Tax Cap
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 9 10 >> | |
|
Re: Tax Cap Just one quick comment about PE teachers |
|
Posted 2/17/11 5:47 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Tax Cap I really do apologize for posting this topic at all. At first, the conversation seemed to be fair and respectful- which was wonderful. But, how quickly it turned so sour! Not my intent at all. I am fairly new to LIF, and I will definitely rethink the next time I want to post something that I feel is relevant to discuss with fellow LIers. Message edited 2011-02-17 17:58:53.427000. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 5:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Most of you fail to realize that the majority of districts on LI including the one I work in, have given pay freezes to teachers, and I do not know a single teacher making $150k. For all of you who are for major change in education, I hope you realize that it comes at a cost, and that means more $$$. To cut salaries, teachers, programs, means a compromised education for your children. Is that what you want? Oh, and 30-35 children in a class (which I have this year, and it is horrible for all involved) means less time that the teacher can spend helping the students who have WAY more learning and behavioral issues than kids did when I was in school. A class of over 30 high school students is a zoo -- I can imagine what 30+ elementary students is like. Do you want your kids taught in a zoo? In that environment, no one learns. Quality education comes at a cost, plain and simple. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 6:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Aries14 I'm sorry but I am just so tired of everyone complaining about teachers salary. My DH is a teacher AND a taxpayer - so I think people need to remember that its not like teachers are not paying these high taxes too. And its not like every teacher is making these huge salaries. My DH has been teaching for six years has his Masters and is still continuing school. He has $500 in school loans a month. I have an assocites and have been at my job for 4 years. We make about the same. And its not even close to what some people were posting that their teacher friends make. I DO think the higher up's in education salaries are WAY out of control. We should be turning our attenton to them. i couldnt agree with this more every teacher pays taxes just like the rest of us. my cousin is 33 and has been teaching for over 10 years in queens and makes around $75K which to me is absurd - he should be making more and he has been going to college since he was 18 just so he can get a better salary he will be paying school loans for the rest of his life |
|
Posted 2/17/11 6:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by luckyinlove Most of you fail to realize that the majority of districts on LI including the one I work in, have given pay freezes to teachers, and I do not know a single teacher making $150k. For all of you who are for major change in education, I hope you realize that it comes at a cost, and that means more $$$. To cut salaries, teachers, programs, means a compromised education for your children. Is that what you want? Oh, and 30-35 children in a class (which I have this year, and it is horrible for all involved) means less time that the teacher can spend helping the students who have WAY more learning and behavioral issues than kids did when I was in school. A class of over 30 high school students is a zoo -- I can imagine what 30+ elementary students is like. Do you want your kids taught in a zoo? In that environment, no one learns. Quality education comes at a cost, plain and simple. completely agree - school has changed so much since i have been there and im only 25 - seeing my little sister who is 9 struggle so much because there are too many kids in a class and not enough activities is so sad to me |
|
Posted 2/17/11 6:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Everyone works hard, we don't need to hear it all the time. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 7:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by DiamondGirl Why is it that every tax thread turns into a teacher salary bash? Living on Long Island is a choice. You choose to live there. The taxes were just as high when you made this choice. Other factors go into why the taxes are high but you focus on teacher salaries, bc hey someone's bitter Oh and if you don't like, you can always move [/QUOTE ITA! hmmmm...and no response to my other questions about attending board meetings. I haven't attended board meetings, but maybe I should start. Like I said, being part of a young couple that is looking to have a young family on Long Island, this is all pretty new and eye opening to me. Regardless of if I have attended board meetings, I am still entitled to my opinion. You're right. You are still entitled to your opinion and I see from this thread that you have a lot to say on this matter. However, I think your opinions would hold more weight if you knew EXACTLY where all the $ is going to. It's so easy to come up with an opinion and not have all the facts. I have my opinions of golfing and professional golfers, but I'll keep those opinions to myself |
|
