Tax Cap

Posted By Message
Pages: << 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 12 >>

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by SlurpeeDad

I guess its a good thing you never named what districts you are talking about, I don't want to know if I live in one of those "lesser" districts. I am not sure where I will be purchasing a house, but I will make sure that when our baby is born, they doesn't go near those "lesser" districts. I may have to send them to private school, just in case one of the "better" districts goes downhill and becomes a "lesser" district.



Be real please. When anyone buys a house the quality of the school district is basically the number one factor in where you choose your home...............if you plan on having children of course. Being in a good district, which living on the island isn't hard to figure out where they are and if you don't know it's easy to find out, was our NUMBER ONE priority.

Again, there's a reason why you pay more for a house and more in taxes for different towns on the island. I'm sure you have some idea of the quality of schools in your area now and when you do buy a house I can promise you, it will be the FIRST thing you consider because of your child who is on the way. DH and I have talked about moving OOS one day and if we do, the quality of schools in wherever else we look will be our NUMBER ONE concern before anything else. As I've stated many times, there is a reason I chose my house in the town I did and there was a reason why I was willing to pay more into my mortgage and taxes..............the school district. So yea, combining districts wouldn't really be something I would want to see. Sorry if that offends you. Chat Icon



I actually never said I disagree with you there, I don't know where I stand on combining districts yet. I just thought the way you stated it was a little rude. I hope that I am in a situation where I can afford a house in a good school district, that is a no brainer. It just doesn't sit well when someone pretty clearly states that their child deserves more because they have money and that a child of a poor person doesn't deserve those same opportunities. That may not be what you were trying to say, but that is how it came out.

Message edited 2011-02-18 09:30:38.293000.

Posted 2/18/11 8:27 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Sassyz75

I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children.

combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration.

This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states...




Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING.

Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away.

Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks.




This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it Chat Icon

This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 9:11 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by MrsECullen7319

Posted by Jenhos

I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days.

I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off.

Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements.

Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain.

I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town?

My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up?

I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile)



ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1...



This blows my mind. You make it sound like all teachers are lazy and just doing the bare minimum. Really? How do you know? By your few experiences as a leave replacement before you couldn't handle it anymore and gave up???

We don't need to be "forced" to perform at our jobs. Most teachers bust their butts everyday "performing" for the kids, their parents, the administration, the state and every other know it all that has never been in a classroom.

It is very easy to say get rid of tenure when you don't have it. Usually people who say "get rid of tenure" don't understand what tenure truly is for.

Posted 2/18/11 9:24 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Tax Cap

Omg. I just can't with these comments about the right to football and cheerleading vs the right to an education for kids that need to be taught differently.

Sure, it there was enough money we would want to do it all but when the budget crunch comes you do the most essential-to me a kid with special needs is more entitled to an education than little bobby is to football, even if it means his parents won't be able to fund it outside of school. How anyone could think otherwise is beyond meChat Icon


ETS: As a parent to 2 youngs kids who are not yet school age, I have no idea if I am going to need these services but I would much rather a top special education be available to my kids should we need it and I would be ticked if it got cut/reduced so that another kid could play football.

Message edited 2011-02-18 09:40:31.507000.

Posted 2/18/11 9:32 AM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Tax Cap

The special needs kidfs will have what they need bc of the law which is why a tax cap is a bad idea. The community won't be able to decide if they want to spend more in taxes if they want certain things to exist in theiir district. Ap is useless? Ya know what I'm done with this thread and I'm a great educator. I hope we can figure out how to improve education in this country for the sake of alllll our children.

Posted 2/18/11 9:55 AM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by BriBri2u

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Sassyz75

I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children.

combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration.

This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states...




Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING.

Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away.

Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks.




This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it Chat Icon

This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Chat Icon



Seriously, so obnoxious. Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 9:57 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Tax Cap

I am soooooo soooooo sooooooo very sad that I came to this thread so late.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 9:58 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Let's face it- it will be easier to get rid of tenure and seniority than to get parents to step up and support their kids, especially in poorer communities. And before anyone says "Well, I'm a good parent" that's not the point. The point is that most teachers earn their money. But because things are hard right now, it's easy to take aim at protections and pay and things like that even though there are only a relatively few bad apples.

Tenure does not mean a job for life, and if a principal lets teachers slide without doing work, then that principal is also part of the problem. Tenure means that a teacher is not beholden to a parent to give a student a certain grade. Tenure means a teacher does not have to give in to ridiculous demands from administrators (and before anyone says that people in the private sector have to deal with absurdities, does that make it right?) It means that a teacher who is falsely accused of somethng by a student (and it's happened to me; I bet it happens to many of us) will not be out on his or her tail immediately. It means that an administrator who has an unfair beef with you can't get you canned.

But hey, get rid of those things. Cut salaries and pensions. I predict that we will continue to compliain, with more legitamacy, about the quality of people who are teaching. Fortunately, I will be able to help my child weather any shortcomings of her teachers. I used to think that we have to weather bad times together, but I'm sick of being scapegoated.

