Tax Cap
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 8 9 10 [11] 12 13 14 | |
|
Re: Tax Cap newsday has something on the LI districts but I can't access that site |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Ophelia people may hate me for saying this but I don't care...every time this argument comes up I SEARCH for this extra intelligence that these seemingly awesome school districts provide your children on these boards with all of you. and to be totally honest, you are all seemingly intelligent women and I cannot tell the difference between you. I have no idea who went where. unless you are ALL product of "the best" schools. I'm a product of the Great Neck School District, which is one of the best. My parents didn't buy a house there, or send me to school there, to show to the world how much money they had, or didn't have, but because they knew there were more resources available at this school district, which became all the more essential when I was identified as having a learning disability. In my opinion, it is that population of students, those with disabilities, who are impacted the most by the kind of resources available at each school district. And, I see it everyday in the work I do, as my office investigates complaints of discrimination, 70% of which are based on disability discrimination, in our public schools. I can say definitively it is those school districts that are lacking resources that are faltering with our special education kids, and that's the population that all too often fall through the cracks. These kids need intense services, well-trained specialists, and a slew of resources that many school districts simply cannot provide. I was a lucky one - although I had a fairly severe learning disability, I went to one of the best public schools in the Country, in which I was provided 3 hours of intense, INTENSE, individual one-on-one services each and every single day for 3 years, with various trained specialists. Without that, I don't know where I would have landed. Message edited 2011-02-18 12:06:39.717000. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Pumpkin1 Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by Ophelia where do you get statistics about how many students to go college from each district and I guess what types of colleges they get in to? I am insanely curious now!!!!! I just make it up & state it as fact. I know I saw that information when I was looking for a home. Maybe it was at www.mlsli.com? Newsday has rankings & puts the percentage of regents diplomas. I also think there may be a column for % going to ivy league. Knowing the kids that went to ivy league schools in my high school, I'd say it's still a toss up if it equates success. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap I'm coming into this late. As a result, I'm not sure how much to say because I don't want to fuel a fire that might have been put out. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Tax Cap Posted by JennP I'm coming into this late. As a result, I'm not sure how much to say because I don't want to fuel a fire that might have been put out. At the same time, I have to mention that I am tired of some people looking at the benefits of teaching in a vacuum. Some people mentioned the raises that come with getting advanced degrees. What is never mentioned is that, for most districts that I know of, that is the ONLY way to get a raise other than cost of living. In the private sector, companies can give raises to anyone they feel like giving to, at any time. In teaching, it is different - our raises are tied to a pay scale. We are not saying it's worse. We are not saying it's better. We are saying - well, I am saying - please don't look at the positive without looking at the negative as well. I am a career changer. When I was in corporate, I got a $10,000 raise because my boss knew I was about to jump ship and he really wanted to keep me. I did not HAVE to get a degree to get that raise. I did nothing other than what I had been doing all long. Yes, I had to work hard. But so do teachers. My point is that there is an advantage to the lack of a pay scale in the private sector: you are not "limited" by it. Oh, and when I left my private sector job, I was making more than $20,000 MORE than I make as a teacher even though I needed LESS education (BA v. MA) to do my job. to this, the ONLY thing I want to say is this teaching for a municipality is a CIVIL SERVICE job. and generally speaking people go in to the civil service for many reasons, but a competitive salary is not one of them. you are not supposed to be able to compare the apples of the private sector to the oranges of the civil service. in MY office, working for the fed govt, we have a huge number of Ivy League attorneys here. Ivy league college and ivy league law school. if anyone feels like it, go look up what a GS-13 makes in the federal govt. or look it up under the admin schedule. we have higher educated attorney's here making less than 100k. the govt is CHOCK FULL of highly educated under paid people. it's the other benefits...or the "common good" thing that keep them here. I feel like certain professions have lost sight of that. not just teachers, but I do feel like it is an issue. |
Posted 2/18/11 12:17 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Tax Cap Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by Pumpkin1 Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by Ophelia where do you get statistics about how many students to go college from each district and I guess what types of colleges they get in to? I am insanely curious now!!!!! I just make it up & state it as fact. I know I saw that information when I was looking for a home. Maybe it was at www.mlsli.com? Newsday has rankings & puts the percentage of regents diplomas. I also think there may be a column for % going to ivy league. Knowing the kids that went to ivy league schools in my high school, I'd say it's still a toss up if it equates success. I have many friends that graduated from the NYCPS and vent to ivy league. a weird number actually. I am probably the least educated person I know.
