Tax Cap

Posted By Message
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 >>

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26


As with any large system, there are flaws and problems. How do you fix it? I don't have all the answers but I know that whining about what a teacher makes won't solve anything. Again, teacher salaries are but a part of the overall tax picture and school budget.




Ignoring teacher salaries, do you (collective you) agree that a superintendent making $462k a year, is a little overkill? Maybe THIS is where change needs to start.

Message edited 2011-02-17 16:28:22.610000.

Posted 2/17/11 4:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by Hofstra26

This whole uproar over teacher salaries is so old. Teachers on the island make a decent salary, get over it. And for the record, most of my friends are teachers, as am I, and none of us have made or are making six figures and some of my friends have been teaching 15 years or more now. Most teachers who do make a six figure salary have been in the system for quite some time and is it really that outlandish that after 15-20 years of working and having an advanced degree and doing a ton of professional development someone should have a six figure salary? I don't understand the argument that teachers should be paid cr@p. Do you fault a doctor, lawyer, engineer, or whomever for making a decent wage? Teachers are also professionals with advanced degrees and should be treated and paid as such.

First, nobody would be where they are today with a great teacher who helped get them there. Second, all anyone does is rant on and on about a teachers salary and the number of days off with NO understanding or what exactly goes into teaching. Lesson plans don't write themselves. The amount of paperwork on a daily basis that is required on top of the teaching and planning that HAS to be done each day is ludicrous. The demands of parents, administrators, and students is constant. And work doesn't stop at 3:30 when the bell rings. Every teacher I know spends A LOT of time outside of school every day grading papers, doing report cards, planning lessons, preparing materials and more. My DH who makes more than twice what I did as a teacher gets to come home at 6:00 and relax while I was stuck in the couch working all night. I'm not complaining, it's the nature of the job, but I hate hearing how teachers have it sooooo easy.

Seriously, I'm just sick of the teacher backlash. It's such bull$hit. Enough already. For all those who aren't teachers, you should have NO comment. Nobody comments of what goes into your job or what you make or what your vacation time looks like so unless you're a teacher in the system and you have a clue you should have no comment. Are their cr@py teachers in the system? Of course.........jut as their are cr@ppy useless people in every job and profession in America but they make up the minority, not the majority. The majority of teachers bust their a$$ so YOUR child is getting the education they deserve and as such, they deserve to make a decent wage just as anybody else in America does. Why shouldn't I be paid well? I work hard, I have a Masters, I do professional development, and I have years of experience. Sorry but in my book, that all accounts for something.

And to expect performance pay in a profession such as teaching would never work. Other people can be assessed on PERSONAL performance but as a teacher your ability to reach and teach EVERY kid that ever crosses your path is affected by 5,000 factors outside of your control. I taught in Flushing, we had an 80%, ESL population (English as a Second Language population) so I CANNOT be held accountable if my class of 35 students, half of which BARELY spoke a word of English, can't perform on the ELA test. How can I make up a language deficit? How can I make up for parents who don't care, who don't work with their kids at home, for being in a school with minimal resources???? I busted my a$$ when I was teaching and by all rights I deserved MORE than I was making and raises too but it doesn't always work that way.

Taxes $uck, we all have to deal with that. But don't be so naive to think that all of that money is going into outlandish teacher salaries. You know all those extra curricular programs you just love for your kids? Or all those fun sports they get to partake in? Or how about your clean, nice, well maintained school buildings your child is in all day? Guess what?.............tax money. Teacher salaries are but a small part of the big tax picture and if you want to continue to have good school districts with great teachers and lots of programs and activities then it comes at a premium. It's just the way it is. You don't like it?..................then move. I mean really, crying over what teachers make is flat out dumb. It's whiny and unproductive and isn't the real problem here. Enough already. Chat Icon Chat Icon



I think all taxpayers have a right to complain about something involved with our money. You may not like it, but that is tough. We all know what goes into being a teacher because every teacher I know reminds me all the time. Maybe things have changed in school, but I am one of 6 kids, and my siblings and I all had the same teachers in k-8th grade. My older siblings were able to tell me what projects certain teachers were going to make me do and I was able to inform my younger siblings the same. Their "teaching plans" didn't change. I could understand if it was one or two teachers in the school, but it was every teacher.