Posted 2/18/11 9:59 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Tax Cap

but now that I am here, if someone wants to humor me, what is the actual argument/debate? I am very confused.

Posted 2/18/11 10:03 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Tax Cap

1. tax caps are bad
2. taxes are too h1gh
3. superintendents make too much $
4. no teachers make too much
5. no they dont
6. yes they do
7. special ed costs too much
8. so cut sports
9. my superintendent still makes too much
10. ap classes are a waste

eta: i forgot to add

3a - consolidate SDs
3b - no way
3c - you're a snob

Message edited 2011-02-18 10:08:40.207000.

Posted 2/18/11 10:07 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Ophelia

but now that I am here, if someone wants to humor me, what is the actual argument/debate? I am very confused.




there are multiple as per LIF

It started with the tax cap....spun off into teachers make too much....to get rid of tenure.....to my kids football is more important than special education....to lets combine districts vs I don't want "those" people going to my kids school Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 10:08 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Meaghan729

1. tax caps are bad
2. taxes are too h1gh
3. superintendents make too much $
4. no teachers make too much
5. no they dont
6. yes they do
7. special ed costs too much
8. so cut sports
9. my superintendent still makes too much
10. ap classes are a waste




Don't forget:
11. Combine schools districts
12. Don't do that, I paid a lot to be in my district.
13. Richie rich doesn't want poor kids diluting their district

Posted 2/18/11 10:10 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Meaghan729

1. tax caps are bad
2. taxes are too h1gh
3. superintendents make too much $
4. no teachers make too much
5. no they dont
6. yes they do
7. special ed costs too much
8. so cut sports
9. my superintendent still makes too much
10. ap classes are a waste




Don't forget:
11. Combine schools districts
12. Don't do that, I paid a lot to be in my district.
13. Richie rich doesn't want poor kids diluting their district



ha you beat me to it!

Posted 2/18/11 10:10 AM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by MrsProfessor

Let's face it- it will be easier to get rid of tenure and seniority than to get parents to step up and support their kids, especially in poorer communities. And before anyone says "Well, I'm a good parent" that's not the point. The point is that most teachers earn their money. But because things are hard right now, it's easy to take aim at protections and pay and things like that even though there are only a relatively few bad apples.

Tenure does not mean a job for life, and if a principal lets teachers slide without doing work, then that principal is also part of the problem. Tenure means that a teacher is not beholden to a parent to give a student a certain grade. Tenure means a teacher does not have to give in to ridiculous demands from administrators (and before anyone says that people in the private sector have to deal with absurdities, does that make it right?) It means that a teacher who is falsely accused of somethng by a student (and it's happened to me; I bet it happens to many of us) will not be out on his or her tail immediately. It means that an administrator who has an unfair beef with you can't get you canned.

But hey, get rid of those things. Cut salaries and pensions. I predict that we will continue to compliain, with more legitamacy, about the quality of people who are teaching. Fortunately, I will be able to help my child weather any shortcomings of her teachers. I used to think that we have to weather bad times together, but I'm sick of being scapegoated.



I think the teachers are looking at this all wrong. I don't think anyone is "scapegoating" teachers. We are just looking at this without the rose colored glasses on. Things have to change, and it isn't just teachers pensions. Administration costs have to change, Police Officers pensions have to change, many things have to change. Since Andrew Cuomo started this plan, the attention has been paid to teachers, but it is across the board. I don't think anyone here really thinks that teachers are doing a bad job, there is just too much money being spent at the current state of time. When there isn't enough money coming in, things have to change. A business that is struggling looks to cut costs, not to raise prices and I believe that is what needs to be done with our current tax system.

Posted 2/18/11 10:11 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Meaghan729

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Meaghan729

1. tax caps are bad
2. taxes are too h1gh
3. superintendents make too much $
4. no teachers make too much
5. no they dont
6. yes they do
7. special ed costs too much
8. so cut sports
9. my superintendent still makes too much
10. ap classes are a waste




Don't forget:
11. Combine schools districts
12. Don't do that, I paid a lot to be in my district.
13. Richie rich doesn't want poor kids diluting their district



ha you beat me to it!



Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 10:12 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Ophelia

I am soooooo soooooo sooooooo very sad that I came to this thread so late.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Seriously!

Posted 2/18/11 10:21 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Tax Cap

So Tenure means you don't have to deal with political BS at work?

Posted 2/18/11 10:27 AM
 

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: Tax Cap

Times are tough, and the options are either to cut spending or to increase taxes to pay for them. Taxes are already very high and I could understand why a cap is being discussed.

However, if $$$ is already allocated to certain areas such as pensions, automatic raises, big salaries, specialty programs (ex: special ed*), it limits where the cuts can come from and could lead to layoffs, larger classes, combined schools or districts, or cutbacks for general education.

Assuming you are going to cut from somewhere, I personally would rather see pensions cut from future contracts rather than cuts from other places. These are highly salaried positions so I think teachers/admin are able to save for retirement like the private sector, and it would gree up a lot of money for current teachers, current students, current school needs, etc.

