Thoughts on this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by SusiBee

Posted by nrthshgrl

I wouldn't' buy it. A kid can pretend to breastfeed her doll without the doll gulping. She doesn't need a gadget to do it. If they really want to simulate motherhood, they need a doll that wakes the little girl up every 2-3 hours hungry & wants to be fed.



Well said.
I don't have children, will never have them, I'm a PANK, but I do like this response.
To be even more realistic, add a little projectile vomitting every once in a while.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 12:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ltdentway99
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1752 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

What if they gave it to teenagers?? Would we then say it promotes teen pregnancy? It's just bizarre for me.

Posted 1/30/13 12:30 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think that having a child MIMIC something (using a mass-produced and marketed product) that their bodies are INCAPABLE of doing at that point in their lives is what's weird about it to me. A 5 year old CAN help change a diaper, or feed a baby with a bottle, etc. A 5 year old CANNOT feed a child from her own breast.



Posted 1/30/13 12:42 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Bearcat

I think that having a child MIMIC something (using a mass-produced and marketed product) that their bodies are INCAPABLE of doing at that point in their lives is what's weird about it to me. A 5 year old CAN help change a diaper, or feed a baby with a bottle, etc. A 5 year old CANNOT feed a child from her own breast.






Very good point.

Posted 1/30/13 12:43 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Thoughts on this?

I think this is a rip off. If a little girl sees BFing happening around them, especially from their mother, they are going to imitate it with the dolls they already have - and I think that's fine and natural even. But to pay for a doll specifically to do this is a waste of money. That's the only issue I have with it.

Posted 1/30/13 12:44 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by Bearcat

I think that having a child MIMIC something (using a mass-produced and marketed product) that their bodies are INCAPABLE of doing at that point in their lives is what's weird about it to me. A 5 year old CAN help change a diaper, or feed a baby with a bottle, etc. A 5 year old CANNOT feed a child from her own breast.






Very good point.



I'm waiting for someone to say "but a 5 year old can't drive a car and we get them the motorized Barbie jeeps" -
IMO not the same. Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 12:44 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

I don't see a problem with it. Let's face it, the only people who are going to be buying this doll are ardently pro-breastfeeding mamas, so they probably grew up watching little siblings nurse and this is hardly exposing them to anything they don't already know about.

Women who are skeeved by breastfeeding would never buy this doll, so motherhood and breastfeeding aren't being "forced" on any little girls.

In terms of forcing young girls to grow up, I would worry more about the trashy clothing marketed to 5 yr olds Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 12:52 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by Bearcat

I think that having a child MIMIC something (using a mass-produced and marketed product) that their bodies are INCAPABLE of doing at that point in their lives is what's weird about it to me. A 5 year old CAN help change a diaper, or feed a baby with a bottle, etc. A 5 year old CANNOT feed a child from her own breast.






Very good point.



I'm waiting for someone to say "but a 5 year old can't drive a car and we get them the motorized Barbie jeeps" -
IMO not the same. Chat Icon



Oh just wait...I'm sure someone will post something like that!

Posted 1/30/13 1:23 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

its wrong, shouldnt draw attention to a kids private part

Posted 1/30/13 7:20 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by computergirl

I don't see a problem with it. Let's face it, the only people who are going to be buying this doll are ardently pro-breastfeeding mamas, so they probably grew up watching little siblings nurse and this is hardly exposing them to anything they don't already know about.

Women who are skeeved by breastfeeding would never buy this doll, so motherhood and breastfeeding aren't being "forced" on any little girls.

In terms of forcing young girls to grow up, I would worry more about the trashy clothing marketed to 5 yr olds Chat Icon




Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 7:23 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by butterfly20

its wrong, shouldnt draw attention to a kids private part



Private part? Really? Chat Icon


FTR I don't see anything wrong with the doll...it's a bit much (but I think the actual peeing and pooping dolls are a bit much too). Kids see their moms nursing and mimic it, not really a big deal Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 7:25 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by brownie

Posted by butterfly20

its wrong, shouldnt draw attention to a kids private part



Private part? Really? Chat Icon


FTR I don't see anything wrong with the doll...it's a bit much (but I think the actual peeing and pooping dolls are a bit much too). Kids see their moms nursing and mimic it, not really a big deal Chat Icon



What's with the head bang? Parts on the body that are covered by clothes normally are considered private parts.

Posted 1/30/13 8:01 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this?

I find it disturbing, but then again, I have never felt any desire to BF , so it would be weird to think a DD of mine would. FTR, I also do not like dolls, that pee, poop, talk etc..I find them disturbing too.

Message edited 2013-01-30 20:03:38.583000.

Posted 1/30/13 8:03 PM
 

StarsStripes
LIF Adult

Member since 12/12

1192 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by brownie

Posted by butterfly20

its wrong, shouldnt draw attention to a kids private part



Private part? Really? Chat Icon


FTR I don't see anything wrong with the doll...it's a bit much (but I think the actual peeing and pooping dolls are a bit much too). Kids see their moms nursing and mimic it, not really a big deal Chat Icon



What's with the head bang? Parts on the body that are covered by clothes normally are considered private parts.



So maybe they shouldn't sell dolls that go pee pee on the potty??? What's the difference? IMO going to the bathroom is pretty gross yet we have dolls and books that promote it to children. I get that little kids can't actually BF but as pp suggested if they see their mommies doing it then maybe they want to copy...I don't see a problem with that. Especially because like urininating, BF is one of the most natural things in the world. I think everyone just needs to get over it already and loosen up!