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Ophelia Posted by JennP I'm coming into this late. As a result, I'm not sure how much to say because I don't want to fuel a fire that might have been put out. At the same time, I have to mention that I am tired of some people looking at the benefits of teaching in a vacuum. Some people mentioned the raises that come with getting advanced degrees. What is never mentioned is that, for most districts that I know of, that is the ONLY way to get a raise other than cost of living. In the private sector, companies can give raises to anyone they feel like giving to, at any time. In teaching, it is different - our raises are tied to a pay scale. We are not saying it's worse. We are not saying it's better. We are saying - well, I am saying - please don't look at the positive without looking at the negative as well. I am a career changer. When I was in corporate, I got a $10,000 raise because my boss knew I was about to jump ship and he really wanted to keep me. I did not HAVE to get a degree to get that raise. I did nothing other than what I had been doing all long. Yes, I had to work hard. But so do teachers. My point is that there is an advantage to the lack of a pay scale in the private sector: you are not "limited" by it. Oh, and when I left my private sector job, I was making more than $20,000 MORE than I make as a teacher even though I needed LESS education (BA v. MA) to do my job. to this, the ONLY thing I want to say is this teaching for a municipality is a CIVIL SERVICE job. and generally speaking people go in to the civil service for many reasons, but a competitive salary is not one of them. you are not supposed to be able to compare the apples of the private sector to the oranges of the civil service. I feel like certain professions have lost sight of that. not just teachers, but I do feel like it is an issue. That is what I was trying to say. I hope I was clear.
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Ophelia people may hate me for saying this but I don't care...every time this argument comes up I SEARCH for this extra intelligence that these seemingly awesome school districts provide your children on these boards with all of you. and to be totally honest, you are all seemingly intelligent women and I cannot tell the difference between you. I have no idea who went where. unless you are ALL product of "the best" schools. I'm a product of the Great Neck School District, which is one of the best. My parents didn't buy a house there, or send me to school there, to show to the world how much money they had, or didn't have, but because they knew there were more resources available at this school district, which became all the more essential when I was identified as having a learning disability. In my opinion, it is that population of students, those with disabilities, who are impacted the most by the kind of resources available at each school district. And, I see it everyday in the work I do, as my office investigates complaints of discrimination, 70% of which are based on disability discrimination, in our public schools. I can say definitively it is those school districts that are lacking resources that are faltering with our special education kids, and that's the population that all too often fall through the cracks. These kids need intense services, well-trained specialists, and a slew of resources that many school districts simply cannot provide. I was a lucky one - although I had a fairly severe learning disability, I went to one of the best public schools in the Country, in which I was provided 3 hours of intense, INTENSE, individual one-on-one services each and every single day for 3 years, with various trained specialists. Without that, I don't know where I would have landed. first I want to say that I have NO idea why your parents chose Great Neck. I don't talk with them on an LI chat board every day of the week and haven't read their comments to threads like this to say second, I want to say that there are many other schools and school systems that provide for learning disabilities and I would imagine someone in your position and with your vantage point would not see the benefit in opening up these programs and giving these changes/advantages to learning disabled kids in the town next to you, or two towns away who needs it but who's parents cannot afford great neck taxes. |
Posted 2/18/11 12:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Ophelia second, I want to say that there are many other schools and school systems that provide for learning disabilities and I would imagine someone in your position and with your vantage point would not see the benefit in opening up these programs and giving these changes/advantages to learning disabled kids in the town next to you, or two towns away who needs it but who's parents cannot afford great neck taxes. Absolutely - I agree - I think it's a tremendous disservice that only certain schools, with a certain degree of resources, provide these kind of services, and that each student with a disability deserves an equal, fair opportunity to succeed by receiving the exact services they need. I'm just trying to show the reason why people choose certain school districts over others - not that they necessarily produce "smarter" or "better" students, but rather, they have more resources available to better serve their students, particularly certain populations who need more resources than others. I'm not saying, however, that this is fair - and I strongly, STRONGLY disagree with this model, which is exactly why I do the work I do, so I can teach those school districts who DON'T have the resources, what they need to know to provide the best services they can to the students who need them. I don't know what the solution is, but from my vantage point, the current model is not working. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 12:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by JennP Posted by Ophelia Posted by JennP I'm coming into this late. As a result, I'm not sure how much to say because I don't want to fuel a fire that might have been put out. At the same time, I have to mention that I am tired of some people looking at the benefits of teaching in a vacuum. Some people mentioned the raises that come with getting advanced degrees. What is never mentioned is that, for most districts that I know of, that is the ONLY way to get a raise other than cost of living. In the private sector, companies can give raises to anyone they feel like giving to, at any time. In teaching, it is different - our raises are tied to a pay scale. We are not saying it's worse. We are not saying it's better. We are saying - well, I am saying - please don't look at the positive without looking at the negative as well. I am a career changer. When I was in corporate, I got a $10,000 raise because my boss knew I was about to jump ship and he really wanted to keep me. I did not HAVE to get a degree to get that raise. I did nothing other than what I had been doing all long. Yes, I had to work hard. But so do teachers. My point is that there is an advantage to the lack of a pay scale in the private sector: you are not "limited" by it. Oh, and when I left my private sector job, I was making more than $20,000 MORE than I make as a teacher even though I needed LESS education (BA v. MA) to do my job. to this, the ONLY thing I want to say is this teaching for a municipality is a CIVIL SERVICE job. and generally speaking people go in to the civil service for many reasons, but a competitive salary is not one of them. you are not supposed to be able to compare the apples of the private sector to the oranges of the civil service. I feel like certain professions have lost sight of that. not just teachers, but I do feel like it is an issue. That is what I was trying to say. I hope I was clear. While I understand what you are saying, there are so many times in the private sector where there are no raises for years and years. Pay cuts even. Benefits are a luxury to some, retirement is something that never gets funded in the private sector. I did not get an increase this year. Year before yes, year before that no. Most people in my ginormous firm this year took pay cuts. That will never happen in the school system. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 2:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap No offense, I don't think anybody on this board truly understands the full effects of what is going on. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Buongiorno No offense, I don't think anybody on this board truly understands the full effects of what is going on. And everyone is writing their opinion as if it were facts and they go so far as to even argue with other posters about why they are right. Consolidating districts??? Do you really know what effect it will have? You cannot compare districts that are already consolidated to ours- We would have to completely change our system, which, I would like to know if anyone has data to show what would happen if this were to come true. Bashing teachers? Seriously, people rant on this board about how teachers are making more than 150,000, because someone's "neighbor's sister's friend knows someone who is a teacher that makes that much". And to the poster that everyone bashed because she said she didn't want to consolidate schools because she purposely picked her school district for a reason and labeled it as a "better school district." Can you blame her? She's thinking of the value of her home, how the fact the price of homes depends on what school district your child goes to. Wouldn't you want to protect the value of your home too? And doesn't everyone realize that we can put all of this negative energy towards what really matters- how we got into this mess to begin with. And no, it is not because of the taxes we pay for the schools. We have seemed to ignore the real reason but instead we continue to focus so much negative energy on this topic (is it easier to argue? Is that the reason?). Imagine what could happen if we put all of this energy into finding out the real reason we are in this mess and having them fix it. so what is the real reason? what is going on that so many people fail to grasp? and teachers salaries are public knowlege. they aren't pulling them out of their arses, they are pulling them off a website. |
Posted 2/18/11 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Buongiorno No offense, I don't think anybody on this board truly understands the full effects of what is going on. And everyone is writing their opinion as if it were facts and they go so far as to even argue with other posters about why they are right. Consolidating districts??? Do you really know what effect it will have? You cannot compare districts that are already consolidated to ours- We would have to completely change our system, which, I would like to know if anyone has data to show what would happen if this were to come true. Bashing teachers? Seriously, people rant on this board about how teachers are making more than 150,000, because someone's "neighbor's sister's friend knows someone who is a teacher that makes that much". And to the poster that everyone bashed because she said she didn't want to consolidate schools because she purposely picked her school district for a reason and labeled it as a "better school district." Can you blame her? She's thinking of the value of her home, how the fact the price of homes depends on what school district your child goes to. Wouldn't you want to protect the value of your home too? And doesn't everyone realize that we can put all of this negative energy towards what really matters- how we got into this mess to begin with. And no, it is not because of the taxes we pay for the schools. We have seemed to ignore the real reason but instead we continue to focus so much negative energy on this topic (is it easier to argue? Is that the reason?). Imagine what could happen if we put all of this energy into finding out the real reason we are in this mess and having them fix it. I read this to the end thinking you were going to have the reason. lol |