School is NOTHING like it used to be when we were kids. Trust me. Even being a teacher I thought I knew what it would be like when I was entering into the profession but it's not the educational system I remember as a kid in the 80's/90's. Gone are the days of dittos and projects. The focus in school is different, the teaching techniques are different, and the teaching philosophies are very different. Any teacher today would agree for sure! Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 4:27 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by neener1211

Posted by Hofstra26


As with any large system, there are flaws and problems. How do you fix it? I don't have all the answers but I know that whining about what a teacher makes won't solve anything. Again, teacher salaries are but a part of the overall tax picture and school budget.




Ignoring teacher salaries, do you (collective you) agree that a superintendent making $452k a year, is a little overkill? Maybe THIS is where change needs to start.



Yes. Absolutely. I do think a half million dollar salary is quite absurd for sure. They deserve a nice salary but $500K/yr is really quite outrageous and I do agree with you on that. Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 4:30 PM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by neener1211

Posted by Hofstra26


As with any large system, there are flaws and problems. How do you fix it? I don't have all the answers but I know that whining about what a teacher makes won't solve anything. Again, teacher salaries are but a part of the overall tax picture and school budget.




Ignoring teacher salaries, do you (collective you) agree that a superintendent making $462k a year, is a little overkill? Maybe THIS is where change needs to start.



Agreed...If Cuomo is the governor of NY and he is making $179k, why should people looking over school districts make more?

Posted 2/17/11 4:32 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by mommy2bella

Posted by Hofstra26


It's whiny and unproductive and isn't the real problem here. Enough already. Chat Icon Chat Icon



What is the real problem?? And how do you propose to fix it so not everyone has to move?



As with any large system, there are flaws and problems. How do you fix it? I don't have all the answers but I know that whining about what a teacher makes won't solve anything. Again, teacher salaries are but a part of the overall tax picture and school budget.




Actually the overt teachers salaries are more than 33% of the budget in my town....and admin and other staffing is another God knows how much because they bury so much of it in lines I can barely decipher.....all budgets are posted online.

I have every right to question it when we keep hearing all of the doomsday plans that we hear from the top of our country to the mayoral town election that is dividing my tiny town now. It's not whining...it's concern over what kind of Long Island we will have in 20 years.

Posted 2/17/11 4:33 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by mommy2bella

you are being defensive because you are a teacher and I get that....I am sorry that this is a time where teachers seem to be the blame for all the ills of the world. It is an unenviable situation. And yes, you may be right about inconsistencies on these sites...but they are darn close.

How do YOU think we should change things?

My dad is a retired cop and his benefits are great....but the pensions for them ALSO are BREAKING THE BANK in our small communities. There is a reason the state took fiscal control of Nassau County....WE ARE BROKE.



I do not live or work in LI but I will say that I agree that the districts need to be consolidated. That would save an enourmous amount of money and would be a good start.

I think though that many parents would not like their district combined w/ a "not desirable district" and things of that nature, this is my guess as to why it is not done and one of the reasons for the high taxes.

I DO get defensive when people like Slurpeedad makes accusations about how teachers don't change lesson plans from year to year Chat Icon , make too much $$, are always talking about ALL the schooling they needed to do to become a teacher.

DUDE your name is slurpeeDAD I assume that means you have KIDS right? Unless you are homeschooling them you better hope their teachers are better than your expectation bc if not you are going to have some problems with your kids.

Message edited 2011-02-17 16:38:42.147000.

Posted 2/17/11 4:34 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

1. I don't understand a cap of 2%. COLA is 3%.

2. Tier 5 was created last year. T5 teachers will pay into their pension every year they work. (T4 has to pay in 10 years).

