Tax Cap
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 10 11 12 [13] 14 | |
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by nicrae Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Jenhos I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days. I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off. Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements. Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain. I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town? My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up? I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile) ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1... This blows my mind. You make it sound like all teachers are lazy and just doing the bare minimum. Really? How do you know? By your few experiences as a leave replacement before you couldn't handle it anymore and gave up??? We don't need to be "forced" to perform at our jobs. Most teachers bust their butts everyday "performing" for the kids, their parents, the administration, the state and every other know it all that has never been in a classroom. It is very easy to say get rid of tenure when you don't have it. Usually people who say "get rid of tenure" don't understand what tenure truly is for. Clearly you are a teacher, and since you got so DEFENSIVE over my post, I guess you may not be performing up to par! If you actually READ my words, you will see I specifically said "lots of older teachers" and I stand by what I said. I witnessed 1st hand comfortable teachers doing basically NOTHING with their students, handing out worksheets from 1980 to keep their class busy for the 40 minute period, and getting away with it b/c they were buddies with the administration... Tenure protects these teachers... Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe. I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want. How many of these teachers did you actually see. I can't see many being in a school with the expectations of the NCLB laws and all of the testing mandates. And. . . If the administration is allowing that to happen, it is part of the problem. I do also need to say tenure DOES NOT mean you can NEVER be fired. There are ways to go about firing a teacher. However, the catch 22 is the DISTRICTS don't want to spend the time and money to do it. This is called a 3020A. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:39 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Tax Cap I must be living in a great area because a lot of you are talking about how much your taxes have DOUBLED. I have been living in my nassau house for almost 4 years and my taxes are pretty stagnant. There have been minor increases, but this year, my escrow even went down. I question the validity of some of your statements that have said that in a few short years your taxes have doubled. Again, you pay to live in a premium environment. My DH gladly moved out here, after being a product of NYC schools because the education/educational opportunities he received there was far inferior to the education/extracurricular opportunities I received. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Moehick Long Island is a truly racist society. Here "good" equals white and "bad" equals any color that is not white. It is truly sickening but you can look at the home board when people recommend good and bad towns and think about what comes to mind. The segregation here is appalling. I am all for consolidation. I was at my DD's kindergarten registration and they are reporting a class size of 83, that is ridiculous. Consolidation with the towns around us would save the taxpayers so much $$$$. The town next to me is one of the few on LI experiencing an increased enrollment but people balk at the idea of integration because it is deemed "bad." Nothing will change here until attitudes change. ![]() AMEN! Finally someone else who GETS it... And I will say it again- my DD goes to what many here would consider a lesser district- and this district HAS ap classes HAS extra curricular activities, winning sports teams, musicals, etc... They have ALL the things that make up a "good" district- but they are 60-70% non white.. and therein makes it bad. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Jacksmommy Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by nicrae Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Jenhos I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days. I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off. Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements. Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain. I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town? My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up? I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile) ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1... This blows my mind. You make it sound like all teachers are lazy and just doing the bare minimum. Really? How do you know? By your few experiences as a leave replacement before you couldn't handle it anymore and gave up??? We don't need to be "forced" to perform at our jobs. Most teachers bust their butts everyday "performing" for the kids, their parents, the administration, the state and every other know it all that has never been in a classroom. It is very easy to say get rid of tenure when you don't have it. Usually people who say "get rid of tenure" don't understand what tenure truly is for. Clearly you are a teacher, and since you got so DEFENSIVE over my post, I guess you may not be performing up to par! If you actually READ my words, you will see I specifically said "lots of older teachers" and I stand by what I said. I witnessed 1st hand comfortable teachers doing basically NOTHING with their students, handing out worksheets from 1980 to keep their class busy for the 40 minute period, and getting away with it b/c they were buddies with the administration... Tenure protects these teachers... Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe. I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want. How many of these teachers did you actually see. I can't see many being in a school with the expectations of the NCLB laws and all of the testing mandates. And. . . If the administration is allowing that to happen, it is part of the problem. I do also need to say tenure DOES NOT mean you can NEVER be fired. There are ways to go about firing a teacher. However, the catch 22 is the DISTRICTS don't want to spend the time and money to do it. This is called a 3020A. I can think of at least 4 teachers in 1 MS...one taught AIS classes, 2 taught resource room, and one taught home economics...and they were all pretty useless when it came to actually teaching the students. None of these teachers were accountable for students tests scores, and all of them had been teaching for YEARS and years & making lots of $$ to basically babysit for 40 minutes...maybe they were great effective teachers in their prime, and maybe that is why the admin liked them enough to not notice their lack of effectiveness now, but I see this as a HUGE problem and WASTE of money. They should be being observed just as much as new teachers, and getting "pop-in" visits which tenured teachers rarely got in this district. AND this is what a lot of posters would consider a higher, wealthier district... |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Nifheim Benefits - I am a state employee and i pay into all my benefits. So should teachers and cops (and my family is filled with cops.) I just wanted to comment on this. I am a teacher and my husband is a police officer. We BOTH have to pay into our benefits. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Sassyz75 Posted by Moehick Long Island is a truly racist society. Here "good" equals white and "bad" equals any color that is not white. It is truly sickening but you can look at the home board when people recommend good and bad towns and think about what comes to mind. The segregation here is appalling. I am all for consolidation. I was at my DD's kindergarten registration and they are reporting a class size of 83, that is ridiculous. Consolidation with the towns around us would save the taxpayers so much $$$$. The town next to me is one of the few on LI experiencing an increased enrollment but people balk at the idea of integration because it is deemed "bad." Nothing will change here until attitudes change. ![]() AMEN! Finally someone else who GETS it... And I will say it again- my DD goes to what many here would consider a lesser district- and this district HAS ap classes HAS extra curricular activities, winning sports teams, musicals, etc... They have ALL the things that make up a "good" district- but they are 60-70% non white.. and therein makes it bad. My mom teaches in a very poor school district. Usually, they recieve a lot of state money/grants/aid to have the programs that other districts do. However, I would NEVER want to bring a child up in her district. Call me a racist if you will (and my child is "non-white". There is a TREMENDOUS amount of gang activity, drug use, weapon carrying, and violence. While I do see some of this in the district I teach in, it is not as blatant as hers and can be avoided. There is also more of an effort to reduce these activities in my school district (and I do not by ANY means teach in a "good" school district. I have seen it bashed on here MANY times) How many children live in the projects in the city and are unfortunately, drawn into a life of crime because of their environment. And while I do think that is a problem, I personally do not know what the solution is. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 10:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. ITA w hofstra |
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Jacksmommy Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by nicrae Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Jenhos I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days. I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off. Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements. Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain. I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town? My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up? I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile) ITA! And if they did away with tenure, teachers would be forced to perform or lose their jobs. I taught (part-time & leave replacements) for 2 years & saw lots of older teachers,who make the big bucks, skirt by with barely planning lessons,while I was busting my behind...I quit teaching because I became so frustrated with district politics, and entitled parents...But, if there was no tenure, they could replace these older burnt out teachers, and hire 2 or 3 teachers for the price of 1... This blows my mind. You make it sound like all teachers are lazy and just doing the bare minimum. Really? How do you know? By your few experiences as a leave replacement before you couldn't handle it anymore and gave up??? We don't need to be "forced" to perform at our jobs. Most teachers bust their butts everyday "performing" for the kids, their parents, the administration, the state and every other know it all that has never been in a classroom. It is very easy to say get rid of tenure when you don't have it. Usually people who say "get rid of tenure" don't understand what tenure truly is for. Clearly you are a teacher, and since you got so DEFENSIVE over my post, I guess you may not be performing up to par! If you actually READ my words, you will see I specifically said "lots of older teachers" and I stand by what I said. I witnessed 1st hand comfortable teachers doing basically NOTHING with their students, handing out worksheets from 1980 to keep their class busy for the 40 minute period, and getting away with it b/c they were buddies with the administration... Tenure protects these teachers... Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe. I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want. How many of these teachers did you actually see. I can't see many being in a school with the expectations of the NCLB laws and all of the testing mandates. And. . . If the administration is allowing that to happen, it is part of the problem. I do also need to say tenure DOES NOT mean you can NEVER be fired. There are ways to go about firing a teacher. However, the catch 22 is the DISTRICTS don't want to spend the time and money to do it. This is called a 3020A. I can think of at least 4 teachers in 1 MS...one taught AIS classes, 2 taught resource room, and one taught home economics...and they were all pretty useless when it came to actually teaching the students. None of these teachers were accountable for students tests scores, and all of them had been teaching for YEARS and years & making lots of $$ to basically babysit for 40 minutes...maybe they were great effective teachers in their prime, and maybe that is why the admin liked them enough to not notice their lack of effectiveness now, but I see this as a HUGE problem and WASTE of money. They should be being observed just as much as new teachers, and getting "pop-in" visits which tenured teachers rarely got in this district. AND this is what a lot of posters would consider a higher, wealthier district... I will say it again. . .that is a problem with administration. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap
|
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsECullen7319 .there are very few other jobs where you will basically never get fired nomatter what...and if districts CAN fire tenured teachers...why does it NEVER happen??? Because the teacher's unions are powerful,and they will come to bat for even the WORST teachers, and like you said, the districts won't be bothered to waste the time or money to go through the process of trying to fire a tenured teacher. Im not alone in my opinion on tenure...and I know that getting rid of teacher tenure will not solve the tax problems, but I do think it would be a step in the right direction of fixing some of the problems with public education in this state/country... ITA |
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by brownie Posted by MrsECullen7319 .there are very few other jobs where you will basically never get fired nomatter what...and if districts CAN fire tenured teachers...why does it NEVER happen??? Because the teacher's unions are powerful,and they will come to bat for even the WORST teachers, and like you said, the districts won't be bothered to waste the time or money to go through the process of trying to fire a tenured teacher. Im not alone in my opinion on tenure...and I know that getting rid of teacher tenure will not solve the tax problems, but I do think it would be a step in the right direction of fixing some of the problems with public education in this state/country... ITA Haven't there been quite a few instances where police have been involved in wrongful shootings but don't get fired due to their job protection? |
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Moehick Posted by brownie Posted by MrsECullen7319 .there are very few other jobs where you will basically never get fired nomatter what...and if districts CAN fire tenured teachers...why does it NEVER happen??? Because the teacher's unions are powerful,and they will come to bat for even the WORST teachers, and like you said, the districts won't be bothered to waste the time or money to go through the process of trying to fire a tenured teacher. Im not alone in my opinion on tenure...and I know that getting rid of teacher tenure will not solve the tax problems, but I do think it would be a step in the right direction of fixing some of the problems with public education in this state/country... ITA Haven't there been quite a few instances where police have been involved in wrongful shootings but don't get fired due to their job protection? That may be true...but I know plenty of cops, and have heard many stories about cops who do lose their jobs...I heard one just recently about a cop losing their job after getting in a hit and run while off duty...I believe wrongful shootings are investigated, and if they are proven accidental than maybe the cops are protected(as they should be!)...this is completely different from a 57 year old teacher sitting around all day every day doing nothing and collecting 6 figures...if cops sit around and do nothing all day (like Im sure a few of them do, especially on LI), then they too should lose their jobs! And I HATE to compare cops & teachers...they are 2 completely different jobs...a teacher's job can be VERY hard, but is very rarely a life or death situation... Message edited 2011-02-19 00:00:53.177000. |
|
Posted 2/18/11 11:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap I have a question about consolidating districts. What would happen to all of the extra supers, assistants, etc? Instead of laying off the teachers, why don't all of these people whose jobs overlap get laid off? And how exactly would consolidating districts save money (I apologize if it's already been answered, I read yesterday and can't remember)? |
|