|
Posted 2/18/11 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by bicosi Posted by Buongiorno No offense, I don't think anybody on this board truly understands the full effects of what is going on. And everyone is writing their opinion as if it were facts and they go so far as to even argue with other posters about why they are right. Consolidating districts??? Do you really know what effect it will have? You cannot compare districts that are already consolidated to ours- We would have to completely change our system, which, I would like to know if anyone has data to show what would happen if this were to come true. Bashing teachers? Seriously, people rant on this board about how teachers are making more than 150,000, because someone's "neighbor's sister's friend knows someone who is a teacher that makes that much". And to the poster that everyone bashed because she said she didn't want to consolidate schools because she purposely picked her school district for a reason and labeled it as a "better school district." Can you blame her? She's thinking of the value of her home, how the fact the price of homes depends on what school district your child goes to. Wouldn't you want to protect the value of your home too? And doesn't everyone realize that we can put all of this negative energy towards what really matters- how we got into this mess to begin with. And no, it is not because of the taxes we pay for the schools. We have seemed to ignore the real reason but instead we continue to focus so much negative energy on this topic (is it easier to argue? Is that the reason?). Imagine what could happen if we put all of this energy into finding out the real reason we are in this mess and having them fix it. I read this to the end thinking you were going to have the reason. lol Me too... lol |
|
Posted 2/18/11 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but... |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Buongiorno No offense, I don't think anybody on this board truly understands the full effects of what is going on. And everyone is writing their opinion as if it were facts and they go so far as to even argue with other posters about why they are right. Consolidating districts??? Do you really know what effect it will have? You cannot compare districts that are already consolidated to ours- We would have to completely change our system, which, I would like to know if anyone has data to show what would happen if this were to come true. Bashing teachers? Seriously, people rant on this board about how teachers are making more than 150,000, because someone's "neighbor's sister's friend knows someone who is a teacher that makes that much". And to the poster that everyone bashed because she said she didn't want to consolidate schools because she purposely picked her school district for a reason and labeled it as a "better school district." Can you blame her? She's thinking of the value of her home, how the fact the price of homes depends on what school district your child goes to. Wouldn't you want to protect the value of your home too? And doesn't everyone realize that we can put all of this negative energy towards what really matters- how we got into this mess to begin with. And no, it is not because of the taxes we pay for the schools. We have seemed to ignore the real reason but instead we continue to focus so much negative energy on this topic (is it easier to argue? Is that the reason?). Imagine what could happen if we put all of this energy into finding out the real reason we are in this mess and having them fix it. Reason????? In reality. People are not getting the income they used to have, don't get raises, lost jobs = they just can't pay more taxes. That's really that just plain and simple. Yet, BOTH sides will have to make a compromise. Money does not grow on tree (I know... I tried!!!) and parents will have to deal with cuts in some areas. So if we have to cut little Johnny's football practice, well.....that's what it's going to have to be. Because let's face it, it's nice to have those extra curriculum activities but they are not "essential" education to be honest. And maybe little Johnny's parents will have to pay the bill for football practice. And if they cannot pay it, well... that's life! And maybe when the economy gets back on it's feet and everything goes back to "the way it was", then maybe little Johnny's school will be able to offer those extra curriculum classes. Yes, little Johnny's will be pis$$ed off that he cannot do the sport he wants to do. The parents will be pi$$ed off that the school is not supporting his hopeful NFL career but it's unrealistic to think that someone gets a cut in pay so that little Johnny's keeps playing football. And maybe it will be the way it used to be in the old days and in other States. Your parents pay for those stuff. The rich kids will do whatever activities they want, the rest will be play football at the playground with the kids in the neigborhood. Meanwhile, the County staff will have to get a grip on reality too. People lost their job, income, bonuses. Don't blame them for not keep saying yes to tax increase. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by juanvi [/QUO second, I want to say that there are many other schools and school systems that provide for learning disabilities and I would imagine someone in your position and with your vantage point would not see the benefit in opening up these programs and giving these changes/advantages to learning disabled kids in the town next to you, or two towns away who needs it but who's parents cannot afford great neck taxes. From what i understand, a child will be bussed to a neighboring district if they need certain services that their particular district doesn't provide. That's correct! Special needs services are really different from the regular SD "rules" people know. Not all SD have special needs or they can't offer services for some disabilities hence why they might go to special needs schools, other districts. I will be honest and say that I am not the most partial person when it comes to special needs but I understand that people might not support us. Yet if it was reversed I could not understand anyone (even if my kid was typical) supporting a sporting activity vs. a child needing special needs. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by Ophelia [the thing I love about NYC public schools as an ATTENDEE of them (I have no teaching experience whatsoever obviously) is that you can go to ANY school at the high school level, based on your MERIT. it doens't matter where you live, who your parents are or how much house they can buy or how much taxes they can pay. it's not about THEIR badge. it's about yours. ETD: for spelling. To piggyback off of this THIS is one of the reason DH and I are hesitant to leave our area of Queens. I am NYC schooled. I grew up upper middle class, some might even say "rich". I went to school with children of ALL economic backgrounds. All races. All religions. It was the BEST and most important part of my education. I would HATE to deny my children that and if I moved to a town in LI where my kids went to their district-- I would. Flame away but I am a better,more informed person bc of my diverse education. And m parents COULD have afforded to send me anywhere. I am OBVIOULSY in support of combining districts 10000% agree. I am a product of NYC public schools as is DH and all of my BFFs. We all do well for ourselves. Some of us better than others but we are all very comfortable. Plenty of the HS kids I graduated with also are doing very well for themselves. I am super hesitant to move out of NYC for this reason. I love the diversity not only when it comes to race/religion/socioeconomic backgrounds but also the diversity that NYC as a city offers. Someone brought up something to the effect of having to give up football/cheerleading and have no activities like NYC public schools. Honestly, while my NYC HS school didn't have the "traditional" cheerleading and football we did have opportunities to internship for major companies like Deloitte and Chase bank as part of our HS experience. That to me is more valuable than football but then to each his own. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Buongiorno Consolidating districts??? Do you really know what effect it will have? You cannot compare districts that are already consolidated to ours- We would have to completely change our system, which, I would like to know if anyone has data to show what would happen if this were to come true. No one knows the full impact of what consolidating will entail. I did go to the board meeting & listened to Daniel Porter, the merger consultant hired by Elwood School Board, even though I live in a neighboring district. While you say "we would completely have to change our system", budgets are not going to pass. Each school district WILL lose & will be on austerity. I believe this cap will be going through. One thing they mentioned at the meeting is that historically we have never had both a governor & NYS congress on the same page regarding property caps. This is the first time, they are. He outlined the laws regarding consolidation and mergers. It was pretty interesting & given the state aid that would be given for a merger it does sound like the only opportunity to save those additional extracurricular activies. Under current law, each merging district would receive 40% of their 2006-2007 formula operating aid for five years. Thereafter, that amount would decrease by 4% per year for the next 9 years. For Elwood, the incentive amount for the 14-year period would be $15 million, not counting the savings to the other district. Source - although I was there & the article only touches on a fraction of what was discussed...mainly the bleeding heart, save our community side. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MamaLeen Posted by BriBri2u Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Seriously, so obnoxious. Oh please stop. There is nothing obnoxious about it. I am not wealthy. I don't live in the "best" area on the island but I live in a nice area. Do I think I am entitled to a high quality education for my child because of where I live? Of course. If I didn't I wouldn't have bought a house where I did, for the price I paid, and for the taxes it costs me. The fact is, to live in a nicer district it costs money and you cannot just combine districts without it causing a ripple effect. Everything would be affected, the quality of education, the house values, the property taxes and so on and so forth. Look, be offended as you want. The reality of the world is that there is no equal opportunity for all. It's a nice idea, it's not a reality. Those with more are afforded more opportunities. Those who can afford to live in a good district do and they pay for it in the house prices and tax bills. It's really that simple. What's to get offended at?