3. Tenure does not mean that you will not get laid off. There are quite a few teachers in my district who are tenured and on the unemployment lines in September. With the tax cap in 2012, I will probably be there as well (I'm not a state mandated position)

4. I work in a very affluent community. We are next to a poor community. Most of the teachers I work with are all for combining districts. It comes down to all the Supers and Asst Supers. I'm not saying there should be one district for each county - but one per town makes sense.

It's the residents who have the problem with combining. LI is so segregated it's repulsive. My coworker in Elwood has said that districts don't want to merge with them, b/c *gasp* they have a black neighborhood.


Blame can go around past the teachers.


5. DH doesn't even have any type of degree and makes and will always make more than I do as a teacher. He gets much better raises than I ever do.


Message edited 2011-02-17 17:48:53.880000.

Posted 2/17/11 4:38 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by mommy2bella

you are being defensive because you are a teacher and I get that....I am sorry that this is a time where teachers seem to be the blame for all the ills of the world. It is an unenviable situation. And yes, you may be right about inconsistencies on these sites...but they are darn close.

How do YOU think we should change things?

My dad is a retired cop and his benefits are great....but the pensions for them ALSO are BREAKING THE BANK in our small communities. There is a reason the state took fiscal control of Nassau County....WE ARE BROKE.



I do not live or work in LI but I will say that I agree that the districts need to be consolidated. That would save an enourmous amount of money and would be a good start.

I think though that many parents would not like combined w/ a "not desirable district" and things of that nature, this is my guess as to why it is not done and one of the reasons for the high taxes.

I DO get defensive when people like Slurpeedad makes accusations about how teachers don't change lesson plans from year to year Chat Icon , make too much $$, are always talking about ALL the schooling they needed to do to become a teacher.

DUDE your name is slurpeeDAD I assume that means you have KIDS right? Unless you are homeschooling them you better hope their teachers are better than your expectation bc if not you are going to have some problems with your kids.



I truly do try and see if from both sides, and I hope that comes across. Like I said, there is no way I would be able to be a teacher nowadays, I see what my sister and friends go through, but everyone has to come together. No solution isn't an option anymore. There is nowhere to hide...doomsday is arriving and it appears that it will only get worse.

Posted 2/17/11 4:39 PM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by mommy2bella

you are being defensive because you are a teacher and I get that....I am sorry that this is a time where teachers seem to be the blame for all the ills of the world. It is an unenviable situation. And yes, you may be right about inconsistencies on these sites...but they are darn close.

How do YOU think we should change things?

My dad is a retired cop and his benefits are great....but the pensions for them ALSO are BREAKING THE BANK in our small communities. There is a reason the state took fiscal control of Nassau County....WE ARE BROKE.



I do not live or work in LI but I will say that I agree that the districts need to be consolidated. That would save an enourmous amount of money and would be a good start.

I think though that many parents would not like combined w/ a "not desirable district" and things of that nature, this is my guess as to why it is not done and one of the reasons for the high taxes.

I DO get defensive when people like Slurpeedad makes accusations about how teachers don't change lesson plans from year to year Chat Icon , make too much $$, are always talking about ALL the schooling they needed to do to become a teacher.

DUDE your name is slurpeeDAD I assume that means you have KIDS right? Unless you are homeschooling them you better hope their teachers are better than your expectation bc if not you are going to have some problems with your kids.



I am not a father yet, but will be later this year. I do hope their teachers are better then I expect, shouldn't we all?

I didn't make an accusation, I stated a fact from when I went to school. I didn't say that teachers are always talking about all the schooling they need, I said how they talk about how hard they work all the time. I apologize if that didn't come out clear. Everyone works hard, we don't need to hear it all the time.

Posted 2/17/11 4:42 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by mommy2bella
I truly do try and see if from both sides, and I hope that comes across. Like I said, there is no way I would be able to be a teacher nowadays, I see what my sister and friends go through, but everyone has to come together. No solution isn't an option anymore. There is nowhere to hide...doomsday is arriving and it appears that it will only get worse.



You come across as someone who respects educators but is rightly concerned about taxes, school budgets etc.

