Thoughts on this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think it's stupid and I wouldn't buy a doll that pees or poops, either. If my kid wants to pretend play with the doll, they can pretend that all those things happen.

I also think this was probably invented by a man who is now sitting around watching women fight about it. Chat Icon

Posted 1/31/13 12:42 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Thoughts on this?

I hope each doll comes with its own lactation consultant! 99.9% of 7 year old moms have trouble producing according to the AAP! Chat Icon

(i am just making a lighthearted joke, not trying to be snarky)

Posted 1/31/13 1:17 PM
 

summertime
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/10

852 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think it is over the top, personally. I wouldnt buy it.

Posted 1/31/13 1:45 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Thoughts on this?

I wouldn't buy it but it doesn't bother me

Posted 1/31/13 3:48 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by JAAMS

Posted by Kitten1929

How anyone could say such negative things about a perfectly healthy bodily function is beyond me, and it begs the conversation about how people feel about breasts and their function in general. No one is sexualizing breasts at all, it's absurd to think that.



I said I think it's inappropriate, so I'm thinking that probably falls into the category of negative things.

I think it's inappropriate because it draws attention to a young girl's breasts, and, no matter which way you look at it, breastfeeding is not a bodily function of a preschooler.



EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Very true, however, IMHO, the doll de-sexualizes the breasts by showing what that are for.

Posted 1/31/13 4:49 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by maybebaby

EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.

Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.

Posted 1/31/13 4:55 PM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Kitten1929

I have no problem with breastfeeding. I don't think a child needs to have a breastfeeding doll...She'll learn about it at the appropriate age, no need to rush it.



Ditto!!

Posted 1/31/13 4:57 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Goobster

Posted by maybebaby

EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.

Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.



I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?

Posted 1/31/13 6:22 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by SweetTooth

I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?



Duh.I don't hate breastfeeding. What would I do if my DD pretended? I would address it as such. I would tell her little girls cannot feed babies like that. And when she is woman with a child, that is something she can do if she wants. But it's not for her to do now. She is a little girl. I would not foster the behavior. I would find it odd personally. So that's what I would say. I wouldn't make a big deal of it but I wouldn't encourage it or pat her on the back. I find it odd for a little girl to pretend she has breasts that can feed a baby.

Why can you teach a child what breasts are for (when they cannot breastfeed or wont be breastfeeding), yet find it odd to correlate also having a doll that would teach about intercourse? Many young children know how babies are made to some extent (I think I learned in school, around age 8. I recall being in 3rd grade). So one act makes a baby, totally "natural", and another act feeds that baby that was made from "intercourse". Both are natural. NEITHER are disgusting. But NEITHER are for children. Breastfeeding is for WOMEN with breasts, not for children.

Message edited 2013-01-31 19:55:40.887000.

Posted 1/31/13 6:47 PM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by Goobster

Posted by maybebaby

EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.

Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.



I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?



I agree, I can't believe you would make that comparison. I would never have sex in front of my kids, but my DS has seen me breastfeed my DD. I really can't get over how people feel about breastfeeding, people are making it out to be a sexual thing between mother and child, which is just obscene, it's an incredibly special bond!

Posted 1/31/13 6:47 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by mrspalomino148

I agree, I can't believe you would make that comparison. I would never have sex in front of my kids, but my DS has seen me breastfeed my DD. I really can't get over how people feel about breastfeeding, people are making it out to be a sexual thing between mother and child, which is just obscene, it's an incredibly special bond!



Dont see what the big deal is. Sex is natural. But it's private. Breastfeeding is natural. But not for children since they cannot breastfeed until they are adults.

I know one is about "nutrition". But to take it to the next extreme and have young girls have a doll to simulate, that has crossed the line, since young girls DO NOT HAVE breasts.

Breastfeeding isn't gross or unnatural. So why is sex now? Right, b/c there is a time for children to learn these things (how babies are made). And kids can't breastfeed until adult age. So why not keep it off the table as a child's toy? That's my point. Some things are off limits as children's toys (hence my sarcastic point above about Barbie and Ken) and a child pretending to tie on a top with pasties for breasts (that they dont even have) crosses that line.

JMO. That's the way I see it.

Message edited 2013-01-31 21:34:53.013000.