Honestly, I don't know why people keep posting this (not to knock OP) because it is just the same old debate and each side thinks they are right.Chat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 8:06 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by StarsStripes

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by brownie

Posted by butterfly20

its wrong, shouldnt draw attention to a kids private part



Private part? Really? Chat Icon


FTR I don't see anything wrong with the doll...it's a bit much (but I think the actual peeing and pooping dolls are a bit much too). Kids see their moms nursing and mimic it, not really a big deal Chat Icon



What's with the head bang? Parts on the body that are covered by clothes normally are considered private parts.



So maybe they shouldn't sell dolls that go pee pee on the potty??? What's the difference? IMO going to the bathroom is pretty gross yet we have dolls and books that promote it to children. I get that little kids can't actually BF but as pp suggested if they see their mommies doing it then maybe they want to copy...I don't see a problem with that. Especially because like urininating, BF is one of the most natural things in the world. I think everyone just needs to get over it already and loosen up!

Honestly, I don't know why people keep posting this (not to knock OP) because it is just the same old debate and each side thinks they are right.Chat Icon



If you read my post , you would see that I said I do not like dolls that pee or poop etc? Why did you just choose to quote me, when I made my position clear? In case it wasn't above or in this post, I DO NOT like dolls that mimic BF, Peeing , pooping, brushing teeth, blowing their nose or any other bodily function. I FIND IT WEIRD! Buy your kid whatever you want, i don't care. the OP asked for opinions, I gave mine.

Posted 1/30/13 8:18 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this?

Just realized StarStripes you've only been here a month....you might not want to attack people so quickly, especially when they gave their opion, like the OP asked for, in a respectful manner.

Posted 1/30/13 8:21 PM
 

muffaboo
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

3797 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

I plan to BF but this doll comes off as inappropriate to me.

Posted 1/30/13 8:25 PM
 

StarsStripes
LIF Adult

Member since 12/12

1192 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by jlm2008

Just realized StarStripes you've only been here a month....you might not want to attack people so quickly, especially when they gave their opion, like the OP asked for, in a respectful manner.



Thanks for the warningChat Icon

Posted 1/30/13 8:29 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Pomegranate5

I think this is a rip off. If a little girl sees BFing happening around them, especially from their mother, they are going to imitate it with the dolls they already have - and I think that's fine and natural even. But to pay for a doll specifically to do this is a waste of money. That's the only issue I have with it.



I agree. Seriously, we need another doll like a hole in the head Chat Icon. My DD used to pretend to nurse her dolls all the time since she would see me nursing her baby brother No need for a special doll though. If a child is exposed to it, they will probably mimic it just like everything else. Not sure what's so "disturbing" about it though Chat Icon

Message edited 2013-01-30 20:43:17.747000.

Posted 1/30/13 8:39 PM
 

Never2Part
LIF Infant

Member since 11/10

214 total posts

Name:
Adore my Che Che :)

Re: Thoughts on this?

vile

Posted 1/30/13 9:01 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Thoughts on this?

I don't think it is a big deal. I probably wouldn't buy it, but lots of little girls' pretend play involves miming the feeding of a baby.

Message edited 2013-01-30 21:12:27.877000.

Posted 1/30/13 9:09 PM
 

thisisme
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/06

560 total posts

Name:
ME

Re: Thoughts on this?

Not for nothing, but I know a lot of children who have seen their moms breast feed their younger siblings and they automatically place a doll to their breast when it's time to pretend to feed them. Because that's what you do to feed a baby in their house. I guess I don't see it any differently. I didn't breast feed, but I don't think there's anything creepy about a little girl wanting to mimic it. I never understood the weird feelings towards breast feeding.

Posted 1/30/13 9:10 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Thoughts on this?

I see nothing wrong with it. If a little girl is watching her mom nurse her sibling and wants to be like mommy, what's the big deal? I have seen girls do that with their dolls for the very same reason. It's not sexualizing her. In fact, its calling attention to the true function of breasts. I formula fed too. I feel people get so bent out of shape over so many things.

Posted 1/30/13 9:42 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Xelindrya

No thank you. Just seems so wrong to me.

Besides... being a mom doesnt mean breastfeeding. Why set her up for catastrophic disappointment if she can't BF later? I think we pressure women enough as it is right now - why do we have to start with our children? It still burns me all those questions and looks that first year "you dont breast feed? Why not?" My tits, my baby, my business. Not even a doctor should have a right to tell me I need to BF.

Honestly I find this disturbing

However, I'd love to see the reactions when boys use it too. Afterall I know plenty boys who feed baby dolls with pretend milk bottles. Lets strap this on a boy and let the mayhem begin.


I wore fire hats and played with fire trucks when I was little. I'm not too bent out if shape that as a grown up I didn't become a fire fighter... Pretend play is pretend play.

Posted 1/30/13 9:46 PM
 

myboysmyheart
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

2743 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Thoughts on this?

Posted by Never2Part

vile




ok, i understand a lot of the opinions and sides on this, but vile??!?!? really? what is VILE about it?

Posted 1/30/13 9:48 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Please keep my baby boy in your thoughts and prayers..... preciouslove 12/19/05 73 Pregnancy
I never do this but I really really need your good thoughts today... UPDATE 10/7 Leeners 10/6/05 54 Families Helping Families ™
what are your thoughts.. re: World trade center? 04bride 10/4/05 42 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!!!Please cross your fingers and wish happy thoughts to Juliette for Monday!!! UPDATED!!! aliasPook 9/10/05 14 Parenting
VMA's!!!! Without further adieu, I would like to share DH's thoughts on the pre-show..... kathleeng 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
So Debg....What thoughts are running through your head right now? btrflygrl 8/19/05 12 Families Helping Families ™