Tax Cap

Posted By Message
Pages: << 9 10 11 [12] 13 14

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.

Posted 2/18/11 5:13 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I used to live in Amityville and our taxes were $5000. My question is why is the education different from that school district and Elwood? I thought they had to follow a certain program. How do teachers get paid with less taxes going towards the school? Also, a co-worker of mine used to be a city worker and he said the people who passed his classes were the ones the parents were involved (money didn't matter).

Why are property taxes so much cheaper in the city (queens)?

Posted 2/18/11 5:14 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by hanna7636

Why are property taxes so much cheaper in the city (queens)?



They are but if you live in NYC they take out NYC taxes from your paycheck...kind of evens out the taxes paid on LI.

Posted 2/18/11 5:15 PM
 

isabelle2137
LIF Adult

Member since 12/06

1076 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

As for consolidation...in my district you could accomplish that without even leaving my town.

The elementary schools in my district = 6. Enrollment for the last 5 years is down across the board at each school.
For just those 6 schools, we have a superintendent, an asst superintendent, an asst to the superintendent and now a brand new deputy superintendent. FOUR administrative positions that have nothing to do with anything above 6th grade. That is absurd. Plain and simple. One of my elementary schools needs to close. Those teachers/principals/nurse/gym teacher need to look for employment elsewhere.

That would help out everyone who lives in my town. If that means increasing class sizes across each of the other elementary schools, so be it.

I am beyond sick of people saying we can't close a school, think of the people you would lay off.

Think of the people who throw money into a district that is very happy to sit back and waste those dollars on a building that does not need to be open, no lights, heat, etc.

It's a harsh reality - I have a husband who is laid off from his job too- but stuff happens. Things need to adjust.

...climbing down from the soapbox now.

Posted 2/18/11 5:16 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?

Posted 2/18/11 5:19 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



No one is arguing that. I think some people are just pointing out that one minute you complain about the high cost of living, high taxes and overinflated home values, and in the next you say that you purposely selected a town with higher taxes because you think that will be more beneficial for your DD, that's all.

Posted 2/18/11 5:21 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



I don't know who eyerolled first but I do think your point gets lost when you use it during a debate - and you do have a valid point. If I go to a more expensive restaurant, I want better service, better food. I think it's the idea that the poor get shafted on education that is so bothersome. No one can debate that when buying a home, you want the nicest area.

I'm not happy that school districts will merge but given the alternative of losing the A/P classes, extra curriculat activites, shortening of the school day, bigger class sizes or letting our taxes go up again, the third alternative is consolidation.

Posted 2/18/11 5:25 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by bicosi

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MamaLeen

Posted by BriBri2u

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Sassyz75

I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children.

combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration.

This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states...




Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING.

Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away.

Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks.




This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it Chat Icon

This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Chat Icon



Seriously, so obnoxious. Chat Icon



Oh please stop. There is nothing obnoxious about it.

I am not wealthy. I don't live in the "best" area on the island but I live in a nice area. Do I think I am entitled to a high quality education for my child because of where I live? Of course. If I didn't I wouldn't have bought a house where I did, for the price I paid, and for the taxes it costs me. The fact is, to live in a nicer district it costs money and you cannot just combine districts without it causing a ripple effect. Everything would be affected, the quality of education, the house values, the property taxes and so on and so forth.

Look, be offended as you want. The reality of the world is that there is no equal opportunity for all. It's a nice idea, it's not a reality. Those with more are afforded more opportunities. Those who can afford to live in a good district do and they pay for it in the house prices and tax bills. It's really that simple. What's to get offended at? Chat Icon Chat Icon



You're complaining in one thread about your "overpriced, stupid house" and in this one you're going on about how much you paid and your good school district and neighborhood.. which is it?



Both. My house is overpriced because I paid a premium back in the height of the housing market and then it crashed and that's annoying. But I made sure to buy a house where I did so that my DD could go to school in a great school district. It was the number one criteria for us when we were house hunting.

So I am not really sure what your point is here. Yes, it's annoying to have had to spend so much on a house especially now that the market has changed and my house has lost value but it doesn't change the fact that I paid to be in a good district and that was something that was important to us. Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 5:26 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



No one is arguing that. I think some people are just pointing out that one minute you complain about the high cost of living, high taxes and overinflated home values, and in the next you say that you purposely selected a town with higher taxes because you think that will be more beneficial for your DD, that's all.