Posted 2/19/11 12:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Jacksmommy Posted by Sassyz75 Posted by Moehick Long Island is a truly racist society. Here "good" equals white and "bad" equals any color that is not white. It is truly sickening but you can look at the home board when people recommend good and bad towns and think about what comes to mind. The segregation here is appalling. I am all for consolidation. I was at my DD's kindergarten registration and they are reporting a class size of 83, that is ridiculous. Consolidation with the towns around us would save the taxpayers so much $$$$. The town next to me is one of the few on LI experiencing an increased enrollment but people balk at the idea of integration because it is deemed "bad." Nothing will change here until attitudes change. ![]() AMEN! Finally someone else who GETS it... And I will say it again- my DD goes to what many here would consider a lesser district- and this district HAS ap classes HAS extra curricular activities, winning sports teams, musicals, etc... They have ALL the things that make up a "good" district- but they are 60-70% non white.. and therein makes it bad. My mom teaches in a very poor school district. Usually, they recieve a lot of state money/grants/aid to have the programs that other districts do. However, I would NEVER want to bring a child up in her district. Call me a racist if you will (and my child is "non-white". There is a TREMENDOUS amount of gang activity, drug use, weapon carrying, and violence. While I do see some of this in the district I teach in, it is not as blatant as hers and can be avoided. There is also more of an effort to reduce these activities in my school district (and I do not by ANY means teach in a "good" school district. I have seen it bashed on here MANY times) How many children live in the projects in the city and are unfortunately, drawn into a life of crime because of their environment. And while I do think that is a problem, I personally do not know what the solution is. I agree we are not talking poor vs affluent districts, but "bad" districts are dangerous. I didn't choose my district based on the color of the people but the safety of the people |
|
Posted 2/19/11 5:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by mosh913 Posted by nrthshgrl I agree that something has to be done to cap property taxes. Right now, school districts are looking to combine - which - from the meetings I've attended sound like the fiscally responsible thing to do. Elwood School District will need to cut EVERY extracurricular activity, all electives, shorten the high school day & increase the elementary class sized to 30. Northport School District is fighting LIPA's tax challenge, which if successful will be impact every resident of Northport & East Northport. With the economy the way it is now, you can't get blood from a stone. Taxpayers are...well taxed. Laid off, underemployed taxpayers are facing some serious economic challenges & managing taxes is one of them. I don't know what the answers are but I do know something needs to be done. Thousands of teachers will be laid off on LI if this tax cap passes. Is anybody thinking about a rippling effect??? Like an above poster stated, how much money is it going to save you a year? Is it worth compromising your child's education? Even if you don't have children, this is our future. I'm a homeowner myself, and sure I hate LI taxes. I'm also a teacher and I'm going to lose my house if I lose my job Me too. I am VERY scared for my families future next year. We would be in forclosure VERY quickly if I get laid off next year. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 5:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by jasmine I didnt realize kindergarten teachers make $150k! I'm not in a position to judge whether they deserve it but with the hours and vacation schedule I definitely picked the wrong career I work for a well paid district and NO ONE makes 150 K!!! There may be two teachers in the whole school who make 120K but, they are both very close to retirement. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 5:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Think this is basically the whole thing about this post...if there is not a take cap my school taxes might go up 14%. I pay $10000 in school taxes so that is $1400 a year. Where am I getting this extra money? I already work 2 extra saturdays a month but the money I make goes to pay a babysitter. My husband or myself will not see a raise in years. Gas prices are going up and I just heard cotton prices are going up. Something needs to change on Long Island. Message edited 2011-02-19 06:21:43.847000. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 6:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap there's so much myth and misinformation on this thread, i don't even know where to start, but here goes: Posted by MrsECullen7319 Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe. I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want. those crazy parents are exactly the problem with eliminating tenure. sometimes it amazes me how quickly the PTA can stir up a witch hunt because a teacher refuses to inflate grades or give the frenzied, entitled mob whatever unreasonable concession it's demanding. if a teacher could bank on job security based on performance i'd agree with you, but this just isn't how schools work. Message edited 2011-02-19 07:31:24.563000. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 7:03 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by bookworm there's so much myth and misinformation on this thread, i don't even know where to start, but here goes: * teachers pay into their benefits just like everybody else. in my district it's the upper administration that has 100% employer contribution for health. * most teachers pay into the retirement system. as another poster said, tier 4 contributes for the first 10 years. that was amended, and new teachers (tier 5) pay their whole career. the folks breaking the retirement system are baby boomers who don't contribute and are all retiring at the same time, and sorry folks, you can't welch on an agreement that was made 30 years ago and that people planned their lives around. i'd also like to point out that the retirement system was heavily invested in the stock market, so in many ways, greedy BANKERS broke it. * someone said they don't complain about what Verizon workers make because they don't pay their salaries. excuse me, but who does? the salary fairy? customers pay those salaries--paying for a service, not all that different from school taxes, which are still lower than tuition at a private school. * i get really tired when people pull out this mythical ineffective gym teacher making 6 figures and then act like that's everyone and blame that for the broken system. you could fire that guy and still have the same problem. most