Tax Cap
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 >> | |
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mom2aidan Posted by nrthshgrl I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less. Posted by juanvi I would talk with your sis about her experience with teaching large class sizes, but I think unless you have stood in front of 30 teens...elementary kids...whatever you really have no idea how difficult it is.. There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools. 30 middle schoolers? I am asking all of you to visit your school district and ask to observe for a day. Talk to your teachers. 30 middle schoolers is NOT feasible! My DD is in 4th grade, she has had as many as 28 kids in a class already. I am not saying that it is easy, maybe her teachers are above and beyond good, but she is getting a great education. This year her class happens to be an inclusion class so they make sure that class is smaller(only 22)I have no issue with it. I spend a fair amount of time up at our school and in her classroom every year. It can be loud and some are tougher than others but IT IS DO-ABLE. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:21 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Tax Cap When can I start chiming in that my tax money goes to help fund a war I don't agree with? |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mom2aidan Posted by CrankyPants Posted by juanvi As for Special Education, something also has to be done. No child left behind from a HS perspective makes no sense. While I agree that special ed is much better than it was years ago, forcing a student to pass a now" watered down" regent exam is not going to help. Like I said, I am talking on a HS level. The Special Ed department has more than doubled. Schools can't do much about it because it's law. I don't think it's fair for those who don't have children that require these services. I think those who don't have kids requiring these services should be satisfied with that and move along. Agreed. You haven't walked a mile in my shoes or in the shoes of these kids and if you are a special educator, I am really glad my kid won't be in your district. I agree! You don't think it's "fair" to children who don't need services???? I pay over 20,000 in taxes per year. That more than covers the cost of my son's services, and he has yet to step foot in a public school. What about families with 3/4/5+ children. I only have 2. Is it fair that I should have to pay for them? What about if my children go to private school? Should I have to pay for public school too? What about doing what is right for our children? Is life fair? What about the greater good? I don't think it's fair for you to say that! |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by Moehick Posted by MrsPowers I do agree with the original post that people need to educate themselves on the issue of a tax cap. There are so many more negative effects to this concept than were mentioned. Go to your Board of Education meetings or PTA meetings or whatever you need to do to inform yourself about it. There are certain things that school districts have to pay for just like we do such as heating cost, maintenance costs, utilities and etc... Teachers do pay for their pensions and health insurance. Also, take a look at recent contract negotions in recent years and in many districts teachers have taken pay freezes. As for the spending, many teachers would agree that thing like Ipads and etc are not necessary. Many teachers would be happy with a blackboard and chalk. Increasing class sizes is very detrimental to the educational system as is cutting extra curricular activities. How good will your school district look when a graduate is applying to colleges with no extra-curricular activities? The bottom line is it is the children that will suffer in this situation. There are numerous teachers across the area that are fearful for their jobs due to these budgetary issues and lack of state funding. Not to mention that the taxes we pay on Long Island do not always come back to Long Island directly. Where do people get the idea that teachers don't pay into health benefits and pension? If thats the case where is my $$ going from my paycheck? Money can be found in the millionaires tax, if implemented would bring in $1 billion this year and $5 billion next year to the state. "At the height of the fiscal crisis two years ago, staring down the barrel of a $20 billion budget gap, the state imposed an income-tax surcharge on New Yorkers earning more than $200,000 a year -- and called it a "millionaire's tax." I voted for it as a temporary solution, expecting that the economy would have turned the corner by now. But a tax isn't temporary if we keep re-authorizing it. Unfortunately, some of my colleagues want to do just that -- arguing that we should extend the tax before it expires this year. If the surcharge were truly a millionaire's tax, maybe it would be worth discussing. But since when do hard-working two-income middle-class families count as millionaires? And the surcharge hasn't even raised the revenue it was supposed to -- falling well short of the projected $4 billion a year." - Micah Kellner I don't think the answer is passing the buck. Your right. The answer is passing the buck only when it lands in a teachers lap. