Thoughts on this?

Posted By Message
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5]

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Kidsaplenty
Maybe if she had a BFinhg doll when she was a kid she wouldnt have such an intense negative response to breastfeeding Chat Icon



You make your choices in what you allow and deem appropriate for your children, and I make my choices in what I allow and find appropriate for mine. You were raised one way and I was raised another way. I was speaking for myself and what I thought of the doll. You may not agree but that doesnt mean your opinion is right vs mine being wrong. At least half (if not most) of people on this thread found this doll inappropriate. Funny how you only replied to me??

After all, I simply responded to the topic of this thread, opinions on this doll.




I replied only to you because on nearly any breastfeeding thread anywhere you appear, claiming you don't hate breastfeeding when every post from you just screams that you do. For as long as I can remember you have posted negative things about breastfeeding and honestly it irks me. A lot. We all get it, you don't like breastfeeding, it's not for you. But when you have a penchant for posting on all nursing topics anywhere, it annoys the ever loving crap out of me. I equate it to if a vegetarian posted on every.single.recipe. on the dining in and out board about how much eating meat is not for them and blah blah blah. Enough. And I'm sure I'm not the only person who feels that way about you BFIng posts.

Posted 1/31/13 10:50 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Kidsaplenty

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Kidsaplenty
Maybe if she had a BFinhg doll when she was a kid she wouldnt have such an intense negative response to breastfeeding Chat Icon



You make your choices in what you allow and deem appropriate for your children, and I make my choices in what I allow and find appropriate for mine. You were raised one way and I was raised another way. I was speaking for myself and what I thought of the doll. You may not agree but that doesnt mean your opinion is right vs mine being wrong. At least half (if not most) of people on this thread found this doll inappropriate. Funny how you only replied to me??

After all, I simply responded to the topic of this thread, opinions on this doll.




I replied only to you because on nearly any breastfeeding thread anywhere you appear, claiming you don't hate breastfeeding when every post from you just screams that you do. For as long as I can remember you have posted negative things about breastfeeding and honestly it irks me. A lot. We all get it, you don't like breastfeeding, it's not for you. But when you have a penchant for posting on all nursing topics anywhere, it annoys the ever loving crap out of me. I equate it to if a vegetarian posted on every.single.recipe. on the dining in and out board about how much eating meat is not for them and blah blah blah. Enough. And I'm sure I'm not the only person who feels that way about you BFIng posts.



Excuse me? Who do you think you are seriously?

I don't care one bit if my posts annoy you or anyone else. I know for a fact yours annoy the crap out of many of US as well. It's not YOUR job to police MY breastfeeding responses. Did you read the whole thread even? I make my FIRST replies today on page FOUR, day 2 of the thread, not quoting anyone other than someone I agreed with, but YOU want to bully me b/c my posts annoy you? Learn how to control yourself. You really have alot of nerve.Chat Icon It's a MESSAGE board, where this OP asked what we THOUGHT. There is NO rule that states if you have ever stated your opinion on another thread you must not post again. Therefore, I am entitled to reply to ANY thread that I have an opinion on, whether it be 5 threads or 50 threads on the same topic.

I guess you're going to have to learn to ignore my BF posts b/c I won't be bullied by you and I will continue to post responses to ANY thread I wish. Chat Icon 5th or 50th time. Not your job to monitor how often I share my opinion on something, especially when the OP is ASKING for opinions.

Message edited 2014-02-14 20:13:25.613000.

Posted 1/31/13 11:14 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by MandJZ

Nope. Just, no.



Same. But I never had a desire to breastfeed at all in my entire life so I can't see wanting my daughter to pretend to do it.
I can see feeling differently if I was comfortable with BFing myself



See, I DO want to breastfeed. Very badly. BUT, my main issues with this (just my gut thoughts) are that a) I don't want to push any one way on my child - I don't want her thinking there is a best way to do something and then feeling badly if later in life she can't. b) I just think we push kids into adulthood too soon. I know girls play house and pretend to be Mommy, but this is just TOO blatant to me and also seems like it may devalue the experience of nursing a bit. For this same reason I don't think I'll encourage those dolls that have diapers/pee or poop/etc.



Not to say that I like this doll but, doesn't a doll with a bottle also push bottle feeding as the right thing to do?