Posted 2/17/11 7:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by luckyinlove Most of you fail to realize that the majority of districts on LI including the one I work in, have given pay freezes to teachers, and I do not know a single teacher making $150k. Neither do I, and I have a lot of teacher friends. and for the record, my DH is NYCDOE - and if he made $150K I would be he makes half that 8 yrs in. any teacher I know in the $100K range coaches multiple sports. Thats a 7am-7pm day. plus everything they do at home. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 7:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mosh913 Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by DiamondGirl Why is it that every tax thread turns into a teacher salary bash? Living on Long Island is a choice. You choose to live there. The taxes were just as high when you made this choice. Other factors go into why the taxes are high but you focus on teacher salaries, bc hey someone's bitter Oh and if you don't like, you can always move [/QUOTE ITA! hmmmm...and no response to my other questions about attending board meetings. I haven't attended board meetings, but maybe I should start. Like I said, being part of a young couple that is looking to have a young family on Long Island, this is all pretty new and eye opening to me. Regardless of if I have attended board meetings, I am still entitled to my opinion. You're right. You are still entitled to your opinion and I see from this thread that you have a lot to say on this matter. However, I think your opinions would hold more weight if you knew EXACTLY where all the $ is going to. It's so easy to come up with an opinion and not have all the facts. I have my opinions of golfing and professional golfers, but I'll keep those opinions to myself You are entitled to your opinion on golfing and golf professionals (which I'm sure is a great opinion, because golf professionals are awesome), but in no way does your tax money pay my salary. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 7:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap I do agree with the original post that people need to educate themselves on the issue of a tax cap. There are so many more negative effects to this concept than were mentioned. Go to your Board of Education meetings or PTA meetings or whatever you need to do to inform yourself about it. There are certain things that school districts have to pay for just like we do such as heating cost, maintenance costs, utilities and etc... |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by colesmom Posted by Meaghan729 I hate to say it, but also look at the cost of special education. NOT saying that these kids don't deserve it. But when I was in elementary school - we had one Special Education class for the entire school - and I went to a large elementary school (6+ classes per grade). I read an interesting study that showed how in the 80s, 56% of special education funding was from the state, 36% locally, and 8% federal. fast forward to 2000, 46% as coming locally (ie taxpayers), 45% from state, and 9% from federal. 10% more of the pie on our shoulders is a lot. When we went to school there was one special ed. class because the majority of special needs students went to BOCES schools which taxpayers were still paying (more) for. We've come a long way in the special education field and realize how effective (for ALL students as well as economically) integrated/inclusion teaching is. It's well documented that for every $1 spent in special education the country's taxpayers are saving $7 down the line. (Successful students = future taxpayers and far fewer younger adults on SS and/or medicare) ITA Pay now, or pay later. This money is an investment made in children who WILL become successful members of our society because of the interventions they've received. And I hate to tell you - but our district just shelled out THOUSANDS for the "gifted" population - and while I know you didn't mean to offend anyone - I certainly am offended. As a teacher and the mother of a special needs child I RESENT someone trying to say that TOO MUCH is spent on special needs children - which is essentially what you are saying, correct? Forget about individual needs and throw them all in one class? The reason it changed is because it didn't work and - as a previous poster pointed out, you were paying for lots of children who were not housed in the general school population. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by jasmine I didnt realize kindergarten teachers make $150k! I'm not in a position to judge whether they deserve it but with the hours and vacation schedule I definitely picked the wrong career Teachers in my district (yes, on LI) do not make $150K, even if they are maxed out on salary. I am a Kindg. teacher and don't even make half of that. Don't assume that all teachers make that money, b/c that is ridiculous. