"Raising" a child
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 | |
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. I think the opposite. I think it has only recently become the norm for both parents to be working f/t. Both my grandmothers were SAHM's as was my mom and ALL my aunts. They only went back to work when their kids were all in school f/t. Maybe that wasn't the norm when I was growing up, but it was the norm for me. I guess you would feel different if you had a FTWM. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:03 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? I'm sorry but a parent, primarily a mother, being home raising their child couldn't be more natural and up until VERY recently was absolutely the norm. A recent notion??? Huh?? I don't know what planet you live on but even in my generation alone, and I'm only 35, I could *maybe* count on one hand what kids in school had moms that worked. The "norm" up until the last 20 yrs was that a mother stayed home and raised the kids while the father was at work making the money. People didn't have 2 income families, that's a recent development in this country and because of that it was completely the norm for a mom to be home with the kids. And this may cause backlash and feel free to flame away but I STRONGLY believe that IF YOU'RE ABLE TO there is nothing better than being the person that is home with your child day in and day out taking care of them. I understand that people need to work and I'm more than thankful to be a SAHM but please, don't even hint at the fact it's unnatural. A mother being with their child(ren) is FAR more natural than a child in day care 8 to 10hrs a day. Nobody can do a better job taking care of my child then me, plain and simple. I actually think it's a sad state of affairs in this country that maternity leave is so pathetic, that most people HAVE to work in order to survive, and that kids don't have a parent with them all of the time in these formative years. I think things were a lot better "back in the day" before 2 parents HAD to work. I don't know, call me "old school" but for me, being a SAHM was very important. My mom was home with me and my siblings and I distinctly remember liking the fact that someone was home to greet me after school, someone was always there when I was sick or had functions at school, that we always had a homemade dinner on the table, and so on. To me that was very "natural" and I cannot imagine it being any other way for when it comes to my DD. There is something to be said for being a SAHM same as their is for being a working mom. It's an age old argument and at the end of the day, it's one of those things where everyone should agree to disagree on this topic. KWIM? Come on guys.... don't go looking for drama. That is NOT what she meant, read above. I wasn't. I actually saw the above and responded before seeing her reply but I still stand by what I said either way.
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child I agree with you, everyone that is in that child's life or plays part is taking part in raising them - kind of the It Takes Village mentality. Esp. caregivers who are with the child on a regular basis. I think its a matter of how you view the word, raising. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Hofstra26 And this may cause backlash and feel free to flame away but I STRONGLY believe that IF YOU'RE ABLE TO there is nothing better than being the person that is home with your child day in and day out taking care of them. We're perfectly able to stay afloat with DH's income alone, we can afford it, but I personally believe the opposite, that it is better for me and my children for me to work, and for them to be in the daycare setting that I chose for them. You will never come to an agreement on this - there is no single right answer here because every single child, every single parent, every single family dynamic is different, and what may be ideal for one family, won't work for another. I know kids who are absolutely WONDERFUL who come from a SAHM family. By the same token, I know kids who come from two working parent homes who are equally as wonderful. Raising a good kid, and being a good parent, is not dependent on whether the mother is at home, it is dependent on whether the situation that the family chose, works for them, based on their particular needs. BUT, no matter what the situation, whether daycare or SAHM, I very much believe in the "village raising a child" concept, which has been around since man evolved from Neanderthals. Whether you work, or you stay at home, I DO believe that it is helpful for both the parent, and the children, that there are other adults involved in influencing/raising the children. THAT was my point. As for the rest, I think I explained what my intent was in my original statement above. I hope that clears it up... Message edited 2011-02-08 13:07:42.580000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Hofstra26 And this may cause backlash and feel free to flame away but I STRONGLY believe that IF YOU'RE ABLE TO there is nothing better than being the person that is home with your child day in and day out taking care of them. We're perfectly able to stay afloat with DH's income alone, we can afford it, but I personally believe the opposite, that it is better for me and my children for me to work, and for them to be in the daycare setting that I chose for them. You will never come to an agreement on this - there is no single right answer here because every single child, every single parent, every single family dynamic is different, and what may be ideal for one family, won't work for another. I know kids who are absolutely WONDERFUL who come from a SAHM family. By the same token, I know kids who come from two working parent homes who are equally as wonderful. Raising a good kid, and being a good parent, is not dependent on whether the mother is at home, it is dependent on whether the situation that the family chose, works for them, based on their particular needs. BUT, no matter what the situation, whether daycare or SAHM, I very much believe in the "village raising a child" concept, which has been around since man evolved from Neanderthals. Whether you work, or you stay at home, I DO believe that it is helpful for both the parent, and the children, that there are other adults involved in influencing/raising the children. THAT was my point. As for the rest, I think I explained what my intent was in my original statement above. I hope that clears it up... Gotcha. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child in primitive societies the majority of the care was divided amongst the women - usually mothers, sisters, aunts, etc. All women had a hand in raising the child. Typically siblings took over once the child was no longer an infant and all children took part of daily life/work once they were able. This carried on until modern day, after WW2 when women started to stay in the workforce and less homes had multi-family/generations. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child I am a big believer in it takes a village. I am a working mom who believes everyone has a role in raising my child from there teachers, their grandmothers who watch them to me a DH. It's my role as their mom to make sure that the people around them are people I want to be a part in raising my children. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by computergirl Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. Even 100 years ago, yes, while the mother was probably at home, she also had significant help from older siblings, grandparents, aunts, etc. I'm not saying one way is wrong or right - I'm just saying that the "village raising a child" concept, which includes parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and even daycare providers, is not a novel concept. Thanks for clarifying. And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. you know, I have to say that if someone said this about breastfeeding, half this board would lose their mfing mind. I am a FTWM and I AGREE with what you wrote, but I just can't get over the contradiction.