ETA: Honestly, the doll is a gimic. I wouldn't buy it because it's a waste of money. I don't think the flower/nipples are needed. If I had a DD she could pretend to nurse just as well with any babydoll. It's just an extra thing to toss money at.

Message edited 2013-02-01 06:51:29.953000.

Posted 2/1/13 6:39 AM
 

MRsFaTThead
NY GIRL IN TEXAS

Member since 6/10

5483 total posts

Name:
WHO GIVES A POO WHO GIVES A FUDGE !!

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by computergirl

I don't see a problem with it. Let's face it, the only people who are going to be buying this doll are ardently pro-breastfeeding mamas, so they probably grew up watching little siblings nurse and this is hardly exposing them to anything they don't already know about.

Women who are skeeved by breastfeeding would never buy this doll, so motherhood and breastfeeding aren't being "forced" on any little girls.

In terms of forcing young girls to grow up, I would worry more about the trashy clothing marketed to 5 yr olds Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/1/13 8:00 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by MandJZ

Nope. Just, no.



Same. But I never had a desire to breastfeed at all in my entire life so I can't see wanting my daughter to pretend to do it.
I can see feeling differently if I was comfortable with BFing myself



See, I DO want to breastfeed. Very badly. BUT, my main issues with this (just my gut thoughts) are that a) I don't want to push any one way on my child - I don't want her thinking there is a best way to do something and then feeling badly if later in life she can't. b) I just think we push kids into adulthood too soon. I know girls play house and pretend to be Mommy, but this is just TOO blatant to me and also seems like it may devalue the experience of nursing a bit. For this same reason I don't think I'll encourage those dolls that have diapers/pee or poop/etc.



Not to say that I like this doll but, doesn't a doll with a bottle also push bottle feeding as the right thing to do?

ETA: Honestly, the doll is a gimic. I wouldn't buy it because it's a waste of money. I don't think the flower/nipples are needed. If I had a DD she could pretend to nurse just as well with any babydoll. It's just an extra thing to toss money at.



I see your point but honestly I would rather my child have a generic doll that she can then pretend to feed both ways if she decides to. I just don't feel comfortable with a 'breastfeeding' doll OR a 'bottle' doll. I also don't love the peeing/pooping dolls. When I was little I had regular dolls and I used my imagination to come up with ways to play with them. This is the type of play I hope to promote in my own home.

Posted 2/1/13 8:12 AM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think the little flowers to represent breasts on a little girl are a little weird, and make me uncomfortable, but I would have no problem with my DD pretending to BF a regular old baby doll. I formula feed, but originally wanted to BF, and I think it is totally natural for a little girl to pretend to feed that way if that is what she is exposed to (and who knows...maybe I'll end up BFing my next child, and she'll see that). I had a Baby Alive as a child, but I kind of dislike those dolls now, and would rather see my DD use her imagination to play with her baby dolls, pretend to give them food, change diapers etc.

Posted 2/1/13 8:31 AM
 

Annie91606
Brotherly love

Member since 12/07

1816 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Thoughts on this?

The doll creeps me out. I feel that nursing is for grown women, and the idea of a little girl pulling up her shirt to breast feed doesn't sit right with me.

Posted 2/1/13 11:04 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Thoughts on this?

I would have no issue with my DD pretending to breastfeed a regular old babydoll. I would find it odd if she did because she and her baby sister were bottle fed, but I wouldn't care. I would never buy a doll for that purpose, but i'd never buy a doll just because it came with a bottle, either.

I find the bib with the 'pasties' very disturbing, though.

Posted 2/1/13 11:28 AM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think it's strange and I breast fed. There are lots of functions that an adult woman would do but you don't need a young child needs to play with a doll that mimics it.

Posted 2/1/13 3:45 PM
 

MrsPenthouse
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

924 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this?

I'm all for anything that normalizes breastfeeding.

That being said, you can pretend to nurse your dolls...this is reaching and I doubt it will sell well.

Posted 2/1/13 4:10 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Thoughts on this?