teachers work really hard. most teachers don't make 6 figures. the ineffective ones that need to be removed are few and far between. * this notion that people with more money shouldn't expect a better education for their kids is absurd. this is a capitalist nation; that's how it works. the state provides a basic, free and public education. people in wealthier neighborhoods exercise their democratic rights when they agree to pay higher taxes to provide their children with added opportunities. this is the reward for working hard in life (educating yourself, sinking energy into career ambition) and thereby making more money than other people. the idea that every high school graduate who has a baby is entitled to these perks is ridiculous. * as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live. * as far as special ed, what i have observed is that there are kids with legit special needs and then there are kids who have gaps in their education due to factors rooted in the home and slide into special ed as a means to make up for those gaps. as a community, i 100% agree that we have to band together and give a little extra for those who are battling disadvantages that are beyond their control. it's the second group, to me, that is exploding faster than really makes sense and milks budgets dry. ESL classes, where the numbers are usually under 15 with a teacher and maybe a para, are also very expensive. maybe it's different in other districts, but this is what i observe in my school on a daily basis. * teachers, in large part, are highly educated, intelligent people. if gov't and voters bear down on them as if they're the root of the problem, you're going to drive away the talent. good teachers are not stuck in teaching; bad ones are. if you strip the job of its perks, people will leave the field. you get what you pay for. do you really want to be stuck with what's leftover? * final point: the tax cap strips districts of financial resources but does nothing to address the problems that make the budgets so difficult to juggle, including all the unfunded mandates that are passed down by the state itself. what remains vulnerable is exactly what you don't want cut--teachers. then class sizes go up, and i'm sorry, but your kid's not going to get a lot of hands-on attention in a room with 29 other kids. if you want the RIGHT stuff cut, there's no easy solution--you have to get into the political mud and exercise your voice as a voter and taxpayer. Speechless...................you took ALL the words out of my mouth!!!!
|
|
Posted 2/19/11 7:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Bookworm, you are the one who made th e best post on this entire thread. All of what you said makes sense. I'm so scared for what lies ahead. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by bookworm there's so much myth and misinformation on this thread, i don't even know where to start, but here goes: * teachers pay into their benefits just like everybody else. in my district it's the upper administration that has 100% employer contribution for health. * most teachers pay into the retirement system. as another poster said, tier 4 contributes for the first 10 years. that was amended, and new teachers (tier 5) pay their whole career. the folks breaking the retirement system are baby boomers who don't contribute and are all retiring at the same time, and sorry folks, you can't welch on an agreement that was made 30 years ago and that people planned their lives around. i'd also like to point out that the retirement system was heavily invested in the stock market, so in many ways, greedy BANKERS broke it. * someone said they don't complain about what Verizon workers make because they don't pay their salaries. excuse me, but who does? the salary fairy? customers pay those salaries--paying for a service, not all that different from school taxes, which are still lower than tuition at a private school. * i get really tired when people pull out this mythical ineffective gym teacher making 6 figures and then act like that's everyone and blame that for the broken system. you could fire that guy and still have the same problem. most teachers work really hard. most teachers don't make 6 figures. the ineffective ones that need to be removed are few and far between. * this notion that people with more money shouldn't expect a better education for their kids is absurd. this is a capitalist nation; that's how it works. the state provides a basic, free and public education. people in wealthier neighborhoods exercise their democratic rights when they agree to pay higher taxes to provide their children with added opportunities. this is the reward for working hard in life (educating yourself, sinking energy into career ambition) and thereby making more money than other people. the idea that every high school graduate who has a baby is entitled to these perks is ridiculous. * as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live. * as far as special ed, what i have observed is that there are kids with legit special needs and then there are kids who have gaps in their education due to factors rooted in the home and slide into special ed as a means to make up for those gaps. as a community, i 100% agree that we have to band together and give a little extra for those who are battling disadvantages that are beyond their control. it's the second group, to me, that is exploding faster than really makes sense and milks budgets dry. ESL classes, where the numbers are usually under 15 with a teacher and maybe a para, are also very expensive. maybe it's different in other districts, but this is what i observe in my school on a daily basis. * teachers, in large part, are highly educated, intelligent people. if gov't and voters bear down on them as if they're the root of the problem, you're going to drive away the talent. good teachers are not stuck in teaching; bad ones are. if you strip the job of its perks, people will leave the field. you get what you pay for. do you really want to be stuck with