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Moehick Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by Moehick Posted by MrsPowers I do agree with the original post that people need to educate themselves on the issue of a tax cap. There are so many more negative effects to this concept than were mentioned. Go to your Board of Education meetings or PTA meetings or whatever you need to do to inform yourself about it. There are certain things that school districts have to pay for just like we do such as heating cost, maintenance costs, utilities and etc... Teachers do pay for their pensions and health insurance. Also, take a look at recent contract negotions in recent years and in many districts teachers have taken pay freezes. As for the spending, many teachers would agree that thing like Ipads and etc are not necessary. Many teachers would be happy with a blackboard and chalk. Increasing class sizes is very detrimental to the educational system as is cutting extra curricular activities. How good will your school district look when a graduate is applying to colleges with no extra-curricular activities? The bottom line is it is the children that will suffer in this situation. There are numerous teachers across the area that are fearful for their jobs due to these budgetary issues and lack of state funding. Not to mention that the taxes we pay on Long Island do not always come back to Long Island directly. Where do people get the idea that teachers don't pay into health benefits and pension? If thats the case where is my $$ going from my paycheck? Money can be found in the millionaires tax, if implemented would bring in $1 billion this year and $5 billion next year to the state. "At the height of the fiscal crisis two years ago, staring down the barrel of a $20 billion budget gap, the state imposed an income-tax surcharge on New Yorkers earning more than $200,000 a year -- and called it a "millionaire's tax." I voted for it as a temporary solution, expecting that the economy would have turned the corner by now. But a tax isn't temporary if we keep re-authorizing it. Unfortunately, some of my colleagues want to do just that -- arguing that we should extend the tax before it expires this year. If the surcharge were truly a millionaire's tax, maybe it would be worth discussing. But since when do hard-working two-income middle-class families count as millionaires? And the surcharge hasn't even raised the revenue it was supposed to -- falling well short of the projected $4 billion a year." - Micah Kellner I don't think the answer is passing the buck. Your right. The answer is passing the buck only when it lands in a teachers lap. If there is a way to lower taxes and not have teachers lose their jobs or have cutbacks, I'm all for it. I don't think taxing certain people more is the correct answer. Where is my incentive to make more money if it is just going to be taxed at a higher rate, especially if the "Millionaire Tax" hasn't worked so far. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Never did I say anyone shouldn't get what they need or deserve but if you put a tax cap in place the kids that have laws protecting them won't be as affected bc its law districts need to do what they have to to provide. That means there may not be anything left over for what all kids deserve including enrichment sports etc. Wasn't that the purpose of the thread? Tax cap? That's what it was in reference to. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 9:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by juanvi Posted by ChrisDee Posted by ChrisDee Posted by Jacksmommy First of all . . to assume that every kindergarten teacher, or every teacher in general gets paid 130,000 (or 122k) is absurd. Most do not. I agree that taxes are out of control - I am a taxpayer too. But as someone who has taught in both the city and Long Island there are plusses and minuses to each situation. Yes, the system is flawed sometimes. Aren't all systems flawed? Didn't the government just pay millions of dollars to bail out private banks? And then they go and do the same thing again. Don't you think your tax dollars are going towards that as well? Or if it is not, it will be! "Private sectors" aren't so great either! ETS: I do agree that something needs to be done. But I am not sure if bashing teachers is what needs to be done. Nobody has to guess or assume what they make it is public record. The longer they have been there they more they make. Enter your districts info in this link and get the facts: http://longisland.newsday.com/templates/simpleDB/?pid=164&brand=newsday&fieldSelect-schoolDistrict=Brookhaven-Comsewogue+Union+Free+Schools&searchField=schoolDistrict&q= Our 4 kindergarten teachers(in DD's school) make between $96,000 and 106,000. Our principal who is in her 4th year of her 1st principal job makes just under $125,000 Why should the principal should be paid less. You need a lot of education to be a principal and you're responsible for more than you can even imagine. The teachers who work on the island PAY TAXES. How much exactly should any of these educators be paid? This is NOT TRUE. Some teachers have LESS education than teachers with MA+60! Message edited 2011-02-17 23:06:22.453000. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 10:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Erica 1. I don't understand a cap of 2%. COLA is 3%. 2. Tier 5 was created last year. T5 teachers will pay into their pension every year they work. (T4 has to pay in 10 years). 3. Tenure does not mean that you will not get laid off. There are quite a few teachers in my district who are tenured and on the unemployment lines in September. With the tax cap in 2012, I will probably be there as well (I'm not a state mandated position) 4. I work in a very affluent community. We are next to a poor community. Most of the teachers I work with are all for combining districts. It comes down to all the Supers and Asst Supers. I'm not saying there should be one district for each county - but one per town makes sense. It's the residents who have the problem with combining. LI is so segregated it's repulsive. My coworker in Elwood has said that districts don't want to merge with them, b/c *gasp* they have a black neighborhood. Blame can go around past the teachers. 5. DH doesn't even have any type of degree and makes and will always make more than I do as a teacher. He gets much better raises than I ever do.
