Re: "Raising" a child
Posted 2/8/2011 2:21:29 PM by maybebaby
Posted by MarisaK
Posted by maybebaby
Posted by MarisaK
Posted by computergirl
Posted by Bxgell2
Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing.
Wow, I just came back online for a minute and some really interesting stuff was said.
I don't understand how your experience with being home with your baby has anything to do with the "naturalness" of it. You didn't like it, fine. I'm sorry it was so traumatizing for you. But plenty of us do like being home with our kids, and stepped away from lucrative careers to do it! As I said in my earlier post, one could also make the case that babies/toddlers spending the majority of their days in a communal setting, cared for by paid employees, while both parents are absent, could be viewed as an odd/unnatural construct. Sweeping generalizations go both ways!
I agree with the poster who said that if you swap in the word "breastfeeding" for "staying home", the hounds would be released and it would be a free for all.
I have to agree with Beth - she's not saying it's unnatural or weird or wrong to stay at home with your child - she's saying it's unnatural to stay at home ALONE, and completely isolated with your child - as in YOU are the ONLY person 'raising' them w/ no 'outside' help or influence whatsoever. - Which to me, is what a lot of people seem to have in their head as their idea of 'raising' their children -
And I DON'T agree that 'staying home w/ your baby' is one of the "most natural things a woman can do' - I don't think it's so 'natural' to completely depend on a man to support me and my child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to spend my entire day entertaining that child, I don't think it's so 'natural' to be the ONLY person that child can depend on and feel safe with -
But that's ME, and that's why I CHOOSE to do what feels 'natural' to me - going back to work and letting someone else HELP to 'raise' and 'influence' my child -
Wow. What you wrote makes me feel really sad in a way....lots and lots of women stay home alone with their kids. With no outside influence other than the occasional trip to the library or a mommy and me type class. But we love what we do. We do it b/c we believe in it, and think it's the best for us and our children.
Everyone has to do what works for them. But by you saying that, completely demeans what many women do for their living...can you imagine if I or anyone else on this board said "Well it's only unnatural if your kid is in daycare from open till close, with hardly any parent time at home". That is basically what you are saying to SAHM's who do it themself with no help.
This wasn't supposed to turn into a debate, and it's STILL not a debate, its just hurtful comments
So let me understand - it's perfectly acceptable to say 'staying home w/ your baby is the MOST natural thing a Mother can do' b/c that is what YOU do .......and it's ok for Beth to basically get questioned and attacked b/c she said SHE felt staying home alone w/ her baby was 'traumatizing' for HER -
but it's NOT ok for ME, to apply MY PERSONAL feelings or experiences (and specifically state that this is MY PERSONAL feeling as it APPLIES TO MYSELF ONLY) ot this situation and state that it's NOT 'the most natural thing in the world' FOR ME .......... ??
How is that at all demeaning to you or what you have chosen to do ? No one is saying it's wrong - we're saying it's NOT 'the MOST natural thing a woman can do'
I never said it was better. I said there is nothing more natural than a mom being with her baby. Plenty of my working mom friends have said the exact same thing. And it doesn't matter if a baby is in daycare, with a grandma, etc...at the end of the day, mom knows best and seeing a mom with her baby is an amazing thing. When it was FIRST stated that it was "unnatural" I did in fact get defensive saying that nothing was more natural than a mom staying home with her child...b/c there is NOTHING unnatural about it!!!
I was civil. I clarified points and i respected beths post and always have. I try never to be disrespectful.
Your words...whether or not you realize it...were very demeaning. And you followed with more insulting words about a man taking care of the family, being the only one in a babies life etc...I don't think you thought about your words at all when writing. Just my opinion.
|