what's leftover? * final point: the tax cap strips districts of financial resources but does nothing to address the problems that make the budgets so difficult to juggle, including all the unfunded mandates that are passed down by the state itself. what remains vulnerable is exactly what you don't want cut--teachers. then class sizes go up, and i'm sorry, but your kid's not going to get a lot of hands-on attention in a room with 29 other kids. if you want the RIGHT stuff cut, there's no easy solution--you have to get into the political mud and exercise your voice as a voter and taxpayer. Speechless...................you took ALL the words out of my mouth!!!! These are great points. But about the consolidation and test scores. Yes, the superintendent would be responsible for the whole district, but at least in MD, each school's scores are still listed separately so if people wanted to use test scores as a guide for where to live, they could. Your elementary school would still be your neighborhood. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by maybesoon Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. ITA w hofstra It is not combining with a lesser district. It is making the districts and taxes more equitable. Some districts might even see taxes go up. I will say again, w/in the district there will still be "good" and "bad" schools. And people will move to the neighborhoods that serve them. In fact, if they combine correctly, your current school won't change. Where I grew up, and where I taught before, two different areas, had more schools with smaller classes than here, so there weren't less schools. There were less superintendents. For example, I now live way out east. We could form a district, everyone could go to the same school except maybe get rid of some of our super small schools (Quogue, Tuckahoe, Wainscott.) But we would get rid of a lot of superintendents. Each school could have a principal and 2 assts, there would be one main superintendent to over see the schools, one in charge of high schools, one- middle, and one-elementary. Also transportation costs are combined and buses are shared. It seems ridiculous to say that LI won't do this, when the rest of the country is heading that way. And trust me, I've traveled a lot for education and met w/other teachers, Long Island schools are not this revered thing that people around here think they are. Message edited 2011-02-19 08:21:33.400000. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by MrsH2009 Posted by maybesoon Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by Sassyz75 I am all for combining districts... people on Long Island have to get over this class thing.... it is amazing in this day in age we have these low minority districts.. it is a crime and a disservice to children. combining districts will really save money- the higher ups- administrators- are redundant. There is no reason that such small districts have such expensive administration. This is coming from someone who does not pay for private school and sends her DD to one of the "bad" read "non white" districts of long island... I honestly think we on Long Island are spoiled- the "bad districts" we have on Long Island are pretty much better than a lot of the "good" districts in other states... Sorry but for what I paid for my house and for what I pay in taxes I will NOT "get over this class thing" and I would NOT want my district to be combined. Why should someone in a lesser area, paying lesser taxes, and who bought a much less expensive home been entitled to the same perks, benefits, and education of my school district which I pay a lot of money into??? Sorry to be harsh but I pay A LOT to be in the district that I am in and if I wanted my DD in a lesser district I would've bought a cheaper house in a cr@ppier area but we didn't. We stretched our budget and we made sacrifices so that our DD would have the best education possible and I would be pretty pi$$ed off if after all of that my DD ends up being combined with another, lesser district. It would irk me to have spent the money we did for NOTHING. Do I feel for kids in lesser districts with less available to them?..........yes, of course. But as with most anything in this country, the more money you have the better opportunities there are for you in life. There will ALWAYS be a class structure, it's naive to think that it will ever go away. Combining districts is not the answer and truthfully, I cannot EVER see it actually happening on this island. The taxpayers in the good districts will NOT let it happen. It's that simple. We pay to be in the good districts, it's not some freebie or some luxury, we pay for it and sometimes at a premium. At the end of the day it's important to my DH and I to be in a great school district and there is just NO way I would ever pay what I pay to be combined with some other district UNLESS it was another great district similar to mine in every way. But to combine with a lesser district???................nope, no thanks. ITA w hofstra It is not combining with a lesser district. It is making the districts and taxes more equitable. Some districts might even see taxes go up. I will say again, w/in the district there will still be "good" and "bad" schools. And people will move to the neighborhoods that serve them. In fact, if they combine correctly, your current school won't change. Where I grew up, and where I taught before, two different areas, had more schools with smaller classes than here, so there weren't less schools. There were less superintendents. For example, I now live way out east. We could form a district, everyone could go to the same school except maybe get rid of some of our super small schools (Quogue, Tuckahoe, Wainscott.) But we would get rid of a lot of superintendents. Each school could have a principal and 2 assts, there would be one main superintendent to over see the schools, one in charge of high schools, one- middle, and one-elementary. Also transportation costs are combined and buses are shared. It seems