|
|
Posted 2/17/11 10:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by ChrisDee Posted by mom2aidan Posted by nrthshgrl I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less. Posted by juanvi I would talk with your sis about her experience with teaching large class sizes, but I think unless you have stood in front of 30 teens...elementary kids...whatever you really have no idea how difficult it is.. There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools. 30 middle schoolers? I am asking all of you to visit your school district and ask to observe for a day. Talk to your teachers. 30 middle schoolers is NOT feasible! My DD is in 4th grade, she has had as many as 28 kids in a class already. I am not saying that it is easy, maybe her teachers are above and beyond good, but she is getting a great education. This year her class happens to be an inclusion class so they make sure that class is smaller(only 22)I have no issue with it. I spend a fair amount of time up at our school and in her classroom every year. It can be loud and some are tougher than others but IT IS DO-ABLE. I agree - depending on the population and their skill level when they enter the class. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mom2aidan Posted by juanvi Posted by ChrisDee Posted by ChrisDee Posted by Jacksmommy First of all . . to assume that every kindergarten teacher, or every teacher in general gets paid 130,000 (or 122k) is absurd. Most do not. I agree that taxes are out of control - I am a taxpayer too. But as someone who has taught in both the city and Long Island there are plusses and minuses to each situation. Yes, the system is flawed sometimes. Aren't all systems flawed? Didn't the government just pay millions of dollars to bail out private banks? And then they go and do the same thing again. Don't you think your tax dollars are going towards that as well? Or if it is not, it will be! "Private sectors" aren't so great either! ETS: I do agree that something needs to be done. But I am not sure if bashing teachers is what needs to be done. Nobody has to guess or assume what they make it is public record. The longer they have been there they more they make. Enter your districts info in this link and get the facts: http://longisland.newsday.com/templates/simpleDB/?pid=164&brand=newsday&fieldSelect-schoolDistrict=Brookhaven-Comsewogue+Union+Free+Schools&searchField=schoolDistrict&q= Our 4 kindergarten teachers(in DD's school) make between $96,000 and 106,000. Our principal who is in her 4th year of her 1st principal job makes just under $125,000 This is NOT TRUE. Some teachers have LESS education than teachers with MA+60! Why should the principal should be paid less. You need a lot of education to be a principal and you're responsible for more than you can even imagine. The teachers who work on the island PAY TAXES. How much exactly should any of these educators be paid? I do not begrudge the teachers their salary, I think that they were VERY wise for choosing that path. I was merely stating a few facts and sharing some info. Telling people to get informed. We do not have a single teacher in our district that makes $150,000 like some people were saying. Our principal(who I happen to really like) did get a pay increase over the past 4 yrs from 103,000 to $125,000. People were saying that there are pay freezes and I am pointing out that obviously not in my school district. Our Superindentent(she just retired) on the other hand $462,000 I think that is total B.S.
|
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap I clicked the link and entered the school district I grew up in on LI. There were MANY teachers in the top 100-200 making well over 100k but guess what? I graduated from HS 23 years ago. Those teachers were not first year teachers when I had them - not even close. My second grade teacher makes $115. I had her in 1977. I think she's earned the right to command her salary. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by juanvi Never did I say anyone shouldn't get what they need or deserve but if you put a tax cap in place the kids that have laws protecting them won't be as affected bc its law districts need to do what they have to to provide. That means there may not be anything left over for what all kids deserve including enrichment sports etc. Wasn't that the purpose of the thread? Tax cap? That's what it was in reference to. Seriously? So - the "regular" kids sports are more important than my child's right to an EDUCATION? Everyone wants to B*TCH and moan about money and the cost of special needs kids. Why don't you pick on welfare recipients? How about that for a topic? Because we are investing in special needs children so they can support THEMSELVES in the future. And wake up - the law protects ALL KIDS - EVERYONE is entitled to a FREE EDUCATION - not free sports. You are in the wrong field.... |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by ChrisDee Posted by mom2aidan Posted by juanvi Posted by ChrisDee Posted by ChrisDee Posted by Jacksmommy First of all . . to assume that every kindergarten teacher, or every teacher in general gets paid 130,000 (or 122k) is absurd. Most do not. I agree that taxes are out of control - I am a taxpayer too. But as someone who has taught in both the city and Long Island there are plusses and minuses to each situation. Yes, the system is flawed sometimes. Aren't all systems flawed? Didn't the government just pay millions of dollars to bail out private banks? And then they go and do the