I do not claim to have all the answers but NYC is not broke.

Teachers make a little less, there are 5 regions and I believe 30 districts.

BUT many people I know WANT TO live in LI bc they want the small class size that NYC does not generally offer and the extra services that many schools in NYC do not offer. These things cost money.

NYC spends MUCH less per general ed pupil than I would guess almost all districts in LI.

But obvioulsy NO parent is going to agree to cutting the spending on THEIR kid, right? (not blaming them! just sayin') eta: and there are many things that factor in to pupil spending not just salaries.

And then no one wants Jericho combined with Roosevelt (totally pulled a "good" and "bad" district out of the air here for arguments sake Chat Icon )

SOOO we are left to complain about teachers salaries Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-02-17 16:46:40.660000.

Posted 2/17/11 4:45 PM
 

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: Tax Cap

I understand that teachers work hard and an argument can be made that they deserve these very high salaries. (I still feel $100k+ for a gym teacher, regardless of experience, is a lot, but that is just personal opinion).

However, I think that given the horrible economic climate and the precarious situation our schools are in, it would be worth considering the following:

1. eliminate pensions. most private companies have already done so because the companies could no longer afford it. these pensions take up a large chunk of the $$$ and in my opinion, employees making six figure salaries with great benefits can save for their own retirement like everyone else. obviously this would need to be phased out over time, it we should move towards this model. i think there is likely a lot of pension abuse as well, and eliminating pensions would help there and free up more money for the schools/students

2. eliminate automatic pay increases from contracts that mandate raises regardless of economic climate and the needs of the schools. raises can be common practice if the money is there, but it seems silly that certain professions are getting automatic 5% or 10% raises in a terrible recession when the private sector is taking pay cuts. hopefully this would eliminate some layoffs and keep class size lower

it's tough when the system promises X and Y and Z in contracts that can't be broken, and has to squeeze more and more out of taxpayers to fill in the gaps, tugging at heartstrings on an emotional and polarizing issue that dubs everyone "not caring about the children" if they don't blindly hold out their wallets. the entitlements of pensions and automatic raises may have been appropriate at some point but I think cutting those for the future is a better and more practical solution than laying off hundreds of teachers, cutting back on the quality of education, or raises taxes even more. the same should be true for admin...

Posted 2/17/11 4:47 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by mommy2bella

you are being defensive because you are a teacher and I get that....I am sorry that this is a time where teachers seem to be the blame for all the ills of the world. It is an unenviable situation. And yes, you may be right about inconsistencies on these sites...but they are darn close.

How do YOU think we should change things?

My dad is a retired cop and his benefits are great....but the pensions for them ALSO are BREAKING THE BANK in our small communities. There is a reason the state took fiscal control of Nassau County....WE ARE BROKE.



I do not live or work in LI but I will say that I agree that the districts need to be consolidated. That would save an enourmous amount of money and would be a good start.

I think though that many parents would not like combined w/ a "not desirable district" and things of that nature, this is my guess as to why it is not done and one of the reasons for the high taxes.

I DO get defensive when people like Slurpeedad makes accusations about how teachers don't change lesson plans from year to year Chat Icon , make too much $$, are always talking about ALL the schooling they needed to do to become a teacher.

DUDE your name is slurpeeDAD I assume that means you have KIDS right? Unless you are homeschooling them you better hope their teachers are better than your expectation bc if not you are going to have some problems with your kids.



I am not a father yet, but will be later this year. I do hope their teachers are better then I expect, shouldn't we all?

I didn't make an accusation, I stated a fact from when I went to school. I didn't say that teachers are always talking about all the schooling they need, I said how they talk about how hard they work all the time. I apologize if that didn't come out clear. Everyone works hard, we don't need to hear it all the time.



The only reason you hear it all the time is because teachers are constantly called out on these boards. If nobody said a word about our salaries the way nobody says anything about the salaries of other professions you would never have to hear a teacher defend how hard they work.