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by DiamondGirl Why is it that every tax thread turns into a teacher salary bash? Living on Long Island is a choice. You choose to live there. The taxes were just as high when you made this choice. Other factors go into why the taxes are high but you focus on teacher salaries, bc hey someone's bitter Oh and if you don't like, you can always move [/QUOTE ITA! hmmmm...and no response to my other questions about attending board meetings. I haven't attended board meetings, but maybe I should start. Like I said, being part of a young couple that is looking to have a young family on Long Island, this is all pretty new and eye opening to me. Regardless of if I have attended board meetings, I am still entitled to my opinion. You're right. You are still entitled to your opinion and I see from this thread that you have a lot to say on this matter. However, I think your opinions would hold more weight if you knew EXACTLY where all the $ is going to. It's so easy to come up with an opinion and not have all the facts. I have my opinions of golfing and professional golfers, but I'll keep those opinions to myself You are entitled to your opinion on golfing and golf professionals (which I'm sure is a great opinion, because golf professionals are awesome), but in no way does your tax money pay my salary. Possibly not, but sometimes my tax money goes to restoring those nice golf courses such as Eisenhower park which golfers play at. Based on the arguments presented in this thread, I am a tax payer and I should know where my money goes to - so . . . Why does some of it go to restoring golf courses??? |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mom2aidan I'm IMPLORING you - don't vote for the tax cap. This is a democracy. They are taking away your RIGHT to vote for the school budget. And truthfully - this is not 23 years ago. 30 kids per class is a HORRIBLE idea. Our population has changed soooo much! I do not understand this, so please explain. How has our population changed so much that 30 kids per class is a horrible idea? My sister works in a private school and some years has 28+ kids in a class. While she said she enjoys having 20 kids, she has no problem teaching 28-30 kids. I work at a public school in Westchester. Our population is very diverse. The first way it has changed is that there are many more ELL students (second language learners). These students are bright and capable but it can take up to 10 years to acquire academic language. They need smaller class sizes because they need more attention - more explicit directions, vocabulary instruction etc.... Additionally - as per a meeting I had yesterday, I think school report cards should be in tomorrow morning's papers. One thing that they show is that the poverty level in New York state is growing and in my district, it is growing fast. The students in this subgroup also have many needs that cannot always be addressed in a group of 28. I teach one "gifted" class. There are 30 kids in that class. That class practically runs itself. The amount of work we accomplish and the quality is AMAZING. It would never happen in my heterogeneous classes. Research shows that if you want to help a reluctant reader, strategy instruction has to be in class sizes of 8-10. By law, if a student doesn't pass the ELA exam with a 3, they need an academic intervention. All of these changes have occurred over time and in order to handle each situation appropriately, it costs $$ |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Nifheim I really have to read it really to base my opinion on yet and hopefully at my union meeting today we might get one side of it. I think the only people against educational reform are those who work in education. Because usually you get excited of what your union rep tells you. Honestly take what your union rep says with a grain of salt and make sure your opinion is based on fact. This is why I am not sure of my opinion yet since all i have heard is from my union which is very one sided. What should be reformed? We need to setup outside entities to oversea each SD budget and really look deep into it. Is there any forensic accountants taking a peek at our local budgets? Teach reform - sorry people but seniority needs to be changed. Too many young teachers out there with just as much passion/talent and ability then someone sitting in a class for 20+ years to be cut. I don't know a solution but there has to be. Benefits - I am a state employee and i pay into all my benefits. So should teachers and cops (and my family is filled with cops.) Super, VPs, etc - higher ups need to be consolidated - jobs overlap WAY to much and there needs to be someway to solve this. 1. We are pro-reform, but not if it's going to compromise the education of children. 2. I pay into my health benefits. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by nrthshgrl I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less. Posted by juanvi I would talk with your sis about her experience with teaching large class sizes, but I think unless you have stood in front of 30 teens...elementary kids...whatever you really have no idea how difficult it is.. There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools. 30 middle schoolers? I am asking all of you to visit your school district and ask to observe for a day. Talk to your teachers. 