same thing again. Don't you think your tax dollars are going towards that as well? Or if it is not, it will be! "Private sectors" aren't so great either! ETS: I do agree that something needs to be done. But I am not sure if bashing teachers is what needs to be done. Nobody has to guess or assume what they make it is public record. The longer they have been there they more they make. Enter your districts info in this link and get the facts: http://longisland.newsday.com/templates/simpleDB/?pid=164&brand=newsday&fieldSelect-schoolDistrict=Brookhaven-Comsewogue+Union+Free+Schools&searchField=schoolDistrict&q= Our 4 kindergarten teachers(in DD's school) make between $96,000 and 106,000. Our principal who is in her 4th year of her 1st principal job makes just under $125,000 Why should the principal should be paid less. You need a lot of education to be a principal and you're responsible for more than you can even imagine. The teachers who work on the island PAY TAXES. How much exactly should any of these educators be paid? I do not begrudge the teachers their salary, I think that they were VERY wise for choosing that path. I was merely stating a few facts and sharing some info. Telling people to get informed. We do not have a single teacher in our district that makes $150,000 like some people were saying. Our principal(who I happen to really like) did get a pay increase over the past 4 yrs from 103,000 to $125,000. People were saying that there are pay freezes and I am pointing out that obviously not in my school district. Our Superindentent(she just retired) on the other hand $462,000 I think that is total B.S.There was an error when I typed. My comment was: This is NOT TRUE. Some teachers have LESS education than teachers with MA+60! The previous poster wrote the other comment |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Jenhos I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days. I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off. Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements. Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain. I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town? My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up? I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile) ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1... |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Parents need to be prepared that if they don't want to pay such high taxes, special programs & extra curricular activities may be cut, and Im ok with that...the MAIN FUNCTION of a school is to be a place where children learn, not have fun! Message edited 2011-02-18 00:10:32.580000. |
|
Posted 2/17/11 11:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. I guess its a good thing you never named what districts you are talking about, I don't want to know if I live in one of those "lesser" districts. I am not sure where I will be purchasing a house, but I will make sure that when our baby is born, they doesn't go near those "lesser" districts. I may have to send them to private school, just in case one of the "better" districts goes downhill and becomes a "lesser" district. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... I think a previous poster had said that each town (town of babylon, town of hempstead, etc) should manage a district- to me, that makes MUCH more sense. Money savings has to come from everyone- not just teachers, not just administrators- but everyone. As a parent, I have to realize that certain things might be eliminated or changed... and I think I am OK with that. There is no free lunch. The state is broke and the counties are broke and the money has to come from somewhere... Either more money is raised by taxes or money is cut.. there is no other way around it... The tax cap may not work- but I think everyone has to have an open and honest dialog. I don't think people are anti-teachers... I think we all recognize the very important jobs teachers do. However it does seem to those of us in "industry" that the severity of the current economy isn't felt by teachers and other public-sector employees. Yes, at one time the trade off to being a "public" employee was that the pay was less but the benefits and pensions made up for it. That is no longer the case. Quite frankly, the median salary for many of the public sector jobs (not just teachers, but others) are above the median income of those of us in industry.. and therein lies the frustration. Those of us in industry- as stated above by previous posters- have been slammed.. no raises.. not for merit, not for COLA... increased health care costs. Reductions in 401k/retirement contributions.. the list goes on.. and for the majority of LI taxpayers, who come from industry, to absorb higher-and-higher property taxes- well it is frustrating.. we understand teachers and administrators pay taxes to, but that doesn't negate the fact that teachers/administrators/public sector employees make more money than most industry workers to begin with. I think everyone, as I said before- has to give a little. The solution cannot rest solely on the backs of one group. I think if everyone would come to the table in the spirit of working together and not pointing fingers, we'd be able to work out of this mess.. but everyone wants to keep what they have- administrators their very high salaries, teachers their banked sick pay (which I do not agree with- it should be use or lose like everywhere else) and the public their "pet" programs... it just can't go on.
