Re: Tax Cap
Posted 2/18/2011 4:59:07 PM by Hofstra26
Posted by melbalalala
Pardon me if this was touched upon in the previous 10 pages... but...
I live in Maryland where school districts are counties here. When people are choosing real estate based on schools, they look to see what high school their kid would go to and the associated elementary/middle schools, not necessarily at the county as a whole.
So, with LI consolidating districts <which is a MUST if people truly care about property taxes> if less desirable areas are clumped with good schools, would this really affect property values? Aren't Long Island homebuyers smart enough to figure out which schools in the district their child will attend and if they're good schools? Aren't Long Islanders smart enough to know that consolidating school districts is really just an administrative thing and not a quality of education thing? Can't they see that around the country a Superintendent manages dozens of schools, not 4 or 5 and gets paid a fraction of what LI superintendents do?
Yes a good high school and a "horrible" high school might wind up being in the same district, but what does that really mean? Shared expenses, shared secretaries in the admin building, shared transportation?
Willing to be corrected if I'm completely off here
It would absolutely 100% affect the house values here. The school district you're zoned for has a big impact on the worth of your house and what you pay in taxes. Depending what district you are in could either save you or cost you thousands upon thousands of dollars.
And to say the quality of education wouldn't change is really not true. How can it not? Many things would change but my biggest concern would be what happens to the value of my house and my taxes? I paid significantly more for my house than I would had I chosen to live in a different town on the island and I pay more in taxes because of it so for me, I have a problem with the idea that someone who paid less for their home and pays less in taxes would also be a part of my school district.
I just don't agree with it and I don't think it's a valid solution to any problem we're having.
|