Taxes can only raise so high, and it's hard because nobody wants to give anything up. No proposed solution is going to be popular unless it involves a money tree in the playground.

*I think special ed is incredibly important and do not think we should cut there. I am just noting it is something else that is automatically allocated part of the budget.

Posted 2/18/11 10:29 AM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by juanvi

The special needs kidfs will have what they need bc of the law which is why a tax cap is a bad idea. The community won't be able to decide if they want to spend more in taxes if they want certain things to exist in theiir district. Ap is useless? Ya know what I'm done with this thread and I'm a great educator. I hope we can figure out how to improve education in this country for the sake of alllll our children.



I was in some AP classes. They were fine but nothing I couldn't live without. Children with SN can't live well without those services, maybe that's why it's law.

I don't know how I feel about a tax cap honestly. I think there are better places to cut from then the school system, especially at the student level... Any student.

Posted 2/18/11 10:36 AM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Eliminating special ed is ridiculous and I can't believe that anyone could think those kids don't need/deserve a good education.

I am not saying that teachers make too much money. I am saying that in these types of times that teachers along with administrators, police, fireman MTA people all need to make sacrifices because the tax payer has to fund their salaries, pensions, benefits etc. That may mean 2-3 years with no raise. Or that they keep whatever is in their pension today but nothing more gets added to it. I apologize if I used Tenure in the wrong way. I have always thought it was rare a Tenured teacher gets the boot.

But because of the way the contracts are set up these things can't be touched so the kids suffer because they have to lose programs and quality of their education. Or their parents have to suck it up and pay more in taxes.

I don't think the private sector is perfect but we the indicidual has to negotiate for ourselves and if the company isn't doing well you can expect to take a freeze in pay and not get paid a bonus no matter how many hours you work or how well you perform.

Posted 2/18/11 10:41 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Meaghan729

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Meaghan729

1. tax caps are bad
2. taxes are too h1gh
3. superintendents make too much $
4. no teachers make too much
5. no they dont
6. yes they do
7. special ed costs too much
8. so cut sports
9. my superintendent still makes too much
10. ap classes are a waste




Don't forget:
11. Combine schools districts
12. Don't do that, I paid a lot to be in my district.
13. Richie rich doesn't want poor kids diluting their district



ha you beat me to it!



Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon thanks guys.

all I really want to add to this discussion, without getting in to the minutiae (can you believe I KNOW that word, as a NYC public schools graduate Chat Icon Chat Icon ) is that teachers and adminstrators...they are all civil service jobs. but from what I am reading some of the admins and higher ups are making more than the POTUS Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon . do you understand how ridiculous that reads to me, as a person outside of the LI bubble?

people may hate me for saying this but I don't care...every time this argument comes up I SEARCH for this extra intelligence that these seemingly awesome school districts provide your children on these boards with all of you. and to be totally honest, you are all seemingly intelligent women and I cannot tell the difference between you. I have no idea who went where. unless you are ALL product of "the best" schools.

I think Hofstra's post pointed out something very intersting. It appears to ME, again, as an outsider, that people wear their school districts like some kind of medal. on LI where you send your kid to school says SO MUCH about you. how much money you have first and foremost.

the thing I love about NYC public schools as an ATTENDEE of them (I have no teaching experience whatsoever obviously) is that you can go to ANY school at the high school level, based on your MERIT. it doens't matter where you live, who your parents are or how much house they can buy or how much taxes they can pay. it's not about THEIR badge. it's about yours.

ETD: for spelling. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-02-18 10:49:06.177000.

Posted 2/18/11 10:42 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Tax Cap

What I want to know is - if we consolidated SDs, wouldn't that mean that there would be MORE resources available to the "lesser" districts, that they didn't originally have access to, therefore raising them up closer to the level of the districts that are more well off? Wouldn't that benefit everyone?

Posted 2/18/11 10:44 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Ophelia
minutae



The only difference I see is that those who are NYC school gradautes use big words that I don't understand Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 10:45 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Ophelia
minutae



The only difference I see is that those who are NYC school gradautes use big words that I don't understand Chat Icon



it's ok. I think I spelled it wrong. that is why you didn't understand. Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I CAN spell ridiculous and definitely. in NYCPS, you can't get your diploma unless you spell those two words right. Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 10:50 AM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

The best school districts are what they are because of the test scores and the percentages of kids that go to college and the types of colleges they go to.
It happens that most of the top districts on the Island fall in affluent neighborhoods. The reason these neigborhoods can command a lot of money for the houses comes down to the reputation of the school district, the safety of the town, the amenities it offers. I don't think sending your kid to one of these schools is a badge of anything except that you want the best you can afford for your kid.

I don't begrudge anyone that can afford to live in any of these neighborhoods.

I would bet if you put up a poll with a list of neighborhoods you would see a trend that would lean toward the nicer neighborhood, with the good school.

I think it is so weird that we look at those who make alot of money as "bad" people, who should pay more and support the rest of us.

Posted 2/18/11 10:50 AM
 
Pages: << 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 12 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Capital Gains Tax Aliking 9/14/05 12 Home
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home