I was venting. It's annoying that it costs so much to live here, who can argue that? But would I change anything when I bought my house? No. I would still pay more to be in a good district. And I didn't purposely select a town with higher taxes. I would love to pay less in taxes but to pay less would mean I wouldn't have been in such a good district. KWIM? It's annoying that to be in the good areas on the island it costs so much. Just because I did it doesn't mean I like that I had too. I wish things could be cheaper but we live in NY so it's just not the way it is. So it's annoying yes but it's the price you pay for good schools.

Posted 2/18/11 5:30 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by bicosi

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MamaLeen

Posted by BriBri2u

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Sassyz75

I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children.

combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration.

This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states...




Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING.

Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away.

Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks.




This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it Chat Icon

This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Chat Icon



Seriously, so obnoxious. Chat Icon



Oh please stop. There is nothing obnoxious about it.

I am not wealthy. I don't live in the "best" area on the island but I live in a nice area. Do I think I am entitled to a high quality education for my child because of where I live? Of course. If I didn't I wouldn't have bought a house where I did, for the price I paid, and for the taxes it costs me. The fact is, to live in a nicer district it costs money and you cannot just combine districts without it causing a ripple effect. Everything would be affected, the quality of education, the house values, the property taxes and so on and so forth.

Look, be offended as you want. The reality of the world is that there is no equal opportunity for all. It's a nice idea, it's not a reality. Those with more are afforded more opportunities. Those who can afford to live in a good district do and they pay for it in the house prices and tax bills. It's really that simple. What's to get offended at? Chat Icon Chat Icon



You're complaining in one thread about your "overpriced, stupid house" and in this one you're going on about how much you paid and your good school district and neighborhood.. which is it?



Both. My house is overpriced because I paid a premium back in the height of the housing market and then it crashed and that's annoying. But I made sure to buy a house where I did so that my DD could go to school in a great school district. It was the number one criteria for us when we were house hunting.

So I am not really sure what your point is here. Yes, it's annoying to have had to spend so much on a house especially now that the market has changed and my house has lost value but it doesn't change the fact that I paid to be in a good district and that was something that was important to us. Chat Icon



I hear you! but we are ALL in the same boat..

All I'm saying is that it's all relative.. just like you said before.. It's a ripple effect.. Don't you think that a tax cap would help us all tremendously in the grand scheme of things?

Message edited 2011-02-18 17:32:47.780000.

Posted 2/18/11 5:31 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



I don't know who eyerolled first but I do think your point gets lost when you use it during a debate - and you do have a valid point. If I go to a more expensive restaurant, I want better service, better food. I think it's the idea that the poor get shafted on education that is so bothersome. No one can debate that when buying a home, you want the nicest area.

I'm not happy that school districts will merge but given the alternative of losing the A/P classes, extra curriculat activites, shortening of the school day, bigger class sizes or letting our taxes go up again, the third alternative is consolidation.



THIS! Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/11 5:32 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



I don't know who eyerolled first but I do think your point gets lost when you use it during a debate - and you do have a valid point. If I go to a more expensive restaurant, I want better service, better food. I think it's the idea that the poor get shafted on education that is so bothersome. No one can debate that when buying a home, you want the nicest area.

I'm not happy that school districts will merge but given the alternative of losing the A/P classes, extra curriculat activites, shortening of the school day, bigger class sizes or letting our taxes go up again, the third alternative is consolidation.



It's bothersome but it's the way it is. I didn't say it to be mean but it's a reality. Look, quite simply it pays to be in the best school district that you can afford and the best school districts usually translate to higher home prices and higher taxes. That's all. So do the poor get shafted, yes. How can they not? I'm not saying it's right by any means but it's life. It's the system that has been created and perpetuated in this nation and it won't ever change. As I've said, equality for all is a nice idea but it's not a reality.

Posted 2/18/11 5:34 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by bicosi

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by bicosi

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MamaLeen

Posted by BriBri2u

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Sassyz75

I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children.

combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration.

This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states...




Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING.

Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away.

Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks.




This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it Chat Icon

This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Chat Icon



Seriously, so obnoxious. Chat Icon



Oh please stop. There is nothing obnoxious about it.

I am not wealthy. I don't live in the "best" area on the island but I live in a nice area. Do I think I am entitled to a high quality education for my child because of where I live? Of course. If I didn't I wouldn't have bought a house where I did, for the price I paid, and for the taxes it costs me. The fact is, to live in a nicer district it costs money and you cannot just combine districts without it causing a ripple effect. Everything would be affected, the quality of education, the house values, the property taxes and so on and so forth.

Look, be offended as you want. The reality of the world is that there is no equal opportunity for all. It's a nice idea, it's not a reality. Those with more are afforded more opportunities. Those who can afford to live in a good district do and they pay for it in the house prices and tax bills. It's really that simple. What's to get offended at? Chat Icon Chat Icon



You're complaining in one thread about your "overpriced, stupid house" and in this one you're going on about how much you paid and your good school district and neighborhood.. which is it?



