Re: Thoughts on this?
Posted 2/1/2013 8:12:05 AM by MandJZ


Posted by sfp0701


Posted by MandJZ


Posted by NervousNell


Posted by MandJZ

Nope. Just, no.



Same. But I never had a desire to breastfeed at all in my entire life so I can't see wanting my daughter to pretend to do it.
I can see feeling differently if I was comfortable with BFing myself



See, I DO want to breastfeed. Very badly. BUT, my main issues with this (just my gut thoughts) are that a) I don't want to push any one way on my child - I don't want her thinking there is a best way to do something and then feeling badly if later in life she can't. b) I just think we push kids into adulthood too soon. I know girls play house and pretend to be Mommy, but this is just TOO blatant to me and also seems like it may devalue the experience of nursing a bit. For this same reason I don't think I'll encourage those dolls that have diapers/pee or poop/etc.



Not to say that I like this doll but, doesn't a doll with a bottle also push bottle feeding as the right thing to do?

ETA: Honestly, the doll is a gimic. I wouldn't buy it because it's a waste of money. I don't think the flower/nipples are needed. If I had a DD she could pretend to nurse just as well with any babydoll. It's just an extra thing to toss money at.



I see your point but honestly I would rather my child have a generic doll that she can then pretend to feed both ways if she decides to. I just don't feel comfortable with a 'breastfeeding' doll OR a 'bottle' doll. I also don't love the peeing/pooping dolls. When I was little I had regular dolls and I used my imagination to come up with ways to play with them. This is the type of play I hope to promote in my own home.
Print Post      Close Window