Posted 1/31/13 6:49 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by mrspalomino148

I agree, I can't believe you would make that comparison. I would never have sex in front of my kids, but my DS has seen me breastfeed my DD. I really can't get over how people feel about breastfeeding, people are making it out to be a sexual thing between mother and child, which is just obscene, it's an incredibly special bond!



And I wasn't implying AT ALL that breastfeeding is sexual. I was making the point that if breastfeeding is natural, so is sexual intercourse to make a baby (which children do learn about at some point whether in school, home or elsewhere). BOTH things ONLY adults (should) do. It's the point about it being for adults, not for children, sexual or not in nature.

Message edited 2013-01-31 18:58:28.023000.

Posted 1/31/13 6:55 PM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Goobster

Posted by mrspalomino148

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by Goobster

Posted by maybebaby

EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.

Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.



I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?



I agree, I can't believe you would make that comparison. I would never have sex in front of my kids, but my DS has seen me breastfeed my DD. I really can't get over how people feel about breastfeeding, people are making it out to be a sexual thing between mother and child, which is just obscene, it's an incredibly special bond!



Dont see what the big deal is. Sex is natural. But it's private. Breastfeeding is natural. But not for children since they cannot breastfeed until they are adults.

I know one is about "nutrition". But to take it to the next extreme and have young girls have a doll to simulate, that has crossed the line, since young girls DO NOT HAVE breasts.

Breastfeeding isn't gross or unnatural. So why is sex now? B/c kids can't and should not have sex? Right. And kids can't breastfeed until adult age. So why not keep it off the table as a child's toy? That's my point. Some things are off limits as children's toys (hence my sarcastic point above about Barbie and Ken) and a child pretending to untie a top to expose a breast (that they dont even have) crosses that line.

JMO. That's the way I see it.




See I understand your point bc I'm assuming you were bottle only for your DC? But do you not see that some families are only EBF? While my oldest had bottles, my youngest never had a bottle, not ever, so in our house the norm is BF instead of bottles since my DS was old enough to remember how his sister was fed, so he told my DD how to feed her babies, just like mommy did kwim? I feel like most things kids do in imaginary play is not age appropriate, like cooking, cleaning etc. So I don't understand what the big deal is, kids do it bc that's what normal is in their home.

Posted 1/31/13 7:02 PM
 

Dani922
Here's to new beginnings

Member since 10/07

7260 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Thoughts on this?

Eh if my daughter wanted it I dont see why not. I wouldnt force it on her or anything. I breastfed both kids for 2 years. My DD knows that's how she was fed as a baby & saw her baby brother breastfed so her baby dolls were generally breastfed as well. She just simulated what she knew

Posted 1/31/13 7:11 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by mrspalomino148


See I understand your point bc I'm assuming you were bottle only for your DC? But do you not see that some families are only EBF? While my oldest had bottles, my youngest never had a bottle, not ever, so in our house the norm is BF instead of bottles since my DS was old enough to remember how his sister was fed, so he told my DD how to feed her babies, just like mommy did kwim? I feel like most things kids do in imaginary play is not age appropriate, like cooking, cleaning etc. So I don't understand what the big deal is, kids do it bc that's what normal is in their home.



I guess in your home that doll would make sense. I see your point. But I personally find the doll (for my home) totally crossing a line that I don't feel should be crossed. I can't say what I would feel if I "did" breastfeed, but I am very big on children being children. Some things just cross a line for me.

I still find it inappropriate for a young girl to pretend she has breasts and tie on a top and pretend to breastfeed a child with the DOLL. If a child mimics mom on her own, that's one thing. But the doll just crosses a line IMO.

Not looking to offend, just find "the doll" inappropriate and over the top. I was being sarcastic about Barbie and Ken. I would not want those dolls either, that's for sure.

Message edited 2013-01-31 21:34:07.130000.

Posted 1/31/13 7:11 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Thoughts on this?

she can nurse a doll she already has-i would not buy one just for that sole purpose
I am 100% for bfing. I do think everyone should give it a whirl-from a completely green standpoint.
If this helps someone introduce nursing to her daughter-great.

Posted 1/31/13 7:11 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this?

I don't think it's the worst thing in the world and it probably wouldn't bother me if I had a daughter and she wanted one.

I mean, kids explore new things they see or learn about in a typically normal and healthy way - I rememer a girl I was friends with as a kid would pretend to BF her dolls.


When I think about it..

I rather a girl playing with a BFing doll and pretending to BF it than a boy with a huge fake (but real-looking) gun pretending to shoot someone, KWIM?