I agree with you 100%, everyone works hard and nobody should have to explain to anyone else just how hard they work. Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 4:49 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

I agree with you 100%, everyone works hard and nobody should have to explain to anyone else just how hard they work. Chat Icon



Except for administrators making $462k.Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 4:52 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by neener1211

Posted by Hofstra26


As with any large system, there are flaws and problems. How do you fix it? I don't have all the answers but I know that whining about what a teacher makes won't solve anything. Again, teacher salaries are but a part of the overall tax picture and school budget.




Ignoring teacher salaries, do you (collective you) agree that a superintendent making $462k a year, is a little overkill? Maybe THIS is where change needs to start.



Agreed...If Cuomo is the governor of NY and he is making $179k, why should people looking over school districts make more?




Some of these Administrators make more then the President of the United States Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 4:53 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Hofstra26

The only reason you hear it all the time is because teachers are constantly called out on these boards. If nobody said a word about our salaries the way nobody says anything about the salaries of other professions you would never have to hear a teacher defend how hard they work.

I agree with you 100%, everyone works hard and nobody should have to explain to anyone else just how hard they work. Chat Icon




The different between teachers salaries and the salaries of those in private industry is WE, taxpayers, pay the teachers salaries. I dont pay the persons salary working for Verizon or Goldman Sachs. Their salary, benefits and pensions aren't coming out of my pocket.

Posted 2/17/11 4:55 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Mommy2Boys

Posted by Hofstra26

The only reason you hear it all the time is because teachers are constantly called out on these boards. If nobody said a word about our salaries the way nobody says anything about the salaries of other professions you would never have to hear a teacher defend how hard they work.

I agree with you 100%, everyone works hard and nobody should have to explain to anyone else just how hard they work. Chat Icon




The different between teachers salaries and the salaries of those in private industry is WE, taxpayers, pay the teachers salaries. I dont pay the persons salary working for Verizon or Goldman Sachs. Their salary, benefits and pensions aren't coming out of my pocket.



I get that, I am stuck with high taxes too but why do you think you pay so much in taxes? Good districts come at a cost. You want good teachers and good programs and good schools???..........then unfortunately it hits your wallet. I don't like paying thousands of dollars a year in taxes but I sure like that my DD will be in a GREAT school district! You get what you pay for.

Posted 2/17/11 5:03 PM
 

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I have a right to complain when $10000 of my $15000 is going to schools and more than half is for salaries and a 1/4 for health benefits. I work for NYC and will not get a pay increase for years to come.

I want my district to merge to save money.

Also, I don't complain when I have to go to work in snow storms because I have a job to do (had to put that in).

Posted 2/17/11 5:09 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by hanna7636

I have a right to complain when $10000 of my $15000 is going to schools and more than half is for salaries and a 1/4 for health benefits. I work for NYC and will not get a pay increase for years to come.

I want my district to merge to save money.

Also, I don't complain when I have to go to work in snow storms because I have a job to do (had to put that in).



Really? You really want your district to merge? This won't be "PC" to say but that's the last thing I would want. I have NO interest in having my district combined with another district, especially a lesser district. There is a reason I broke the bank on a $480K house and I pay $9K/yr in taxes. I pay to have a GREAT school district, it's the reason we bought in the town we did. I could've bought a cheaper house in a lesser district but I wanted better for my DD. I would NOT want my district to be combined, not at all. Sorry, but it's the truth.

Posted 2/17/11 5:17 PM
 

LemonHead
Sour Girl

Member since 3/08

5271 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by faithann

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by faithann

Posted by Meaghan729
I got an MBA and my job didn't say "good for you here is $10K more". and many of us in the private sector do not have pensions and great medical.



Your job in the private sector (perks, benefits, drawbacks and all) was YOUR choice.




Nobody is complaining about our choices, we are just done paying for teachers pensions.



Commenting that your boss doesn't give raises for earning an MBA sounds like a complaint to me. In my opinion, a comment like that weakens the poster's previous argument.

I understand that you are sick of paying for teacher's pensions. I get it. What about the other government employees whose pensions you are paying? You don't mind paying theirs? They deserve their pensions, but teachers don't?