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by nrthshgrl While I agree with the "it takes a village to raise a child." I also agree that the word "raise" is really "influence" at the end of the day my children are my responsibility, not theirs.. To say a teacher "raises" my children because they are with them 8 hours a day, you may as well say that their friends at school are raising them too. While daycare teachers & teacher do have a hand in teaching my children, they aren't permanent. They switch classrooms every year. DH & I are the permanent influences in their lives. I consider grandparents as part of raising them as long as they are active in the child's life. I agree with you 100% |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by computergirl Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. Even 100 years ago, yes, while the mother was probably at home, she also had significant help from older siblings, grandparents, aunts, etc. I'm not saying one way is wrong or right - I'm just saying that the "village raising a child" concept, which includes parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and even daycare providers, is not a novel concept. Thanks for clarifying. And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. It is not unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her baby, but I DO think it is unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her child, without any assistance from family, friends, daycare, what-not. Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. This discussion is not about SAHM v. Working Moms. It's about whether others "raise" our children, whether we are SAHM or working, and I say yes, others DO, and I take it one step further by saying they SHOULD. But, again, that is MY opinion and I recognize that others may disagree. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Janice so, what I really feel is that daycare providers, not grandparents or family, daycare providers are not raising kids...simply because they really have no vested interest in your child. not saying that negatively-they are nice and love your child, take great care of your child...but really-they aren't in it for the long haul of every child that passes through. or maybe i am wrong and it was just the relationship i had with the boy who i watched...who i do love and spent sunday morning with at a playdate. This is neither here, nor there really on the topic at hand, but just wanted to point out that daycare provider/child relationships are not always necessarily "not for the long haul" .. I am a licensed provider (on an extended maternity leave till I jump back into it ), but have maintained some special relationships with some of my former daycare children to this day....One little girl ( not so little anymore, shes now 11 ) I am still extremely close with...Took care of her from 18 months old till she began kindergarten....She just invited me to see her in a play she was in, we are friends on Facebook (yes, she's on FB ) and have continued to speak and see each other far beyond me caring for her....Another little boy (who is now 8) I watched from 5 months on and have become extremely close to his mom and dad, and see him very often as well... And a bunch others, that I still hear from (whether it be Chritmas cards etc...) I still remember all my daycare childrens birthdays to this day! I hear from my former daycare parents how these children still talk about me, remember things I taught them ( lifting up the wings on their juicebox is a biggie ) etc....I have been fortunate enough to be a SAHM currently , and have the option of returning to work (as an in-home daycare provider) and continue to be at home with my own DC's while bringing in income , while providing quality care for those parents who do work out of the home...best of both worlds for us. So, while ultimately IMO, the parent raises the child, other positive individuals in their lives (that the parents allow and choose for the children to be influenced by) do contribute to what they develop into and become...Its not a bad thing, its life
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ophelia Posted by maybebaby And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. you know, I have to say that if someone said this about breastfeeding, half this board would lose their mfing mind. I am a FTWM and I AGREE with what you wrote, but I just can't get over the contradiction. What contradiction?? I am so confused I simply said that "unnatural" was a bad choice of words. And that it has NOTHING to do with being better to be at home...i just don't want to read that it is unnatural, when i think most moms (working or not) agree that its a pretty natural thing for a parent to be home with their kid. And as for breastfeeding? I didn't. I formula fed. But i think breastfeeding is one of the most natural things in the world...women were meant to do it, I just chose not to. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by computergirl Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. Even 100 years ago, yes, while the mother was probably at home, she also had significant help from older siblings, grandparents, aunts, etc. I'm not saying one way is wrong or right - I'm just saying that the "village raising a child" concept, which includes parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and even daycare providers, is not a novel concept. Thanks for clarifying. And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. It is not unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her baby, but I DO think it is unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her child, without any assistance from family, friends, daycare, what-not. Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. This discussion is not about SAHM v. Working Moms. It's about whether others "raise" our children, whether we are SAHM or working, and I say yes, others DO, and I take it one step further by saying they SHOULD. But, again, that is MY opinion and I recognize that others may disagree. No, the discussion wasn't about SAHM vs working mom. And it shouldn't be. B/c it doesn't matter. I just got defensive when i read your first comment. Which i think you can see can come across very different as to how you later explain it. But i have to say....I pretty much parent in isolation, or at least i did for 2 years until johnny went to PT school...and i didn't find it unnatural. At all. DH worked, my family lived in NY while i was in VA. DH came home every day at 4:30 which was awesome. but from 6:30a-4:30pm it was me and Johnny. And at times it was a bit isolating, but overall a wonderful experience i wouldn't have traded for the world. I didn't honestly need anyone else. BUT if he had been in someone elses care PT during that time, it would have been ok with me! I think it's good for kids to be exposed to others of course, i just didn't have that option.. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. Yet AGAIN, I am NOT saying that STAYING HOME with your baby is UNNATURAL. I am saying that staying home, in isolation, without any influence/raising from other people, whether family, friends, or a daycare setting, is not natural. I think the SAHM concept is a beautiful thing, but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. This is how we behave as humans historically, and I think that's because it is how we function and how we operate, biologically. You may disagree, but I wish people would stop taking this so personally. I'm not saying being a SAHM is wrong. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:52 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by Ophelia Posted by maybebaby And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural. you know, I have to say that if someone said this about breastfeeding, half this board would lose their mfing mind. I am a FTWM and I AGREE with what you wrote, but I just can't get over the contradiction. What contradiction?? I am so confused I simply said that "unnatural" was a bad choice of words. And that it has NOTHING to do with being better to be at home...i just don't want to read that it is unnatural, when i think most moms (working or not) agree that its a pretty natural thing for a parent to be home with their kid. And as for breastfeeding? I didn't. I formula fed. But i think breastfeeding is one of the most natural things in the world...women were meant to do it, I just chose not to. saying that something is the 'most natural". I just feel like saying anything is the most natural is bound to ruffle some feathers (just as saying something is unnatural would). doing what is historically the "most natural" thing is not what our society is about any more, any way. |
Posted 2/8/11 1:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. Yet AGAIN, I am NOT saying that STAYING HOME with your baby is UNNATURAL. I am saying that staying home, in isolation, without any influence/raising from other people, whether family, friends, or a daycare setting, is not natural. I think the SAHM concept is a beautiful thing, but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. This is how we behave as humans historically, and I think that's because it is how we function and how we operate, biologically. You may disagree, but I wish people would stop taking this so personally. I'm not saying being a SAHM is wrong. Beth-I appreciate your responses and I do know that you are not saying being a SAHM is wrong...I think things can tend to get misinterpreted when one writes... People are going to take certain things personally, I did at first. Think about it...if you read the words "I honestly think its more unnatural for a mom to put her child in daycare.." you probably would have had something to say about that, no?? Even if the poster later clarified? Just playing devils advocate. I now totally get what you're saying. No debate!
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Yet AGAIN, I am NOT saying that STAYING HOME with your baby is UNNATURAL. I am saying that staying home, in isolation, without any influence/raising from other people, whether family, friends, or a daycare setting, is not natural. I think the SAHM concept is a beautiful thing, but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. This is how we behave as humans historically, and I think that's because it is how we function and how we operate, biologically. You may disagree, but I wish people would stop taking this so personally. I'm not saying being a SAHM is wrong. I still 100% disagree with this explanation.. but that's just my opinion. ETA - I am a SAHM and wouldn't have it any other way, even if my son and I were locked in one room all day, lol - but that's what this board is all about. Agreeing to disagree :) Message edited 2011-02-08 14:01:56.847000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 Yet AGAIN, I am NOT saying that STAYING HOME with your baby is UNNATURAL. I am saying that staying home, in isolation, without any influence/raising from other people, whether family, friends, or a daycare setting, is not natural. I think the SAHM concept is a beautiful thing, but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. This is how we behave as humans historically, and I think that's because it is how we function and how we operate, biologically. You may disagree, but I wish people would stop taking this so personally. I'm not saying being a SAHM is wrong. Honestly, I get where you're coming from, I'm really just playing devil's advocate here for the other side. You have to admit your original comments were provocative. I don't want to start or participate in a SAHM vs working war because those wars are a joke, and I can tell you don't either... we just see things differently. But I like how you can explain your side eloquently without resorting to the usual below-the-belt jabs, kwim? |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:02 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Hofstra26 It is not unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her baby, but I DO think it is unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her child, without any assistance from family, friends, daycare, what-not. Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. This discussion is not about SAHM v. Working Moms. It's about whether others "raise" our children, whether we are SAHM or working, and I say yes, others DO, and I take it one step further by saying they SHOULD. But, again, that is MY opinion and I recognize that others may disagree. This is not to start drama but how is being home with your LO "beyond traumatizing"? That's a pretty strong statement and I'm not sure I understand what you mean. How is being home with your child all day a traumatic event? And for who, you or the child? As for parenting in isolation, that is what a SAHM does. It's kind of the nature of the beast. My friends, my parents, my neighbors, etc. all work so the only person I can rely on all day is me and I don't think that's a bad thing. My DD isn't suffering because of it. I don't really need assistance from anyone to take care of my DD, that's not to say I don't enjoy seeing family and friends, but I don't *need* them day in and day out. KWIM? My DD is thriving and doing great not in spite of the fact that I'm home with her alone every day but because of it. She gets 100% of my attention, she has solid routines, she has a mom who is a teacher and loves to read with her and teach her, and I've never been happier, I love every minute of being home with her. I don't see where anything traumatizing could come of MY situation. I suppose everyone has a different experience being a SAHM. I really don't think you are following or absorbing her point at all. all she is saying is that HISTORICALLY, for thousands of years, the role of SAHM as sole provider/care giver for the child did not exist. human beings...we are pack animals and are not built that we. we are built for socialization. the 'recent' trend towards isolation is new, and not necessarily "natural" for lack of a better term, to our biology. Message edited 2011-02-08 14:04:40.373000. |
Posted 2/8/11 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by MarisaK Posted by computergirl Posted by Bxgell2 Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said. I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways! I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all. I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children - And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with - But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child - Wow. What you wrote makes me feel really sad in a way....lots and lots of women stay home alone with their kids. With no outside influence other than the occasional trip to the library or a mommy and me type class. But we love what we do. We do it b/c we believe in it, and think it's the best for us and our children. Everyone has to do what works for them. But by you saying that, completely demeans what many women do for their living...can you imagine if I or anyone else on this board said "Well it's only unnatural if your kid is in daycare from open till close, with hardly any parent time at home". That is basically what you are saying to SAHM's who do it themself with no help. This wasn't supposed to turn into a debate, and it's STILL not a debate, its just hurtful comments
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ophelia Posted by Hofstra26 It is not unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her baby, but I DO think it is unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her child, without any assistance from family, friends, daycare, what-not. Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing. This discussion is not about SAHM v. Working Moms. It's about whether others "raise" our children, whether we are SAHM or working, and I say yes, others DO, and I take it one step further by saying they SHOULD. But, again, that is MY opinion and I recognize that others may disagree. This is not to start drama but how is being home with your LO "beyond traumatizing"? That's a pretty strong statement and I'm not sure I understand what you mean. How is being home with your child all day a traumatic event? And for who, you or the child? As for parenting in isolation, that is what a SAHM does. It's kind of the nature of the beast. My friends, my parents, my neighbors, etc. all work so the only person I can rely on all day is me and I don't think that's a bad thing. My DD isn't suffering because of it. I don't really need assistance from anyone to take care of my DD, that's not to say I don't enjoy seeing family and friends, but I don't *need* them day in and day out. KWIM? My DD is thriving and doing great not in spite of the fact that I'm home with her alone every day but because of it. She gets 100% of my attention, she has solid routines, she has a mom who is a teacher and loves to read with her and teach her, and I've never been happier, I love every minute of being home with her. I don't see where anything traumatizing could come of MY situation. I suppose everyone has a different experience being a SAHM. I really don't think you are following or absorbing her point at all. all she is saying is that HISTORICALLY, for thousands of years, the role of SAHM as sole provider/care giver for the child did not exist. human beings...we are pack animals and are not built that we. we are built for socialization. the 'recent' trend towards isolation is new, and not necessarily "natural" for lack of a better term, to our biology. I do get her point actually. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 2:09 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is anyone on here raising a bi-lingual child? | LaPetiteSirène | 1/31/07 | 21 | Parenting |
| Cost of raising a child...interesting article | caper24 | 6/15/10 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mlny | 3/20/10 | 12 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mrsdstowe | 3/20/10 | 4 | Parenting |
| What kind of child am I raising? | nrthshgrl | 2/21/09 | 39 | Parenting |
| Is anyone raising their child vegetarian/vegan? | dm24angel | 1/16/08 | 5 | Parenting |











), but have maintained some special relationships with some of my former daycare children to this day....One little girl ( not so little anymore, shes now 11
) I am still extremely close with...Took care of her from 18 months old till she began kindergarten....She just invited me to see her in a play she was in, we are friends on Facebook (yes, she's on FB
) and have continued to speak and see each other far beyond me caring for her....