Which is hypocritical of me to say, because both are pretend play and both are situations that the kids are not mature enough to manage.

Posted 1/31/13 7:12 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by Goobster

Posted by maybebaby

EXACTLY!!!

Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.




Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.

Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.



I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?



Maybe if she had a BFinhg doll when she was a kid she wouldnt have such an intense negative response to breastfeeding Chat Icon

Posted 1/31/13 7:13 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this?

FTR, I love the Goobster and I don't think she hates BFing..just maybe the intense debate of it being the best way possible - period. I get that way with political debates.

I personally don't think that feeling resonates with her response here, KWIM?

(I say this all in peace, by the way!)

Everyone has something they feel intensely about, right? Chat Icon

Posted 1/31/13 7:19 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

FTR, I love the Goobster and I don't think she hates BFing..just maybe the intense debate of it being the best way possible - period. I get that way with political debates.

I personally don't think that feeling resonates with her response here, KWIM?

(I say this all in peace, by the way!)

Everyone has something they feel intensely about, right? Chat Icon



I don't hate it. It's not for me. And I would never allow my DD to have this doll. I just looked at the pic again and the pasties/flowers for nipples, oh no way. I find this extremely inappropriate.

But if a mom BFs and a child mimics with a doll, I dont find that so odd. We have had this discussion about this doll before on here. The top to tie on with the pasties/flowers for nipples, are all what cross a very inappropriate line for me.

Message edited 2013-01-31 21:36:29.417000.

Posted 1/31/13 7:25 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Kidsaplenty
Maybe if she had a BFinhg doll when she was a kid she wouldnt have such an intense negative response to breastfeeding Chat Icon



You make your choices in what you allow and deem appropriate for your children, and I make my choices in what I allow and find appropriate for mine. You were raised one way and I was raised another way. I was speaking for myself and what I thought of the doll. You may not agree but that doesnt mean your opinion is right vs mine being wrong. At least half (if not most) of people on this thread found this doll inappropriate. Funny how you only replied to me??

After all, I simply responded to the topic of this thread, opinions on this doll.

Message edited 2013-01-31 21:37:24.453000.

Posted 1/31/13 7:46 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Thoughts on this?

I dont think it is neccesary but I see nothing wrong with it, it is 100% in my mind the same as a doll that pees or poops. Something the body does , done by a doll.

Nothing much phases me though, bigger fish to fry in my pan that top worry about a doll.

I might say, wow thats something "new" , but I wouldn't care about it, I wouldn't buy it unless my child asked for it. If they did, then so be it, fine by me.

Posted 1/31/13 9:24 PM
 

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by maybebaby

I hope each doll comes with its own lactation consultant! 99.9% of 7 year old moms have trouble producing according to the AAP! Chat Icon

(i am just making a lighthearted joke, not trying to be snarky)



lmao!!! Chat Icon

Posted 1/31/13 9:51 PM
 

kimbalina
Bring on the glitter and bows!

Member since 6/08

15158 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Kitten1929

I have no problem with breastfeeding. I don't think a child needs to have a breastfeeding doll...She'll learn about it at the appropriate age, no need to rush it.



Agreed.

Posted 1/31/13 10:42 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Dani922

Eh if my daughter wanted it I dont see why not. I wouldnt force it on her or anything. I breastfed both kids for 2 years. My DD knows that's how she was fed as a baby & saw her baby brother breastfed so her baby dolls were generally breastfed as well. She just simulated what she knew



100% agree. No kids here, but apparently i used to "breastfeed" my bay dolls when i was little because mom breastfed my sister...i think it's sweet...

Posted 1/31/13 10:45 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Please keep my baby boy in your thoughts and prayers..... preciouslove 12/19/05 73 Pregnancy
I never do this but I really really need your good thoughts today... UPDATE 10/7 Leeners 10/6/05 54 Families Helping Families ™
what are your thoughts.. re: World trade center? 04bride 10/4/05 42 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!!!Please cross your fingers and wish happy thoughts to Juliette for Monday!!! UPDATED!!! aliasPook 9/10/05 14 Parenting
VMA's!!!! Without further adieu, I would like to share DH's thoughts on the pre-show..... kathleeng 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
So Debg....What thoughts are running through your head right now? btrflygrl 8/19/05 12 Families Helping Families ™