There is so much misinformation and armchair quarterbacking about education on these boards- it's ridiculous. I don't know any gym teacher that makes over 150k- unless they're now a superintendent. I wish people would do their research instead of jumping on the teacher-hating bandwagon that most people on this site seem to be on.

School taxes go to much more than just teacher's pensions. Most of the schools on the island are 50+ years old- school taxes also go to repairs, heating costs, electric, busing students to multiple schools, maintaining the grounds, etc. Go to the board meetings and see what they actually discuss. My guess is that you've never been. If you did, your argument would be a whole lot stronger than just "We're done paying for teacher's pensions."






I don't have an MBA, nor did I say that my boss doesn't give raises for them. I may have said that my wife would not be GUARANTEED a raise if she got her MBA.

Just because you don't know any gym teachers that make that much money, doesn't mean that it isn't the case. Seethruny.net is a wonderful thing and an eye opener to everyone.

I don't think tax payers should be funding ANY pensions. The topic started with teachers, and that is where it has stayed, but I have issues with people getting taxed for public employees pensions while we have to foot the bill for our own.

You are picking one comment I made and trying to base your entire argument against it. Read back other statements before you jump down my throat.



Maybe YOU should reread the other statements. The first part of my reply was directed towards Meagan's statement about her MBA/boss. You know, the one you defended? When you jumped down my throat first?

You said she wasn't complaining about her choices, I said an argument like that weakens a poster's previous argument. Not yours.

Seethruny should not be anyone's only source of information. It is filled with incorrect information. I am not the first poster to point that out. When I hear of a gym teacher making over 150k and that's the source, I'm not going to buy it. And neither does any other teacher I know.

The only point (or argument) I'm trying to make is to do your research. There are some very worthwhile things that your school taxes are being spent on. Find out what they are instead of obsessing over what a gym teacher makes per year.






Posted 2/17/11 5:24 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Could someone tell my kids' teachers that dittos are passe & they shouldn't be using them? The amount of dittos & packets coming home is ridiculous - and as for the lesson plans, it doesn't change year to year. My kids are two years apart & it hasn't changed.

Posted by Erica

4. I work in a very affluent community. We are next to a poor community. Most of the teachers I work with are all for combining districts. It comes down to all the Supers and Asst Supers. I'm not saying their should be one district for each county - but one per town makes sense.

It's the residents who have the problem with combining. LI is so segregated it's repulsive. My coworker in Elwood has said that districts don't want to merge with them, b/c *gasp* they have a black neighborhood.

Blame can go around past the teachers.



I believe most teachers are for merging districts to save money. I do believe they get the dire straits that their districts are in. As I said I was at the Elwood School Board meeting. The "savings" on administration doesn't sound like it's going to happen if they're making one super a building principal. Doubt they'll be lowering the salary.

As for the *gasp* neighborhood surrounding Elwood, there is gang activity in South Huntington - including a shooting near the elementary school. While I'm not in Elwood School District, I could completely understand the concern.

Posted 2/17/11 5:28 PM
 

LemonHead
Sour Girl

Member since 3/08

5271 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Katareen

I've read several Newsday articles about districts giving iPads to elementary/middle school students. What good is this doing? I find ridiculous moves like this to be a complete waste of taxpayer money. While this is just a small example, I'm sure there is much more unnecessary spending that isn't as publicized.




Unless you've researched the budget for this specific district, don't assume that this is taxpayer money being used to purchase iPads- the money for things like this comes from special state grants.

Posted 2/17/11 5:32 PM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by faithann

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by faithann

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by faithann

Posted by Meaghan729
I got an MBA and my job didn't say "good for you here is $10K more". and many of us in the private sector do not have pensions and great medical.



Your job in the private sector (perks, benefits, drawbacks and all) was YOUR choice.




Nobody is complaining about our choices, we are just done paying for teachers pensions.



Commenting that your boss doesn't give raises for earning an MBA sounds like a complaint to me. In my opinion, a comment like that weakens the poster's previous argument.