30 middle schoolers is NOT feasible! |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Meaghan729 Posted by nrthshgrl I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less. I pulled figures directly from a study. I actually read multiple studies. the localities are funding a larger piece of the pie than the state. I am in agreement that it is needed- but is a part of the increase. BOCES is funded by the state mostly. State funding has dropped considerably to local districts. the long term cost is less, but not in the terms of property taxes, which is what we are discussing. Where in the study does it say how funding for "typically developing children" has changed over the years? Or is that not a concern for you? |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by juanvi There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools. Agreed! As for Special Education, something also has to be done. No child left behind from a HS perspective makes no sense. While I agree that special ed is much better than it was years ago, forcing a student to pass a now" watered down" regent exam is not going to help. Like I said, I am talking on a HS level. The Special Ed department has more than doubled. Schools can't do much about it because it's law. I don't think it's fair for those who don't have children that require these services. There is no law protecting what they get so with a tax cap, if there is just no money because of special education that needs to be funded, they will be hit with more electives, EC avctivities cuts. And of course, class size. I don't understand your point. Are you saying that we should limit what "THEY GET" to save money? Guess what: "THEY" are entitled to the same thing EVERY child is entitled to - a free education in the United States of America. I'm sorry "THEY" are costing you so much money. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Jacksmommy Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by mosh913 Posted by DiamondGirl Why is it that every tax thread turns into a teacher salary bash? Living on Long Island is a choice. You choose to live there. The taxes were just as high when you made this choice. Other factors go into why the taxes are high but you focus on teacher salaries, bc hey someone's bitter Oh and if you don't like, you can always move [/QUOTE ITA! hmmmm...and no response to my other questions about attending board meetings. I haven't attended board meetings, but maybe I should start. Like I said, being part of a young couple that is looking to have a young family on Long Island, this is all pretty new and eye opening to me. Regardless of if I have attended board meetings, I am still entitled to my opinion. You're right. You are still entitled to your opinion and I see from this thread that you have a lot to say on this matter. However, I think your opinions would hold more weight if you knew EXACTLY where all the $ is going to. It's so easy to come up with an opinion and not have all the facts. I have my opinions of golfing and professional golfers, but I'll keep those opinions to myself You are entitled to your opinion on golfing and golf professionals (which I'm sure is a great opinion, because golf professionals are awesome), but in no way does your tax money pay my salary. Possibly not, but sometimes my tax money goes to restoring those nice golf courses such as Eisenhower park which golfers play at. Based on the arguments presented in this thread, I am a tax payer and I should know where my money goes to - so . . . Why does some of it go to restoring golf courses??? Renovating golf courses will enhance the facility and increase revenue coming in through Eisenhower Park. I am trying to research it, but I believe when the Champions Tour played their tournament for a few years at Eisenhower Park, part of the proceeds went back into the golf course making it less taxing on the public. The USGA gave a lot of money to renovate Bethpage when the US Open first went there in 2002. I know taxes go to fund these parks, but they also bring money in to the state. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by CrankyPants Posted by juanvi As for Special Education, something also has to be done. No child left behind from a HS perspective makes no sense. While I agree that special ed is much better than it was years ago, forcing a student to pass a now" watered down" regent exam is not going to help. Like I said, I am talking on a HS level. The Special Ed department has more than doubled. Schools can't do much about it because it's law. I don't think it's fair for those who don't have children that require these services. I think those who don't have kids requiring these services should be satisfied with that and move along. Agreed. You haven't walked a mile in my shoes or in the shoes of these kids and if you are a special educator, I am really glad my kid won't be in your district. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by neener1211 Posted by Mommy2Boys Posted by ChrisDee Posted by hanna7636 NYC $162,800 Police commissioner That doesn't seem like a lot for overseeing 30000 people so why would a Superintendent's salary be more. Here is the link for my district's budget http://www.elwood.k12.ny.us/Assets/District_Documents/Budget_Presentation_Feb_3_2011.pdf Our Superindendent(retired last year) Shelley Saffer -- Brookhaven-Comsewogue Union Free Schools $462,084.00 Here is my link(salaries in my district) The top ones are ALL admin's http://longisland.newsday.com/templates/simpleDB/?pid=164&brand=newsday&fieldSelect-schoolDistrict=Brookhaven-Comsewogue+Union+Free+Schools&searchField=schoolDistrict&q= BE INFORMED! On top of that, can't they retire, collect a pension and still work in another district? yes OR they can retire and come back as a "per diem" or "interim acting" administrator and make nearly DOUBLE plus perks: apartments, cars, expense allowance. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 8:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Forgive me if this has been mentioned, but what about the MTA tax? Sachem alone pays over half a million dollars in MTA taxes! Why are our schools expected to pay for this? |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsPowers I do agree with the original post that people need to educate themselves on the issue of a tax cap. There are so many more negative effects to this concept than were mentioned. Go to your Board of Education meetings or PTA meetings or whatever you need to do to inform yourself about it. There are certain things that school districts have to pay for just like we do such as heating cost, maintenance costs, utilities and etc... Teachers do pay for their pensions and health insurance. Also, take a look at recent contract negotions in recent years and in many districts teachers have taken pay freezes. As for the spending, many teachers would agree that thing like Ipads and etc are not necessary. Many teachers would be happy with a blackboard and chalk. Increasing class sizes is very detrimental to the educational system as is cutting extra curricular activities. How good will your school district look when a graduate is applying to colleges with no extra-curricular activities? The bottom line is it is the children that will suffer in this situation. There are numerous teachers across the area that are fearful for their jobs due to these budgetary issues and lack of state funding. Not to mention that the taxes we pay on Long Island do not always come back to Long Island directly. Where do people get the idea that teachers don't pay into health benefits and pension? If thats the case where is my $$ going from my paycheck? Money can be found in the millionaires tax, if implemented would bring in $1 billion this year and $5 billion next year to the state. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by DiamondGirl So who is FOR merging? bc it seems to me THIS would help to solve some of fiscal problems. I think that Hofstra's HONEST answer probably is shared by the majority which is why the taxes won't change. ME! And I have a 10 yr old in 4th grade right now. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Moehick Posted by MrsPowers I do agree with the original post that people need to educate themselves on the issue of a tax cap. There are so many more negative effects to this concept than were mentioned. Go to your Board of Education meetings or PTA meetings or whatever you need to do to inform yourself about it. There are certain things that school districts have to pay for just like we do such as heating cost, maintenance costs, utilities and etc... Teachers do pay for their pensions and health insurance. Also, take a look at recent contract negotions in recent years and in many districts teachers have taken pay freezes. As for the spending, many teachers would agree that thing like Ipads and etc are not necessary. Many teachers would be happy with a blackboard and chalk. Increasing class sizes is very detrimental to the educational system as is cutting extra curricular activities. How good will your school district look when a graduate is applying to colleges with no extra-curricular activities? The bottom line is it is the children that will suffer in this situation. There are numerous teachers across the area that are fearful for their jobs due to these budgetary issues and lack of state funding. Not to mention that the taxes we pay on Long Island do not always come back to Long Island directly. Where do people get the idea that teachers don't pay into health benefits and pension? If thats the case where is my $$ going from my paycheck? Money can be found in the millionaires tax, if implemented would bring in $1 billion this year and $5 billion next year to the state. "At the height of the fiscal crisis two years ago, staring down the barrel of a $20 billion budget gap, the state imposed an income-tax surcharge on New Yorkers earning more than $200,000 a year -- and called it a "millionaire's tax." I voted for it as a temporary solution, expecting that the economy would have turned the corner by now. But a tax isn't temporary if we keep re-authorizing it. Unfortunately, some of my colleagues want to do just that -- arguing that we should extend the tax before it expires this year. If the surcharge were truly a millionaire's tax, maybe it would be worth discussing. But since when do hard-working two-income middle-class families count as millionaires? And the surcharge hasn't even raised the revenue it was supposed to -- falling well short of the projected $4 billion a year." - Micah Kellner I don't think the answer is passing the buck. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:18 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 9 10 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Gains Tax | Aliking | 9/14/05 | 12 | Home |
| Tax Free Week! | christy | 9/1/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free??? | momAGAIN | 8/29/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free week? | CarrieAnn | 8/28/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Tax question | checka | 8/26/05 | 3 | Home |
| tax question | Redhead | 6/17/05 | 6 | Home |






[/QUOTE
he makes half that 8 yrs in. 


I'm not in a position to judge whether they deserve it but with the hours and vacation schedule I definitely picked the wrong career


