"Raising" a child
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
|
Re: "Raising" a child I am 100% committed, dedicated to being a sahm. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:11 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:13 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Hofstra26 I do get her point actually. ah ok. your posts/points made it seem like you didn't. sorry. |
Posted 2/8/11 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by MarisaK Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - Wow. What you wrote makes me feel really sad in a way....lots and lots of women stay home alone with their kids. With no outside influence other than the occasional trip to the library or a mommy and me type class. But we love what we do. We do it b/c we believe in it, and think it's the best for us and our children. Everyone has to do what works for them. But by you saying that, completely demeans what many women do for their living...can you imagine if I or anyone else on this board said "Well it's only unnatural if your kid is in daycare from open till close, with hardly any parent time at home". That is basically what you are saying to SAHM's who do it themself with no help. This wasn't supposed to turn into a debate, and it's STILL not a debate, its just hurtful comments So let me understand - it's perfectly acceptable to say 'staying home w/ your baby is the MOST natural thing a Mother can do' b/c that is what YOU do .......and it's ok for Beth to basically get questioned and attacked b/c she said SHE felt staying home alone w/ her baby was 'traumatizing' for HER - but it's NOT ok for ME, to apply MY PERSONAL feelings or experiences (and specifically state that this is MY PERSONAL feeling as it APPLIES TO MYSELF ONLY) ot this situation and state that it's NOT 'the most natural thing in the world' FOR ME .......... ?? How is that at all demeaning to you or what you have chosen to do ? No one is saying it's wrong - we're saying it's NOT 'the MOST natural thing a woman can do' |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. Completely, completely agree. Very demeaning. I think I'm done posting..sigh.. Message edited 2011-02-08 14:15:27.183000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:15 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. ftr, I dont share her feelings. I feel there is a lot of naturalness to thousands of years of learned behaviors, but she may have evolved ahead of me. I am fine with that. she can rock on with her bad self. she takes nothing away from my feelings by having her own. |
Posted 2/8/11 2:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child I think some kids would be better off if their parents sold them to the circus. Message edited 2011-02-08 14:17:40.273000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by CrankyPants I think some kids would be better off if their parents sold them to the circus. And, it's unnatural for an elephant to balance on a tiny ball. ETA: OH, and I'm a better mom than all of you so I win.
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by CrankyPants I think some kids would be better off if their parents sold them to the circus. And, it's unnatural for an elephant to balance on a tiny ball. ETA: OH, and I'm a better mom than all of you so I win. Marry me
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. ftr, I dont share her feelings. I feel there is a lot of naturalness to thousands of years of learned behaviors, but she may have evolved ahead of me. I am fine with that. she can rock on with her bad self. she takes nothing away from my feelings by having her own. Thank you - and I'm not so 'evolved' I'm just a different person - cut from a different mold. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. Totally agree. What the heck is wrong with you girls that you can't see her comments for what they are - they apply ONLY to herself? She finds it unnatural for HERSELF. No one else. There is just no debate in that! She made ZERO negative comments. She simply stated how she felt. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by MarisaK Posted by maybebaby Posted by MarisaK Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - Wow. What you wrote makes me feel really sad in a way....lots and lots of women stay home alone with their kids. With no outside influence other than the occasional trip to the library or a mommy and me type class. But we love what we do. We do it b/c we believe in it, and think it's the best for us and our children. Everyone has to do what works for them. But by you saying that, completely demeans what many women do for their living...can you imagine if I or anyone else on this board said "Well it's only unnatural if your kid is in daycare from open till close, with hardly any parent time at home". That is basically what you are saying to SAHM's who do it themself with no help. This wasn't supposed to turn into a debate, and it's STILL not a debate, its just hurtful comments So let me understand - it's perfectly acceptable to say 'staying home w/ your baby is the MOST natural thing a Mother can do' b/c that is what YOU do .......and it's ok for Beth to basically get questioned and attacked b/c she said SHE felt staying home alone w/ her baby was 'traumatizing' for HER - but it's NOT ok for ME, to apply MY PERSONAL feelings or experiences (and specifically state that this is MY PERSONAL feeling as it APPLIES TO MYSELF ONLY) ot this situation and state that it's NOT 'the most natural thing in the world' FOR ME .......... ?? How is that at all demeaning to you or what you have chosen to do ? No one is saying it's wrong - we're saying it's NOT 'the MOST natural thing a woman can do' I never said it was better. I said there is nothing more natural than a mom being with her baby. Plenty of my working mom friends have said the exact same thing. And it doesn't matter if a baby is in daycare, with a grandma, etc...at the end of the day, mom knows best and seeing a mom with her baby is an amazing thing. When it was FIRST stated that it was "unnatural" I did in fact get defensive saying that nothing was more natural than a mom staying home with her child...b/c there is NOTHING unnatural about it!!! I was civil. I clarified points and i respected beths post and always have. I try never to be disrespectful. Your words...whether or not you realize it...were very demeaning. And you followed with more insulting words about a man taking care of the family, being the only one in a babies life etc...I don't think you thought about your words at all when writing. Just my opinion. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by CrankyPants I think some kids would be better off if their parents sold them to the circus. And, it's unnatural for an elephant to balance on a tiny ball. ETA: OH, and I'm a better mom than all of you so I win. You are my new best friend.
