WHO PAYS?????

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

WHO PAYS?????

My mother passed away 5 years ago so who would you say pays for the baby shower. I have a sister who basically paid for my bridal shower with my brides maids.
Is it fair that my sister has to take on the baby shower as well?. My mother in law didn't chip in for my sister in laws baby shower. Chat Icon
I kind of feel like it's my MIL's grandchild..not my sisters so she should chip in for the baby shower with my sister. However its' going to be difficult to convince her of that when no one asked her to chip in for my SIL!!!

Just feel so bad for my sister in this situation!!Chat Icon

What are your thoughts??

Posted 5/18/09 10:42 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Can you guys chip in? I don't want my sisters and mother to have to foot the bill for the shower so DH and I will take care of most of it.

Posted 5/18/09 10:44 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Considering the circumstances, I would think your MIL would offer. Kind of to fill the void of your mom (though, I know that can never really be).

If I were you, I would not say anything BUT I would have DH talk to her and connect her with your sister.

Posted 5/18/09 10:45 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: WHO PAYS?????

I thought of that and told my sister I woudl chip in and she refused to let me.

Posted 5/18/09 10:45 AM
 

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by Linda1003

My mother passed away 5 years ago so who would you say pays for the baby shower. I have a sister who basically paid for my bridal shower with my brides maids.
Is it fair that my sister has to take on the baby shower as well?. My mother in law didn't chip in for my sister in laws baby shower. Chat Icon
I kind of feel like it's my MIL's grandchild..not my sisters so she should chip in for the baby shower with my sister. However its' going to be difficult to convince her of that when no one asked her to chip in for my SIL!!!

Just feel so bad for my sister in this situation!!Chat Icon

What are your thoughts??



I am in the same situation, but MIL also passed away. I have no sisters, and just got married in Nov. So SIL and friends paid for bridal shower. I don't even want tot have one, I get so stressed over this. Maybe dad can pay? LOL

Message edited 2009-05-18 10:46:58.330000.

Posted 5/18/09 10:46 AM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

My dad threw or shall I say he paid for and my SIL's planned the whole thing.

Is that an option?

Posted 5/18/09 10:55 AM
 

jennarose023
Jack's gonna be a big brother!

Member since 11/08

7769 total posts

Name:
<font color=green><b>Jenna</b></font color=green>

Re: WHO PAYS?????

maybe your DH can talk to his mom and ask her to help your sister out?

Posted 5/18/09 10:56 AM
 

anewday
<3

Member since 9/08

1493 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: WHO PAYS?????

I would ask dh or sister to call your MIL and ask her what she would like to do (kind of putting her on the spot in a nice way) if she can't or doesn't want to be involved with the shower then Chat Icon for you & dh...I would chip in myself & if my sister didnt want me to I would just agree to make it on a small scale (in home).

Me and my mother through my SIL's shower if it was up to her mother she wouldnt have had one! We did it in the house and everyone made food (I think it was one of the nicest showers!)

Posted 5/18/09 10:56 AM
 

FLaCaTaCa
Kelsey Elyse = Love

Member since 5/05

1855 total posts

Name:
Stacy

Re: WHO PAYS?????

In your situation, I would hope that your MIL offered to help.

DH and I live far from home so we are traveling to one baby shower and paying to get ourselves there and throwing our own here. I have no regrets about throwing our own baby shower except that everyone is telling me what I should and shouldn't do and I am not having it! I am actually having a blast and we have stayed really low under budget thus far.

Posted 5/18/09 11:01 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by anewday

I would chip in myself & if my sister didnt want me to I would just agree to make it on a small scale (in home).

Me and my mother through my SIL's shower if it was up to her mother she wouldnt have had one! We did it in the house and everyone made food (I think it was one of the nicest showers!)



ITA--I would have an in-home shower and have pot luck with food made by you and your sisters! Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 11:02 AM
 

DanandNette
Love my baby boy!

Member since 9/08

2830 total posts

Name:
Jennette

Re: WHO PAYS?????

If it isn't awkward I would see if DH could maybe talk to his mom and maybe he can work something out with her and they can split it. That was really sweet of your sister to take care of your bridal shower. If she wants to chip in again that is totally sweet but I wouldn't put that on her again.

Posted 5/18/09 11:34 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: WHO PAYS?????

My MIL and my mom are splitting it. I think its fair ifyour mIL footed some of it or contributed in some way, then maybe you and your sister contributing towards the rest?

Posted 5/18/09 11:36 AM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: WHO PAYS?????

I agree with having DH talk to his Mom...from there, I would say do an at home thing.
My mother is extremely ill right now and my sister is due a few days after me, so my other sister is pretty much doing everything for the shower (joint) by herself. So, we are doing a house shower so it's less expensive.

Posted 5/18/09 11:40 AM
 

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

My mother passed away 5 years ago too. Chat Icon
It stinks not having a mom around to enjoy all this baby excitement.


Anyway, my sister is planning it, I suspect my dad will be paying. But really I am not sure. My girlfriends did offer to help my sister out.