Both. My house is overpriced because I paid a premium back in the height of the housing market and then it crashed and that's annoying. But I made sure to buy a house where I did so that my DD could go to school in a great school district. It was the number one criteria for us when we were house hunting.

So I am not really sure what your point is here. Yes, it's annoying to have had to spend so much on a house especially now that the market has changed and my house has lost value but it doesn't change the fact that I paid to be in a good district and that was something that was important to us. Chat Icon



I hear you! but we are ALL in the same boat..

All I'm saying is that it's all relative.. just like you said before.. It's a ripple effect.. Don't you think that a tax cap would help us all tremendously in the grand scheme of things?



Maybe. Maybe not. I just don't think there is a clear and simple answer and surely not a solution that will please all. KWIM?

Posted 2/18/11 5:36 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



I have to say that I am not liberal by any stretch of the imagination and yet I am aghast by this commentary. Yes, people with more money will have more but that does not mean we should do out best to reduce the disparity in education. There are MANY areas in this country that have copnsolidated school districts and still manage to have wealthy neighborhoods despite this.

The irony in your argument is that many people would place you in the category of the "poor" as a 480K house is really not all that much. So I say, consolidate the district - the "haves" can still send their kids to say, Friends Academy if they want (which is what they do in other parts of the country) and the "have-nots" will have a more equal chance of education. I think that when people are actually faced with reality of becoming one of the "have-nots" they quickly come off their high horse.

Posted 2/18/11 5:57 PM
 

allikat
LIF Infant

Member since 5/06

283 total posts

Name:
Alli

Re: Tax Cap


Bicosi-

Without having read much of this thread anymore, I just wanted to go back to the idea of a tax cap.

Unfortunately, with a tax cap our taxes will not go down. We're talking about making drastic changes to our education system for maybe a $200/year difference between our taxes going up regularly and our taxes going up with a tax CAP. It is just that- a CAP, not a DECREASE.

This was the only point of my original post. There's a lot if research and history about tax caps. We should all be informed.

Posted 2/18/11 6:16 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfect™

Re: Tax Cap

Long Island is a truly racist society. Here "good" equals white and "bad" equals any color that is not white. It is truly sickening but you can look at the home board when people recommend good and bad towns and think about what comes to mind. The segregation here is appalling. I am all for consolidation. I was at my DD's kindergarten registration and they are reporting a class size of 83, that is ridiculous. Consolidation with the towns around us would save the taxpayers so much $$$$. The town next to me is one of the few on LI experiencing an increased enrollment but people balk at the idea of integration because it is deemed "bad." Nothing will change here until attitudes change.

Posted 2/18/11 6:29 PM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by melbalalala

Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but...

I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole.

So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do?

Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation?

Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here Chat Icon



I think you are right on!!! ITA

Posted 2/18/11 6:51 PM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by ChrisDee

Posted by melbalalala

Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but...

I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole.

So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do?

Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation?

Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here Chat Icon



I think you are right on!!! ITA




I grew up in MD and I agree consolidate!!!! Maryland has a county system. That doesn't mean that they aren't good and bad schools w/in the county and yes the wealthier neighborhoods have better schools. People still fought to move into certain neighborhoods for certain schools, but resources are shared through all the schools. It also results in less layoffs among teachers, teachers can move to schools w/in their county easily, but will cause layoffs among superintendents. I taught for 8 years in Howard County. We had 39 elementary schools, 18 middle schools and 12 high schools. All under one superintendent, an amazing man. Of course there were asst. superintendents, but only one person pulling a much deserved superintendent salary. I am not bashing LI schools, as I now work at one and will send our future children to one, but my county in MD had amazing resources and was a nationally ranked school system. Consolidation will not hurt the schools if done correctly, and will only benefit teachers and students.

Posted 2/18/11 7:06 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by ChrisDee

Posted by melbalalala

Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but...

I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole.

So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do?

Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation?

Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here Chat Icon



I think you are right on!!! ITA



It was the same way in NC. The SD was the County. Then you picked which town you wanted to live in. Some towns had bigger/smaller houses. Different budget but the tax were the same rate in the whole County. The tax rate would change from one Country to another.

Posted 2/18/11 7:07 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by smdl

Posted by ChrisDee

Posted by melbalalala

Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but...

I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole.

So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do?

Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation?

Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here Chat Icon



I think you are right on!!! ITA



It was the same way in NC. The SD was the County. Then you picked which town you wanted to live in. Some towns had bigger/smaller houses. Different budget but the tax were the same rate in the whole County. The tax rate would change from one Country to another.