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by headoverheels Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. Totally agree. What the heck is wrong with you girls that you can't see her comments for what they are - they apply ONLY to herself? She finds it unnatural for HERSELF. No one else. There is just no debate in that! She made ZERO negative comments. She simply stated how she felt. D-to the- itto |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. T Message edited 2011-02-08 14:23:58.293000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by headoverheels Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. Totally agree. What the heck is wrong with you girls that you can't see her comments for what they are - they apply ONLY to herself? She finds it unnatural for HERSELF. No one else. There is just no debate in that! She made ZERO negative comments. She simply stated how she felt. Really? NO negative comments? Even if they were personal accounts of personal feelings, they were certainly negative. SO...if I or any other SAHM's said things like "For ME it's unnatural to take an infant and put them in full time daycare, I should be the ONLY one entertaining and influencing them b/c i'm the mother.." NO ONE would internalize that and become defensive??? People most certainly would become defensive, guaranteed!! But we are supposed to not take any comments about SAHM's personally?? I don't get it. Message edited 2011-02-08 14:28:17.833000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child all I think of when I read threads like these is one simple thing: you will NEVER see a group of men debating/being offended or exploring this issue. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by beachgirl but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. T I really don't understand this statement. Millions of moms stay home and take care of their kids by themselves every day and have been doing it for years and doing it very effectively - I am a product of a household where my mom had to give up her career when she got married and she stayed home BY HERSELF and raised 8 kids, and it did not traumatize her in any way. What outside sources would they need in order to do it effectively? ITA with you 100% |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by headoverheels Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. Totally agree. What the heck is wrong with you girls that you can't see her comments for what they are - they apply ONLY to herself? She finds it unnatural for HERSELF. No one else. There is just no debate in that! She made ZERO negative comments. She simply stated how she felt. Really? NO negative comments? Even if they were personal accounts of personal feelings, they were certainly negative. No, they were explanatory. YOU made them negative. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - Wow. What you wrote makes me feel really sad in a way....lots and lots of women stay home alone with their kids. With no outside influence other than the occasional trip to the library or a mommy and me type class. But we love what we do. We do it b/c we believe in it, and think it's the best for us and our children. Everyone has to do what works for them. But by you saying that, completely demeans what many women do for their living...can you imagine if I or anyone else on this board said "Well it's only unnatural if your kid is in daycare from open till close, with hardly any parent time at home". That is basically what you are saying to SAHM's who do it themself with no help. This wasn't supposed to turn into a debate, and it's STILL not a debate, its just hurtful comments So let me understand - it's perfectly acceptable to say 'staying home w/ your baby is the MOST natural thing a Mother can do' b/c that is what YOU do .......and it's ok for Beth to basically get questioned and attacked b/c she said SHE felt staying home alone w/ her baby was 'traumatizing' for HER - but it's NOT ok for ME, to apply MY PERSONAL feelings or experiences (and specifically state that this is MY PERSONAL feeling as it APPLIES TO MYSELF ONLY) ot this situation and state that it's NOT 'the most natural thing in the world' FOR ME .......... ?? How is that at all demeaning to you or what you have chosen to do ? No one is saying it's wrong - we're saying it's NOT 'the MOST natural thing a woman can do' I never said it was better. I said there is nothing more natural than a mom being with her baby. Plenty of my working mom friends have said the exact same thing. And it doesn't matter if a baby is in daycare, with a grandma, etc...at the end of the day, mom knows best and seeing a mom with her baby is an amazing thing. When it was FIRST stated that it was "unnatural" I did in fact get defensive saying that nothing was more natural than a mom staying home with her child...b/c there is NOTHING unnatural about it!!! I was civil. I clarified points and i respected beths post and always have. I try never to be disrespectful. Your words...whether or not you realize it...were very demeaning. And you followed with more insulting words about a man taking care of the family, being the only one in a babies life etc...I don't think you thought about your words at all when writing. Just my opinion. You are internalizing my words and applying them to yourself - And that's fine if that's what you want to do - but I was not deamaning - I was very specific in my post, and in my words and was very careful to state the it WAS IN FACT UNNATURAL FOR ME - You AGAIN, are stating that there is "NOTHING unnatural about it" So, basically you just keep repeating this 'fact' that something is the 'most natural thing' - when I have stated FOR MYSELF as it applies to MYSELF ONLY that it is in fact, NOT so 'natural' to me - But I'm the one who's demeaning ? |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Hofstra26 As for parenting in isolation, that is what a SAHM does. It's kind of the nature of the beast. My friends, my parents, my neighbors, etc. all work so the only person I can rely on all day is me and I don't think that's a bad thing. My DD isn't suffering because of it. I don't really need assistance from anyone to take care of my DD, that's not to say I don't enjoy seeing family and friends, but I don't *need* them day in and day out. KWIM? This. This right here is what is a relatively new concept. My mom was a SAHM to 4 kids. She was not