Re: WHO PAYS?????
Posted 5/18/2009 3:03:51 PM by Linda1003


Posted by brownie


Posted by Wendy


Posted by Linda1003


Posted by nov04libride


Posted by Wendy


Posted by Linda1003
My sister said if we have it at the house she needs to pay 1/2 of the catering. Chat Icon



I guess I'm in the minority but I don't think you have the right to tell someone they HAVE to contribute to a party YOU want thrown.

I don't disagree that it would be nice/the right thing to do for your MIL to OFFER but if she doesn't, IMO you & your DH should foot the bill.



ITA. I would never tell someone that she NEEDS to pay for half of it...I would definitely pay for it myself before forcing someone to pay who didn't offer.

Can you and your sister make the food? I had a catered shower at my aunt's 2 weekends ago, and it was great, and very affordable--we did wraps and no hot food, but tons of appetizers...


Im not looking to battle this out but a shower is thrown for the baby. The grandparents should throw the shower. i offered to pay with my sister and she refused saying it's not my responsibility to pay for my own shower. MIL invites her family and friends too so why is it our responsibility to pay for her family and friends!! if that's the case, should we leave out MIL's family and friends?



No battle - you asked for opinions and I just happen to disagree with you. Both of my DH's parents are deceased. Should I insist his brothers chip in for the shower or else not invite anyone on his side of the family?



I think asking the grandparents is different from asking DH's brothers, KWIM?

Either way, everyone has an opinion about this....I happen to agree with OP, especially being in a similar situation

It would be nice if for all baby showers, BOTH grandparents to be offered to help pay for some Chat Icon



Thank you Brownie. Grandparents paying and siblings are very different.
Print Post      Close Window