WHO PAYS?????
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by Wendy Posted by Linda1003 Posted by nov04libride Posted by Wendy Posted by Linda1003 My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown. I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill. ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer. Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers... Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends? No battle - you asked for opinions and I just happen to disagree with you. Both of my DH's parents are deceased. Should I insist his brothers chip in for the shower or else not invite anyone on his side of the family? I think asking the grandparents is different from asking DH's brothers, KWIM? Either way, everyone has an opinion about this....I happen to agree with OP, especially being in a similar situation It would be nice if for all baby showers, BOTH grandparents to be offered to help pay for some
|
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:02 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Just to clarify..my dh isn't going to call my MIL up and say "hey you...pay up or else". It will be done tackfully. So lets all stop thinking that we are bullying her into paying for the shower. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by brownie Posted by Wendy Posted by Linda1003 Posted by nov04libride Posted by Wendy Posted by Linda1003 My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown. I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill. ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer. Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers... Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends? No battle - you asked for opinions and I just happen to disagree with you. Both of my DH's parents are deceased. Should I insist his brothers chip in for the shower or else not invite anyone on his side of the family? I think asking the grandparents is different from asking DH's brothers, KWIM? Either way, everyone has an opinion about this....I happen to agree with OP, especially being in a similar situation It would be nice if for all baby showers, BOTH grandparents to be offered to help pay for some Thank you Brownie. Grandparents paying and siblings are very different. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by Linda1003 Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers... Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends? I think your mother in law SHOULD help pay, but no one has the right to tell her she has to pay. It is the same as a traditional wedding. Yes traditionally the brides family pays, but it is always nice when the grooms family offers to help pay. If they don't does that mean that their family and friends are not welcome to the wedding? My family has very little money, so like my wedding, I will probably pay for my own baby shower. I think a better way to approach your MIL would to be honest with her, and see her reaction before your sister says she has to do anything. There may be feelings of resent and you don't want that to take away from such a happy occasion. Try having your DH or even your sister approach her and say, "we want to throw Linda a wonderful shower, but we need some help financially." Give her the cost of the caterer and see what she offers. I feel this may be a bit more diplomatic. Good luck on however you decide to approach it. I know it will be a beautiful day for your and your baby!
|
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by katiebug Posted by Linda1003 Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers... Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends? I think your mother in law SHOULD help pay, but no one has the right to tell her she has to pay. It is the same as a traditional wedding. Yes traditionally the brides family pays, but it is always nice when the grooms family offers to help pay. If they don't does that mean that their family and friends are not welcome to the wedding? My family has very little money, so like my wedding, I will probably pay for my own baby shower. I think a better way to approach your MIL would to be honest with her, and see her reaction before your sister says she has to do anything. There may be feelings of resent and you don't want that to take away from such a happy occasion. Try having your DH or even your sister approach her and say, "we want to throw Linda a wonderful shower, but we need some help financially." Give her the cost of the caterer and see what she offers. I feel this may be a bit more diplomatic. Good luck on however you decide to approach it. I know it will be a beautiful day for your and your baby! see my above post: Just to clarify..my dh isn't going to call my MIL up and say "hey you...pay up or else". It will be done tackfully. So lets all stop thinking that we are bullying her into paying for the shower. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by Linda1003 see my above post: Just to clarify..my dh isn't going to call my MIL up and say "hey you...pay up or else". It will be done tackfully. So lets all stop thinking that we are bullying her into paying for the shower. Ah.... I posted while you were posting. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? I say have your sister call MIL and ask her if she'd like to contribute to her grandchilds shower. That's what my Mom plans on doing. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Thanks for everyone's advise. i do really appreciate everyone's point of view. Just really surprised that people would think we would approach my MIL like that. Maybe the way I put it sounded that way but I just typed it quickly. Of course dh isn't going to FORCE her to pay but advise her that it's the right thing to do. Message edited 2009-05-18 15:26:00.250000. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by Linda1003 Thanks for everyone's advise. i do really appreciate everyone's point of view. Just really surprised that people would think we would approach my MIL like that. Maybe the way I put it sounded that way but I just typed it quickly. Of course dh isn't going to FORCE her to pay but advise her that it's the right thing to do. I have offered to pay but my sister refuses to take money from me in any way. I have come to realize that my opinion on the matter is that the grandparents should pay for the shower.( In the absense of any grandparents then the family decides for themselves what's best) If my MIL wants to invite the world (which she does) then she should chip in for the catering at the very least. Again thanks for everyones thoughts. I see your point--I do--but I think maybe it's kinder to ask her to make food, and then if she says no, she'd rather give money, then that's up to her. My MIL brought the fruit salad to my shower, which everyone loved. I think giving someone the option of buying or doing/making something is nice. Maybe the most tactful way of asking her is to give her the option of making or supplying the food herself, KWIM? Or assign her a category--have DH ask her to get the cake or apps or something. Honestly, I bought lots of the stuff for my shower--I have a Costco membership and my mom didn't--and I wouldn't let my mom pay me for it. She's single and I don't want her to feel financially pressured to do this for me. Message edited 2009-05-18 15:36:45.877000. |
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: WHO PAYS????? Posted by DPerotti I say have your sister call MIL and ask her if she'd like to contribute to her grandchilds shower. That's what my Mom plans on doing. For my sisters shower, my mom & I made all of the "tea sandwhiches" (cucumber, turkey & cheese, ham & cheese, tuna, egg salad) & salads,made the cupcake tower (with help from her MIL and SIL). So if you sister has to foot the bill, tell her to keep it easy with little sandwhiches and light salads. OR she can ask your MIL if she could make two dishes & be in charge of the champagne punch ya know..etc..etc.. this way you aren't asking her to put on a certain amount of money and maybe your MIL will want to help since this is for her grandchild. I would love this and you are right. To me... I woudln't care if we ordered Pizza for the shower. I already told my siter no favors..just lilipops or something. we are def trying to keep it very inexpensive! We are having it at my house..no favors. Food is the important thing..since my sister has three little kids and MIL doesn't cook making food woudl be way too much trouble. So we def have to cater. I told my sister that we would do something but no hot food b/c that just always costs a bundle of money.
|
|
Posted 5/18/09 3:35 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| It pays to be friends with your neighbors... literally! | greenfreak | 9/5/08 | 3 | Home |
| teaching kids to "try it" pays off... at least, this time | MarathonKnitter | 5/13/08 | 1 | Parenting |
| I am looking for a job that goes from afternoon until evening that pays well..any ideas? | BigB | 12/4/07 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Who pays for disability?? Your job or the state? | JustBrowsin | 9/25/07 | 2 | Pregnancy |
| It pays to be nice! | QuoteTheRaven424 | 2/12/06 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Minor league red sox affillate pays little league teams to change their name from the Yankees | VirginiaDeb | 2/10/06 | 0 | Sports |