alone all day, every day. She had my grandparents and aunts and uncles to help her. She didn't have friends that worked, they all had kids and were home with them. She could reach out, during the day for help with things, whether it was to have a friend come over and visit, bring the kids over to play with us, ask my grandparents to pick something up at the store for us. Most mothers and grandmothers did not work when I was a kid and even most grandfathers were able to retire at a younger age than they can now. I am a FTWM, but was home on maternity leave for 11 months. While I loved it, it was very isolating and at times lonely. My DS has no grandparents. All but one of my friends work FT, and the one who doesn't work has kids much older and is running around with them all day and weekend. My contribution to this discussion is that my DS is being raised very differently than I was, and would be even if I were a SAHM. He does not have the same number of family members involved in his life as I did, adults or children. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by beachgirl but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. T I really don't understand this statement. Millions of moms stay home and take care of their kids by themselves every day and have been doing it for years and doing it very effectively - I am a product of a household where my mom had to give up her career when she got married and she stayed home BY HERSELF and raised 8 kids, and it did not traumatize her in any way. What outside sources would they need in order to do it effectively? Ok, I think this is the last post I'm going to make to try to clarify/elaborate on my point because I am starting to become frustrated in this endeavor. While millions of moms stay home and take care of their kids by themselves today, this is not typical of the human species HISTORICALLY, that is why I say it's not natural. Historically, for 99.9% of our history as a species, we have utilized the "village" concept when it comes to raising our children. This doesn't mean DAYCARE, and it doesn't mean that mothers didn't stay home with their babies. They did, but they did so within a larger social framework, with a huge network of support through family, friends, etc. I think there's a very real and valid reason for that - it's in our DNA, in our biology, because we are SOCIAL and emotional creatures, beyond any other species on the planet. So, yes, while it is occuring today, I don't necessarily think it's natural, even if it works for someone and their family, because it goes against our social nature and upbringing, historically. That is my opinion. I'm not saying it's wrong, I'm not saying I'm better than anyone, I'm not saying my situation is superior. I am stating an opinion, and I understand people may disagree, but I can assure you I am not making any personal attacks. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Really? NO negative comments? Even if they were personal accounts of personal feelings, they were certainly negative. SO...if I or any other SAHM's said things like "For ME it's unnatural to take an infant and put them in full time daycare, I should be the ONLY one entertaining and influencing them b/c i'm the mother.." NO ONE would internalize that and become defensive??? . actually and honestly, no. I assume that you chose to stay at home b/c you DO feel this way. that is why YOU made YOUR choice. and I don't have a problem about you feeling like that is the most natural thing for your family at all. |
Posted 2/8/11 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ophelia Posted by maybebaby Really? NO negative comments? Even if they were personal accounts of personal feelings, they were certainly negative. SO...if I or any other SAHM's said things like "For ME it's unnatural to take an infant and put them in full time daycare, I should be the ONLY one entertaining and influencing them b/c i'm the mother.." NO ONE would internalize that and become defensive??? . actually and honestly, no. I assume that you chose to stay at home b/c you DO feel this way. that is why YOU made YOUR choice. and I don't have a problem about you feeling like that is the most natural thing for your family at all. Maybe YOU wouldn't feel attacked, but i can assure you that those words would be VERY hurtful to working mothers, and i would never ever write it. I don't even believe that, i was using it as an example. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by headoverheels Posted by maybebaby Posted by headoverheels Posted by Ophelia Posted by computergirl Posted by MarisaK I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - This is the sort of demeaning post that takes a civil debate and starts the downward spiral. I disagree. I read Marissa as stating how SHE feels about HERSELF. it starts to go to **** when people start INTERNALIZING and applying her comments about HERself on to their lives. Totally agree. What the heck is wrong with you girls that you can't see her comments for what they are - they apply ONLY to herself? She finds it unnatural for HERSELF. No one else. There is just no debate in that! She made ZERO negative comments. She simply stated how she felt. Really? NO negative comments? Even if they were personal accounts of personal feelings, they were certainly negative. No, they were explanatory. YOU made them negative. I added to my earlier reply. And yes, explanatory posts can certainly be negative. Of course they can! I am not twisting words to make them negative, they are what they are. Again, so if i went in a tirade about how being a SAHM is (in my opinion) the greatest thing one can do for a child (not saying it is just to clarify), there would be NO backlash for that?? Even if it is just "explanatory"? Message edited 2011-02-08 14:36:36.340000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:35 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is anyone on here raising a bi-lingual child? | LaPetiteSirène | 1/31/07 | 21 | Parenting |
| Cost of raising a child...interesting article | caper24 | 6/15/10 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mlny | 3/20/10 | 12 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mrsdstowe | 3/20/10 | 4 | Parenting |
| What kind of child am I raising? | nrthshgrl | 2/21/09 | 39 | Parenting |
| Is anyone raising their child vegetarian/vegan? | dm24angel | 1/16/08 | 5 | Parenting |














