HERSELF much less her children to BF. I am sure many of the BFing mom's here make a concerted effort to eat as healthy as possible. A woman of limited funds cannot and often does not eat as well as those of us who can afford to do so in which case, BFing may NOT be he best option. Seriously? If all I could afford to eat was a can of Spaghettios, Id give my kid formula. I totally see what you're saying. However WIC does provide nutritional food for BFing mothers as well (and of course for children). From their website: The following benefits are provided to WIC participants: Supplemental nutritious foods Nutrition education and counseling at WIC clinics Screening and referrals to other health, welfare and social services Food, nutrition counseling, and access to health services are provided to low-income women, infants, and children under the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children, popularly known as WIC. WIC provides Federal grants to States for supplemental foods, health care referrals, and nutrition education for low-income pregnant, breastfeeding, and non-breastfeeding postpartum women, and to infants and children who are found to be at nutritional risk. ETA: this thread has obviously gone in a whole other direction but I do think WIC promoting BFing is a good thing. Nothing wrong with that. Maybe this specific commercial wasn't the best but I see nothing wrong with WIC making an effort to promote BFing. I also think that just becuase you can buy healthy foods on WIC doesn't mean you will eat them. I chose to not eat healthy- I'm just very bad when it comes to healthy eating. I prefer junk. In my case- FORMULA is best for my baby. I can't imagine the cr@p that would be in my breastmilk- judging by my diet! |
Posted 10/15/10 11:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... i just have to say i really don't get why people go so nuts over ff or bf. why is it anyone's business what you feed your kid as long as its a healthy option. my mom bf me for a week then switched to formula and i seemed to grow up fine. As for as the wic thing, i do think healthier options should be mandatory for the program (no soda, no cheesewiz type products, no sugar cereals, etc) but formula and breast milk shouldn't be on the table. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I've tried to stay out of this but since it's back on page 1, i'll add my $.02 |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Little-J-Mommy Did I battle the guilt of "giving up"? You bet I did!! Did this thread strike a chord with me to make me feel like a sh11ty mom for giving up? You bet it did deb, but that is just it. you can't "give up" unless you tried. you did bf your baby. then you stopped. you tried it out. But either way, you could afford the alternative. no one is saying anyone is a sh!tty mom. bf or ff. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice Posted by Little-J-Mommy Did I battle the guilt of "giving up"? You bet I did!! Did this thread strike a chord with me to make me feel like a sh11ty mom for giving up? You bet it did deb, but that is just it. you can't "give up" unless you tried. you did bf your baby. then you stopped. you tried it out. But either way, you could afford the alternative. no one is saying anyone is a sh!tty mom. bf or ff. But what if I couldn't afford it? What if I needed assistance? Would I have been forced to continue and make us all miserable because I didn't fall under an approved category? kwim? I do know that *you're* not calling me sh!tty, it's just that guilty conscience creeping back up
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... no, i think you tried it. it did not work. go on now to wic formula. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I formula fed both of my kids and I didn't even try to breastfeed them (I thought about it for a little longer with my second, that should count for something, right?). I have my reasons and they are not medical or anything else that some cited as exemptions. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice Posted by Little-J-Mommy Did I battle the guilt of "giving up"? You bet I did!! Did this thread strike a chord with me to make me feel like a sh11ty mom for giving up? You bet it did deb, but that is just it. you can't "give up" unless you tried. you did bf your baby. then you stopped. you tried it out. But either way, you could afford the alternative. no one is saying anyone is a sh!tty mom. bf or ff. But Janice, and I hope you can read my tone b/c I am not trying to be snarky at all, but what would constitute enought "Trying" then. I tried very hard to BF. DS never latched well, my breasts hurt so much I could not even dry them with a towel. And that was for almost 4 months. But I had support. And I was able to be on maternity leave. I can't imagine doing that if if I was in a bad situation anyway. A woman who needs help and does not want to BF could just walk in and say she "tried." She could even see a LC but unless you are sending her home with one for weeks (I saw one a number of times and though DS would usually latch there, we still had problems) how would you know? I just don't think BF is something you can FORCE someone to do. But denying a child formula isn't going to help anyone. I also agree with Goldi - I think there are definately women who really shouldn't be breastfeeding. They probably likely shouldn't have been pregnant either, but I don't think we can take away a persons right to have a baby - as much as that would seem a good idea sometimes. ETA - I do think that education on this is so important and I don;t really have a problem with the commercial itself - though it may be somewhat of false advertising if it gets some woman to consider BF more, I don't think that is all bad. Message edited 2010-10-15 12:00:41.003000. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... pam-that is it. just trying. an open mind to it. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... cranky-watch your back. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice pam-that is it. just trying. an open mind to it. that would be enough. I had 2 babies on weight management for weeks. It was a nightmare beyond belief. I am stuck. I have to nurse, I can't afford formula and I don't qualify for WIC. I CRIED in drs office with #2. A loud cry. I did not want to be in this position again to be forced to nurse. I am. forced to nurse. No one said anything about drs notes...just an open mind that WIC should be allowed to push for. I did not mean this at all to change WICs procedures...more like the mother's. Try it if you can't afford formula if you are capable. not a law. but before you use other resources, try this first. that is it. I would not want any mother who has financial stress to also stress latching, supply...just an open mind to trying it. This, exactly. I agree. I don't see the down side of educating peope on anything. ETA: I think it was Ophelia (sorry Jess!) who mentioned the note... Message edited 2010-10-15 12:12:20.397000. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by eddiesmommy I dont think a womens choice to BF or not, regardless of how she acquires formula if needed, should be based on her financial position. Her body, no one elses place to intervene. There are MANY MANY women who dont BF for reason other than lack of supply or whatever. Everyones experience with BFing is different and I would NEVER tell a women what she has to or does not have to do with her body. Her body and her childs health do not go hand in hand. If she chooses not the BF, that is HER choice. What I dont understand, why when BFing vs FF always comes up, the common response is "happy mom, happy baby", "you have to do what works for you" but if a mother is in a financially tough position the response by some of those same women is "tough, you cant afford to feed your family yourself, not my problem, you should have to BF if you can". Half of the responses here are operating under the assumption that most mothers are abusing the system, which is NOT the case. Most people on WIC are good, decent people who need a little help. Im so appalled at the lack of empathy for people in a tough spot. I hope none of us should never find yourself in a similar position. I bet that would humble a lot of the responders in this thread. I have never seen such hypocrisy in my life. A vast majority of this posts outright disgusts me. AGREED! And I bet about 40% of this board would qualify for WIC. The income guidelines are HIGH..It is not Food stamps. They dont give you free formula..They supplement it.... I hate that this thread got so heated. I think we all agree on a LOT of things, the most important ones. And I stay away from these threads for the most part cause its common knowledge of what it will turn into. BUT....Being referred to as ABUSING the system is pretty harsh and while I respect and try to learn and grow from others points of views, I hope some will learn as well from the opposite side of the coin.... What bothers me more then anything is the just horrible judgement of Mothers ...TOTAL lack of empathy. . |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice pam-that is it. just trying. an open mind to it. that would be enough. I had 2 babies on weight management for weeks. It was a nightmare beyond belief. I am stuck. I have to nurse, I can't afford formula and I don't qualify for WIC. I CRIED in drs office with #2. A loud cry. I did not want to be in this position again to be forced to nurse. I am. forced to nurse. No one said anything about drs notes...just an open mind that WIC should be allowed to push for. I did not mean this at all to change WICs procedures...more like the mother's. Try it if you can't afford formula if you are capable. not a law. but before you use other resources, try this first. that is it. I would not want any mother who has financial stress to also stress latching, supply...just an open mind to trying it. Your seriously changing your tune. Try it is a bit different from calling someone an abuser/fraud and implying they be denied. That is your opinion right? But you yourself are saying you cannot afford formula...have cried over it....HOW would you feel if any of us judged you on your choices made? I wouldnt DARE to....It is cruel.... |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... We speak from our experiences. I spoke from mine. I make no apologies. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice cranky-watch your back. Did you see my "however"???? educate educate educate
|
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... i gotta go, so this is my last post... |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by Janice i gotta go, so this is my last post... but of course i changed my tune. i had an opinion. bf before going to WIC. still is my opinion. i don't want to hurt anyone. I was not talking about anyone. i was saying if someone is pregnant and they are applying for wic, then they should try to nurse. of course if you can't nurse, don't. not talking about that person. if you can, try it. no laws, no being denied. it is an awful feeling not to be able to afford formula. it is the only feeling i know. both kids need dairy free and soy free. i can't swing it. i cried. i am trapped. insurance won't help. apria won't help. i am there. i am alllllll for social programs. healthcare, headstart...anything. i don't see the harm in trying out a resource before going to another. that is it. I wish you had said this first.. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... Posted by CarlieJLD7 I also agree 100% that if you can physically produce milk, and are not on meds and are fully capable of breastfeeding, then you should not be able to get WIC for formula... just becuase you don't want to breastfeed... It is 100% a personal decision, but you are not using your personal money, and you are using all of our taxpayers money b/c of your decision then that is unacceptable. I cannot DISAGREE more with this Formula is food for an infant, no different than providing table food for older infants and kids. Besides the fact that if you breastfeed you either have to have the baby attached to you to feed them every few hours or buy a breast pump which in turn would still come out of our tax dollars. I dont think anyone should be forced to BF just because someone like you thinks they should. Every woman should have the option to BF and do what is best for them. While there are tons of people who abuse the system, there are tons of people who NEED the system who have fallen on hard times. I think people should worry about our tax dollars being mispent elsewhere rather than on formula for babies. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... just fm'ed you. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial... I am REALLY late to this conversation. I think information and education about BF is great. However, all the information in the world means nothing without an adequate support system - which unfortunately, many people do not have. |
|
Posted 10/15/10 12:45 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breastfeeding question | betty | 9/7/05 | 5 | Parenting |
| ? for breastfeeding moms | MrsBumbleb | 9/6/05 | 10 | Parenting |
| Questions about breastfeeding, and pumps... | 05mommy09 | 8/21/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| The Breastfeeding Protection Initiative | KPtoys | 8/19/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Breastfeeding | NK926 | 8/17/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| Calling all breastfeeding moms | Dani00518 | 7/25/05 | 7 | Parenting |