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by melbalalala Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but... I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole. So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do? Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation? Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here It would absolutely 100% affect the house values here. The school district you're zoned for has a big impact on the worth of your house and what you pay in taxes. Depending what district you are in could either save you or cost you thousands upon thousands of dollars. And to say the quality of education wouldn't change is really not true. How can it not? Many things would change but my biggest concern would be what happens to the value of my house and my taxes? I paid significantly more for my house than I would had I chosen to live in a different town on the island and I pay more in taxes because of it so for me, I have a problem with the idea that someone who paid less for their home and pays less in taxes would also be a part of my school district. I just don't agree with it and I don't think it's a valid solution to any problem we're having. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsECullen7319 Parents need to be prepared that if they don't want to pay such high taxes, special programs & extra curricular activities may be cut, and Im ok with that...the MAIN FUNCTION of a school is to be a place where children learn, not have fun! Also, the way I understand it, is that honors classes are useless...AP classes are beneficial, but there is no reason to have an honors program AND an AP program in school...Either your child is smart enough to take AP classes and earn college credit, or not...and then the regular Regents class should be fine... You can enroll your child in other sports teams, dance school, or music programs,not school related on your own dime if you choose...taxpayers should not be forced to fund your child's extracurricular activities in times like these... Some districts just offer WAY to much, and should cut some things to save money in times like these... Honors classes are useless? I'm sorry, but I've taught honors classes and regents classes. To me, tracking is necessary. We need to provide education to those who are going to change the way our country is run in the future..not lump them all together in one huge heap. What's funny, is that technically "gifted ed" falls under the category of special ed..yet it is so often ignored by the school districts. As for the difference between districts? I've taught at some of the lower schools on LI and some of the top ones. The difference, to me, is how the PARENTS are involved in their child's education. I provide the same education; parents often pay more for the "extras" in a district. And if people are willing to pay to be in a better district, why begrudge them? If you have the money, it entitles you to certain privileges. End of story, and this will never change; unless, of course, we become a socialist/communist society.... |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by MamaLeen Posted by BriBri2u Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. This is such an obnoxious post...if this is the attitude of a "better sd" area - you can keep it This is a great example of how money really makes people think they are better than others just because they have. Again Seriously, so obnoxious. Oh please stop. There is nothing obnoxious about it. I am not wealthy. I don't live in the "best" area on the island but I live in a nice area. Do I think I am entitled to a high quality education for my child because of where I live? Of course. If I didn't I wouldn't have bought a house where I did, for the price I paid, and for the taxes it costs me. The fact is, to live in a nicer district it costs money and you cannot just combine districts without it causing a ripple effect. Everything would be affected, the quality of education, the house values, the property taxes and so on and so forth. Look, be offended as you want. The reality of the world is that there is no equal opportunity for all. It's a nice idea, it's not a reality. Those with more are afforded more opportunities. Those who can afford to live in a good district do and they pay for it in the house prices and tax bills. It's really that simple. What's to get offended at? You're complaining in one thread about your "overpriced, stupid house" and in this one you're going on about how much you paid and your good school district and neighborhood.. which is it? |
|
Posted 2/18/11 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 5:00 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 8 9 10 [11] 12 13 14 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Gains Tax | Aliking | 9/14/05 | 12 | Home |
| Tax Free Week! | christy | 9/1/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free??? | momAGAIN | 8/29/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free week? | CarrieAnn | 8/28/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Tax question | checka | 8/26/05 | 3 | Home |
| tax question | Redhead | 6/17/05 | 6 | Home |