Ditto.. it was the same where I lived in TX..

Posted 2/18/11 7:31 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by allikat


Bicosi-

Without having read much of this thread anymore, I just wanted to go back to the idea of a tax cap.

Unfortunately, with a tax cap our taxes will not go down. We're talking about making drastic changes to our education system for maybe a $200/year difference between our taxes going up regularly and our taxes going up with a tax CAP. It is just that- a CAP, not a DECREASE.

This was the only point of my original post. There's a lot if research and history about tax caps. We should all be informed.



Totally hear you.. but we cannot continue the way things are.. We need to put a cap on everything I believe.. again, part from consolidation, major reform is necessary..

Posted 2/18/11 7:34 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by stickydust

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 20mrsc10
I've never understood why this idea bothers others so much.



I think t's less the idea than the eyerolling in this thread.



All of the Chat Icon Chat Icon is because nobody likes to hear the truth. Everyone is so quick to take offense to EVERYTHING and EVERYONE on here.

With regards to what I have said all along, this island, this state, this country........it's not equal. Nothing is equal. People who have money (and this is not to imply I do because I am FAR from wealthy) have more opportunity and honestly, is it a bad thing? I wish I had more. Who doesn't? To find it snobbish that people with more money expect finer schools, finer educations, nicer homes, and better everything is silly.

Sorry people, but the harsh reality is that money makes the world go round. How can you even slightly argue that?



I have to say that I am not liberal by any stretch of the imagination and yet I am aghast by this commentary. Yes, people with more money will have more but that does not mean we should do out best to reduce the disparity in education. There are MANY areas in this country that have copnsolidated school districts and still manage to have wealthy neighborhoods despite this.

The irony in your argument is that many people would place you in the category of the "poor" as a 480K house is really not all that much. So I say, consolidate the district - the "haves" can still send their kids to say, Friends Academy if they want (which is what they do in other parts of the country) and the "have-nots" will have a more equal chance of education. I think that when people are actually faced with reality of becoming one of the "have-nots" they quickly come off their high horse.



Chat Icon Chat Icon A $480K house is far from considered poor on this island. I live in the Stony Brook and am in the 3VSD which is comprised of Stony Brook, Setauket, and Old Field. None of which are considered poor areas on the island. Therefore, there is zero irony in my argument. i live in a nice area of LI with good schools. There is no arguing that. But anyway..................enough said.

Posted 2/18/11 7:36 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nicrae

Posted by MrsECullen7319

Posted by Jenhos

I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days.

I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off.

Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements.

Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain.

I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town?

My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up?

I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile)



ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1...



This blows my mind. You make it sound like all teachers are lazy and just doing the bare minimum. Really? How do you know? By your few experiences as a leave replacement before you couldn't handle it anymore and gave up???

We don't need to be "forced" to perform at our jobs. Most teachers bust their butts everyday "performing" for the kids, their parents, the administration, the state and every other know it all that has never been in a classroom.

It is very easy to say get rid of tenure when you don't have it. Usually people who say "get rid of tenure" don't understand what tenure truly is for.





Clearly you are a teacher, and since you got so DEFENSIVE over my post, I guess you may not be performing up to par! If you actually READ my words, you will see I specifically said "lots of older teachers" and I stand by what I said. I witnessed 1st hand comfortable teachers doing basically NOTHING with their students, handing out worksheets from 1980 to keep their class busy for the 40 minute period, and getting away with it b/c they were buddies with the administration... Tenure protects these teachers... Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe.

I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want.

Posted 2/18/11 9:55 PM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Tax Cap

I think that some of you need to familiarize yourself with the concept of tenure, how it originated and what it means. It does NOT mean we can't get fired. In fact, in my old school there were several "seasoned" teachers that were harassed and forced to resign/fired bc the principal did not like them- despite their tenure.

The tax cap will leave us with the same problems and an even bigger education crisis. Teachers are not the ones who put this country into debt.....

Posted 2/18/11 10:25 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

my taxes are 1 K a month and we can't manage w/ much more of an increase. I hope there is a tax cap. I feel like everyone's pay will be frozen, and pensions will be done away with. It happened in the private sector and it will have to happen here too. Our children won't suffer bc these teachers,cops etc need their jobs and won't be leaving (just like any private sector person) No one in the private sector has pensions anymore. The system is bankrupt!! my DH hasn't had a raise in 3 years so we know how it feels

Posted 2/18/11 10:34 PM
 
Pages: << 9 10 11 [12] 13 14
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Capital Gains Tax Aliking 9/14/05 12 Home
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home