I understand that you are sick of paying for teacher's pensions. I get it. What about the other government employees whose pensions you are paying? You don't mind paying theirs? They deserve their pensions, but teachers don't?

There is so much misinformation and armchair quarterbacking about education on these boards- it's ridiculous. I don't know any gym teacher that makes over 150k- unless they're now a superintendent. I wish people would do their research instead of jumping on the teacher-hating bandwagon that most people on this site seem to be on.

School taxes go to much more than just teacher's pensions. Most of the schools on the island are 50+ years old- school taxes also go to repairs, heating costs, electric, busing students to multiple schools, maintaining the grounds, etc. Go to the board meetings and see what they actually discuss. My guess is that you've never been. If you did, your argument would be a whole lot stronger than just "We're done paying for teacher's pensions."






I don't have an MBA, nor did I say that my boss doesn't give raises for them. I may have said that my wife would not be GUARANTEED a raise if she got her MBA.

Just because you don't know any gym teachers that make that much money, doesn't mean that it isn't the case. Seethruny.net is a wonderful thing and an eye opener to everyone.

I don't think tax payers should be funding ANY pensions. The topic started with teachers, and that is where it has stayed, but I have issues with people getting taxed for public employees pensions while we have to foot the bill for our own.

You are picking one comment I made and trying to base your entire argument against it. Read back other statements before you jump down my throat.



Maybe YOU should reread the other statements. The first part of my reply was directed towards Meagan's statement about her MBA/boss. You know, the one you defended? When you jumped down my throat first?

You said she wasn't complaining about her choices, I said an argument like that weakens a poster's previous argument. Not yours.

Seethruny should not be anyone's only source of information. It is filled with incorrect information. I am not the first poster to point that out. When I hear of a gym teacher making over 150k and that's the source, I'm not going to buy it. And neither does any other teacher I know.

The only point (or argument) I'm trying to make is to do your research. There are some very worthwhile things that your school taxes are being spent on. Find out what they are instead of obsessing over what a gym teacher makes per year.





Wow, I make one comment about a gym teacher and I am "obsessing." I had follow up comments when questions were asked. I did not get the gym teachers salary through seethroughny though, but it was validated there. You can believe what you want to believe, but I go by numbers that I can actually look up.

Posted 2/17/11 5:33 PM
 

DaisyGirl
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1650 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by jasmine


2. eliminate automatic pay increases from contracts that mandate raises regardless of economic climate and the needs of the schools. raises can be common practice if the money is there, but it seems silly that certain professions are getting automatic 5% or 10% raises in a terrible recession when the private sector is taking pay cuts. hopefully this would eliminate some layoffs and keep class size lower



I don't know of any teachers who are getting 5-10% pay increases or any district where this has ever happened. Most teachers are taking little to no pay raises because of everything that is going on financially.

Posted 2/17/11 5:34 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Tax Cap

So who is FOR merging? bc it seems to me THIS would help to solve some of fiscal problems.

I think that Hofstra's HONEST answer probably is shared by the majority which is why the taxes won't change.

Posted 2/17/11 5:37 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl

The "savings" on administration doesn't sound like it's going to happen if they're making one super a building principal. Doubt they'll be lowering the salary.




I don't know the specifics of the deal, but my thoughts are that one building principal will now be out of a job (so that's some money saved), but in the long run, this guy will eventually retire and a much smaller salary will take his place.


As for the *gasp* neighborhood surrounding Elwood, there is gang activity in South Huntington - including a shooting near the elementary school.



I think you mean Huntington schools? Jack Abrams? I haven't heard of any shootings in S Huntington, but could have missed it. Huntington is not one of the districts that Elwood reached out to.

I was talking about the opposite situation. Harborfields residents rejected an Elwood merger in the 90's because of the area between Park, Broadway, Manor and Little Plains. Even Elwood, a district that people rate well, is attacked.

Posted 2/17/11 5:45 PM
 
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Capital Gains Tax Aliking 9/14/05 12 Home
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home