I EBF both of my DC's and would encourage my DD to EBF one day. THAT SAID - I do find this doll to be inappropriate. The fact of the matter is that our society sexualizes female breasts and long before they become a means to feed her child they will be sexual. So while I agree that there is nothing sexual about a mother BF her child and agree that it is natural unfortunately that is not the focus of a woman's breasts in society. At this age I feel it is inappropriate to draw attention to this aspect of a child's body and teach a little girl something that is not age appropriate and, frankly, could be confusing to them. IMO a little girl imitating her mother feeding a baby by holding a doll up to her chest - on her OWN imitating what she has seen and probably doesn't fully understand - is entirely different than buying my DD a doll and drawing attention to her breasts by affixing them with flower pasties and having a sucking doll pressed against them.

Message edited 2013-02-01 16:16:22.310000.

Posted 2/1/13 4:15 PM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Thoughts on this?

What's next? A My First Period Doll

Posted 2/1/13 9:11 PM
 

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by mrsboss

What's next? A My First Period Doll




Omg...this really had me LOL Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/1/13 9:35 PM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by OffWithHerHead23

My DDs used to preted to breastfeed their baby dolls all the time. I see no probelm with it. It's what my daughters are used to... to them, seeing a baby with a bottle is weirder.


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/2/13 11:44 AM
 

JMG2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/12

401 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by BklynBabe12

This is disturbing. Let children be children!



This! Exactly this! Teach them to ride a bike, not breastfeed.

ETA: If I had a daughter and saw she was pretending to breastfeed her doll. I would not in anyway tell her no and think she was doing something wrong, but it's not something I would introduce to her. If she had questions then I would be more happy to answer them for her but I don't think I would need a breastfeeding doll to explain it to her.

Message edited 2013-02-02 12:28:04.710000.

Posted 2/2/13 12:25 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Thoughts on this?

No one is going to buy this doll anyway, so I don't really even understand why it is up for debate. I don't really see anything wrong with it, but at the same time I would not buy it. My kids can use a regular doll to pretend to breastfeed, I don't need to spend any money on this product which I am sure is way overpriced.
I would place some lofty bets you won't see this on the shelves of Toys R Us anytime soon.

Posted 2/2/13 1:20 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Thoughts on this?

Also, I'm not really sure why so many people are posting it is innappropriate because a girl playing with it would be lifting up her shirt.

Actually, the little apron thing keeps a kid from lifting up her shirt, which a girl who is imitating her mom breastfeeding might do.

External Image

Posted 2/2/13 1:24 PM
 

TyReseGreen
Lil Prince is here

Member since 8/11

6338 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by BklynBabe12

This is disturbing. Let children be children!



Agree

Posted 2/2/13 3:00 PM
 

MrsDiamondgrlie
Bailey

Member since 5/05

12810 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Thoughts on this?

That is kind of weird unless the kid playing with the doll has a mom who is currently BFing and the kid wants to pretend they are too. When I was 4, my mom had my sister and my mom BF'ed and I did the same thing with my doll, it just wasnt a specialized doll to do it.

Posted 2/3/13 9:39 AM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Xelindrya

No thank you. Just seems so wrong to me.

Besides... being a mom doesnt mean breastfeeding. Why set her up for catastrophic disappointment if she can't BF later? I think we pressure women enough as it is right now - why do we have to start with our children? It still burns me all those questions and looks that first year "you dont breast feed? Why not?" My tits, my baby, my business. Not even a doctor should have a right to tell me I need to BF.

Honestly I find this disturbing

However, I'd love to see the reactions when boys use it too. Afterall I know plenty boys who feed baby dolls with pretend milk bottles. Lets strap this on a boy and let the mayhem begin.


I completely agree with this. I just don't find it necessary to keep "pushing bf" on woman. It's not for everyone, end of story. I too find it disturbing.

And just for the record- I did BF!!!!!

Message edited 2013-02-03 13:46:43.777000.

Posted 2/3/13 1:24 PM
 
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Please keep my baby boy in your thoughts and prayers..... preciouslove 12/19/05 73 Pregnancy
I never do this but I really really need your good thoughts today... UPDATE 10/7 Leeners 10/6/05 54 Families Helping Families ™
what are your thoughts.. re: World trade center? 04bride 10/4/05 42 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!!!Please cross your fingers and wish happy thoughts to Juliette for Monday!!! UPDATED!!! aliasPook 9/10/05 14 Parenting
VMA's!!!! Without further adieu, I would like to share DH's thoughts on the pre-show..... kathleeng 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
So Debg....What thoughts are running through your head right now? btrflygrl 8/19/05 12 Families Helping Families ™