I think your DH should approach the topic with your MIL. But like you said, she didnt pay for her daughter's shower.


If my father wasn't paying, I wouldn't want my sister to foot that bill.
I would probably insist it be at my house & have bbq, keep it cheap and casual. Those are the best parties IMO








Message edited 2009-05-18 11:51:28.440000.

Posted 5/18/09 11:48 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by sleepie76

My mother passed away 5 years ago too. Chat Icon
It stinks not having a mom around to enjoy all this baby excitement.


Anyway, my sister is planning it, I suspect my dad will be paying. But really I am not sure. My girlfriends did offer to help my sister out.


I think your DH should approach the topic with your MIL. But like you said, she didnt pay for her daughter's shower.


If my father wasn't paying, I wouldn't want my sister to foot that bill.
I would probably insist it be at my house & have bbq, keep it cheap and casual. Those are the best parties IMO











Sorry for your loss too!! Yeah it's difficult to go threw all of these happy events with out her!!Chat Icon

Oh it wasn't her daughters' that my MIL didn't chip in.. it was her daughter in laws that she didn't chip in for. So that's why I don't think she thinks she needs to chip in for mine..KWIM?

I will def have DH talk to MIL. We;ll see what happens.

We def planned on having it at the house for $$ reasons..keep the cost down. thanks everyone for your advise!!Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 12:12 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by DanandNette

If it isn't awkward I would see if DH could maybe talk to his mom and maybe he can work something out with her and they can split it. That was really sweet of your sister to take care of your bridal shower. If she wants to chip in again that is totally sweet but I wouldn't put that on her again.




Ditto. I would hope MIL offers (but knowing mine, ya never know)

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 1:02 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by brownie

Posted by DanandNette

If it isn't awkward I would see if DH could maybe talk to his mom and maybe he can work something out with her and they can split it. That was really sweet of your sister to take care of your bridal shower. If she wants to chip in again that is totally sweet but I wouldn't put that on her again.




Ditto. I would hope MIL offers (but knowing mine, ya never know)

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I def know she woulen't offer. I just dont think she knows any beter.

I spoke with dh an my sister...DH asked my sister what he should tell his mom. My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 1:15 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Good!

My MIL (I could imagine not putting 2 + 2 together) is clueless too

Luckily it sounds like you have a great sister Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 1:20 PM
 

vmac
Mommy VMac

Member since 8/07

1860 total posts

Name:
Vanessa

Re: WHO PAYS?????

I am sorry your Mom isn't here for your shower! Chat Icon

I hope your MIL would step in here. My MIL and my mom are planning mine together. It's both their grandchild, and they are both inviting people so it just seems appropriate that both sides help.

Posted 5/18/09 1:22 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: WHO PAYS?????

My mother passed away 5 years ago as well (3 years prior to DS's birth) my shower was paid for by my Dad and MIL. My dad wanted to pay for it all but my MIL insisted on splitting it.

My brother and MIL planned it.

In your case maybe talk to you MIL about how you dont know how to handle the shower....

Also maybe you can do a small shower at your house or a family members house and even offer to pay for it yourself if you dont think you MIL will help at all....

Posted 5/18/09 1:27 PM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.

Posted 5/18/09 2:16 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by Wendy

Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.



ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer.

Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers...

Posted 5/18/09 2:35 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by Wendy

Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.



ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer.

Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers...


Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends?

Posted 5/18/09 2:55 PM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by Wendy

Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.



ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer.

Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers...


Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends?



No battle - you asked for opinions and I just happen to disagree with you. Both of my DH's parents are deceased. Should I insist his brothers chip in for the shower or else not invite anyone on his side of the family?

Posted 5/18/09 2:59 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WHO PAYS?????

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by Wendy

Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.



ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer.

Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers...


Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends?



I agree with you, I know everyone has their own opinion about this...this kinda happened with me...MIL didn't offer to pay for anything, and we're having it at my mom's house, and my mom had to limit the number of people MIL could invite...I mean, if she's not going to contribute anything, I don't think she should have free reign of who to invite....it would be a HECK of a lot easier if MIL just did (what I think is) the "right thing" and offered to pay for some...I mean its her grandchild too

Maybe your sister could call her and ask her if she is planning to help at all..so not telling her, but kind of asking, "hey are you helping or not?" kinda thing....

Sorry you have to deal with this...I wish all showers could be drama free Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/09 3:00 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
It pays to be friends with your neighbors... literally! greenfreak 9/5/08 3 Home
teaching kids to "try it" pays off... at least, this time MarathonKnitter 5/13/08 1 Parenting
I am looking for a job that goes from afternoon until evening that pays well..any ideas? BigB 12/4/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
Who pays for disability?? Your job or the state? JustBrowsin 9/25/07 2 Pregnancy
It pays to be nice! QuoteTheRaven424 2/12/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
Minor league red sox affillate pays little league teams to change their name from the Yankees VirginiaDeb 2/10/06 0 Sports