ridiculous to say that LI won't do this, when the rest of the country is heading that way. And trust me, I've traveled a lot for education and met w/other teachers, Long Island schools are not this revered thing that people around here think they are. I am not sure why people do not understand this concept. YOUR school will still be YOUR school. YOUR neighborhood will go to YOUR local school. What is the issue? |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by bookworm there's so much myth and misinformation on this thread, i don't even know where to start, but here goes: * teachers pay into their benefits just like everybody else. in my district it's the upper administration that has 100% employer contribution for health. * most teachers pay into the retirement system. as another poster said, tier 4 contributes for the first 10 years. that was amended, and new teachers (tier 5) pay their whole career. the folks breaking the retirement system are baby boomers who don't contribute and are all retiring at the same time, and sorry folks, you can't welch on an agreement that was made 30 years ago and that people planned their lives around. i'd also like to point out that the retirement system was heavily invested in the stock market, so in many ways, greedy BANKERS broke it. * someone said they don't complain about what Verizon workers make because they don't pay their salaries. excuse me, but who does? the salary fairy? customers pay those salaries--paying for a service, not all that different from school taxes, which are still lower than tuition at a private school. * i get really tired when people pull out this mythical ineffective gym teacher making 6 figures and then act like that's everyone and blame that for the broken system. you could fire that guy and still have the same problem. most teachers work really hard. most teachers don't make 6 figures. the ineffective ones that need to be removed are few and far between. * this notion that people with more money shouldn't expect a better education for their kids is absurd. this is a capitalist nation; that's how it works. the state provides a basic, free and public education. people in wealthier neighborhoods exercise their democratic rights when they agree to pay higher taxes to provide their children with added opportunities. this is the reward for working hard in life (educating yourself, sinking energy into career ambition) and thereby making more money than other people. the idea that every high school graduate who has a baby is entitled to these perks is ridiculous. * as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live. * as far as special ed, what i have observed is that there are kids with legit special needs and then there are kids who have gaps in their education due to factors rooted in the home and slide into special ed as a means to make up for those gaps. as a community, i 100% agree that we have to band together and give a little extra for those who are battling disadvantages that are beyond their control. it's the second group, to me, that is exploding faster than really makes sense and milks budgets dry. ESL classes, where the numbers are usually under 15 with a teacher and maybe a para, are also very expensive. maybe it's different in other districts, but this is what i observe in my school on a daily basis. * teachers, in large part, are highly educated, intelligent people. if gov't and voters bear down on them as if they're the root of the problem, you're going to drive away the talent. good teachers are not stuck in teaching; bad ones are. if you strip the job of its perks, people will leave the field. you get what you pay for. do you really want to be stuck with what's leftover? * final point: the tax cap strips districts of financial resources but does nothing to address the problems that make the budgets so difficult to juggle, including all the unfunded mandates that are passed down by the state itself. what remains vulnerable is exactly what you don't want cut--teachers. then class sizes go up, and i'm sorry, but your kid's not going to get a lot of hands-on attention in a room with 29 other kids. if you want the RIGHT stuff cut, there's no easy solution--you have to get into the political mud and exercise your voice as a voter and taxpayer. ETA: Posted by MrsECullen7319 Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe. I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want. those crazy parents are exactly the problem with eliminating tenure. sometimes it amazes me how quickly the PTA can stir up a witch hunt because a teacher refuses to inflate grades or give the frenzied, entitled mob whatever unreasonable concession it's demanding. if a teacher could bank on job security based on performance i'd agree with you, but this just isn't how schools work. I've stayed far, far away from this thread, but I just had to say thank you. You said it all perfectly (and especially the tenure point.) |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Tax Cap Posted by bookworm * as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live. I understand that not all kids have the best parents, but when is the teacher held responsible for a child not learning on a level on par with their grade? My sister is guilty of saying the same things. She takes credit for when a student does awesome, but puts the blame on a parent when the student fails. |
|
Posted 2/19/11 8:50 AM
|
|
| Pages: << 10 11 12 [13] 14 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Gains Tax | Aliking | 9/14/05 | 12 | Home |
| Tax Free Week! | christy | 9/1/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free??? | momAGAIN | 8/29/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| tax free week? | CarrieAnn | 8/28/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Tax question | checka | 8/26/05 | 3 | Home |
| tax question | Redhead | 6/17/05 | 6 | Home |








I'm not in a position to judge whether they deserve it but with the hours and vacation schedule I definitely picked the wrong career