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mom2aidan Posted by juanvi Never did I say anyone shouldn't get what they need or deserve but if you put a tax cap in place the kids that have laws protecting them won't be as affected bc its law districts need to do what they have to to provide. That means there may not be anything left over for what all kids deserve including enrichment sports etc. Wasn't that the purpose of the thread? Tax cap? That's what it was in reference to. Seriously? So - the "regular" kids sports are more important than my child's right to an EDUCATION? Everyone wants to B*TCH and moan about money and the cost of special needs kids. Why don't you pick on welfare recipients? How about that for a topic? Because we are investing in special needs children so they can support THEMSELVES in the future. And wake up - the law protects ALL KIDS - EVERYONE is entitled to a FREE EDUCATION - not free sports. You are in the wrong field.... not every child is gifted academically. but they excel in sports. it gives them self confidence, a sense of community, team. what if their parents can't afford them to join a team? these after school activities keep them out of trouble most of the time. plus, a lot of the teams do fundraisers. look at the rocky point cheerleaders in newsday. they fundraise for themselves AND others. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 5:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Jenhos I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days. I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off. Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements. Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain. I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town? My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up? I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile) ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1... When I first started teaching, I was in favor of getting rid of tenure. Now - there is no way. I have seen parents try to campaign to get rid of GOOD teachers who didn't give their kids the grades they wanted, I have watched administrators HARASS teachers they dislike - sometimes for personal reasons, in an attempt to get rid of them. You wouldn't believe what goes on. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 5:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Meaghan729 Posted by mom2aidan Posted by juanvi Never did I say anyone shouldn't get what they need or deserve but if you put a tax cap in place the kids that have laws protecting them won't be as affected bc its law districts need to do what they have to to provide. That means there may not be anything left over for what all kids deserve including enrichment sports etc. Wasn't that the purpose of the thread? Tax cap? That's what it was in reference to. Seriously? So - the "regular" kids sports are more important than my child's right to an EDUCATION? Everyone wants to B*TCH and moan about money and the cost of special needs kids. Why don't you pick on welfare recipients? How about that for a topic? Because we are investing in special needs children so they can support THEMSELVES in the future. And wake up - the law protects ALL KIDS - EVERYONE is entitled to a FREE EDUCATION - not free sports. You are in the wrong field.... not every child is gifted academically. but they excel in sports. it gives them self confidence, a sense of community, team. what if their parents can't afford them to join a team? these after school activities keep them out of trouble most of the time. plus, a lot of the teams do fundraisers. look at the rocky point cheerleaders in newsday. they fundraise for themselves AND others. I agree and I HATE the idea of getting rid of extracurricular sports BUT sports have to be cut BEFORE special education, and the PP implied in an earlier post that special education gets "too much" funding. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 5:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap My sister has a child in Harley and she says that in the beginning (have not asked her recently) that there was fundraiser all the time. Why do 5 year olds need to raise money? |
|
Posted 2/18/11 6:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. I guess its a good thing you never named what districts you are talking about, I don't want to know if I live in one of those "lesser" districts. I am not sure where I will be purchasing a house, but I will make sure that when our baby is born, they doesn't go near those "lesser" districts. I may have to send them to private school, just in case one of the "better" districts goes downhill and becomes a "lesser" district. Be real please. When anyone buys a house the quality of the school district is basically the number one factor in where you choose your home...............if you plan on having children of course. Being in a good district, which living on the island isn't hard to figure out where they are and if you don't know it's easy to find out, was our NUMBER ONE priority. Again, there's a reason why you pay more for a house and more in taxes for different towns on the island. I'm sure you have some idea of the quality of schools in your area now and when you do buy a house I can promise you, it will be the FIRST thing you consider because of your child who is on the way. DH and I have talked about moving OOS one day and if we do, the quality of schools in wherever else we look will be our NUMBER ONE concern before anything else. As I've stated many times, there is a reason I chose my house in the town I did and there was a reason why I was willing to pay more into my mortgage and taxes..............the school district. So yea, combining districts wouldn't really be something I would want to see. Sorry if that offends you.
Message edited 2011-02-18 07:43:37.350000. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 7:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by lipglossjunky73 When can I start chiming in that my tax money goes to help fund a war I don't agree with? In my field, I have first hand experience with budget cuts. Anyone who resents the education of special needs kids astounds me. We can cart them off to crappy, cheap programming now and then pay for that the rest of our taxpaying lives, or support them and teach them in their district programs, and remember we are part of a COMMUNITY. These are the kids you will see in your churches, local events, supermarkets, etc... Thank you! And what about the abuses of OT in our firehouses, police departments, MTA and so on. Our taxes pay for that too. We also like our garbage to be taken every Monday and Thursday, and for the snow to be plowed. Taxes pay for that too. We all recognze the need to hold accountable the people mananging our tax dollars. To me, those are the people in office, and the administrators (and super's) of our school districts. Do I like that my house is worth less then it was 3 years ago? No. Do I like that my taxes go up significantly anyway? No. But my DD is in a kindergarten class with 16 kids and an aid, and I will pay every last penny I have for that. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 8:24 AM
|
|
| Pages: << 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Gains Tax | Aliking | 9/14/05 | 12 | Home |
| Tax Free Week! | christy | 9/1/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free??? | momAGAIN | 8/29/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free week? | CarrieAnn | 8/28/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Tax question | checka | 8/26/05 | 3 | Home |
| tax question | Redhead | 6/17/05 | 6 | Home |










I think that is total B.S.



